Everything posted by TheLeviathan
- Game Score: Twins 6, Rays 5
-
Envisioning a Good Twins Rotation in 2022 (For Real!)
Certainly one offseason isn't enough to make the rotation great, but much of the way the White Sox built their rotation can be matched by the Twins. Lynn was a trade. Kuechel was a mid-level pitching deal in FA. Giolito and Cease were prospects acquisitions. Rodon was there for the taking by anyone. The team will need to let their young starters get seasoned next year, but in 2023 they can absolutely be on the path the White Sox took. Just spend this offseason acquiring a Kuechel-like guy and look for a trade opportunity. Then trust your young arms.
-
Did the FO misevaluate their pitching additions?
Well, I think we can conclude that they did. Either they thought they could get more out of these guys than they did, they mishandled them while they were here, or they just identified guys that were washed up. I'm not sure what it was exactly, but it clearly didn't work. And none of these guys are magically better elsewhere either. (Some worse, some only slightly better) They swung and they missed. The bigger issue is that a reasonable person could go in knowing that they weren't all going to work, but having them all NOT work is the problem.
-
The Twins Shouldn't Spend (Much) On Starting Pitching This Offseason
Sure, but only because we drop 25M AAV on a shortstop.
-
Envisioning a Good Twins Rotation in 2022 (For Real!)
I'm not sure I would classify this plan as "good". It's likely far less of a disaster as last year with some upside, but "good" seems highly unlikely. I would like to see Ryan, Ober, Dobnak start the year but there is a good chance they may need seasoning. Or stretching out. To supplement that I'd sign one Happ-like veteran as a filler. Maybe that's Pineda if he comes back reasonably, but I don't think he'll be worth it. Then I'd sign Jon Gray to a five year 70M deal. And I'd trade what we have to for Zac Gallen as a buy-low option. I hate speculating what that might be, but I'd pay it. Gallen-Gray-Ryan-Ober-Dobnak/Pineda/Warmbody Holding a Place for a Young Guy has potential to be good. Still probably not a good chance of it though.
-
Can the Pitching Staff Compete in 2022?
It's all hypothetical, but in the pure hindsight article the best we could do is 72 wins which, yes, is in the WC, but that's best case scenario. I think that assuming not-league worst, but averagish, is more like where Cleveland sits. Maybe you can argue that's WC contention. I don't think I would. Too many injuries and things went wrong this year. I think that the root of those problems may be closer to 2 years old rather than 1.
-
2021 Off-Season Thread
Jesus, this team is a parody at this point. At this point signing Sidney Rice to play TE seems like something worth gambling on in Vegas.
-
2021 Off-Season Thread
I know....they may need another one.
-
2021 Off-Season Thread
Especially Holmes. I sorta liked that pick when they made it. I thought he was an athlete who could bulk up enough to play the 3 tech....but he looks both slow and small for it. He's a complete waste of a roster spot IMO. This week off before the season starts is going to change this cutdown process. There is going to be a lot of IR maneuvering we haven't seen before. Right now we have no long-snapper, need more TE depth, have too many LBs, and could use an OL or a QB too.
-
2021 Off-Season Thread
That's a more talented player than I expected too.
-
Can the Pitching Staff Compete in 2022?
I can get behind that. Though I'm not sure even with good moves this team was going to be in a better position with Buxton hurt most of the year and just too many things going wrong. I mean, you can't bat 1.000, so even if half the moves they made were better where does that land us? To me, still in a reset/retool position, but maybe I'm just being pessimistic. I definitely agree it seemed to come faster than I would've thought a year or two ago.
-
2021 Off-Season Thread
TE depth across the league is pretty good. That might be an area we see them swing a deal. You can't play 2 TE sets 98% of the time and field Conklin and Dillon in those roles.
-
Let the Learning Commence for Twins Brass
Did the Twins organization send out a press release with a headline like "Twins Declare Hard Work for Suckers and Old Fogeys. Team will Play the Game the Wrong Way, with Calculators in their Pocket Protectors" If no, then I guess Frank really kicked the stuffing out of that strawman. Even got you to be his sidekick on that silly fallacy.
-
Let the Learning Commence for Twins Brass
Except he then retweeted his wife saying this (shortly after retweeting yet another anti-tech/analytics piece about robot umpires): Leadership begets Leadership... what is the organizational mantra? The Twins of the 80's & 90's were built upon fundamentals, team chemistry, players arrived early and left late because they loved being there. Analytics won't replace hard work & a big heart... ask Kirby Puckett! Ripping analytics was a clear implication and subtext to his post. As if analytics is opposed to fundamentals. It's implying the team doesn't care about clubhouse culture and attitude....despite being the FO and manager who has prioritized that more than any in my lifetime. Your tortured analogy only works if you are complaining about airplanes because they serve french fries. At which point, yes, the two opinions are tied together and I can examine your reasons on both and how you wed them together. He can have those opinions, but then he can be criticized for them as well. Pretending they don't exist or weren't the point is silly.
- Can the Pitching Staff Compete in 2022?
- Let the Learning Commence for Twins Brass
- Can the Pitching Staff Compete in 2022?
- Let the Learning Commence for Twins Brass
- Buck Can Bankroll His Future in Final Month
- Buck Can Bankroll His Future in Final Month
- Buck Can Bankroll His Future in Final Month
-
Buck Can Bankroll His Future in Final Month
I totally understand the David Ortizian Dread. However, framing his injuries as "unlucky" is only honest if you choose to completely ignore the pre-2021 past. And....well....I don't find that to be a terribly fair way to frame things. "Conveniently selective" comes to mind. You can be for the gamble without selectively re-writing history. This guy's prime, 25 year old freaky amazing athleticism has not saved him from being utterly brittle. That is part of the equation. It's 95% negative for the idea of an extension. But I'll bet on the combo of that 5% discount in cost and the Hail Mary it might all come together. As @gunnarthorsaid....they can afford to roll those dice. But let's not pretend that we're not betting on a longshot here.
-
Colóme: What Happened?
The rest of the league didn't seem eager to sign him either, something in their scouting/analytics was telling them to steer clear. I guess we should have too.
-
Buck Can Bankroll His Future in Final Month
This is the mass TD delusion I'm referring to. It's like this board needs a damn intervention. I would prefer not to repost Van's list but I feel like it's necessary: 2015: Sprained left thumb, 46 GP 2016: Knee contusion/back spasms, 92 GP 2017: Groin strain/migraines, 140 GP 2018: Migraines/fractured toe/strained wrist, 28 GP 2019: Wrist contusion/concussion/left shoulder dislocation/labrum surgery, 87 GP 2020: Concussion symptoms, left shoulder injury, sprained left-foot, 39 GP 2021: Hip injury/broken wrist You know what's not a good predictor of health? See above. Stop arguing that his most recent injury, while unlucky, is reflective of his situation. I'd feel BETTER if he had a bunch of consistent injuries to the same part of his body or unlucky breaks. But he doesn't. He's basically managed every injury known to man. He's amassed roughly 3 seasons of PA in 7 SEASONS. The argument that "we can't predict the future" is misleading because....of course we can't. What we use to predict is the past and play the odds. The past has given us clear information: this guy cannot be counted on to be healthy with any reasonable certainty. If we get lucky and he magically stops this 7 year run of consistent problems? Great. But for the love of all that's good in the world....can we stop sticking our heads in the sand? Or spinning this history as "unlucky". In his physical prime he's been out 60% of his career. You know what IS predictive? Age doesn't help that. As I said.....gamble away, but let's stop the spin-jobs. I want to resign him, but I'm going in eyes wide open: he is a massive injury risk and almost certain to miss significant time during that extension.
- Buck Can Bankroll His Future in Final Month