Everything posted by Mark G
-
Minnesota Twins Extension Candidate: Luis Arraez
No disrespect, but a question: how did you feel about the long term extension with Buxton? We knew about his injury history and with his chronic knee issues no one knows how long he will play center field with the same ability, but we gave him 100 mil to keep him for his career even though we had no way of knowing how long that career will last with his injury history and total body fragility. And as much as I like his power, I would take Arraez overall with the bat. Would an incentive loaded deal work for Arraez, ala the one we gave to Buck? (would he even consider it?) Just wondering what you think along those lines.
-
Minnesota Twins Extension Candidate: Luis Arraez
He has the eye and the type of swing that, assuming no career threatening injuries, could last until age 38, much less 28. If the team doctors think he is going to be alright overall, and we play him safely, lock him up now for 4 years with an option. When he is in his early thirties both sides can reassess where he wants to be and if we want him for his career. But for now, give him a fair contract and make it known he is valued. I am betting the fans would love to see it as well. He may not be the defensive wizard everyone would like to see, but he can play multiple positions and DH when he needs a break. He should be a part of the core going forward.
-
How Will Kyle Farmer Fit in for the Twins?
Why am I thinking to myself that if Farmer was everything we are trying to make him out to be, why is Cincinnati so willing to send him packing for a minor league prospect not ready for prime time? And why are we so willing to jettison a proven veteran 3rd baseman who, by the way, also has a history of filling in at short for (pardon the pun) short periods of time? A right handed bat for a right handed bat, and not a better hitter all around. What? The 3ish million we are going to save? Or is it really just that he could be a 3rd string catcher in a pinch? A 32 year old with 2 more years of arbitration doesn't suggest a proven commodity; he has, however, proven durable, based on at bats over the last 2 years. Overall, I just am not feeling good about trades with Cincinnati since the Mahle trade, so I will reserve judgment until about mid season, when we know how the two are working out. If they both come through, as I have said on occasion, I will take my crow medium rare. But recent history with the FO trades gives me pause, so I will wait and see. I will miss Urshela in the middle of the lineup and on the left side of the infield. 3ish million better buy something pretty good.
-
Here's How Massive a Carlos Correa Contract Needs To Be
Much, if not all, of what you say is true. But at the end of the day, Boras, or any other agent, works for the player, not the other way around. I know, a lot of players just turn it over to the agent and walk away, claiming no knowledge of, or responsibility for the negotiations, but at the end of the day if the player wants to play somewhere, he will play there more times than not if he is good enough. And Correa is good enough. So we will see how much he really wants to play here, or if it was just lip service, if our bid is competitive. But it is our job to make it competitive!! And creativity is part of that. If the smartest guys in the room can't make a truly competitive bid, then look to the owner's box, because nothing gets done without that say so. And that is where my true doubt lies.
-
Here's How Massive a Carlos Correa Contract Needs To Be
We need to craft something that guarantees us his prime years, paying him upfront for those years, and also giving him an option later in the contract that would allow him to move to a contender if we haven't been much of one. I question if he will take a 9 year deal committing himself to us for his career unless he feels he can win here, and I am not sure he feels that. Let him make his money while we get his prime years, and then let him go to a contender (if he so chooses) in the latter part of his career. It is a win win for him and the team.
-
I Will Give Carlos Correa This $10 Bill If He Signs with Minnesota
Maybe we should organize a go fund me page. ?
-
Carlos Correa Officially Opts Out of Twins Contract
This makes the most sense to me. Maybe, say, after 4 years the team has an option on the 5th, and after that it is the players option from then on through each remaining year. Gives us some security, and gives him the chance to move toward the end of his career to a championship contender (assuming we aren't). Give him a partial no trade deal, maybe giving him the chance to pick 8-10 teams he would agree to and not the rest. Gives him a say in any trade, which he will probably want. And give him the choice of front loading, or back loading the contract, or just making it a constant number throughout. Lay out the number of dollars and the number of years, and let him and Boras write in the amount they want each year, as long as it adds up to the total dollars. I know, that may overload payroll on a given year, but it would relax it in another, and it would be a very nice gesture to someone who has options. And make an actual competitive offer, or move on. Your aren't stringing Correa along, you are only stringing us, the fans, along, and we are bloody sick of it. Just one man's extremely humble opinion.
- Jim Pohlad Wants Carlos Correa Back. Will Twins Do What It Takes?
-
Handbook Preview: 3 RP Reunions the Twins Should Consider
While I wouldn't exactly send hate mail to the FO if they signed any of the 3, none of the 3 excite me all that much. Fulmer might have the lead in this extremely humble observer's opinion, but I would still look long and hard for an upgrade from the past, rather than a stroll down memory lane.
-
Jim Pohlad Wants Carlos Correa Back. Will Twins Do What It Takes?
You know, it's funny; the article referred to was the Charlie Walters article, and even at the time I read that article I thought to myself this is just Charlie being Charlie. Scott Boras could care less about a state income tax over a 7-10 year contract period; it probably doesn't even enter his head. Anyway, as the poet once said, "it is to laugh". As for the article itself, 3 or 4 generic quotes from JP is so meaningless I blew it off the minute I moved on to the rest of the article. That is also textbook Pohlad; making everyone think he is doing something, without really committing himself to a bloody thing. Between him, Bell, Falvine, and Rocco, I have never heard so many people say so much and mean so little in a lifetime of watching this team. Makes me pine for the days when old Calvin would have a couple of drinks and get near a live mic. Good or bad, at least you got the skinny. ?
-
In First Move of Off Season, Twins Pick Up Sonny Gray's Option
"Twins fans should welcome another year of the ace on the mound." As much as I like Gray, and as happy as I am that they picked up the option, I have to ask myself: how far has baseball fallen when someone with 120 innings and only 9 quality starts is talked about as an "ace"? I must be getting old. ? :
-
Planning for the Future Behind the Plate
The key word in the entire post here was options. Options. Plural. We have options at every position in the field except catcher, arguably the most important position for no other reason than it is exclusive. Along with the other players you mentioned, you could move Urshella to short and slot in Miranda at 3rd. Arraez has played 3 different infield positions. All our outfielders could man any of the spots for a brief time if necessary. I could go on, but don't need to. Two positions on the diamond are not interchangeable or you could move a player to in a pinch if absolutely necessary; pitcher and catcher. From the get go I have been basing my thought process on what our 40 man roster contains, not on what we would call up from the minors and have to move the 40 man around. Last I saw we had 47 players on the 40 man, but some are current free agents and others we expect to not bring back as well. The article said it would probably end up being about 39 on the roster before adding and moving others as well. But as of today, none of the other 38 projected to be left standing could be put behind the plate; hence my thought process that this is the single most pressing position to look at in the beginning of the off season; by no means the only position, but the most pressing. And I would prefer not waiting until low cost defense first catchers are all that are left. Whether it be through FA or trade, get out ahead of this, or we relive '22 indefinitely. I would even entertain bringing back Sanchez if all else failed, but I would like to think we could do better, which we won't if we wait too long. I think our disagreement might simply stem from the concept of pressing vs. important. Other positions may very well be more important in the long run, but I believe this position is the most pressing currently, as there are not many quality guys available and there will be multiple buyers. Doesn't mean we can't look at other positions at the same time, but I feel there is more time with other positions because, as I said, there are options at the other positions, even if they are not necessarily the most desirable options. One catcher is an option, not options. And now that I have worn out my welcome, I will say thanks for the chat. ?
-
Planning for the Future Behind the Plate
I'm not sure, here, but are you telling me that half the playoff teams have one catcher? One catcher on their playoff roster? Because that is what we have right now. Even if we had an incredibly terrible catcher along side Jeffers, at least we would have more than one. Right now we have one. I may be overlooking something here, but did I mention we have only one? Because right now, we have one. I am pretty sure all I said was I wanted more than one, and I am hoping they don't wait until the better ones are gone before we try to grab one. As the song goes, "one is the loneliest number. Two can be as bad as one, it's the loneliest number since the number one." Right now, I would settle for as bad as one, no matter who is actually number two. I say this with all due respect, but, yeah, it's a pretty pressing need, no matter who we share the boat with.
-
Planning for the Future Behind the Plate
You know, I keep hearing people say "we have other needs" beyond catcher, and I understand that, but for the life of me, I can't think of one more pressing in the here and now. One injury prone .200 - .210 hitting catcher on the entire 40 man? And no one in the near future of the organization ready to move up? Picture only having one of any other position, much less a position you can't just slot someone into in an emergency; they kind of have to be a catcher, you know? What ever direction they go, defense first or offense, framer or good arm, etc., they better do it PDQ, or the league will make the decision for them by snarfing up everyone worth anything. We have at least some depth at every other position on the field; this may very well not be our only need, but it is the most pressing at the moment.
-
Reviewing 2022 Performances by the Twins Catching Prospects
"Could there be an internal option?" Let me see, how can I put this..........?
-
Offensive overload of Ace Articles and discussion
It is interesting to see the difference in each year and how each side of the ball did. Sometimes, though, it can be a little misleading if all you see is the averages year by year, meaning they gave up an average of 4.22 runs per game in '22 for example, and scored an average of 4.30 runs per game. Now I don't know the numbers for previous years off the top of my head, but last year we scored 3 runs or less in 48+ percent of our games and 4 runs or more in 51+ percent. We also won 48+ percent of our games and lost 51+ percent of our games. If we score 8 runs in one game and 1 the next, we average 4.5 runs per game (slightly over league average), but I bet we come out 1-1. Now that can probably be said for most teams, obviously, but we really need to add a proven run producer that can help balance that out, as Nelson Cruz did when he was here. That 4th run (or more?) per game clearly makes a difference over 162 games. And it would be safe to guess one more stud RP might have make the difference in several games as well. Sometimes a single addition on each side of the ball can make a difference in a season; but I always hope for 3 or 4. Thanks for the look back; it is interesting to see the ups and downs.
-
Carlos Correa and Luis Arraez Named 2022 Silver Slugger Finalists
I am chuckling a little as I write this, because I marvel at baseball for their ability to include as many categories and individual players as the law allows, so to speak. They have Arraez slotted at 1b for the gold glove category, but utility for the silver slugger. They have no idea what to do with the only 2 way player (pitcher/DH) in the game today, as he is the only one who has even picked up a bat, much less hit regularly. So they slot him in at..........utility?? On what planet is Ohtani a utility player? But, again, where do you slot a pitcher for the silver slugger award? DH? Or "utility"? And they create enough metrics in the batting category to be able to point to something to justify whoever they decide to pick for each position. But, just like the Oscars, it is an honor just to be nominated, right guys? This should be fun to watch.
-
Twins Trade Candidate: Jorge Polanco
Paragraph one: spot on. Paragraph two: spot on. Can't argue with a single word. Paragraph three is where I can't help but go back to the thought that we would trade one of the few above average players we have is because they are the only ones that would bring anything back. And Jorge in particular is going to lose trade value every year (even every month) that goes by from this point forward, although that can be said for a lot of the guys I suppose. Yes, you can spend to fill holes, and I hope they do if the right deal is out there (SS?), but that just adds to the 40 man without a subtraction. For every player we buy in the off season another player has to be moved from the 40 man. If we could spare spots on that roster would we trade the prospects that are being taken off? Your logic is impeccable in its own way, but how do we keep the prospects we want protected from the Rule 5 if we keep adding free agents that bump them from the roster? Or do you think that there is simply enough dead weight we are going to let go of that would make the point moot? I don't think there is anyone here who just doesn't like Jorge and is saying dump him, I sense that it is more along the lines that some of us feel he would bring the most in return at this time and we have needs greater than the difference at 2nd he would be over his replacement. Do not trade him just to make a deal of course, I remember letting Rosario go thinking we had plenty of OF prospects to take over, and how did that work out for us........but I digress. But if Jorge, alone or as part of a package, would bring something we need more than simply a better 2B than who would take over, I would (sadly) say bite the bullet and fill a need. I would trade any player on the 40 man, for that matter, that would make us a better club, but if I go there I am off topic, so I stayed with trading Jorge just for that purpose. Sometimes the hole you need to fill doesn't happen through free agency; a trade or two might be needed. You may very well be right when it is all said and done, but I don't want to rule something out that might improve the overall make up of the club. Besides, they don't listen to me anymore ever since they stopped taking my calls. So you don't have to worry.
-
Twins Trade Candidate: Jorge Polanco
I concur on quite a bit. I have lobbied to keep Urshella for a while now, and still want to. And, while I don't think Arraez would be a 140 game a year 2nd baseman, he could spell 1st and DH often enough to keep him from that. Or maybe give Gordon a shot with Arraez as his back up. But right now I see a roster with a lot of outfielders, and a lot of infielders who play 2nd and 3rd and fill in at 1st. But we didn't have a true 1st baseman much of last year, and we aren't going to bring back Sano, so do we keep the converts there and hope for the best, or find a first baseman? And we surely need another catcher (one that can throw out runners?), we have to sign a SS of some length and ability, and I see a need for a couple of stud BP guys. And that is assuming we are going to go with the starters we have now. If we buy those needs with all that cash everyone thinks we are going to have (I am not holding my breath on that), then aren't we just clogging our 40 man even more? We have a lot of assets and a lot of holes. Back in the day ( i know how much everyone hates it when I say that), we would trade one to fill the other. Right now the proven major leaguer that has a fairly decent contract and 3 years of control is an asset that, coupled with a prospect or two, might bring something to fill one of those needs. No one wants to pull that trigger, but it just might be the best bullet we have.
-
Twins Trade Candidate: Jorge Polanco
Not a bad thought at all, but as for his value, it is in the number of years of control we have right now and a 6 figure salary as opposed to an 8 figure salary, which is what Jorge is going to get in '24 and '25. That, in and of itself, might be enticing to plenty of teams, but it is probably what will keep him here. As an aside, and at the risk of being told I am off topic, we talk a lot about should we keep Urshella at 3rd or not. In the same sense that we might have a log jam at 2nd, do we have a log jam at 3rd? And is that why a lot of folks here don't think we should keep him, giving the job to Miranda, or if he fails, someone up and coming the following year. Why would 2nd base be any different? 30 mil for the next 3 years of a 30ish (starting next year) Polanco, or about the same to a 30ish Urshella. We have to make way at some point for the kids coming up, or trade them. And only one year of control('23) of Urshella makes him worth little in trade, where as Polanco has a value right now. Do we wait until he doesn't have that value? Do we keep him his whole career and move the kids coming up? I happen to believe we have enough depth that someone will step up and take control of the position, leaving the cash for other things. Isn't that how we have been looking at 3rd base? And first with Sano? We might have to make moves we don't want to make to adjust our 40 man to a better balance. Just my thought.
-
Twins Trade Candidate: Jorge Polanco
I would submit that his trade value is the highest it might be right now. He turns 30 next July, and the older he gets the less valuable he is. And he has 3 years of control now, and the less control as time goes by also decreases his value in a trade. Coming off an injury is never ideal, but at 29 (currently), a team friendly contract, and 3 years of team control pretty much maximizes his trade value; the longer we wait that only decreases. Waiting for him to be healthy and bring his stats back to normal might make him look better to the eye, but teams today look at the above when considering giving something up in trade. Or so I am told every day on TD.
-
Twins Trade Candidate: Jorge Polanco
If one of the draws another team might be looking at is the amount of control left, and we have multiple options at 2nd if we were to move him, waiting until the trade deadline or even next year wouldn't make sense at all. If you are going to move someone, you move him when his value is at its highest to get the maximum return. I have lobbied for a while to move Jorge, as we need to make room for the younger guys, we have multiple options, and we can use the money saved to buy other immediate needs. If we are going to move him, move him now so you know what you have to work with on those other needs, before those needs are snapped up elsewhere.
-
15 Free Agent Starters the Minnesota Twins Could Target
Not entirely a motley crew, but not a lot to get excited about either. Take an honest shot at a couple of the upper tier guys (Rodon?), meaning serious offers, but if not, maybe stay with our own kids before any of these guys. I would rather sign stud BP guys than iffy #3 or #4 starters.
-
Revisiting The Josh Donaldson (Gio Urshela) Trade
Trade turned out alright. I really like Urshella; a good player, a good guy in the dugout, and he stayed healthy on a team that needed that more than any stat the computer can spit out. I hope they keep him around for a while. Sanchez on the other hand............ Overall, at least for the 1st year in hindsight, an A-.
-
Edouard Julien Can Take the Next Step in 2023
The key point there would be if there's an opening. I would never hesitate to call up the best option we have on the 40 man due to injuries (which we all know we are famous for), but not just to see how he does. I still believe in letting them come along step by step, and not having faced pitching beyond AA for more than 2 weeks, as you suggest, I would hesitate quite a bit unless absolutely necessary. He has plenty of time as long as he stays healthy. I also happen to believe in trades when you have a log jam of players in the same or similar positions. When an organization has several 2nd and/or 3rd base players in the system, as an example, and there is no avenue to be brought up except by injury, out of respect to the players in that log jam it would be beneficial for all concerned to trade from the strength for a place of weakness the organization may have, in our case catcher. Maybe the best solution to all the prospects we have in the infield who can play multiple positions except SS would be to move one or two to open up spots. I believe it is time to trade Polanco for example, while he still has value, and bring along the young guys. If push comes to shove, Arraez can hold it down until one or more is ready, or Gordon as well. Maybe that would allow players to come along faster.