Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

LastOnePicked

Verified Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by LastOnePicked

  1. Ah, got it. So Pagan forced himself into the closer role for five consecutive blown saves against Cleveland. Perhaps through force or threat of force? Extortion? Now things are clearer. I apologize for my earlier hasty judgement. C'mon, even Gleeman and the Geek seem comfortable admitting that Rocco's had a terrible year in terms of decision-making. I'm fine to have it be an "and the players" sort of thing, but the buck has to stop somewhere, doesn't it? I mean, this team has quit in September. Not just lost - quit. That's a real problem.
  2. I don't expect this out of any MLB manager. This task seems better suited to scouting and MiLB development. And I don't ding Rocco for this. If this were my argument, Gordon's development would easily be a point in Rocco's favor. But to say that Rocco hasn't been given talent just doesn't add up. Rocco started his tenure here with the benefit of a fairly highly-ranked farm system and annual payrolls that have been in the top half of the league. To be fair, you were referencing 2022, but I'm not just advocating his firing over 2022, but rather that 2022 represents a culmination of failures that don't suggest an ability to shape a championship club, even in the best of circumstances. And I'm sorry, but his excuse-making after the recent KC losses - where he even argued that the territory between KC's infield and outfield is somehow larger than most stadiums (that's absurd) and THAT'S why his players were letting pop flies fall in for hits, that just represents a loser's attitude. It's an attitude I fear has become contagious. You're right - there are probably only a handful of great managers in MLB, and Rocco clearly isn't one of them. Doesn't it make sense that we should at least try to get one of the great ones? Doesn't a mid-to-small market team need the best coaching available to try and offset the payroll spending limitations? Anyways, that's my closing argument on this topic. I'll let it rest. For now.
  3. Then what the h-e-double-hockey-sticks are we all arguing about here? ? Based on your read of the predictions, shouldn't we all be ready for a change? I mean, if the consensus was that this team would not contend, and they are not contenders, why is the fanbase split? Or let me put it more honestly: I simply don't understand what happened this season that would warrant Rocco's return in 2023. Maybe that's just what I need to admit. What are some of you seeing that I can't see? What about this team seems improved? What has Rocco helped to develop here that gets us closer to a title? Or is it just fear of change that makes firing the manager seem scary?
  4. I appreciate the thoughtful response, but I couldn't possibly disagree more vehemently with this statement. A winning mentality makes its own luck, or it makes change when it falls short. I mean, isn't it funny how only the "lucky" teams seem to prioritize their depth, build a strong bullpen, can hit with RISP, and don't stick with a failing closer? I think luck has stunningly little to do with where the Twins now find themselves.
  5. Maybe we can put this playground logic to rest once and for all. No one expects any fan to fill these shoes. But fans are not in any way wrong to call for change, particularly after zero postseason success and two disastrous seasons. Many of the folks who are upset about this also predicted a rough season in 2022. And they've been proven absolutely right. The Rocco/FO defenders? Not so much.
  6. We're keeping Baldelli because of past performance and the hope he'll return to form? This is the exact same mistake this organization made with Pagan, and it will have the exact same consequences. Baldelli doesn't have it. There's just no getting around the sloppy play, the total lack of guts and the culture of excuses he's fostered here. If you've ever wondered if this organization prioritizes its "insider society" over winning championships, this decision should make this issue crystal clear. Terrible decision. I predict 2023 will be another trainwreck season for this club.
  7. Hey, if you like Baldelli as the Twins manager, good for you. I just cannot square these two statements. To me, this is like saying, "I tore the airbags out of my car. I just wish the car was a little more safe to drive."
  8. I'm confused - didn't we have this exact same conversation at the end of last season? What exactly do we expect to see change? We know who these folks are, and we clearly see their results. I don't think those results warrant another year of futility. If we fans don't push aggressively for change NOW - at the very least a new manager + pitching and hitting coaches - I fear we'd be making the same exact mistake as sticking with Colome or Pagan. Yes, there was past success with both, but the results now are pretty clearly damaging the team's chances at winning.
  9. First, Cleveland continues to churn out reliable starters, despite the fact that they've been a winning organization for a while now. So yes, the Twins continue to fall far short of their example. Second, it's not so much the run differential, it's also the durability. Cleveland's young staff has remained largely healthy. Ours has not. That's what I think people are referring to when they say the pipeline is busted. You don't praise a pitching staff for promise, and there's not much to be excited about when an Ober or a Winder arrive and can only make 10-12 starts a year.
  10. I've really been trying to pin down what's wrong with this club in terms of culture, and your reply helped trigger some additional thoughts, so thank you. I'll have to find the citation, but basically there was a research project a few years back that tried to explore the relationship between mentoring messages and student success on math tests. If I remember correctly, the project drew from a pool of students who had approximately the same strong math aptitude scores. They divided the pool into two groups and separated them: Group A were essentially told that they were average students, and if they worked harder than anyone, they could improve and actually become great at math. Group B were told that they were already high achievers at math, and that all they had to do was simply maintain their excellence. When tested at the end of the year, Group A outscored Group B by a large margin. That's not surprising. What is surprising is that when it came time to take optional tests - to test their learning along the way - almost every student in Group A took optional tests. Almost no students in Group B did. Rocco is very good at supportive messages. He's kind, and he sees the best in his players. Sadly, I think that's maybe part of the problem. I don't think he understands how to instill a sense of urgency and hunger in his players. He's stuck in 2019 thinking - that this is still a 100-win team. What he doesn't understand is that the 2019 team really wasn't all that good, and the playoffs proved it.
  11. Except usually in a rebuild you gain top prospects, not lose them. If only the rebuild had started already.
  12. Fair. But I'm sure people thought this about Jayce Tingler in San Diego, too. Epic collapses usually require a shake-up. And it seems to be paying off for the Padres.
  13. Even if they had originally planned to do so, I don't believe the FO can possibly bring back Baldelli after this complete faceplant finish. I know a lot of folks here on TD think his job is safe, but I don't think you can watch the way this team has carried itself and keep him on. I'm not even sure he wants the job anymore at this point. Time for a change in the dugout. All new coaching staff in 2023.
  14. A few counterpoints: 1) Gray and Ryan are #3-caliber starters. Every other starter you list here is unproven, injury-prone or both. It would take a miracle to keep 5 of these guys healthy for a season, and even in peak health there isn't a single dominant starter in the bunch. 2) Lewis will only play a half season at best, as he'll need a 12 month recovery - and he'll be coming back from a second torn ACL. Buxton's injuries now include chronic hip and knee issues, which will likely limit his playing time even further in 2023. Kirilloff may never come back at this point, since experimental bone shaving procedures in the wrist are about as uncertain in terms of impact as procedures can get. Jeffers, Larnach, Polanco and Arraez are also hobbling from what are now multi-season injuries. 3) Can Thielbar keep pitching with this kind of success? Even so, that's only 3-4 potentially-strong relievers and no established closer. 4) There's no evidence that this FO is learning from past mistakes. See the Bundy and Archer signings and the Paddack and Mahle trades as proof. 5) It's maybe more than luck at this point. It's maybe a pattern of not understanding what's happening with players, or how to avoid repeated injuries, or even how to draft, trade for and sign players that are more durable. If there's no learning happening, and no changes in approach, there's no reason to think the injury trends for this team won't continue. If anything, this year's injuries to players like Lewis and Buxton make next year's injuries even more likely. 6) This team needs a lot more than a big move in free agency. We got a big move in 2022 and it ultimately led nowhere. I don't see any reason to trust this FO's ability to spend $40M, and honestly, what holes could this team realistically patch with that money? Sorry, I wish I could see what you're seeing for 2023. I just can't at this point.
  15. Lewis absolutely cannot be counted on if and when he returns. Two ACL tears can't help but have a major impact on his career as an infielder. If he can provide anything, that's wonderful, but no one should count on him as a regular SS going forward. Lee and Miller likely won't be ready in 2023 either. This club will be just so much farther from contention without Correa, and they were clearly far away even with him. 2023 has to be the start of a true rebuild, so take your lumps with Palacios, let Lewis recover, let Lee develop and see if there's a low-cost SS to be found, either in free agency or through a waiver claim.
  16. Personally, I can't believe I was so mad at the prospect that a full season wasn't going to be played this year due to the lockout. Really should've thought that one through. 60 games would've been just right.
  17. I sometimes get the feeling that Twins fans do more work to bolster this team than the FO. It's an interesting thought experiment, though. Trades for Lopez, Mahle, etc. wouldn't have happened, but perhaps Gray, Correa, Kepler, Polanco and/or Arraez would have been dealt for good prospects. Doubtful that the team would have rallied in August/September the way they did in April/May, but the vibe of a second straight losing year would have been buffered by the strengthened farm system and the sense that a rebuild was well underway. Come to think of it, I prefer your alternate reality scenario. The vibe would have been different, yes.
  18. Correct. He's a competitor, and there are no other fighters here. The Twins need to develop top talent and a culture of winning. Put the money from Correa's contract into an organization-wide rebuild. Don't just sign Astros' former stars - become the next Astros.
  19. Out of all of the terrible things that have happened this season, this sentence stands out as the worst. And it's not that you're wrong, either. Ugh, what a sign of a dismal franchise, when Jake Cave seems worth keeping.
  20. First, I loved the response. I think it's a thoughtful take and a lot more generous and hopeful than my own. But, I really think I'd caution anyone who feels good about these options going forward. Two are veterans with MAJOR injury questions marks (Maeda, Mahle). Two are promising young starters with MAJOR injury question marks (Ober, Winder). Two are completely unproven commodities (Sands, SWR). And two are #3-#4 starters at best on a playoff-caliber team (Gray, Ryan). That's not what I'd call a lot of options that the team can bank on for 2023, no. And beyond those we mentioned, there are virtually no top arms waiting in the wings in the minors. Add to that, this will be a club with a brand new pitching coach with no relationships with the players on which to build. So, pessimism is warranted. And it may not even be an issue of them all experiencing injuries in 2023. This just isn't a team that can stack up against the competition. There are no elite players at any position, with the exception of our platoon CF, who is also injury prone. I stand by my argument: the time for a total system rebuild is now.
  21. Good article. I understand where you're coming from here, and you're probably right about the team's "failure to capitalize." But I wonder if there wasn't a bigger problem beneath all this: delusional thinking. Bringing in Correa was the kind of "go big or go home" deal that we Twins fans have been begging for for years. However, putting him behind a starting staff of one established #2-#3 starter, two very iffy reclamation projects, one promising homer-prone rookie and another promising young starter with a significant history of injuries was questionable at best. Then, trading away your best reliever just before the season started for a starting pitcher with chronic arm problems and a closer who destroyed his team's playoff chances the year before was borderline insanity. Yes, Rogers did ultimately decline, but Paddack was almost instantly injured and Pagan - well, we all know exactly what happened there. No one should have been surprised. Added to that, the team put its emphasis on a resurgent Buxton as the team leader, and at first that looked like it would pay off beautifully. Sadly, reality couldn't be denied. Injuries take their toll on a body, and Buxton's season was derailed again, just as it has been, and just as it always will be. The reality was that this was a last place team that didn't have the pieces at SP, RP, C, DH and CF to compete in 2022. The delusional thinking was that the team could simply sign a top SS and a few bargain SPs and get right back into contention. Falvey and Levine put too much stock in their ability to build a pitching staff and relief corps. It's good they believe in themselves on this front, but seemingly no one else who follows baseball shares their confidence. The FO should have seen these many question marks. They should have realized that the previous window of contention had closed. It would have been disappointing, but they should have committed to a rebuilding process, using 2022 as an audition for young arms and rookie talent. Instead, they weakened the farm system in the offseason and at the deadline, likely prolonging any chance at a return to contention. The disappointing end of 2022 could have marked the end of Year 2 of a rebuild, with a surging farm system and a better idea of whom to keep and whom to trade. Instead, the work of righting the ship for this club still has yet to begin. Reality is painful sometimes. Anyone who thinks this team has a shot at contending in 2023 likely has a lot more pain ahead.
  22. Maybe the real lesson out of this whole deal is this: be like the As or Reds. Admit when it's time to rebuild, unload likely-to-bust arms at peak trade value, and try to speed up the return to contention.
  23. I'm thinking you missed the general point of the article (winning playoff games should be an absolute imperative for this club), but I'll run with what you might think is a knock on me. Yes, all I care about is the Twins winning the World Series. I wish more Twins fans, players and personnel felt the same. If you don't set ambitious goals, you'll never meet them.
  24. I've seen this argument a few times, but where is this line of thinking coming from? I don't see anything that indicates that 2023 is a part of some plan for winning. No Correa. Injured prospects. Depleted farm system. Buxton likely having already given his best on the field. Busted pitching pipeline. This FO has shown absolutely no ability to sign impact starters or relievers. What am I missing about this strange focus on the FO's mysterious "plan" for 2023?
  25. With respect, no. It has been 18 years since the Twins last playoff victory. If anything, expectations have become perennially too low for this club.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.