Everything posted by TheLeviathan
-
MLB gives first proposal re New Payroll Rules
Also, just to throw this out there....I too agree that the MLBPA is unlikely to take this deal, but I disagree that the middle "will" be squeezed. It's already being squeezed. A lot of guys who are not elite, but not terrible, already struggle to find contracts compared to a decade or so ago. And if they do get a contract with the AAV they're looking for (roughly) they are getting nowhere near the term they once did. The MLBPA SHOULD view this as an acceptable starting point because the cap floor would help create more market competition for those kinds of players much like it does in the NHL. Teams like Florida are now bidding up guys they otherwise would've been out on because they have to hit their floor. But, once again, the MLBPA will be too short-sighted to do the right thing. I'm no cheerleader for the owners (those greedy SOBs can pay for their own businesses and stop exploiting minor leaguers) but the MLBPA is why baseball's financials are broken and minor leaguers eat ramen three times a day. They need to leverage their position for the betterment of the game.
-
Would you sign a big-time SS if that meant having to trade Royce Lewis?
Yes, Martin has question marks about SS, but we got him precisely because we bought low on him. We bought low on the pitcher too. That's how we managed to get both of them. In your scenario, I want to be the Twins, not the Blue Jays. I don't want to sell my prospect low so that I have to pair them with another sell-low prospect to get a deal done. Those kinds of deals will blow up in your face. (And you for sure won't get much team control in doing so) I get your hesitation on Lewis though. I think I share it to some degree. I'm just a "swing for the fences" kind of guy in terms of what I want my FO to do. That being the case....I'll always prefer to gamble on a talent that went first overall over selling them for something "sorta fine" in the near term. Especially when my team is sorta bad right now.
-
MLB gives first proposal re New Payroll Rules
I think this has more to do with baseball as a sport than it does anything else. But perhaps you're right....if you are I think the place to look would be at the bottom of the league. How often are some of the teams with the poorest financial situations, outmatched badly by their competitors, and without the resources to compete.....landing in the bottom? I wish I had the time to research that right now (I'll try later) but my sense is that these teams that pop up for the World Series are individual anomalies that belie the fact that they were stuck in a tar pit for years prior. Yeah, KC is in that mix, but that was after 25 years of putridness. Tampa appears to be the exception that proves the rule: money buys less margin for error, quicker turnaround times, and better odds of sustainability. Baseball's current financial landscape doesn't prevent you from building a winner, but it's like having a mile race with someone who gets to use a scooter on flat ground and you're hiking up a mountain with a 70 pound suitcase.
-
MLB gives first proposal re New Payroll Rules
Baseball desperately, desperately needs a salary cap and floor. I can't type the word "desperately" enough for this situation.
-
Jack Morris Apologizes After Using Asian Accent During Shohei Ohtani's At Bat, Suspended By Bally Sports Network
I'm shocked that Jack Morris, an avowed jerk (I'd use another word), said something like this and didn't think it was all that bad. What a tool.
-
Would you sign a big-time SS if that meant having to trade Royce Lewis?
A high value pitcher isn't going to have a narrow band of teams on the hunt for him. If he's on the block, anyone willing to sell anyone is going to be willing to listen. Same for any prospect who has a lot of steam. The problem with Lewis is that the steam got abruptly halted. Royce Lewis, with the fact that there is a lot of tarnish on him right now, is not going to land you a good, controllable pitcher. Your argument seems to want to have it both ways: pretend he's still really valuable while quietly saying "yeah but he's totally questionable right now" and hoping no one heard the quiet part. That's not how trades in sports work anymore. You can't slip the warts by people thinking you can package him for something good. He's lost the kind of luster to pull that off. He's going to have to get on the field and show people he still has that pedigree or they aren't going to care where he's ranked on a prospect list. Once he does that? Now we can talk about moving him for a good, controllable pitcher. In October when he hasn't had a meaningful at-bat in what feels like a decade? You aren't getting that kind of value.
-
Would you sign a big-time SS if that meant having to trade Royce Lewis?
So you've got a narrow band of teams who are willing to overlook the fact that he hasn't played due to injury....that's not a sell high situation. Your argument is that this is his highest peak and you might be right, but if this is the peak it doesn't have much value. So why sell on that when there is still a decent chance he's the talent we took 1st overall? I don't want to give that up for some 4th starter.
-
Would you sign a big-time SS if that meant having to trade Royce Lewis?
Yes, but it isn't going to be headlined by Lewis. That's why he's a sell low.
-
Would you sign a big-time SS if that meant having to trade Royce Lewis?
I understand the concerns about where he'll play and if he'll hit. But so do other teams and there is no positive track record to give him anything other than a "gamble" trade value. If you could tell me you could get Jose Berrios 2.0 with 3 years left of team control? Sure. What I think you're more likely to get is James Shields. And, yes, that analogy is on purpose though admittedly a bit much.
-
Would you sign a big-time SS if that meant having to trade Royce Lewis?
I don't disagree that being Top 100 has value. But this guy has been Top 20 and has that kind of pedigree. Selling him off after consecutive injury plagued seasons and an adjustment year simply can't be a sell-high point. We're better off seeing if he's that first overall talent. If it flops? So be it, I'd rather shoot high than sell low.
-
2021 Off-Season Thread
Bringing back Weatherly never made a damn bit of sense to me.
-
Would you sign a big-time SS if that meant having to trade Royce Lewis?
Trading Royce Lewis now would be a sell-low move. No thanks, he's still going to be in this organization's top 5 with serious upside to prove his pedigree. Selling him now is taking pennies on the dollar because of a phantom problem of "too many shortstops" or some other bizarre notion.
-
Twins Options at Shortstop in 2022
By statistical measure, and this falls in line with historical trends for shortstops his age, he's not the defender he was. The stats being used are wrc+ or OPS+ because they capture a fuller picture of the hitter's performance and then compare it to other shortstops/players around the league. Meaning the numbers we're posting capture the more complete story (Simmons is a bad hitter this year) and only fairly compare him to his peers at SS. (Which, again, compared to other shortstops....he's still a bad hitter) These are not "fantasy" stats or "bookie" stats. They are mathematical formulas that more accurately capture player performance. By every statistical measure we have, Andrelton Simmons is a bad baseball player. Nick Gordon might be too, but if he's not it helps the 2022 Twins. Simmons has no present and no future in helping the Twins.
- Twins Options at Shortstop in 2022
- Twins Options at Shortstop in 2022
- Twins Options at Shortstop in 2022
-
Trevor Larnach's struggles
- Twins Options at Shortstop in 2022
Only twice in his career has his OPS been above average. And only barely both times. He has been demonstrably below average with the bat his entire career. He's going to 32. He isn't a hitting coach from being an asset. He's more likely an even worse liability than he already is as age saps his defensive abilities.- Twins Options at Shortstop in 2022
- 2021 Off-Season Thread
This team isn't good enough to have crappy special teams.- Larnach optioned; Gordon recalled
This argument is bulletproof. It makes zero sense what they're doing. 60 OPS+ players ain't helping you win a damn thing.- Larnach optioned; Gordon recalled
Ha! That's hilarious. Nice catch,- Larnach optioned; Gordon recalled
Nick Gordon batting 1.000 since his callup. If I use the RpR Law of Ignoring Sample Size.....we should get his bust ready for Canton.- Larnach optioned; Gordon recalled
Right now the only positional moving he's doing is between the bench and the gatorade jug. Inexplicable while Captain 60 OPS+ continues to play shortstop. We're literally playing the equivalent of a 30 something Pedro Florimon over a former 1st round pick in a lost season.- Twins Options at Shortstop in 2022
- Twins Options at Shortstop in 2022