Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Alex

Verified Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Alex

  1. I agree. I'm just adding that expecting Mauer to provide that value at catcher more than 2-3 years out (when it would be ideal for him to be playing catcher) was probably a longshot anyway. Now, though, they know what they're missing at least. The problem with the Twins is they aren't really good at getting that extra value in positions like C, SS, or 2B for a lot reasons, some their fault some not, but that's another discussion.
  2. IMO, it's better that they are aware of the need now than what would likely have been a need to move him three years from now when they will be competitive. (For comparison and the standard that Mauer often is held to, Johnny Bench was done catching after age 32.) If the Twins haven't been grooming or considering anyone, I can understand it is a bit sooner than anyone hoped, but Mauer hasn't been a full time catcher for some time. He might have caught 90 games this year if healthy the entire season. We can certainly hope that Mauer would have caught until he was in his mid to late thirties, but that hope isn't necessarily realistic, especially if you hope for his bat to remain elite. The chances of both were very slim, so not having a backup plan a couple of years from now would have been bad business. At least they can start to address the need now rather than when the are starting to get competitive again and lose an advatage then.
  3. Which LHB have come to die at Target Field?
  4. I hope they don't sign him. I love the guy and hope he turns it around next season but I don't think it's worth the Twins pursuing him.
  5. Possibly, yes.
  6. Jokin, You did see my apology, right? As I didn't mean to come off as severe as you apparently thought, and I chose the word convoluted carefully as the discussion was branching into, IMO, a lot of unknown hypotheticals about long term contracts and trade results. It was my stance that at the time, they weren't doing/getting much of either for the players listed. I'll agree that's a problem within the organization but it isn't/wouldn't have been unique to Ortiz's had he stayed with the Twins. I don't disagree with anything you said about the Twins or even disagree that the Ortiz handling was a mistake. My opinion is that while by itself it may have been a horrible one it doesn't go as far as franchise ruining or killing, as was mentioned earlier. But, I'd agree that it is symptomatic of some poor organizational practices.
  7. My apologies. I could have used a better word than petty, though I still think it's fair to use "convoluted" when we're talking about some very hypothetical and dependent situations that include a lot of if-then (trade value, extensions) 10 years in the past.
  8. I very much appreciate the research, though I'll admit I'm still confused by the release in terms of the actual transaction. Was it a non-tender situation? I thought it was a release after he passed through waivers? I agree it would be interesting to hear his own reflection on that.
  9. Petty and convoluted, not contrived. Petty because it was almost a decade ago and everyone had a chance at him. Convoluted because we don't really know how much longer the Twins would have had him anyway and the overall impact it actually had on the team. Sure we can put forth theories of contracts, etc..but none of that means anything as there's too much time between then and now to know how it all would have played out. That's the point I'm trying to make: nothing wrong with being upset about it, but let's keep it in perspective. As for the first paragraph, you're saying I acknowledged much more than I did I my post, putting a ton of words in my mouth, which was simply about flipping players at the end of their contracts.
  10. Absolutely. No doubt there. Of those six, really only Morneau and Mauer were signed to significant long term deals, I think the others were bought out arbitration contracts and a couple extended an extra year or two. (I tried to do some research but couldn't actually find specifics, so I'm just going by the years/numbers to make educated guesses). Absolutely, but at that point, the Twins didn't have as good of a record of flipping players late in their contracts for "good players." See the above list -- who have the Twins gotten for them? Like I said, there certainly were issues with how they handled Ortiz and there are even concerns from that situation that linger to today's team about how the Twins handle players. However, even I think it's really petty and convoluted to hold this one over them for so long and I have been almost as critical of the front office as anyone here.
  11. I get (and agree) that it was a clear mistake. However, I'm really not buying the idea it set the franchise "back" in Hershel Walker type fashion. Maybe he helps the team to be more competitive with the Yankees in 2003 and 2004 (but two wins worth?) and I don't see how he's around after that.
  12. Absolutely, but does quoting the success of low payroll teams as support for not spending make sense when you have nothing in common with them?
  13. I think it's fine to be frustrated that he was let go for nothing, but it seemed a lot of teams felt the same way. Yes, the Twins could have kept him and gotten a couple more years, but to think the Twins would have had him beyond that and signed him to a big contract is over the top. There's no way he would have been a Twin long term, so I don't think it's worth still being frustrated over.
  14. I thought Aaron's take on the payroll question was excellent where Ryan points to the A's and Rays as teams that win without low payroll but then the Twins don't really do anything they do.
  15. IMO, it misses massive points of the entire argument. And while I completely understand the value of Mauer at catcher, the fact that the team has enough problems is exactly why Mauer could move to 1B next year, even if it's only for a season. There's no Prince Fielder over there that he'd be knocking out of position. His "special" status is only necessary if this team is going to compete. Health long term is far more important right now. Then, who are the Twins going to pursue in FA that hit .800+OPS? Lets see some names. As I mentioned, there is a smaller number than people seem to think (less than 50 players last season). I'll agree, though, that it would be easier and cheaper to find, say, a .750 OPS first baseman than catcher. But, there are other problems going after a first baseman in FA, like what happens if Mauer isn't going to play C? There isn't a lot known at this point, so it would be tough to move forward at this point on something like that.
  16. I hated that exchange. I hope it sounded better than it came across in reading it because TR came across as a smug jerk who acted as if he had hidden information and that fans have no clue.
  17. I don't think anyone, literally -- not a single person, has said anything close to this on any of the threads I've read here. The point most people make is that the situation the Twins are now in that they can actually build the farm system and have resources to maintain a competitive (not necessarily division winning) team. However, they've been unable to do it and have even seemed unwilling to try.
  18. Fact is, though I'm glad you pointed it out, the distinction doesn't matter. Mauer is a good enough hitter that he be starting at 1B for most teams in the MLB all all but a couple of AL teams at DH.
  19. I'm not even going to address the contract issue. It just doesn't impact the Twins in a meaningful way in the immediate future. There were less than 50 players with an OPS over .800 last season. Mauer was 16th. Of those 50 players, just 33 had a higher slugging. That's pretty darn valuable regardless. Is it more valuable at catcher? Obviously. But among first basemen, his OPS and SLG would rank 5th and 10th respectively. If you want to use wOBA Mauer looks even better and would rank third among first basemen.
  20. Ok. It seemed implied in your stance and some of the things you said, especially regarding risk, which you just explained better as value and not hitting. Obviously, some of us prefer the risk and value long term from the short term value of him catching. Assuming no more concussions, how many seasons do you think he'll be catching 80-90 or more games a season?
  21. It's not just a small sample size issue, it's also that there are plenty of reasons to consider your conclusions from the data hugely flawed are not representative of what a move to first base would actually mean for his hitting. -All of his PAs at 1B have come in seasons where he is primarily a catcher. -His PAs at 1B are few and scattered among several seasons -When Mauer played first base in the past, it was typically because he wasn't healthy enough to play catcher. So, any hitting numbers at 1B should be assessed with that in mind. Now, if you want to continue to stubbornly believe that there is actually significant risk that he would be a worse hitter at 1B, based solely on those stats, that's really your call, but don't be surprised when they are dismissed. IMO, the "conjecture" (which at the very least is an understanding of what catching does to a player's body) is just as valid as those stats. Which is to say, neither mean anything until we see a full year where Mauer plays mostly first base.
  22. I'd love to see anything that points this. I think he uses the term "analytics" loosely.
  23. Great read, thanks. It reminds me that couple weeks ago, my daughter, who is six, and I were watching the Pirates in the playoffs. She recognized Morneau immediately -- she has his jersey. Liriano was pitching, so I pointed out he was a former Twin as well. We enjoyed a couple innings together, but over the course of the those innings I explained "playoffs" and why the Twins weren't playing. A few days later, I had the playoffs on again and she told me, "Mauer's not going to be a Twin much longer is he?" Baffled by where this comment came from, I reassured her that he'll likely be a Twin almost until she becomes a teenager. I then asked why she thought that, and she said, "All the good players go play for other teams." It made me realize not just how long ago 1991 was, but how long ago 2009 feels, too.
  24. For what it's worth, through Sept 13, 18 players in the MLB had been placed on the 7 Day Concussion DL. Of those 18, 10 were catchers. With that information, it's tough to argue there's equal risk at other positions. A link to the article: For catchers, concussion dangers all too real
  25. I absolutely agree. One thing I've found interesting, at least with Twins that have been out for a significant time with concussions, is their sports background, even if they haven't had concussions, or rather been diagnosed with them, in their past. Mauer has caught and he played football in high school. Denard Span played football. Morneau and Koskie were both hockey players. Now, it's probably true that a lot of pro players were multi-sport athletes, but it's just something I thought was interesting

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.