Everything posted by TheLeviathan
- Week in Review: September Slide
-
2021 Vikings Season Thread
Guaranteeing that much money to Cook was always a bad move. Running backs, harsh as this is to say, should just be dudes you grind on rookie contracts and move on. If Mattison ain't good enough to come in and be 80% of Cook then we don't have a good enough backup.
-
Pie chart of blame
I'm pretty sure half the signs from the dugout are also telling the hitters to "aim for the little white ball" and I've heard Arraez and Donaldson need constant reminders to breath and digest. Worst of all, Alex Colome will literally wet himself if not reminded by his coaches to hold it. It's a shame, I'd gladly take the league minimum if my utter failures could just be chocked up to "my coach didn't tell me to".
-
2021 Vikings Season Thread
I can get behind that explanation, that makes sense. I will say, the Bucs are as modern an offense as there is and they won their first game much the way we intended to win yesterday. As stringer said, I think the wins were there for the taking, the problem is the execution. But I have had similar thoughts to what you say here about our inside-2-minutes offense.
-
2021 Vikings Season Thread
I guess I disagree Nick. I thought the offense was exceptionally well called. No turnovers, several big plays, the run game gashed them all day long, they did try some different things and the formations were all over the place. A bit more aggressiveness in situations I can understand, but I can't complain about the offense. The defense on the other hand....some really boneheaded plays. Is it just me or did Dantzler come in and look like he totally changed the way the secondary was playing in terms of physicality?
-
2021 Vikings Season Thread
It wasn't so much blaming the offense, I thought they played exceptionally well. They scored 30+, that should win you an NFL game. It was more the devaluing of the timeout vs. 19 seconds. To me, burn the 19 seconds and give me that flexible, instant stoppage. A second timeout might have allowed them to behave differently on the drive down. But even more I think about how valuable it could have been had the offense not done so well on that drive and it was more of a grind.
-
2021 Vikings Season Thread
Ok....I was at the game and one decision rubbed me wrong, tell me if I'm alone: The sack to end the Card's last drive was at 2:19. Zimmer used his second timeout. Then the punt, a 2 yard Thielen gain, and a Cook run before the 2 minute warning. Is 19 seconds (minus punt time) worth more than having two timeouts in your pocket? I prefer the two TOs.
-
How do you define "ace" and is Jose Berríos one?
Jose Berrios is a really good pitcher. "Ace" just seems like a thing we too frequently use to demean really good pitchers because they aren't a life altering Randy Johnson in their prime. Because, well, almost no one is so the criticism often becomes mean spirited. Not always, but it sure feels like it. Scott Baker got the same treatment during his stretch as a really good pitcher for us. Additionally, I'd say the Aceiest Ace of all the Aces in baseball the last ten years (Kershaw) has been consistently mediocre to awful in the postseason. And that is typically a quality people associate with earning that label. Yet, many definitions of "ace" would purposely not count him. It's ok to have your own ace definition, I just wish people would understand their definition and apply it fairly. It's ok to want a dominant, intimidating, Johan-level dude fronting your rotation. They just number in one or two handfuls most seasons leaguewide and are virtually unattainable if you didn't develop them yourself.
- One Buy Low Candidate to Solve Minnesota’s Shortstop Need
-
2021 Vikings Season Thread
Lost in this Oh-so-Vikings loss is that the boys up front were fantastic today. Great protection and holes you could drive a truck through. Feels like 0-4 coming in a bunch of close losses.
-
Who is your top position player FA target?
Polanco hasn't actually been bad at SS this year, for the record. I'd rather have him there than Simmons. I'd rather see what Pat Meares is up to than Simmons. I'd rather play Sano at SS than resign Simmons. I'd rather see Kirk Cousins at SS than resign Simmons. Royce Lewis may be a fine option down the road but I hope the Twins don't bake that into their planning. He feels years away and is no certainty given what the young man has been through.
-
Who is your top position player FA target?
Everything @chpettit19said. This team has a ton of money to spend and they should spend half of it on the most important position on the field defensively. We have some arms near-ready but nothing ready at SS anytime soon. (The kid from Toronto is a LF) We can still spend 30ish million to bring in one good starter and Pineda and some filler to help pitching depth. As for names, Correa is the best defensive player, Story might be the best overall player, but let the big fish circle them. We should throw a ton of money at Baez or Seager and lock that position in place for a half a decade. They'll be a better fit and value for us. Resigning Simmons might kill my fanhood. Seriously.
-
Who is in your 2022 Opening Day Lineup?
By what measure is Seager a sub-average fielder? By fangraphs and B-ref he is average to slightly above average.
-
Who is in your 2022 Opening Day Lineup?
Next year? Probably not, but I think this team needs to be thinking 2023. That's when most of those young guys you mention should be ready to contribute after some seasoning in '22. Thing is....the FA shortstop market will never be better than this year and the organization has no one ready to fill that position any time soon. I get the appeal of investing heavy in pitching, but the farm does look to have some near-ready contributors there. I do think we need to address the depth of the pitching and to that end I'd trade Donaldson, I'd sign at least one guy for a mid-tier contract, I'd bring back Pineda, and I'm on the record wanting to target Zac Gallen as a buy-low. But big money free agency? Go get a stud shortstop is the way to go IMO.
-
Who is in your 2022 Opening Day Lineup?
Plus, one $100M pitcher doesn't really change the fact that the staff lacks a depth of quality. Fielding a good defense is going to help bring several of those bad pitchers up in quality too. Also....we'd be replacing a negative player with a righteously positive one on a daily basis.
-
Who is in your 2022 Opening Day Lineup?
C - Garver, Jeffers 1B - Kiriloff 2B- Polanco 3B - Arraez/Miranda SS - Seager LF - Larnach CF - Buxton RF - Kepler DH - Sano/Rooker Deal Donaldson for pitching or to free up money for Seager. We absolutely have to sign a right-handed hitting OF. Probably two for the bench. And one of them should play CF. Arraez-Polanco-Seager-Buck-Kiriloff-Garver-Larnach-Sano-Kepler is a damn fine lineup and a not-terrible defense. Pitching probably isn't contention ready in 2022, but opportunities will be there and a rotation of Ober-Ryan-Pineda-Trade Target-Competent FA Guy is at least at a "not embarrassing" level of quality.
-
Who is in your 2022 Opening Day Lineup?
I disagree, I think you get more bang for your buck putting that money into a hitter and if they are a good fielder (like Seager) that helps ALL your pitchers.
-
The Athletic: 15 second pitch clock cuts *21 minutes* off MiLB game times
The rule is mostly already in the books too! Just need some tweaks and enforcement!
-
2021 Vikings Season Thread
Best DUI cover ever! (Can't help it, first thing that came to mind. Hope Ev is ok!)
-
How quickly we Forget
It shouldn't have taken this many requests to get an actual argument with evidence presented. I'll admit, I didn't remember that Gonsalves was that high in 2018, so I definitely erred by how I undersold him. However, the two biggest problems with your argument aren't the ones you apologized for: 1) You're making the argument that it wasn't "Barren" - who said it was barren? Gunnathor referred to it as a "nice" array of talent. I think the counter argument, which has been done almost exclusively with evidence has been, "No...not nice. Quite below average". Even is Gonsalves was the next greatest pitcher in baseball, I'm still not sure that would qualify the Twins farm at the time as "nice". Especially when you consider how bad they were in 2016 and 2017 and the overhaul done to the pitching staff by the time they were not bad in 2019 and 2020. One player might defeat (in a strictly literal sense) the idea it was barren, but no one is arguing that so it doesn't really matter. It's the sum total of what was available. And, again, it wasn't good. Which leads me to.... 2) The guy you cited as evidence the cupboards weren't barren is not good at baseball. He's a total flop. Sure, we have the benefit of hindsight now, but it's become abundantly clear that the guys in the farm at the time were mostly not good players. I mean, gunnathor cited Tyler Jay in his list. Tyler Jay!!!!! You're making the opposite case of what you mean to: If Gonsalves is proof, by virtue of having a spot on a top 100 list, that the farm was good and he was our best prospect....isn't that a massive indictment? Our best prospect in the minors was a dud and almost everyone else turned out duds too. How can that possibly qualify as a "nice" group of talents?
-
How quickly we Forget
No, we're on track. We're talking pitching. With evidence. You keep taking us off evidence and just throwing conversational hot takes out. As a-wan notes....Gonsalves was our best non-Berrios pitcher in 2017. He might not crack the top 10 of our current crop. Definitely not top 5. You argue that the prospect rankings dropped after some hitting promotions and Berrios. Well, that means the total farm (INCLUDING HITTERS!!!) was middling. And the hitters were carrying most of that ranking! Hence, by simple logic.....the pitching prospects must not have been very good relative to the rest of the league. But, for about the fourth time, maybe you'll actually present some non-folksy arguments or evidence for us to chew on. So....Do you have any that counters the reams of evidence posted by Brock, Captain, a-wan, etc? If not, maybe you should just stop piggybacking on a false idea and throwing us all off the track. Unless, of course, Terry Ryan is mailing you checks for this. If so, what's your cut? And how do I also sell my soul and get in on it?
-
How quickly we Forget
If one pitcher graduating is enough to send your prospect ratings into the bottom third of the league.....I don't think that helps your argument one single bit.
-
How quickly we Forget
@Hosken Bombo Disco Note the evidence used. You are "conversationally" misleading people with a demonstrably false claim. One you refuse to give any merit to with actual information. I won't presume bad intentions that you KNOW the claim is false, but perhaps before you piggyback on a misleading claim you might want to, I don't know, make sure it isn't false?
-
How quickly we Forget
If such a claim had evidence one would think by now you would provide it rather than tap dancing around vague definitions.
-
How quickly we Forget
This is not evidence. Hence why it is you who is making the misleading claim that 2017's pitching was left "fine".