Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

mazeville

Verified Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by mazeville

  1. Eh not a fan of this. Kinda get it. But honestly this team outperformed expectations considering everything that befell this team this year.
  2. One definite positive thing to take away from the past month is Kohl Stewart's performance. He's earned himself a shot at the rotation next year for sure. And good for him.
  3. What I generally like is their decisiveness. They made some interesting deals over the offseason to improve the club. They didn't work out, for one reason or another. But you have to give them credit for recognizing the market, waiting it out, and getting a bunch of guys on cheaper-than-expected deals. And then when the team was clearly out of contention, the FO made a bunch of trades to improve the farm system. I don't like the Buxton saga one bit and it looks awfully bad. And I would prefer the team stop giving crucial reliever innings to older players at this point. But I remain relatively bullish on this front office. Another year like this, though, and I might change my mind.
  4. Hm. I think the Twins can contend. They have starters, especially if Berrios takes a step forward and Romero can play a full season. A staff starting with those two, plus Kyle Gibson and Jake Odorizzi and then pick your fifth starter isn't bad. But a stronger starter at the top of that order would look much, much better. Problem I have is that said starter would cost too much either in terms of dollars (and years) in a free agency deal or prospects. The biggest question mark to me is Byron Buxton. If he is healthy and can hit the Twins have a much, much better chance of contending than if he isn't. And his status for next year makes me so iffy that I'm inclined to do relatively little going into next year. I might sign some guys, like Logan Forsythe on a one-year, repair-my-image deal, or a DH and a starter. I most certainly hold off on making any big prospect trades simply because I do not know what I'm going to get out of this team next year. If they're in contention in July, then they can trade a prospect or two to make a run.
  5. Um ... it's basically due to the fact that the team lost five starters for large chunks of the season due to injury or suspension by the time the trade deadline rolled around. Ervin Santana Jason Castro Jorge Polanco Byron Buxton Miguel Sano I'm sorry, but any team that loses four position players from its starting nine and its opening day starter is going to struggle. Add to that the struggles of Brian Dozier, who apparently suffered from a knee injury in April and simply wasn't the same all year long, plus the poor performances of free agent pickups Logan Morrison, Lance Lynn and especially Addison Reed. We can nitpick around the edges all we want. But the signings didn't work out and too many players were lost to injury or suspension. By the time the trade deadline rolled around the Twins were seven games out of first place and opted to sell, which only made matters worse.
  6. Probably nobody reads this as this is on page 10, but ... I've liked so much of what this front office has done. I liked its offseason. I like the fact that they concluded they had no chance of competing and helped build the farm system by trading away free agents. But this is just frustrating. I like Jake Cave and think he has definite potential. I like Tyler Austin. But I don't see why you don't bring Buxton up and give him more at-bats this year to get that swing right. This was a player who had a 5.2 WAR last year and who won the platinum glove. He had a very slow start -- and that's totally on Byron, who NEEDS to get his act together early in the season; the best way to protect yourself from getting sent to the minors is to play better, for god's sake -- but he was injured for much of the year. He was put on the DL for a migraine, had his toe injury badly mishandled then hurt his wrist in the minors. Good grief give the dude a break. I would not blame Buxton one bit if he filed a grievance. I would not blame him one bit if he left as a free agent.
  7. Career numbers: Johnny Field: .196/.235/.339 Byron Buxton: .230/.285./.387 WAR ... Johnny Field: -0.3 Byron Buxton: 6.9 You're making a conclusion based on 94 plate appearances, roughly a third of which came after Buxton was brought back too early from a toe injury.
  8. This is so maddening. I know I'm late to the party, but I sure hope Doogie is wrong. Not bringing up Buxton can only be seen as a service time issue. Even if it isn't, everybody is going to THINK it is and that's not a good thing, either. If his wrist still has issues, he should not be playing. I don't care if it's Rochester or Minnesota or Fort Myers. If he's healthy enough to swing a bat, he should be up here testing out his swing on major league breaking balls. My view of the front office is completely different now because of this. As I said, I hope Doogie is wrong. But one year of service time doesn't matter if the player isn't very good. If he's not wrong, then the Twins deserve every bit of criticism for being "cheap" that they get because of this.
  9. Yeah. People forget that this team lost five starters for a fat chunk of the year due to injury or suspension. I believe, quite strongly in fact, that they have the tools to contend next year. Might not look like it now, but if Buxton is healthy and hitting and Sano plays better this is a much different team.
  10. It's a long season. Slumps happen. And frankly it's good to see him go through it. See how he works his way out of it.
  11. Oh for crying out loud. My point, because you apparently can't figure that out, is that improvement off of last year was perfectly reasonable and, frankly, expected. But apparently I have to point all of this stuff out based on your points above ... 1. The Twins had loads of talent last year with definite question marks in the rotation and in the bullpen, but those question marks were allegedly addressed with the acquisitions of Rodney, Reed, Lynn and Odorizzi. But they had solid position players, a potential superstar in Byron Buxton and strong potential from Eddie Rosario (who realized it to a degree) and Max Kepler (who hasn't); an all star in Brian Dozier, another all star in Miguel Sano; an on-base machine in Joe Mauer, etc. It had two gold glovers and another in Mauer who should have won. It was a talented team. 2. Well, thank you for that obvious point. Except you apparently paid almost no attention to the free agent market. The Twins had one of the best offseasons in the game outside of the injury to Santana and Sano. 3. And yet there are still like just five good teams in the American League. There is only one team in the AL Central with a winning record. 4. Sure. But the Twins not that long ago had one of the top farm systems in the game. This team was supposed to be a contender at this point. What did we get for all of those 90-loss seasons? 5. Who? Which teams had players coming back from injury that turned it around? Where are all of these super competitive teams outside of New York, Boston, Cleveland, Oakland and Houston? Where? 6. Well, sure. But we were told Santana would be back by May. Other than that I don't know what other injuries you're talking about. Polanco? That's part of the problem and the Twins had the depth to deal with it thanks to Eduardo Escobar. 7. Yeah sure. The point is not remotely that the teams "bank wins" or anything like that. I knew full well in spring training that this team was in serious danger of disappointing. The point is that improvement STILL should have been expected. At the very least they should have matched last year's performance. But this was a young team that made the playoffs last year and added a bunch of players to the roster who should have made improvements. Does that guarantee the playoffs? Of course not. But this team was only 7 games out at the trade deadline, after which the front office (rightly, in my opinion) traded away a bunch of soon-to-be free agents. And that happened in a year in which many of those free agents disappointed while the two players we've been told for years would be among the top players in the game by now were sent to the minors as much for performance as anything. Oh, and they have a terrible record in one-run losses. They were 4-16 in those games in early July. If they simply had a .500 record in those games (not unreasonable), they are one game out of first place by the trade deadline and are probably adding, rather than subtracting. So don't tell me that this team couldn't contend.
  12. They won 85 games last year. They added Jake Odorizzi, Lance Lynn, Logan Morrison, Addison Reed and Fernando Rodney to said team. Young players, Buxton chief among them, were supposed to take steps forward. Or at least not regress to the minors. So improvement should have been expected. And please point me to any source that guessed 95 wins would be the bare minimum to get to the playoffs. In any event, if the Twins were on pace to simply improve by 5 games they absolutely would be in contention. And 5 games was not much to ask from this team given their additions over the offseason combined with improvement expected by the young players as well as starting pitching depth. That they aren't in contention is a disappointment. As well it should be.
  13. I think the season looks very differently if Buxton, Sano, Santana and Dozier perform differently, if Polanco didn't have an 80-game suspension and if Morrison wasn't horrible. On its own, Buxton performing for the full year like he did in the second half of last year would have kept this team within easy striking of the Indians at the trade deadline and then who knows what happens.
  14. I think they were supposed to compete this year. They went to the Wild Card game last year. And there were relatively few teams that were expected to be truly competitive, providing the Twins with an opening (look at the AL Central this year). That they didn't is due largely to the failure of Buxton, the injury to Santana, and the ineffectiveness of the team's free-agent signings. But they could have been competitive this year, no question about it.
  15. No. Much of Buxton's problems this year have been injury related, not performance related. The only way that he should not be allowed to come back up in September is if somehow his wrist cannot handle the bat. He needs to get up and get some at-bats against major league pitching this year. He cannot wait until next spring to see major league breaking balls. This is not remotely a Dozier situation.
  16. I think they absolutely can contend next year. They still have the makings of a strong rotation, led by Berrios and Gibson, and assuming Fernando Romero step up. Then you have Odorizzi and probably Gonsalves (but also perhaps a number of other options). Byron Buxton appears, for now, to be figuring things out at AAA again. He alone could help lift the Twins into something resembling contention, especially if we keep getting the Sano we're getting now, plus Rosario continues to play well. We'll also have Polanco for a full year. The team will have to rebuild the bullpen, preferably starting from within. But there's the makings of a good team here. Or maybe I'm too optimistic.
  17. Come on. Let's get real. Byron Buxton needs to be up this year, taking a shot against major league breaking balls. This is not a debate. It is exactly what the Twins will do. And it is exactly what the Twins should do. He needs to be up at the major league level, getting that bat of his back in shape.
  18. I cannot agree with this more. Twins are not going to compete. It's increasingly likely that Morrison will play elsewhere next year. Find a taker for him and get Austin some regular at-bats the rest of the season.
  19. I'm pretty late to this party but I think it would be a terrible idea to just shut Buxton down for the whole year. Give his wrist plenty of time to heal - couple weeks, a month, whatever. When he's ready to come back, put him in Rochester until the AAA season is over and then bring him up in September and give him a month against major league pitching. The Twins' contention timeline depends an awful lot on Byron Buxton, and it would be nice to at least get him some reps against major league breaking balls. The Twins' contention timeline is a LOT shorter if Byron Buxton is playing to his full potential.
  20. I for one am glad that we have a regime that does not sit on its hands at deadline time, one way or the other. This team clearly could not contend without Sano and Buxton being healthy and productive, among other things, and had little chance to catch the Indians. So they turned expiring contracts into a bunch of prospects. Good. Makes it more fun as a fan and gives the team assets to use in the future.
  21. It's not "too valuable to let go of." It's "too valuable to let go for the price this article seems to believe he is worth." Those are two very different things. Kyle Gibson IS a valuable pitcher. Just about all of his numbers have improved over last year and he is striking out two more batters per nine innings than he did the year before. And his improvement began in the second half of last year when he was as big a part of the Twins' run to the playoffs as any other member of the team. If the Twins hope to contend next year, he'd be a good piece to have on the staff. So you don't give him up for anything. You certainly don't give him up for the pieces suggested in the post above.
  22. Yeah the scenario you're painting here suggests to me that you don't trade Gibson. The Twins want to contend next year. Fabulous. If they do, they need starters, and Gibson under contract for next year and is doing well. I love the trades the Twins have made and am on board with trading free agents. But Gibson should only be traded if the offer is amazing. For instance, any trade with the Brewers HAS to start with Keston Hiura, or perhaps Burns + Ray. If you say, "no way the Brewers do that," then I say no thank you and walk away. The Twins don't have to trade Gibson. That's the best position to be in.
  23. They don't remotely generate the return you'd want for either. They are both too young to trade at this point. I think the Aaron Hicks situation is the perfect example of why you should remain patient with these players as long as humanly possible. Hicks would look great in the Twins outfield right now. He'd look even better alongside a healthy, productive Buxton.
  24. I certainly do not trade Fernando Romero for two years of J.T. Realmuto. We might need catching, I don't disagree with that at all. But as I recall we also need a top starter and Romero has the stuff to pair with Berrios to sit atop the pitching staff for a long time. Romero and Kirilloff for Realmuto is too expensive in any event. Wait it out.
  25. Some of these guys should be traded to at least open up spots for young players to see what you have. So I would trade at least one starter, for instance, to give Slegers, Gonsalves, etc., more time in the majors. And I would trade a reliever or two to get some of the young guys in AAA more time up here and let someone like Pressly get a shot at closer. Depressing. I'd rather be competing for the playoffs.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.