Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Alex

Verified Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Alex

  1. With both Willingham and Doumit's ideal position being DH and both of them being horrible in the field, I am definitely concerned about what keeping them both means for roster flexibility next season, especially the way Gardy uses veterans (though I appreciated that he benched Willingham in favor of Pinto, maybe its a sign of things to come?). If DH is their best position and they don't hit better than last season, well.... The roster crunch comes in for two reasons. They currently prevent the team from upgrading a poor hitting and poor defensive outfield via FA or trade (unless they are involved) and by midseason we could see Rosario OF, possibly Hicks, and --longshot-- Buxton. That said, they do have time to move one or either of them before that happens, but I'm at the point where I'd like to see them sign an OF that has a better track record defensively and offensively. But yeah, they don't necessarily need to move one of them yet.
  2. For whatever reason you have the impression I think everything was fixable, but I don't. You seem to think I have the impression that the team could be competing for the division this year but that isn't it at all. I'm frustrated that people are giving Ryan a complete pass and making excuses on where the major league team was this season as natural or unavoidable. I'm not looking for a quick fix, even if by "fix" we mean an above .500 team. I'm looking at least for decisions that improve the team. I appreciate and understand where he started, but so little was done that we're exactly where we were at this time last offseason. I don't think the expectation of that is too much to ask and I'm certainly not willing to make the excuses you are for him about this season's team: His ability to acquire serviceable starting pitching and starting Aaron Hicks were fully within his responsibility. At this point I'm going to leave it here because we either disagree on key points, or the the focus keeps changing.
  3. If you think rebuilding requires losing horribly, that's fine. I don't think it does. Now, maybe for the Twins, because of their clear struggles to evaluate and develop late first round talent in the recent years it is easier, but that's another problem. As for your litany of reasons why the Twins crashed, I don't think poor decisions and development from previous management excuse current management from the same, or at least for doing very little. The fact that I think you can both field at least a mildly competitive team and rebuild at the same time, is one of my frustrations with the last two years. Nothing was done to improve key holes in the organization on the major league team while new holes were actually created, and it sure doesn't seem like much will be done next year. I'm willing to give a pass on 2011 and some aspects of 2012, but I think 2013 was a complete mishandling and don't look forward to 2014, but I hope I'm wrong. If the Twins turn it around by 2015/16, it won't be because they lost 96 plus games three or four seasons in a row. In fact, it will have very little to do with that. It will be mostly because they had success with international talent signed prior to those years, trades, and any free agent signings. Buxton looks like he will play a role but it's hard to say with the other top picks in that timeframe.
  4. Again, though the Reds didn't bottom out like the Twins have. Fair point on San Fran. I was going based off a comparison, perhaps in another thread or article that someone else made of teams that we should emulate. All I was attempting was to show that the seasons the Twins have gone through are not necessary to rebuild, and I think that's pretty clear that they don't. Sure, some teams do, and some teams are just poorly run organizations, but I'd argue that the almost complete inaction of the front office is why the Twins are where they are and not some sort of magical baseball cycle.
  5. To be fair, I was referring to your use of "three years" which I thought referred to the opening three years of Target Field, and the year I was talking about should be clear based on the free agents. Regardless, he had an immediate impact on the 2012 roster, so arguing the roster was out of his control just isn't quite true.
  6. Well, if you think the Twins are still suffering lingering effects from being a low-market team, that's fair. I was making a point to those who accept that the Twins are a mid-market team but also saying their struggles are "normal" for mid-market teams. If you want to say Twins are worse off than the Cardinals and Giants because they're still "in recovery" that's a different discussion, one I'd disagree with off hand, but a different one nonetheless.
  7. Sorry, but the third year he had the reins for the offseason (at Target Field) and was making decisions (or not) that affected the roster. Some good, some bad, and some good then but bad now: Willingham, Doumit, Bourton, Carrol, re-signing Capps (which, btw, cost us an opportunity for a draft pick), and promoting Dozier are just off the top of my head. Heck he signed the biggest FA contract ever for the organization!
  8. Seems that several people miss the point of this comparison. I'm comparing the Twins and their situation in last three/four years to those teams. I'm not using the Twins previous years because they aren't relevant, especially to the Giants and Cardinals (the A's have been in a worse situation than the twins current one for a long time). I'd argue that's reasonable. The point is this: The Twins' current situation is comparable to those three teams (or better in the case of the As) financially. In the last 20 years, you'd think they'd have gone through something similar, but they haven't, so to argue these awful two or three seasons HAD to be part of the normal rebuilding for a mid-market team is just plain false. And while we're using .500 as the bench mark, these teams found ways to avoid being completely awful even in losing seasons. I really don't get how this is debatable.
  9. Those aren't rebuilds. Those are terribly run organizations for extended periods of time. I'd point to the Cardinals, Athletics, and Giants, all of whom are comparable to or worse off than the Twins. They've managed to rebuild without bottoming out for multiple years over the last 20. As for Boston, whether or not you want to blame it on the manager, that's something the Twins haven't changed.
  10. Yes, in that a I think every one of those players would have been an improvement for the Twins. It's no secret that FA are both high risk and tend to be overpaid in dollar amount vs. WAR (and it looks like about 2x as much as one would expect), and taking basically just the highest paid FA is going to scew that quite a bit. Either way, eschewing FA as a rule is just an option the Twins don't have. They need to find some help out there or they'll lose more fans.
  11. How convenient! Plenty of mid-market teams or less have been able to rebuild and do so while being competitive without a single pick that high. As others have mentioned, if you're just using the draft it's going to be a long wait for those players. Luckily for Ryan, Buxton is moving very quickly and the previous GM already had other seeds of the rebuild in place before he arrived otherwise it would be an even longer wait (assuming all works out).
  12. Referring to the Cubs top 5 farm system: "Does it help us win big league games right now?" Epstein said. "No. But it will in the future." - See more at: Chicago Cubs: Clock ticking for Theo Epstein - Chicago Tribune "We need certain things that, in my opinion, we are more likely to find from someone outside the organization at this point,'' Epstein said. "Some things you just can't get from the status quo.'' - See more at: Chicago Cubs: If Theo Epstein is unable to hire Joe Girardi to replace Dale Sveum, he risks compounding his mistake - Chicago Tribune On free agency: http://www.bleachernation.com/2013/09/18/theo-epstein-speaks-free-agent-binging-on-base-needing-players-regressing-baez-baezing/ Now, I had a hard time seeing where Terry Ryan sounds like a visionary, even if his quotes about Free Agency sound very similar. However, as the last article states, he actually did acquire some free agents. They certainly have an opposite view of changing managers and he lays out a pretty clear plan for offense and the types of players he goes after. He's been on pretty much the same clock as Ryan and, imo, has been far more active, though he's be met with comparable lack of success. Now, the question is should we care? Not really. I'm focused on the Twins and what Ryan can do. To that end, I agree with stringer bell's assessment and the fact that he's been so passive has been concerning. I'll continue to advocate that rebuilding does not require consecutive 96+ loss seasons.
  13. Who is advocating that? I think most people would prefer he do his due diligence, evaluate players and make this team better. Almost any position on this team, with a couple of notable exceptions (C, 2B, maybe 1B depending on Mauer) could be upgraded easily.
  14. I'd be curious to read the quotes about Theo you're referring to. Any links?
  15. I agree but I think this was actually more than I thought the Twins would get for him.
  16. Some people continually give him more credit than I believe he's due, and that's the part of your post I was responding to. Not to mention that looking at what he's done is important in actually evaluating him. For my part, I would have liked to see a better team at Target field than the one we've seen the last two seasons, but instead we've had little action taken by Ryan on that end, and he's also made very little difference in adding to the farm system while that has happened. We've disagreed about whether it is actually natural in other threads, especially for a team to be this bad and I've highlighted several teams that avoided that did that are in the Twins position or worse in terms of markets. I'm not arguing that they aren't rebuilding rebuilding, but we'll have to agree to disagree on that and whether "rebuilding" means you have to lose 291 games in three seasons. You certainly don't have to win divisions doing it, but at a certain point they're just doing a poor job. As for next season, I'll be happy to re-evaluate when Spring Training roles around, but outside of free agency, I'm incredibly interested to see what path they'll take that will help them be a better team next season. I don't see how they'll make a significant trade without sacrificing that precious depth in the minors and they have nothing of real value on the major league team. I'm sure we'll see a couple of our prospects move up, but to think they are going to come in and start turning the team around instantly as they try to figure out the big leagues is a bit much.
  17. No, you certainly don't, but you have to do something better than the other teams and the Twins don't have many options for the immediate future outside of FA. As far as they next year or two is concerned, they are at a "last resort" type measure. As for part two, he is very likely to succeed at some point with the farm system, but he'll have done so with a large portion of core players that weren't acquired while he was GM. Then, of course, he's presided over two 96+ seasons and likely a third unless he actually improves the major league club. As I mentioned in another thread, some people find this acceptable and natural, but I disagree and see a GM who did very little to help the big league club at best and at worst, tried and failed miserably.
  18. Morneau was actually very good against RHP this season and neither of those players were ever as good as he was. Morneau, Willingham, Doumit all lack defensive flexibility. Doumit and Willingham are both used best as DHs. Factor in that Mauer catching is irresponsible and likely at 1B and you have two of the other three who should be sitting or providing major defensive liability somewhere. So having all four of these players on the roster with not enough spots to go around pretty much starts the offense off where it was last year with no real additions. I'd like to see them move either Doumit or Hammer before the seasons starts even if they don't sign Morneau.
  19. Twins picking even that up is only worthwhile if they get rid of both Doumit and Willingham.
  20. I think/hope this is the case, but Deduno will probably get a nod ahead of Gibson to start the seasonunless Gibson shows a lot of improvement in the offseason.
  21. Absolutely. A incredibly high risk player is all they could hope for, but I still wonder if the Twins will overvalue them and thus not get what the expect and keep them. But, I agree, unclogging the roster is far more important. One thing that people may not realize is that they make $10M together, and while money shouldn't be an issue, that $10M could be put to far better use instead.
  22. That's fair, but I guess I was hoping for more than a back of the rotation pitcher, which he could be with more control but time is running out for him to figure it out.
  23. HAHA. Completely thought I had typed him but he must have been too obvious! So, the five next season must be Sano, Rosario, Buxton, and Meyer and May (or Stewart?)? I don't have much hope for May anymore, sadly.
  24. I'd be highly impressed if either one of those players bring back anything more than a reliever or AAAA type player. I predict they'll be on the major league roster next season clogging it up and one of the reasons the Twins are going to continue to struggle since they should be bench players at this point, but that would leave a single spot on the bench for a catcher (with 13 pitchers).
  25. I assume he didn't mean debut. That would allow for Mauer, Pinto, Dozier, Perkins, Hicks and Gibson, but I can't figure out the other one (unless it's a relief pitcher).

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.