Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Mark G

Verified Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Mark G

  1. First off, don't base your assessment of the coming year(s) by what this FO or above says; they have never been straight forward with us in their entire existence. Second, don't try to assume a payroll number going into the season. The 3 years combined of '20-'22 have produced a total of just under 3.2M tickets sold. In other words, the last 3 years put together have produced a net loss that JP is not going to take lightly. So, assume a payroll cut back, while hoping for better. We will very likely go with the contracts we are bound to pay no matter what, and pull back on new ones, other than low salary deals for existing or new players. The one exception just might be Correa, since he has publicly declared he would like to stay, but only if a long term deal can be made for market price. JP might want to invest long term in a player he can point to, ala Mauer, that helps the team and gives good PR when it comes to fan interest. If not, get used to hoping we can put together a healthy roster that produces above and beyond expectations. And, just as an aside, we also have to remember we do not get 57 games against Detroit, KC, and Chicago next year, as it is a balanced schedule. That has helped keep us afloat for years now, and will be gone from now on. Can we compete with the whole league from now on? Just a thought.
  2. Agree with a lot, but keeping Bundy at 11M and cutting loose Cave at 1M or so isn't the kind of financial move this FO is likely to make.
  3. A while back (not sure exactly how far, but not too far) I floated the idea of putting Gio at short if Correa left, and I was scolded for that, too. That's why I didn't do it this time, but I agree with you that it is not a bad short term solution. He has played it before, and it wouldn't be long term. And look at it this way: with all the major shifts we put on left handed pitchers, he has moved over into the traditional SS position so many times he is probably used to it. Overall, I like the guy and he isn't that expensive in todays baseball dollars. Give him an extension.
  4. Totally agree on the catching situation. In the opinion of this extremely humble observer it is as dire as any position we have right now. But I will continue to submit we get nothing for Urshela by just not tendering him and letting him go. I would submit that we trade Polanco while he does have value, and move Arraez to 2nd, breaking up that logjam somewhat. Polanco reminds me a lot of Rasario; once he started to fall, he fell quite a bit. Polanco is starting to get hurt more, and his production shows. Trade him while he has value, hold onto Urshela while he is playing well, and keep Miranda free to play both corners. I just don't trust the health of Polanco and Kirilloff.
  5. "How to honor Ohtani is a dilemma, because the Cy possibly is destined for Dylan Cease (with Alek Manoah as a dark horse coming on strong down the stretch)" I'm kind of thinking Verlander, myself. Where am I going wrong? Good idea about the 3 different award categories. Without some kind of a change it is always going to be the same debate: is it the player of the year award, or the most valuable player award? And I already won that debate. Just kidding.
  6. I am a little confused on one or two things. You say you want to keep Gio, but not long term, because Miranda has the better bat, can improve his defense over time, and is part of the future core. On the other hand you say Miranda is likely not the 3rd baseman of the future with all the prospects we have coming up, and if AK does get well and takes on 1st base as a primary position, where does that leave Miranda? If Miranda has been groomed to be our 3rd baseman of the future, then Gio is only going to warrant the one year arbitration offer; there is no room for both at one position longer term. But if Miranda is only holding down the position until one of the prospects shows up and takes over, I will go back to the bird in the hand argument. Gio is a proven commodity, and I will take that over potential prospects coming up in '24 or beyond, because they not only have to develop thoroughly, they have to stay healthy and that is a real trick in this organization. Miranda can play both 3rd and 1st, and can DH on other days. And even if AK comes back next year and plays up to his potential, that injury is always one swing away from derailing the whole plan; and he can play the OF as well. We took a gamble on a 33 year old Donaldson, knowing Miranda was in the wings, but won't take a chance on a 30-31 year old Gio? I don't think it would take 4 years, but 2 or 3 with an option would be appropriate, at least in this extremely humble observers opinion. But I will add the price has to be right; no Donaldson esq contract. In a different post I threw out the idea that it might be time to trade Polanco while he still has a decent return value. That opens up a spot for Arraez, and breaks the logjam of 1st and 3rd base players somewhat. Right now, from what I have seen this year, Urshella is healthier than Polanco and can match his bat. We have trade value for Palanco, and virtually none for Urshella, with no team control after '23. Might be a better plan for the immediate future while we wait for the long term future to prove itself. Just one man's thought process at 2:20 in the morning.
  7. My head is definitely spinning on this one. Love him........trade him.........gotta have a guy like him.........unless he can play another postion, we don't need him........ Going to bed now, I am dizzy (Just kidding, I really am just teasing)
  8. I wouldn't. As I, and others have said in the past, I trust the eye test more than the "metrics". There is a reason Gio has played in 138 games, exclusively at one position, when Rocco had alternatives. Just have to agree to disagree on this one.
  9. Again, a bird in the hand. You have a pretty good 3rd baseman who can hit in your clubhouse. You have a player who played 3rd base in the minors, but hasn't shown the defense you would like, but sure can hit, and can also be put in another position sitting next to him. And you have an outfielder/1st baseman who has shown he can't stay healthy enough to count on. Then you have a bunch of potential prospects who may, or may not, ever spend much time in the above mentioned clubhouse, and certainly not knowing how long it may take for them to get to that clubhouse. A proven commodity vs. all of the above. Hmmmmmm........... Again, a bird in the hand. Where am I going wrong?
  10. Agree with most, but at the end you say if he were a FA today he would get 3-4 year offers; offers being plural. I believe that is right; more than one team in MLB would consider that. My thought process is if multiple other teams (at least I believe there would be) think he is worth the offer, why wouldn't we? Our 3rd base options are a lesser fielder who we could play elsewhere, and prospects we hope will be ready soon. A bird in the hand...........
  11. "I don't trust these defensive stats unless they match up with the eye test." Agreed!
  12. Agree completely..............almost. I still like Thielbar. He only made 1.3M this year, and has 2 years arbitration left. He shouldn't be too expensive for another year or two.
  13. I know this is probably shouting from the bleachers, so to speak, a minority of one, probably. What if we were to sign Urshela, leaving him at 3rd, trade Polanco while he still has decent value, put Arraez at 2nd primarily with Gordon as the utility guy filling in, use Miranda and Kirilloff at 1st with the other DHing when not in the field. That is one medium priced IF guy and 4 pretty cheap ones, and a pretty decent batting order. It leaves money to sign Correa, or pitching if Carlos leaves, and the outfield has more than enough guys to fight it out for 4 spots. And find a catcher!! Now, if Carlos does leave, we may have to live with a stop gap FA for a year until one of our guys are ready, but we could fit one into the budget. I will try not to read the responses; I get scolded enough at home.
  14. No brainer. He is your starting 3rd baseman. His numbers match up with virtually anyone on the team all told, less power than Buck but hits for a much better average, has numbers overall that match pretty well with Correa and Miranda, and doesn't hit as much for average as Arraez, but has more power. Absolutely a better defensive 3rd baseman than Miranda, and I am SO sick and tired of saying 10M is too much to pay for a player with his overall performance. I would sign him to an extension, maybe 2 years with a team option for a 3rd, and if the team goes south you could trade him with his contract control being a good bargaining chip. He is a good all around player and not a problem child as far as I have ever read. Sign him!
  15. I wonder about the context of that clip; what was said before and after would be helpful to know. It is in contrast to the article I read in Wednesday's paper about him wanting very much to stay long term. He used the analogy about being married vs. dating, saying he wanted to marry an organization and was waiting for the Twins to, in his words, "pop the question". It was a very positive article with more quotes suggesting he would like to stay here, but he did imply it would take a long term contract. The ball is in JP's court; he has to decide relatively soon. I have to believe the team wants him back, and Rocco would love to pencil his name in the lineup 140 times a year. But if it comes down to nothing but money, wish him well next week, because it will be the last we see of him.
  16. Boy, it is nice to see another appreciating Urshela. I have loved him from the beginning, and I really hope they stay with him next year and maybe beyond. He has another year of arbitration left, so we have the option, but I think it will be contingent on signing Correa. If we do, we would probably cut payroll in other areas, Urshela being one of the cuts, but I sure hope we keep him.
  17. Very good question; I wish I could answer it. I say that because there was an article yesterday about Correa, and how he said once again he would like to stay long term if it could be worked out. As he put it, he is waiting for them to "pop the question". He wants to get married to an organization, not just date one. Yes, his words, not mine. He wants to stay. What say you, JP?
  18. Agreed. I have always liked the Caveman. He plays all 3 positions more than decently, is easy on the payroll, and has some pop from time to time. I don't expect a 4th outfielder to hit more than Mauer, just more than Jeffers.
  19. No, but we might assume they won't be healthy and successful here. Just kidding...............sort of.
  20. I agree with everything here...........except.........the buck stops with Jim Pohlad. These are his people, hand picked by him and supported by him. He oversees everything in this organization, and has the final say in who runs it. The FO, as we know it, is still run by JP. Every one works for him. He is the only one who can change things. And this extremely humble observer doesn't think he will.
  21. As Harry Truman once said, "the buck stops here", meaning that eventually the responsibility for the actions (or lack of them) of the people he put in place rested with him, as he was the one who put them in place and was supposed to oversee their work. If it is ap ra po for the President to accept responsibility, it should also rest on the owner of a franchise who, also, puts people into place and is the overseer of their work. There are mistakes and missteps to go around, as Cody points out, but the buck has to stop with JP. And only JP can make the changes necessary to improve the team going forward, either by putting better people in place, or by demanding more, and demanding accountability out of the people already in place. What say you, JP? Where does the Twins buck stop? (and I don't mean Byron)
  22. Point well taken, and it is true. But your car being valuable in and of itself doesn't get you anything but offers for that car. It doesn't take you anywhere else. A car that leads a fleet, and leads it to the winners circle, will get the award because without it, the fleet finishes lower. Your collection is what it is, even with the best car; it will never win anything as a collection. Being the best (which I don't give to either one because their roles are completely different and they both excel at their roles) individual doesn't make you the most valuable leader, leading your team to heights higher than they would have reached without you. The whole time Trout was considered the best player in the game the team didn't win, anymore than they are winning now. I could make a case that without Clase, Cleveland wouldn't be in the playoffs. Houston, on the other hand, is stacked; no one player is making a difference because their talent runs too deep. Without any one of them the team still wins. The Yankees can't say that about Judge, and Cleveland can't say that about Clase. Just being the best is not what the award is about; again, it's not the player of the year award. It is supposed to go to the player who was the difference maker between where they are and where they would have been, and without Ohtani they would have finished below Texas and still above Oakland. Not much of a difference. Judge may have literally carried his team to the division title. Without him they would still have made the playoffs in some manner, but without him they do not win the number of games they did. As much as I love to have a give and take, I learn a lot from all the articles and feedbacks, this one is such a no brainer I don't get why it came up.
  23. That may very well be true, but you are right about not being MVP. The MVP is solely, SOLELY, for the most VALUABLE player. Would the Yankees win the division without Judge? Would the Angels be........oh, I don't know, in 4th place instead of 3rd, if they didn't have Ohtani? This is NOT the player of the year award, it is the most valuable. Where would this player's team be without him? I don't know how this is even a discussion.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.