Everything posted by TheLeviathan
-
2021 Vikings Season Thread
Our run defense is a serious problem. I don't understand why we're so bad. That 30 yard run before half....good god.
-
Basking in Buxton’s Season
Josh Donaldson hurts his leg muscles all sorts of ways. By your definition, we should totally expect him to be completely healthy! He won't run wrong, to first, against the *insert last injury opponent here* every time. Pure bad luck. C'mon. You can favor this extension without that sort of thing. This isn't controversial: That's not how human bodies work. "Bad luck" doesn't explain missing 300 out of a possible 480 games since 2018. Read that again if you need to. Not every athlete is able to play as long as others because their skills break down. Not every athlete is able to endure the same contact or wear and tear and come through it the same. Buck has demonstrated - to the tune of nearly missing 2/3s of the games he has been eligible to play - that his body doesn't seem to endure those rigors as well as others. Acting like he's just "good luck" away from playing more often is seriously naive. The Twins can't, and shouldn't, be that naive in their negotiations. And you're only punishing yourself as a fan to keep going to that well. Ask Nick Nelson and his Three Time Running "Buck for MVP" column in March that has, you guessed it, never materialized due to injury. Your kind of thinking keeps going back to that well because it refuses to acknowledge a problem that has persisted and, in all likelihood, will continue to continue. When we have a data point that Buck can play a whole season, THEN the narrative should change.
-
2021 Vikings Season Thread
The defense played ok but man was the offense a mess after the first drive. Our WR were not getting quick separation and their D-line is too good to hold on to the ball.
-
2021 Vikings Season Thread
I think the bigger problem is Cook shouldn't be out there. The line battle hasn't been one sided, they are holding their own.
-
Basking in Buxton’s Season
Guys who get injured don't do so by choice, I don't understand why anyone thinks this is a reasonable way to look at things. Of course Buxton isn't hurling his body purposely into injury with the intent to be injured. The problem is that we have ample evidence that some players maintain durability and others simply don't. Josh Donaldson isn't "doing something" or "choosing" to keep hurting his balky leg muscles. He's just clearly more prone to injuries there. His body can't handle the sport without more chance of injury relative to his peers. Likewise, we have a crap ton of evidence this is the case for Buxton. Could he suddenly be able to play baseball without getting hurt all the time? Sure. I hope that's the case. I'm on board for that gamble and want an extension. But I'm over this fairy tale that it's some kind of given he's going to be healthy. If Vegas was doing odds on Buxton's future games played per season, I guarantee you that over/under is WAY short of 150. It's probably short of 100.
-
Basking in Buxton’s Season
Who cares whose fault they are? All we have to predict the future is trends of the past. Players with this kind of history rarely become durable. The time of his life where his body was the most resilient was spent playing halves to thirds of seasons. That has bearing on a 7 year contract.
-
Does MLB need to change way minor league players live?
If you didn't like it getting political you could have steered away from "dumb kids can't stretch peanuts" line of argument. I'll repeat because it basically trashes all of your arguments, is not political, and compares MLB to their peers. They're terrible. And there is no moral or financial justification for it.
-
Does MLB need to change way minor league players live?
This post says the exact opposite of everything you said @bean5302 At this point you are long-windedly defending greed. You should reread the post you liked and better understand the thesis so you aren't so offbase.
-
Does MLB need to change way minor league players live?
And your math included no agent fees and as rosy a picture as possible and still left them 30k. My link puts that into context of professional sports along with a litany of issues you didn't consider. You are defending poverty on the basis of "slightly better than homeless and living off happy meals". For what purpose....I have no freaking clue.
-
Does MLB need to change way minor league players live?
No, not rocket science. These guys are being woefully underpaid. Only the elite draft choices are going to overcome this kind of pay with their signing bonus. Especially when you take agent fees out as well as taxes. There is no justifiable reason for baseball to be this cheap about their pay. None. Morally or financially.
-
Does MLB need to change way minor league players live?
There is no reason these guys are eating fast food, living in bunk beds in some random person's house, and unable to afford the basic necessities to live a quality life. Baseball is starving these guys, literally and figuratively, and they are investments in their future product. A meager increase is all it would take to correct this and yet the MLBPA and Owners constantly exploit these guys for their own leverage. This isn't about sound financial planning or any of that....it's wondering why a multi-billion dollar industry pays peanuts to players. A drop in the bucket changes this whole narrative and yet stubborn greed rules the day. There is no justifying that behavior.
-
Simmons Wants to Know the Real Story Behind Reliever’s Broken Hand
Is this where I make a snowflake crack? Yeesh, sense of humor please.
-
Basking in Buxton’s Season
How many people saw that he only started 55 games and thought it was more? I was going to guess he played half the season, but it's a third. Ouch. He stayed on the field after he came back, that was a very promising end. Hopefully they get a very fair contract done with incentives for Buck and protections in case we spend the next 7 years with 50 games played.
-
The Uncertain Future of Twins Catching
How is it uncertain? We have a guy in Jeffers who is 24, showed some great things so far in his young career, Rortvedt is still a guy I think we can count on as a future big leaguer, if only as a backup. So the team has options - keep Garver and let he and Jeffers hold it down another year so Rortvedt can season a bit more in AAA or, if you get a nice offer, deal Garver to plug another hole. But the Twins are in a leverage position, they don't need to do anything.
-
2021 Vikings Season Thread
Agreed, I guess I just meant to point out that there was a good mix. More quick throws is a good thing, but they weren't all that way. Frankly, it seemed like a very diversified set of plays - screens, short throws against cushions, play action with rollouts, play action from the pocket, slants, deep ins, inside runs, outside runs, zones, tosses, some power runs. I don't remember the last time a Vikings offense looked that eclectic.
- End of the Line for Brent Rooker?
-
Games of all Kinds (Video, Board, Mobile, Card, etc.)
Since this is a baseball site. If any of you folks have an itch to GM a team using Baseball Mogul, we have the Twins open in the league I have been running the last decade. We sim three times a week, super stable and fun file. @Vanimal46this is your OOTP alternative!
-
2021 Vikings Season Thread
They still took a lot of middle and deep shots though too. I think what you're see is we're attacking all levels of the defense based on what they're giving us. Dude still had nearly 9 yards per throw. It's not like we're checking down and dinking and dunking. When he dropped back he had a lot of clean pockets. Not to mention the massive, gaping holes they are opening in the running game. These last two games the O-line has been a top 10 unit. Maybe top 5.
-
Current TV, regardless the year
That trailer was phenomenal. "What If..." has been a little disappointing IMO.
-
2021 Vikings Season Thread
Agreed, though schematically the Bears made no adjustments. The edge the Vikings have is their skill players are so good at getting open that it allows us to quick throw on people. The other thing the Bears didn't do enough was use the screen game. The couple times they did it was effective, but they didn't go back to it. The Vikings screened a lot to get the d-line to backdown and then hit them over the top. I think that gameplan can work again, but you're right....this might be the best defensive line they'll see all year.
-
End of the Line for Brent Rooker?
I appreciate this conversation and I think this issue is a really difficult one. A few things to point out: * As bad as it has felt, Rooker has a .691 OPS. Now, you might scoff at that but I think we forget that we're in a pitcher dominated year (in part because they are a bunch of cheats) but that OPS is not terribly far from the norm. I'm not making a value judgement on that, merely pointing out that it's fair to point out that he shouldn't be compared to historical examples of what would impress us. He should be compared to his peers now. By that comparison, he hasn't been "bad". Not "good" either, but not bad. * The team drafted way too many guys who can't field. That's the real issue here. If I'm the Twins I give Arraez a 3B glove and give him extensive work there all offseason. That's his new home. Donaldson looks washed, certainly like he's going to struggle to deliver on that price tag. Trade him and move on. That means with Sano getting some reps at 3B as well you have some room at DH to play a guy sometimes. That means Rooker may have some options to play at 1B, DH, or LF from time to time with enough consistency to evaluate him. I think Marten is the future LFer and could be a really good one defensively and offensively but he will need most of next year. The problem for Rooker is he has to fight off Larnach, Sano, Marten, Gordon, Celestino, etc. But as long as he has an option, with his draft pedigree and flashes of potential, I don't make that decision now. I keep him on the 40, I work with him on his defense and improving his approach, and hope he can hold down regular at-bats next year to see if we can find out if he has value or not. We have time, we should take it.
-
The Cardinals win 16 in a row
Yup, and you can say it with me folks, the playoffs are nothing but a series of tyrannical small samples that eat baseball logic alive.
-
Bailey Ober's successful innings management
Flawless handling. Hopefully we see more of this, but his situation gives me some faith in the FO.
-
2021 Vikings Season Thread
A really good offense seems to be true. Either way it sure seems like you can say this about 95% of the league. Weird year.
-
2021 Vikings Season Thread
It's another high quality game from the OL. This is a really nice win.