Everything posted by Alex
-
Mackey: Twins lack innovation
I get how our prospects can create some hope, but with such a reliance on them and only one (maybe two) really good pitchers in the system I just don't see how anyone can be so confident the Twins will be winning anytime soon if that is all they rely on. Right now the major league roster boasts one all-star, one promising player (Arcia), one who had a good September (Pinto) and a couple of decent relief pitchers. That's it. That leaves a ton of holes to fill before you get "winning" again.
-
Mackey: Twins lack innovation
I'm not convinced they were the first to capitalize on the value of defense, and would argue the other way, that they value(d) defense too much (consistently trotting out no-hit middle infielder, getting rid of Hardy, who btw is a good defender AND could hit). I also think they've over-valued the bullpen and especially the closer role (Ramos for Capps?). As for platoon situations, well, did you get the chance to read the article where neither the manager nor general manager really believe in them?
-
Article: Talking Pitching: Kevin Correia
I disagree that that was the intent of the organization going into the last offseason unless you want to discount what they said as completely disingenuous (competing in September, pursuing pitching FA).
-
Strib article
There was a ton of talk in the article about a roster overhaul. I'll be fascinated to see if it happens and what it looks like, but I don't think there are all that many players that I care whether I see in a Twins uniform or not next season (even if I think it's unlikely). I think all but the following hitters are relatively replaceable: Mauer, Dozier, Arcia, and possibly Pinto. On the pitching side of things I don't think we ended the season with a single starter that isn't replaceable, though a couple of bullpen guys earned their keep.
-
Mackey: Twins lack innovation
Terry Ryan was recently quoted as saying he's "not a velocity guy" so I don't think he'd bother.
-
Mackey: Twins lack innovation
I'm glad that someone in the media has started to champion this opinion (though I'll say up until that article, he'd seemed far more supportive of the Twins approach). It's frustrating to me to continually hear the arrogance that comes from Ryan and others when asked about a change in philosophy (ie they aren't having it) when the team has had three straight losing seasons and looks headed to a fourth. To extend the discussion from Seth's article: If the employee I had had failed at three projects in a row, they better "get after" doing something different on the fourth.
-
Article: Twins Must Shake Loser Mentality This Offseason
Everyone's free to use their own starting point. However, if you want to start it when Ryan arrived, or even last year, we should really only be talking then about what he's done since that time and not before. And frankly, he hasn't done as much, but he's getting a ton of the the credit for a farm system. 2012: (+)Drafted Buxton. No doubt this was a great pick, but almost any pick was going to greatly improve their farm system since they were picking 2nd. 2013: (+) Meyer, May, Cole Stewart (-) Span, Revere. Definitely a trade that should pay off, but both Span and Revere were young enough to be part of a rebuild and their departure looks to have left what may be at least a 1-2 year hole in CF and at a clear cost to the major league club. Frankly, I don't know how much hope we should have for May to be a significant piece. The rest of the bunch that looks to be a significant part of the rebuild had very little to do with Ryan. Sano, Rosario, Arcia, and Pinto, and only the latter two have tasted the big leagues at all. So, in total at best, he's drafted two promising players and acquired one other via trade at significant cost to the major league club while the rest of the rebuild were brought in under different leadership. If you take away the draft picks as completely his (because a high level of talent would have been added to the farm system regardless of who the GM was with two high picks), I think you're left with one promising young pitcher as the only current gain in the rebuild. Meanwhile, the big league club has gotten worse.
-
Article: Twins Must Shake Loser Mentality This Offseason
I know. And it's so nice because of all the work he put in last year he doesn't have to do as much work this offseason. Oh.
-
Article: Twins Must Shake Loser Mentality This Offseason
The more I read from the manager and front office, the more I'd like to see a complete overhaul from the top down, not just limited to managers. Organizational philosophies come across as antiquated and the FO doesn't seem to see a reason to try to change it.
-
Article: Twins Must Shake Loser Mentality This Offseason
I think you could make an argument that the Twins are in worse shape than the Indians, especially in terms of pitching.
-
Terry Ryan last appearance on Inside Twins
With each interview I get more and more disappointed about how this organization is being run. In the last week, Mike Bernadino quoted Ryan as saying he's not a velocity guy and that he also held some disdain for win expectation. I actually don't mind the latter as the point was about the team outplayed the expectation by three, when that small of a number is really not indicative of anything, but tha wasn't how Ryan put it and it seemed to be another time the Twins scoffed at ideas outside of their traditional ones.
-
Terry Ryan last appearance on Inside Twins
If pitching is better than the ERA stat indicates, why did we carry 13 pitchers?
-
Gomez
Gotcha. My point was that Gomez believed he was beaned on purpose, which is an acceptable unwritten rule under certain circumstances in baseball, no?
-
Gomez
I'm giving Gomez a pass? Not at all. I think he acted like an idiot (see my previous post where I said I've got no problem with McCann and whoever else feeling like they can yap at him for being an idiot -- it was the blocking of the plate that was over the top). One person acting like an idiot does not require people to react to it in the same way.
-
Gomez
I think that's debatable,especially when it' those unwritten rules that got Gomez pissed off in the first place. Also, consider that the enforcement of the behavior was far more of a spectacle than the behavior itself.
-
Gomez
You get paid in the MLB for games you're suspended?
-
Article: Catching No Longer an Option For Mauer
Not to mention that his money is moot since it's not keeping the Twins from spending.
-
Gomez
I have a tough time with people making McCann into a hero and with the fact that he's the clear reason the benches ultimately cleared and likely didn't receive more than a slap on the wrist. I've got no problem with him telling Gomez to run or even jawing with him the whole time but once he stood on the baseline, the outcome was inevitable. McCann is not the baseball etiquette police and the fact that he said he was going to step out of the baseline after he had his say really doesn't matter -- he's not entitled to that. I don't really see anyone's actions here as admirable, just a big bunch adult men who were acting like boys.
-
Article: The Turnaround in Cleveland
I was really surprised that only two players on their roster were high picks from within the organization.
-
Game Thread: Indians@Twins 9/26 7:10PM
I assume Gardy argued it with the ump?
-
Article: Liam Hendriks Deserves Another Chance
There's a difference between these two and Hendriks -- Swarzak is 28, Duensing is 30. (Heck, Kyle Gibson is older than he is) .Hendriks is 24 has the equivalent of one full major league season under his belt. I'm not saying he'll be an ace, but I think it's a bit early to cut ties. I'd like to see if he can figure it out next year.
-
Twins Dislike Platoons
That's a good point, and when the alternative was Doumit, that's a decent switch.
-
Twins Dislike Platoons
Look at the article I posted. There were some good examples there
-
Twins Dislike Platoons
I don't think that's true at all, especially as left-handed hitters in general tend to have more extreme splits than righties (I think I got that overall information from Tom Tango's book, but can't remember exactly). An example (all in good fun): Jamey Carroll had Morneau by almost 100 points of OPS against LHP this season and for his career has a higher OPS against LHP. That's a player that was considered on of the best hitters in the Twins history and you could have made an argument for platooning him with a utility infielder. And another fun note: Despite the fact that Morneau was terrible against lefties (hadn't put up an OPS over .600 for multiple years against them) he was still in the heart of the lineup against them. (All that said, Morneau was pretty good against lefties for the peak of his career).
-
Twins Dislike Platoons
You are correct. In his case I had flipped the numbers. My apologies, but it definitely adds to the point that the opportunity was there and wasn't used and probably should have been.