Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Alex

Verified Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Alex

  1. Huh? You must have completely misread my response. Who wrote off the future? I said "...3 90 loss seasons or more," as in the ones we've been through. I then asked a question: Were those three 90 loss seasons avoidable? As in, were they necessary for the rebuild? My answer is no, the were not necessary and poor management, talent evaluation, and sitting on hands is what caused them (well, at least the last two).
  2. I don't think anyone disagrees that the minor league development and farm system have been great (but only a small part of that is due to current management) Overall, the question will be wether three or more 90 loss seasons were inevitable and unavoidable for the major league club (edit: the ones we've just been through).
  3. I'd add Hermann to the list because of his flexibility. I prefer him over Doumit at this point.
  4. In the wake of some of the Carlos Gomez discussion, I thought this article might be worth a look. Latino players bring much- needed flair to baseball. | SportsonEarth.com : Jorge Arangure Jr. Article Whichever side you lean more strongly toward, I think this article makes some thoughtful points well worth considering.
  5. I'd add that "not taking shortcuts" is pretty darn arrogant just by itself as if there is an accepted "right" way to do things and another "easier" way to get better faster that is somehow less ethical or worse.
  6. Yes, hopefully they are changing, but there won't be satisfactory evidence of the truth of that until the major league team stops losing 90 games a season.
  7. People are taking this Presley response too far and completely out of context, extrapolating entire philosophy about who will startin CF from a basic question. The original question (by Labambo) was who would start in CF based on some other waiver suggestions (which is what this thread was about) A couple of us, myself included, responded that Presley is currently the best option on the roster, not that he is "the answer" to CF. That response had nothing to do with whether I supported the Twins overall philosophy but is based on available options and likelihood. I personally hope the Twins in do something about several positions, but because of both Hicks and Buxton, I don't see them signing a FA to fill there (at least that are any different from those already on the roster or played it recently), nor do I think it should be a major priority since they basically need to keep the spot warm for a few months at most hopefully. I'd prefer they go spend money and make acquisitions at other positions of higher possible need (SP, SS, a corner OF). Of course, that's a topic for another thread.
  8. I think Hicks and Arcia are in different places. Also, I've no looked at Hick's month by month splits to see how much of his overall numbers were buoyed by RH ABs. I think it's incredibly important that he is at least capable of hitting RHP before getting a long term callup. I think it's a bad idea to hand him the starting job again, but that's different than giving up on him, which I'm not doing.
  9. It's also the least innovative strategy there is and and many teams have proven they don't need it for long term success. Good organizations limit their losing seasons and maximize their winning ones.
  10. If Perkins goes down, we'll need them to grab Capps.
  11. I don't think the same argument can be made for Arcia last season or this upcoming one at all.. I agree Arcia should have been getting ABs instead of either one of those as he was clearly ready for the majors. I hated what they did with him in terms of up and down. Presley might only be starting for half a season depending on Buxton. And, as I mentioned in an ideal world, Mastro gets back to normal and becomes an effective bat against LHP to create a decent platoon. The question of Hicks really depends on whether getting MLB at bats for a player who isn't ready is helpful to their development. I don't think it is.
  12. There is some variation between "losing season" and 90+ loss season. Well-run organizations don't bottom out, imo. The Giants, for example, had two 90 loss seasons in a row in that time but weren't ever as bad as the Twins have been (and look to be next year). The A's had 3 losing seasons, hit .500 and then lost, but they never lost 90 games in the span you are talking about. The Mets have been bad but not as bad as the Twins. I'd argue that any team with a decade of losing isn't worth considering in any rebuild discussion. They were just poorly run. Comparing us to the Brewers, Tigers, Orioles, Seattle, Wash/Mon during those long spells of futility is an incredibly frightening proposition. But, I think they're fair in that, IMO, the Twins have not been well run in recent years.
  13. I do hope that is the case, but there are also quotes that seem to go against the grain in terms of any measuring statistic or logical evaluation (like Ryan's quote about the starting pitching).
  14. I get your point here, but I think it's really only the organization that is at least sounding like Presley is more of a stopgap. Your last paragraph, I completely agree with and I just can't believe some of the quotes we are getting. At some point, they are either transparent attempts to spread false optimism or they actually have a completely out-of-whack evaluation system. I think that until Hicks can hit RHP he has no business in the majors, at least for now. There's more value (to him and the team) in him playing everyday at his age than having him sit or be overwhelmed on the big club.
  15. This is an interesting theory and maybe they do (not unlike Beane in the opening scene/chapter of Moneyball, but do you have evidence of that?) Considering the resulting aggregates recently, I'd say there's little evidence of it, or at least he's not been successful in the evaluation to do so.
  16. I think Ryan recently indicated he believed that the starting staff was better than its ERA, but there aren't many statistics where they would be considered anything but horrible. I'm really not sure what they are looking at with their pitchers. Roenicke was probably a salary issue. Not that they need to worry about that terribly, but if a player is replaceable and has little upside, there's no reason to keep them around.
  17. I'm really not clear why Hicks would be a better option. He was clearly outmatched and put in a position to have a historically awful rookie season. Putting him out there again seems like a further exercise in futility until he shows he's improved in AAA, not to mention sends a pretty terrible message to players and fans -- not that they seem to care about that lately. I don't think Alex Presley is the answer but he's the best option right now, barring a FA signing, to keep the spot warm. Whether he should bat lead off is another question, but the Twins have a whole host of terrible hitters and not one of them fits as an ideal lead off candidate, or if they could hit there they fit better somewhere else.
  18. Not a need to waive Mastro yet. If Mastro can recover from injury and work enough rust off to hit big league pitching, he becomes an ideal 4th OF for the Twins as he's a RHB and can cross platoon with Pressley and Arcia. Errr....nevermind.
  19. I think Pressley will be our opening day CF next season.
  20. I applaud the author of the post, but this reference to starters exemplifies what I consider to be an incredibly basic flaw in the argument: the opposing ideas in the "blueprint" are not mutually exclusive. The choice does not have to between one ace and 4 awful pitchers vs. 5 quality pitchers. You can actually build a rotation that includes and ace and four quality pitchers. In fact, good teams do. The same is true of the lineup. Just because you sign a guy that hits 35 HR or more doesn't mean you have to have 8 holes in the other spots. This is especially true now with the depth of the farm system AND the available money the Twins have, but it means you have to draft, sign, and develop the right players.
  21. Some examples would be nice, wouldn't they? At some point a bad team is a bad team. The more I look the more I struggle to find a team that has been as awful as the Twins for as long that hasn't been terrible for a very long time (Royals, Pittsburgh, etc...) This cycle narrative has no merit until someone produces some solid evidence to the contrary. I've already shown several teams that are in situations similar to the Twins and could add others (like the Giants) that avoid the rock bottom the Twins are in.
  22. Did you read my post? Three teams I checked didn't have three 90+ in the last two decades. Sure, maybe somewhere in their history, but that's no evidence of a cycle, which should be repeatable. My hunch, based on teams I've looked at, is that only organizations deemed "terrible" would have multiple 90 loss seasons in a half decade --- those that have a history of losing. Please, share them if you have them. It's one thing to say winning/drafting talent is cyclical, but to say the three horrific seasons of the Twins is a common occurrence and pattern for any/all decent organizations just isn't true. I'm tempted to go team by team, but I might have more luck chasing down Bigfoot.
  23. If you want to continue to a) say it is a five year plan and indicate this is normal for mid market teams in this situation, please feel free to give evidence so we can discuss it further. For example, the Twins have recently been compared to more mid-market teams like the Cardinals and Braves How many 90 loss seasons have the Cards had since 1990? 1, and they've only been below .500 a handful of times. How about Atlanta? 2 90 loss seasons. This cyclical idea just doesn't hold water, folks, at least to the point where you have to bottom out like the Twins have. There are teams (not named the Yankees or Red Sox) that have been good or competitive for a long time without bottoming out multiple years in a row. Sure there are teams that have been bad that whole time, but to say this isn't doable or is normal if just false. Look up some records, please. Edit: Oh, and the A's who are in a worse situation than the Twins financially without a doubt haven't had to bottom out either. They had two 90 loss seasons (1993 and 1997). Yes, they've had several losing seasons. but they've had a lot of successful ones, too and are typically winning 45% of their games or more. So, that makes three exceptions to the rule so far of teams in situations currently similar (and one worse) to the Twins that have not even had 3 90 loss seasons in 23 years, much less three in a row (and probably a fourth).
  24. The irony, of course, is that while the Twins did have elements of their lineups on winning teams that were "small ball" and get a lot of credit for that they certainly weren't bereft of sluggers and OBP guys. The more small ball type teams, that were winning teams, had trouble getting anywhere in the playoffs. The teams that did do deep were some of the best hitting teams in the organizatio
  25. Whie I understand your point, it's more than just analytics where the organization is stuck in traditional thought patterns (platoons being our latest example). The sabermetric piece is certainly a notable element, especially as it's now a pretty basic element of scouting, but hiring from within, rehiring the same coaching staff, etc...it all gives the appearance of a stagnant organization.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.