Everything posted by Alex
-
Mauer to 1st?
Again, that's fair a point, but I think you tried to come across pretty heavily on a semantical point (the tense chosen by the poster), who by the way, just stated Mauer's offense "suffers when he catches" not "he's a better hitter when he plays 1B." There's a lot of room for interpretation there, for example did the poster mean on a daily basis or over a season? Still no evidence either way for that as he's played significant numbers of games at catcher every season, so it's tough to know for sure. However, it's actually a very reasonable stance to take that Mauer would be a better hitter at 1B based on the lack of evidence but other things we know about catching and catchers. For example, look at Mike Napoli. He had one of his better and most healthy seasons playing first base all year. He did it at age 32 and also said he's never had legs this fresh this late in the year. Does that mean a loss of potential value within a season? Absolutely, even though Napoli had one of his healthiest and better hitting seasons, his overall value was not where it would be if he were at catcher (based on BBREF WAR). But, like we've said, there are plenty of other reasons to move Mauer.
-
Mauer to 1st?
That's fair, that there's no evidence to support it. I just pointed out that you arguing it as a "falsehood" based on 200ish PA isn't useful evidence either as it ignores the context of those PAs. I don't think that arguing he's a better hitter at catcher is any more valid because, imo, we just don't know. You can argue it's not a "convincing argument" but I don't find your statistics, in this case, compelling, and I'm normally way on the side of the "statheads" on this site. I'd like to see what he does at 1B for a full season before I make that judgement, especially in a meaningless season, which looks like it will be the case next season...
-
Mauer to 1st?
If you think throwing up those two statlines (one of which involves less than 300 PAs) is sufficient evidence that he'd be a better hitter at catcher, that's fine. To me, because I realize the context that those at-bats came, they mean pretty much next to nothing, especially in terms of future predictability. If he gets 500 PAs at 1B in the next season (2014) and then returns to catching after that and hits better (2015) I could be convinced. Or, have there been a lot of studies that show players hit differently moving positions? If there are, I haven't read any. To your question, I'm not convinced he WILL be a better hitter at 1B, but I can't imagine he'd be worse. It's also tough to compare as he'll be a year older (unless something similar to what I suggested happens above). Back to DL---no, you can't protect him completely, but if he catches, he will get more foul balls off the facemask, which led to concussions for several catchers last season, and the next time it happens is likely to be more severe. Did first baseman last season have more concussions? If so, I'd agree that we should keep him at catcher. At some point, especially in terms of brain injuries, I think there's more responsibility involved than simply what value he provides. If that does nothing for you, then consider that the next foul ball of his mask could end his career and then you get very little value after that. Finally, if the Twins are headed to 90 losses again next season, there's really no point, in my opinion, to him catching at all.
-
Mauer to 1st?
I agree that Mauer has more value at catcher -- there's no doubt. But for his health, I'd have no problem with a move to first. And come on, there there's no falsehood to kill. Simply posting those numbers is incomplete analysis at best. Mauer has just 232 PAs at 1B and most has often played 1B as a day off of catching (so his legs wouldn't be fresh) or coming off of injury (again, likely not at the top of his game). So, it's not surprising that his numbers are lower. Not to mention his peak season, 2009, he didn't play 1B at all. His 29 HR were all hit at catcher, skewing that slugging heavily in his favor.
-
What about trading Hicks?
Yeah, it's something they should try, but I'd be surprised if the Twins do that.
-
Sid's article on Morneau
Unless he starts turning things around quickly, he won't have much longer in this league unfortunately. I think 1-2 at most.
-
Atlanta's draft/develoment from BA
. This fits with a lot of other aspects of the organization in terms of risk: hiring from within, keeping Gardy, and their approach to free agency. It's only when they have low expectations and are taking some risk anyway (late picks, young international talent) that they are willing to assume a higher level of risk.
-
What about trading Hicks?
Some players are slow to develop because they aren't going to develop, so stating one player struggled doesn't mean all struggling players are destined for greatness, which is what this kind of stance purports. BTW, did you take a look at Morneau when comparing him to Hicks? They're development has been nothing alike except when they made their debut. Morneau destroyed the minors and didn't have a down year there. When called up he did struggle for 115 ABs, but that's it. He was then an above average hitter except for 2005 when he was slightly below average. All that said, I wouldn't trade Hicks unless he does bring back starting pitching, which I don't think he will by himself. This should be true of almost any player in the organization except maybe Sano or Buxton. Of course, that's why we're in this predicament, we don't have enough players that could bring that back.
-
Sid's article on Morneau
I think Morneau is highly unlikely to end up on a playoff team considering his recent seasons. He's far more likely to get an opportunity on a team that is coming off a losing season or rebuilding, who can take a risk because they don't have anything better waiting in the wings.
-
Article: Pitching and Playoffs: Farm, Free Agency, or Trades?
Just like they dealt Shields, I think they'll deal them as long as they can get more for value for them than they would get from a qualifying offer. For Shields, they got a near major league ready player with all six years of team control, much better than a supplemental pick and the risk involved in developing the player.
-
Article: Pitching and Playoffs: Farm, Free Agency, or Trades?
The prevailing argument on this site (from those that argue against free agents) and from "the man" himself is that free agents are "short cuts" and we don't need them. We accept our suffering and the suffering of the fans as necessary. Signing free agents would be counter to and might actually mitigate said suffering.
-
The Doumit, Willingham trade challenge
If by Arcia "falling apart completely in the second half" you actually mean increasing his OPS by 20 points, then yes, he fell apart. His OBP and AVG did leave something to be desired, but then, wasn't he hurt as well? As for the rest, I won't disagree with you completely on Cola or Parmelee, but I don't think that Pressley or Mastro are really in the same category and shouldn't be considered fill ins because they can play any outfield position and should be 4th OF anyway. As for this point, if we're talking about better than his career numbers, you're right. However, I was referring to a better hitter than he was last season (and better than I think he'll be next season). Not to mention that if we're just looking for a DH, it really wouldn't cost that much. "Younger hitters" is a pretty big group.
-
The Doumit, Willingham trade challenge
It may have been missed, but I'm not for trading Willingham outright. I'm for trading him provided a suitable replacement bat and more flexible player (someone who isn't ideally suited to just DH) would be placed in his spot I think it's a bit much to say there is "no" downside but I definitely see more upside keeping him over Doumit.
-
The Doumit, Willingham trade challenge
Thanks, this was going to be my next point. It's not just that there's concern over whether he has declined but that if he doesn't hit well, he doesn't have much else he can do.
-
The Doumit, Willingham trade challenge
Please note my use of the words "dramatically "and "hope." Saying someone is the second best hitter on this team is like saying, well, someone is the best pitcher on this team -- ie not much. I'd argue that Arcia will probably fit that bill next year, but again, that's hope. But, more to the point, Willingham had one good month in 2013, one. I realize he was hurt some of the season and hopefully he comes back to some kind of form, but I think an .800 OPS is a questionable hope. Until he shows that last year was a fluke and not a sign of decline (not unusual in a 34 year-old power hitter -- 35 next season), I don't know how the notion that he improves the lineup "dramatically" or is the "2nd best hitter on the team" isn't debatable.
-
The Doumit, Willingham trade challenge
The problem is the lineup doesn't get dramatically better with Doumit and Willingham in there. I mean, we all hope it does, but.... I do think that part of the assumption in trading them (at least my hope) is they bring in a younger, better hitter.
-
Twins Rule#2 on building a team...Defense makes a below Ave rotation Ave
But part of the problem with "the system" (or the theory of this one) is that it requires multiple areas to work in cohesion. If all of your pitchers are contact pitchers, you must have a lot of good fielders. This limits the kinds of players that you can pursue in free agency, and even the draft, too. For example, I think this played out in the fact that the Twins tend to struggle to develop middle infielders that can hit and cut players like Cabrera and Hardy loose while keeping Florimon as the answer at SS. When you have more variables that rely on and affect each other, the loss or weakening of that one variable decreases the final result dramatically.
-
Terry Ryans Rules for constructing a low cost, risk averse winner as i see it part I
I'd add that innings are also a hard constraint. You have a finite amount of innings to accumulate WAR so if you're counting by WAR you need good pitchers in those innings.
-
Twins Rule#2 on building a team...Defense makes a below Ave rotation Ave
Livian Hernandez had a 5.58 ERA, an ERA+ of 77, and threw 140 IP. He won 10 games solely because of offensive support and he shouldn't be the kind of guy that supports any pitching theory. He would have fit perfectly on the 2013 Twins, and his record would have been much worse. It also seems that using pitcher wins to justify aggregate ERA theory is a kind of contradiction. If anything, his signing explains the flaw in the rules, that flaw in the theory. Finally, I'll say that while I find your theories interesting and good for generating discussion, the tone of the posts comes across as if they are some kind of indisputable facts.
-
Randball's take on salary
While this may certainly be true to some extent, there will always be value to be found on the dollar as money shifts and something else becomes over/underpaid. Probably not to the extent that teams were able to find hidden gems in the past, but there's only so much money to go around. That said, because I don't think the Twins are set up to be innovative right now, I don't have confidence in them finding that value any more.
-
The Doumit, Willingham trade challenge
IIRC the Twins OF defense was the worst in the league by a lot of metrics. Even if you don't buy into those, it should be obvious more range in the outfield is the difference not just between outs and hits but also singles and extra base hits. With. a team that has the worst strikeout rate in the league, you need good defense everywhere, not just up the middle. Not sure if you watched Boston in their series but the number of balls these OF we're able to cut off and get to was notable. i also think that Hammer's defense is a big reason he has so little value, both by metrics and the fact that he's still here, even with that 2012 season. Just something worth considering.
-
Article: Pitching and Playoffs: Farm, Free Agency, or Trades?
It's so tiring to hear the point-of-view that argues against spending, as if those who argue for it think it's possible to build a rotation only through spending and that we could care less about the farm system. That just isn't the case, as others have mentioned, the Twins have left themselves little choice at this point. We'd all love if the Twins had shown themselves capable of drafting and developing a full rotation. Right now, the only capable pitcher -- brought through the Twins system -- anywhere near the bigs looks like Gibson and he's hasn't pitched like a top 1 or 2 (or even 3 or 4 so far).
-
Were the "glory years" a fraud?
Absolutely, or it's just not looked at as such an egregious offense because they're not "wrecking baseball" with gaudy numbers.
-
Were the "glory years" a fraud?
This one tends to get hard to debate because we tend to think "our guys" (whoever they are) aren't doing it.
-
Were the "glory years" a fraud?
I think this is spot on, though I'm slightly more forgiving of it at that time since the situation was far different. I don't consider them a fraud, if only because they did pretty well with the resources they had, even if there were mistakes. However, I think that some people hold up those years higher than they should be.