Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

markos

Provisional Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by markos

  1. I think you are overstating the Dodgers need for Dozier. The Dodgers have a very good team, right now, even with their current options at 2B. I think they are clearly the best team in their division, and they are definitely in the top-2 in the National League. In a sense, Dozier is a luxury, not a need. I personally think it makes more sense for a team with a cushion like the Dodgers to hold onto their prospects and see what real needs pop up in July. If they really want to go deep in the playoffs, they would probably be better served picking up another elite reliever at the deadline, or another ace so they don't need to rely on Maeda to pitch more than once a series.
  2. For those interested, I've posted the results of the survey about Dozier and the Dodgers. http://twinsdaily.com/topic/24575-dozier-to-dodgers-feedback/?p=570783
  3. Thanks to everyone who responded to my questions about the Dozier-to-Dodgers trade. Here are the results... 1) Who do you expect the Dodgers to consider untouchable? Urias was unanimous. 56% considered Bellinger untouchable. Just one or two people thought that Alvarez or Buehler were untouchable. 2) How do you rank the following pitching prospects (feel free to include other names): Yadier Alvarez, Walker Buehler, Jose De Leon, Jordan Sheffield, Brock Stewart, Ross Stripling? Alvarez and De Leon ended up in virtual tie for the top spot. Buehler was the clear #3, with Stewart, Sheffield and Stripling following in that order. 3) How do you rank the following hitting prospects (feel free to include other names): Cody Bellinger, Willie Calhoun, Yusniel Diaz, Gavin Lux, Alex Verdugo? Not much of surprise, as Bellinger was the unanimous #1. Verdugo was the clear #2 pick, followed by Calhoun and Lux in a tie for #3, with Diaz the last spot. 4) Which of these role players (if any) would you be okay with as a 3rd or 4th piece (add other names if you want): Austin Barnes, Chris Taylor, Trace Thompson, Andrew Toles, Scott Van Slyke? A lot of people responded with "it depends...", which makes sense - the quality of the first two pieces of the trade changes who is acceptable as a third or fourth piece. For those that did pick and/or rank these players, here is the order: 1) Toles 2) Barnes 3) Thompson 4) Puig 5) Taylor 5) Who are some interesting sleepers in the Dodgers system that you like? A lot of names (10!) were mentioned in this section. However, by far the most popular were: 1) Mitchell White 2t) Chase De Jong 2t) Keibert Ruiz 6) Who are on your 'I don't want this player in a trade no matter what' list? Not many names were added here. Four people mentioned Calhoun. Puig got two votes, and Van Slyke, Barnes and Thompson all got a single vote. 7) What is your minimum acceptable trade? Rather than just list everyone's response here, I will attempt to generalize toward frameworks. I apologize in advance if I misinterpreted your commented, but I'm trying my best. - Nearly everyone who responded indicated a deal centered around the De Leon/Alvarez combo that Dave has been reporting would be acceptable based on their "minimum". - Similarly, a strong majority indicated that they would accept a trade containing two of the big three pitching prospects (De Leon, Alvarez, Buehler). - Only 4 of 15 people indicated that they would be okay with a trade centering around De Leon and Stewart. - 11 of the responses indicated at least 3 players back. - No one suggested a one-for-one deal. 8) What is your dream trade (that does not include anyone you considered untouchable)? As with the above question, I'm generalizing here. - Almost everyone's dream trade starts with De Leon and Alvarez, and then included one of Bellinger, Buehler or, for some, Stewart. - Roughly half are also hoping for a 4th legitimate prospect as well. 9) Would you consider it a failure if Dozier is in a Twins uniform on Opening Day? Fairly even split. Seven people said Yes; five people said No. The remainder commented something along the lines of "not knowing what they actual offers were, it is hard to say one way or the other..." 10) What do expect Dozier's WAR to be in 2017 & 2018? The majority predicted Dozier to perform in the 4-5 WAR range for both 2017 and 2018. However, there were several optimists in the group that predicted that Dozier would either meet or exceed his 2016 performance. This pushed the overall average up to 5.2 WAR for 2017 and 4.9 WAR for 2018. 11) If Dozier is traded to the Dodgers, what is your over/under for his home runs in 2017? The vast majority (12 of 14) predicted that Dozier would hit 30 or less HRs in 2017. The most optimistic person predicted 35. The average was 28.5.
  4. Where are you from (be as specific as you are comfortable): - Originally from South Dakota. Moved around a bit after college, but now settled in DC. What is your age (or age range, if you prefer): - Mid-thirties. How long have you been a Twins fan? - I've been a Twins fan for as long as I can remember. What have a couple of your best Twins memories been? - After being sent to bed in the middle of the game, I remember waking up my dad super early in the morning the day after Game 7 of the 1991 WS. I just asked "Did they win?". He said yes, and I went back to bed. - Alone in a Northern Virginia bar, rooting for the Twins in game 163 in 2009. Only person in the bar that cared about the game. Who have some of your favorite players been? - I don't think any recent player can match the love I had as a child for Greg Gagne and Scott Erickson. How long have you been reading Twins Daily (or were you following some writers before Twins Daily)? - I think from the beginning. What brings you back to Twins Daily? How often do you stop by the site? - I come back for the informed and civil discussion. Also, it is a place I find links to other Twins-related info. I stop by way too often.
  5. The trade would be "headlined" by the young pitching prospects. Wisler and Foltynewicz would play the role of Stewart in the various Dodger trades: a cheap, controllable, MLB-ready backend starter with a little upside.
  6. When Wade Davis was on the block, I had a crazy idea that the Twins should trade Dozier/Santana for Davis/Ventura/2 prospects, and then flip Davis. It didn't really work because KC is shedding payroll. Also, I wish the Braves were another year into their rebuild. I could see a Dozier for one of Wisler/Foltynewicz and two of Allard/Newcomb/Wentz/Fried/Muller/Anderson/Soroka/Toussaint working. But the Braves just aren't quite in a position to start winning.
  7. I think it is the 18IP that scares off people... More seriously, I would be a lot more excited about De Leon if he had ever pitched more than 114 innings in a season.
  8. Optimistically, I'd put the combo at ~$90M: $50M for De Leon and $30M-$40M for Alvarez.
  9. And the one contender happens to be extremely stingy with their prospects. Instead of the Dodgers, if they were dealing with the Giants/Rangers/Red Sox/Nats, a good deal would get done.
  10. I don't have hard evidence of this, but I now recall Dan Brooks writing/talking about how he projects the PitchFX data backwards to get the actual release point and release velocity because the PitchFX system doesn't actually pick up the ball until... 10? 20? feet in front of the pitcher. Therefore, the max velocity recorded by PitchFX would be different than the max velocity reported on radar guns. I think this is true...
  11. That poll already exists! (kind of...) http://twinsdaily.com/topic/24575-dozier-to-dodgers-feedback/
  12. BrooksBaseball has his average fastball velocities during his four starts as: 92.04 91.57 92.50 93.99 And he hit 95 in 3 of his 4 starts. I'm not sure why Fangraphs says he only averaged 91.6...
  13. Good. My productivity at work will improve a lot once this saga if finally over.
  14. I think that the Surplus Value framework is more or less correct for valuing players, but I think that the specifics currently used by the larger sabermetric community are limited, and possibly incorrect. First, there is an assumption of unlimited roster spots, infinite playing time and perfect liquidity, and therefore players that are below average but above replacement level have significant surplus value when they are cheap. In a certain sense, it is definitely true that cheap, non-terrible players have value. But I'm not remotely convinced that it scales linearly with WAR, and that role-players and superstars can be plugged into the same formula. At the extremes this is very obvious, as everyone realizes that your favorite team can't package together 6 B prospect and expect the Angels to agree to give them Mike Trout, even if the Surplus Value calculations line up. But the Surplus Value framework doesn't build in any quality-vs-quantity tradeoff, so it is hard to know how to adjust the numbers for low-ceiling players. In addition, baseball players aren't super liquid assets, so there are significant transaction costs associated with converting surplus value into an asset that will actually help the team. In particular, a good team (90+ wins) basically needs its top (by playing time) 20 players to average 2 WAR per player. If one of those players is a 1 WAR talent (like, for example, Stewart), then someone else on the roster needs to be 3+ WAR to make up the difference. Second, if the Surplus Value implementation is correct, then one should be able to demonstrate that empirically. But in reality, the opposite is true. I've tracked roughly two dozen MLBer-for-prospect trades over the past three years. Using PECOTA, KATOH, The Point of Pittsburgh tables, and my own best guesses to fill in the projected values, over and over again the Surplus Value of the prospect side vastly exceeds that of the MLBer side. Generally speaking, the prospect Surplus Value is usually 150% to 200% of the MLBer Surplus Value. Examples of position players: Zobrist/Escobar to OAK - $40M vs $65M Zobrist to KC - $7M vs $30M Cespedes to NYM - $15M vs $30M Kendrick to LAD - $18M vs $30M Frazier to CWS - $31M vs $70M Upton to SDP - $17M vs $70M Myers to SDP - $81M vs $172M Lucroy to TEX - $50M vs $75M Gomez to HOU - $50M vs $100M Two significant exceptions: Donaldson to TOR - $85M vs $66M Simmons to ATL - $60M vs $15M // Maybe teams don't value defense? One even: Eaton to WAS - $100M vs $90M (using KATOH) or $110M (using TPOP table) Two hypotheses 1) Teams value prospects for their future WAA rather than their future WAR 2) The 8% discount rate on future WAR used by TPOP and others is grossly incorrect, and a more appropriate value is something like 40%. So even we agree that Dozier has roughly $50M in surplus value, I think past trades indicate that he is worth something like $75M to $100M in prospects. Someone who is super optimistic about De Leon and Stewart could agree that they get close to the $75M number. But if one isn't (and using your numbers, maybe we shouldn't be), then it seems completely reasonable to want another significant piece in the trade.
  15. Yes. It really comes down to how one values De Leon and Stewart. And right now all of us amateurs are kind of flying blind, as most of the big prospect analysts have yet to chime in on the Dodgers system in particular or released their top-100 lists for the year. So it is hard to know exactly how concerned they are with De Leon's health and how optimistic they are about Stewart. Right now, I'm cautiously optimistic about De Leon, and like you think he is a top-30, maybe top-20 overall prospect, and maybe a top-5 pitcher. I'm very optimistic (probably overly optimistic) about Stewart. I think a De Leon-Stewart-<something> package compares reasonably well to the packages received for Gomez, Lucroy (both the Texas deal and rejected Cleveland deal), and Donaldson, particularly when you factor in the other players included with Gomez and Lucroy. I think it is light compared to the Eaton deal, but a lot depends on how one values his significantly better contract. I think De Leon-Buehler-<something> is on par with the Eaton deal. And I think an De Leon-Alvarez deal blows them all out of the water.
  16. This is part of the problem. The Dodgers are certainly in good enough shape with their current roster that they can sign a stopgap 2B right now (ex. bring back Utley or add Stephen Drew) and just wait until July to re-evaluate their needs. If the Dodgers are out of contention in July, so much has gone wrong for the team that the decision about Dozier wouldn't have mattered one way or the other.
  17. Is good player development luck? The Indians have a great rotation even though their recent high 1st round picks have skewed toward hitters. The Mets have churned out a bunch of great pitchers (when healthy), and they used one top pick on Harvey, but otherwise developed a couple of picks in the 30-70 range (Matz, Fulmer), converted a shortstop (deGrom), and targeted high-upside prospects in trades (Thor, Wheeler). I'm not remotely convinced that a top-5 pick has significantly better odds of turning into a great pitcher than the combined odds of 3 pitchers picked in the 30-100 range.
  18. Thanks to everyone for their feedback. I'm bumping this in case any of the post-Christmas crowd wants to chime in.
  19. Are you positive that the Alvarez on the table is the top-prospect, and not some other random guy in the Dodgers system named Alvarez?
  20. I would argue that every pitcher is potentially a Tommy John in the making. Where did you read that Alvarez's delivery is "mildly violent"? I've read that he is very smooth for a guy who throws 100+.
  21. I agree. For me, Reyes is the potential game changer who is a better pitcher than anyone the Dodgers could offer outside of Urias. De Leon and Weaver are very close. De Leon probably has a little more upside (and the projection systems like him more), but Weaver hasn't had the injury issues. They are both shortish, primarily fastball-changeup guys with fastballs in the low 90s. Weaver is younger. I don't know, they are close. I don't think they Cards have anyone who they could match with Weaver that would be better than Alvarez or Buehler on the Dodger's side. My ranking would be something like: Reyes + anything De Leon + Alvarez De Leon + Buehler De Leon + Anyone else == Weaver + Anyone else
  22. Sorry. I was strictly comparing defensive ability - I wasn't trying to compare him to Kubel or Cuddyer on the offensive side.
  23. Reports are that he is very slow - Eric Longenhagen put a 30 grade on his speed. I think best case you're looking at another Kubel or maybe Cuddyer (without the arm).

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.