Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Alex

Verified Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Alex

  1. I think the last comment is true of both sides and that at this point, we're not changing each others' opinions. I wouldn't say the Twins didn't try and address their pitching depth at all, I'd just argue that it wasn't done in any meaningful way, and I'll leave it at that. The upside is that we still have half a season to see what that brings and we could end up being wrong if KC turns his recent troubles around and Pelfrey really has found his stride.
  2. I think this is exactly what's going on. Some of us would have liked to have seen more in the offseason, even if it failed, because there was clearly more out there that could have helped the Twins. While others think that there's really nothing more he could have done.
  3. Thanks for the condescension, but I was debating the following point from you, implying some of us were making disingenuous arguments. You argued that people (with my perspective) had somehow changed our opinions and we were all wild about Ryan's offseason. My point was that in fact, many of us that are arguing TR did a poor job in pursuing FA had that perspective in the first place and are now using evidence to support that. I think the specific examples are an extension of that. As for looking at the rotation in hindsight, you're right to some extent that those specific things you mention couldn't have been predicted. However, those of us that were critical of the offseason (and much of the national media, too) were correct on the whole about the rotation, that the Twins rotation would be one of the worst in baseball. The argument has been brought up here (and in your post) that Ryan shouldn't have gone any harder because there weren't FA pitchers that could improve the Twins rotation. So, the argument has been made that TRs lack of aggressiveness was the correct strategy. That last part of the argument is based on absolute hindsight (and in my opinion, false). There were a lot more pitchers than the just the three you mention that would have improved the Twins rotation. You're right that the Twins may not have been lucky enough, or done a good enough job evaluating things in the first place, to land one of them, but it's clear that the original strategy failed.
  4. I think you'll find less hypocrisy than you think. Most of us frustrated with the results were saying not enough done, though I'll admit I thought it would be better than it is. Ironically, I think, it's more likely you're seeing some people who took the stance that the rotation would be better are now saying, "Well, what could he have done?" using hindsight to justify their original position. For example.... You use hindsight here, but there are other problems with the argument. For example, there are more than a dozen pitchers in the list that would have improved the Twins rotation, not just three. Some of us point out that fact repeatedly but it seems to get ignored. Also, if you're only going to go for low cost starters, you better be better at it than everyone else, but people are using it as an excuse as if it's not his fault that TR limited himself and then wasn't able to improve the rotation. Finally, what's silly is people saying we can't be critical of a GM who said starting pitching is the Twins #1 need and that we want to be competitive in September, but we're out of it in July and have the worst rotation in baseball. Seriously?
  5. Ok. I went back and looked at it. It has a big reliance on prospects who, at best, just moved to AA this year, which -especially after Hicks- seems like it should be cautious about. I hope you're right about it because there's holes to fill to get it back to even 2012 levels, IMO, much less competitive levels. My point is, even I hope you're right about the approach to FA changing, but if not, I still don't see how these major question marks alter the accountability landscape.
  6. Good to know, but what makes next season different from this one, except that it's another season worth? I'm mean if you were OK with this offseason why would more movement be necessary for next? I don't see the discussion being that much different and it's likely the FA pitching market won't be as robust, or at least any better and with the new revenue actually available FA prices may increase again. The Twins will have significantly fewer trade chips this offseason as well. If your argument is that the Twins will be better, overall, there are reasons that's in doubt. The lineup could have as many losses as gains next season with players leaving and/or continuing to age and the only hitter I reasonably expect to add significantly to the lineup next season would be Arcia. I'm not trying to be argumentative her but I am curious what the difference is in accountability between seasons.
  7. If anyone knew Gibson wouldn't be starting the year in the majors, it was Ryan. That was something he should have been aware of, so he could have made a plan for this. The argument was often made that additional signings would block Gibson. Of course, we have at least two spots that could open even after he has been called up. Most of us, thought that Diamond would be considerably worse this season, though arguably not as bad as he was. His early numbers were too good to be true but his end of the season numbers should have been a warning. Worley is certainly a disappointment, and those of us who can only view numbers certainly hoped for better, but I would hope Ryan would have been able to make a better decision with more information than that. Of course, maybe he's been hurt all season. No matter how we cut it, results or prediction, there wasn't a ton of hope for this starting staff, so IMO, those backing TR here don't have that much to stand on unless, of course, not a single GM in the league improved his rotation through FA this season?
  8. I'd settle for them being better. It makes it easier to upgrade next year as well rather than start from the exact same point this offseason as last offseason. Not to mention overall options (trades) become better with better players.
  9. If you are just arguing the top three, then fine, but there were a lot more that would have been upgrades to our current staff.
  10. Ok, even if we give him some credit for recognizing what may have been a crap shoot, it's worth remembering that even he recognized starting pitching as problem #1 and that FA was going to be one way to look at fixing it (he said this in multiple interviews). I just have a very hard time giving him a pass when the starting staff has been bad for three years and they have not used assets to improve it. They've sat on money, held onto players they probably should have traded (and still are), re-signed a player when letting him go would have netted a draft pick (Capps), and have mis-evaluated what talent they have and talent have acquired to some extent. Now, this thread is about FA, so we'll stick to that, but there are pitchers out there that did succeed and it would have been nice to see the Twins at least take some risks or make a better effort than they did (I think you'd see many of us far more forgiving if they did), considering the money they had. Ryan on interviews seemed shellshocked by the amount pitchers were getting and rather than recognize it as the changing landscape backed completely off and sealed this season's demise as well.
  11. So far, one of the two parties is doing a better job
  12. Agreed, no one should have been expecting a massive improvement (and after the offseason most weren't) but the rotation is actually worse and that with two better situations from last season: no significant injuries and a much improved up the middle defense. One would expect on those factors alone, the pitching should be better.
  13. By extension anyone could, and a lot of better hitting 1B wwild
  14. RBI production is often a function of lineup position. Batting, for example, behind one of the league's best hitters. Coincidentally, it's also the reason our best hitter has so few RBIs, because he's consistently hitting behind a leadoff position that has been pretty terrible.
  15. What's a reasonable contract for one of the league's worst hitting first basemen? I am asking seriously, even though I think it's a bad idea to sign him at all, especially as we might be adding Plouffe's name to the list of players that might be fighting for time there.
  16. If we're honest with ourselves, both holding onto Morneau for the rest of the season and/or extending him are bad baseball moves. I love Morneau, but there are enough players in the organization that we have that can play first base and have at least comparable overall production.
  17. Interesting that this is what we label as a gamble here (no offense to the person that said it) and exactly what some of us are talking about when we mention low risk. Pelfrey had very little upside even if healthy and was signed to a relatively cheap contract. Overall I liked the signing, just as I would have been fine with another pitcher who shall not be named, too, had it been for back of the rotation filling. Instead, these low risk/low upside moves were the spearhead for turning this ML worst rotation around (or not, as we've now seen). Context is everything.
  18. I meant in terms of GMs, every one of them is going to prefer low risk/high reward strategies when given an option. My point was that at best, Ryan tends to go with low risk/marginal reward, especially in FA. The Twins need someone who is willing to take bigger risks on players with higher upside than what Ryan has done so far. Mauer's contract is a great discussion point because it's not something he would likely have done or do now (though tough to know) but the Twins have gotten their money's worth so far.
  19. Everyone is low risk/high reward. The problem with Ryan is he is never willing to take a shot a high risk/high upside player. I'd argue that Ryan is overall, low risk/marginal reward type spender and every once in awhile there is a big hit, that hasn't lasted or hasn't been returned for value. The only place he's arguably done that is in the pen (Burton, Fien) where you have the lowest value and most transitional players, and there were plenty of failures there besides those two in the last couple of seasons.
  20. Well, for my money regarding Meyer, I'd much rather have him shut down than how the organization often handles injuries. Hopefully they got this right from the start and he doesn't need surgery or something.
  21. People tend to have less impact on a game (by your measures) when the players ahead of them don't geton in front of them, especially true during his hottest hitting streak of the season, and it's tough to score when you don't really have anyone hitting behind you, but despite that, as pointed out, he's still scoring more runs than anyone else on the team. Edit: While I'm not sure this is a stat you care about, Mauer has the highest Win Probability Added on the team. It's not saying much this season, and he is lower than last year, but it's pretty ridiculous to be critical of him, IMO.
  22. It's probably partially that but also because, as mentioned, that he has hit more balls in the air and is striking out more. I actually think the notion he's change his approach is dead wrong, btw. I think he has, and the numbers are a result of it not working as well with RISP or he's just having bad luck. On the other hand, it doesn't matter what he does, people were criticizing him for it last season, too when he was pretty damn good at it.
  23. The irony with this lineup, of course, is that if he's batting third, he's likely got two guys in front of him that can't get on base so he comes up with two outs. IMO, it never makes sense to give your worst hitters more at bats by placing them at the top of the lineup. I don't mind Carroll at the top, though, and hopefully Dozier continues to hit.
  24. The DH allows the great hitters of the game to stay a bit longer, and I think that's a good thing, even if there is something elegant about making everyone hit. One of the best reasons I've seen for everyone going to the same rule is not only the above idea but the fact that AL teams often give significant cash to one of their best hitters but they end up often having to sit him regularly and maybe even in key games down the stretch with the new schedule. This, combined with the idea above, even without the fact that I'm partial to seeing players do what they are good at, would put me in the camp where I'd like to see DH rule as common.
  25. He's played 32 games at catcher and 12 at DH, so it's not like they're inflating the value that much. Honestly, I'd prefer he didn't play catcher at all this season. But to also be fair, a .900+ OPS is going to be darn valuable wherever you play. But I agree, the travesty is the inability to build around him.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.