Everything posted by Alex
-
Hypothetical: Would you have traded Joe Mauer for Fielder or Kinsler?
Well, "consider" is far different from "for sure" and while I haven't run the numbers I think there's still more who would say "no." Either way it's interesting in that Fielder has been a better overall hitter (900+ OPS) for his career than Mauer. As to the last paragraph, it sort of shows that a player who has an unfriendly team contract, good hitter or no, is likely to get a similar player in return.
-
Hypothetical: Would you have traded Joe Mauer for Fielder or Kinsler?
By some probably, but that's part of the reason I thought it a valid question now, and I wouldn't have even bothered if he was catching,
-
Fangraphs on Arcia's Power Potential
Here it is again. I'd really appreciate some data or extended study on this as it is becoming a popular narrative. You did couch it at least, saying "early indicators..." but I'd still like to know what people are referencing when they point to this. EDIT: I see that someone did post something in the other thread.
-
Article: Should Twins Offer Bronson Arroyo A Third Year?
I've seen that people say Target Field is hard on LHB. Can someone point me to data over time, and not just yearly park factors? Target Field has fluctuated each year in terms of overall park factors, and in the last two years they have been above 1.0 for runs scored and even for HR in 2012.
-
Hypothetical: Would you have traded Joe Mauer for Fielder or Kinsler?
Those are good points about Mauer but there are reasons to be optimistic about his health with a move to first base. RC is a counting stat, so games played is a big factor. Joe was almost two points higher than Fielder in RC/27. If Fielder continues to be healthier, or rather Mauer continues to be unhealthy, then the counting aspect of that stat will become more relevant. However, if Mauer had played closer to 140 games last season he would have outpaced Fielder.
-
Hypothetical: Would you have traded Joe Mauer for Fielder or Kinsler?
No problem. Thanks for the link. I'd point, out, though, that that list is a list of the highest contracts by players 28 and older, not the 10 worst contracts. He doesn't list the Twins as a team that would redo a contract from that list, but I'm not actually so sure. He he also has a clear bias that he seems to expect FA to be worth what they are paid , but that's nearly impossible with these contracts. Teams are often paying a premium price for a rare, unique talent and demand is driven up by competition. Not that I disagree with his premise overall, that these are very risky contracts but teams certainly hope they're the exception.
-
Hypothetical: Would you have traded Joe Mauer for Fielder or Kinsler?
In athletes it can be pretty damning, and I am having trouble thinking of severely overweight position players that lasted. As for slump, it was from May to July where he hit below .800 OPS. Then in August he had an .813 OPS and wrapped up Sept and Oct back to form with a .933 OPS. But, overall, I agree with you that it's surprising there haven't been more people willing to commit. I'm not saying I would but with the mentality some have around Mauer and Fielder being a .900+ OPS career hitter and having more power I'm surprised that people wouldn't be willing to take the risk.
-
Official 'Twins Aren't Doing Stuff' Thread
I don't disagree, going forward, but we're talking about predictions here and the predictions were mostly about the rotation as a whole, even if individual predictions were off, the overall issue is that the status of the Twins rotation and variables were such that there would be limited success regardless. Consider that the rotation was even healthy.
-
Official 'Twins Aren't Doing Stuff' Thread
There were people who projected the rotation would be bad, and I remember several articles where it was predicted to be at the bottom of the MLB. The fact that who was predicted to be bad was off is somewhat moot.
-
Hypothetical: Would you have traded Joe Mauer for Fielder or Kinsler?
I couldn't find a recent article on this. I saw just the one after the 2011 season and while he mentions Mauer, Mauer wasn't actually in the top 10. It's odd, too considering that he's actually been MORE productive since then.
-
Hypothetical: Would you have traded Joe Mauer for Fielder or Kinsler?
I'm glad someone else appreciates Mauer as much as I do, but Fielder didn't get $30M a year because he was a second tier talent. I'm not saying I'd trade Mauer for these guys either, but I'd be interested to get a couple of names of players that you'd consider. Still, it was part of my point with the question is that, especially in Fielder's case, trading Mauer for one of the most durable power hitting 1B in the league isn't a no-brainer.
-
Hypothetical: Would you have traded Joe Mauer for Fielder or Kinsler?
Fielder's contract takes him through age 36 and Mauer's through age 35. Assume Detroit pays the money and they're basically the same. That said, I still have concerns about Fielder's potential for decline where I think you might see Mauer actually get better for a season or two.
-
Hypothetical: Would you have traded Joe Mauer for Fielder or Kinsler?
Great to see the responses so far and it's pretty interesting and maybe even surprising to me that there's only been one "definite" for Fielder and few other that would consider it at best. I'd have thought that with the way people sometimes talk about Mauer, they'd be jumping at the chance for a bona-fide power hitting 1B like Fielder over him, especially if they're both playing 1B and their contracts are pretty much the same at this point. Maybe that will change as the day goes on, but it's been interesting to read so far.
-
Here we go again, Duensing & Swarzak told to prepare to start...
A concerning undertone is that it seems to mean that they aren't going to get a decent free agent, but I hope it's a "just in case." The guys they've "penciled in" are likely Correia, Gibson, Diamond, Deduno, Johnson/Swarzack/Worley/Duensing.
-
Hypothetical: Would you have traded Joe Mauer for Fielder or Kinsler?
If Mauer would have been willing to waive his no trade clause, would you have traded him for Kinsler of Fielder? With such an odd trade that involves so much money, and with Mauer moving to first base I think it's an interesting question that puts Mauer's value and contract into perspective, especially for those that are so critical of him. My answer would be no for both. Even as a 1B, where so many argue his bat isn't as strong relatively and his contract loses value, I still would not have wanted Kinsler or Fielder for him, even if Fielder returns to previous form for a year or two and Kinsler plays a harder position to fill. Mauer's still going to provide more value than either one I think, over the course of the rest of his contract. What would you have done?
-
Prince Fielder traded for Kinsler!!!!
Is it worth pointing out the Tigers sent more cash in this trade than the Twins have ever spent on a free agent?
-
Article: Twins Receive Bad News and Make a Minor Move
Totally agree and I really don't get the frustration for this move. If we'd traded any other 27 year old minor league reliever for a minor league starter wouldn't we consider it a good move? Not earth shattering, of course, but a decent move. Obviously they need to make bigger ones through FA, but that doesn't mean that this was a bad trade(back?)
-
Article: Gleeman and the Geek, Episode 120: Moving Mauer and Wedding Balls
Just want to point out that Bench is often held up as the model for durability and longevity (Barreiro often does it and Aaron did it in the podcast) , but he caught just over 100 games at age 32 and was essentially done catching. So he actually fit Aaron's definition of the norm and is not an exception.
-
Matt Garza?!
How about we change this to even first round pick that wasn't in the last two years?
-
Article: Twins making a "strong push" for Nolasco
To be fair, you're talking about a player who hasn't played above A-ball, another who the Twins moved through all levels of the minors, and one of the best hitting catchers in the history of the game. None of whom are pitchers. What they continue to do with Buxton will be interesting. Not that the Twins had a pitcher that they should have considered recently and they've actually bungled moving players recently who they've moved quickly or had skip levels, so I agree there's far more to this than two opposing methods.
-
The Twins Record with New Pitching.
This is a great point. Thrylos's point was valid as well, that simply taking WAR and assuming those are the games you can add doesn't really work out.
-
Article: The Ripple Effect of Mauer's Move to First
Yeah, mine as well, but I don't really see the Twins doing it this offseason. I could be wrong.
-
Article: The Ripple Effect of Mauer's Move to First
RE: Sano While I know that Sano's injury doesn't seem to be too bad, just the fact of the (hopefully) near miss really shows that slotting in prospects as automatic at a position or making significant roster plans around them isn't always effective.
-
Article: The Ripple Effect of Mauer's Move to First
This is a great point, but it probably is a season or two away with Doumit and Willingham on the roster.
-
Article: Rumors and Expectations
Context is important, but saying people can't complain or be frustrated because other organizations were worse isn't a very compelling argument. Also, I don't get the debate about whether it has to be prospects OR free agents. The Twins are in a position to acquire both.