Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Alex

Verified Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Alex

  1. While I advocating signing a MI because I didn't think Dozier would really be a regular starter in the majors, they put him out there and let him play and it looks like I'll be wrong about that, which I'm more than happy to admit. I don't get why they haven't applied this philosophy with other players mentioned who have shown that they can hit AAA pitching.
  2. I don't see how this is debatable, honestly. Going back to 2011, the only significant trade(s) the team has made to help bring in young talent is to trade young major league talent (Span, Revere). They let a handful of veterans walk for nothing at that time (Nathan, Cuddyer, Kubel). It's looking unlikely that they will get anything out of their veteran FA signings from our recent offseasons Willingham, Doumit, Carroll, Correa, Pelfrey) or for Morneau, who will be leaving shortly. If they wanted players to help with a 2014 or even 2015 rebuild those players would have ideally brought something back already. Anything they bring back now will likely be further out that that, and it's far more likely they bring back nothing at all of value. Maybe that's true to some extent, but they've only been treading water these last two seasons and have shown minimal improvement-- the FA they've signed haven't helped them much -- they're not really better off and certainly don't look to be climbing out of anything. In fact, the opposite may be true if Willingham and Doumit have similar seasons next year. Who and where do you see them signing this offseason that could help be part of that? The only bet I'd make is that they sign a veteran 1B. Beyond that, I really don't see them signing anyone and I bet they again leave the FA SP market alone, or at least don't make any signings of significance.
  3. I think I realized part of the contention here is maybe the term "blocked." With the exception of Colabello, who I think has earned a chance at regular playing time, it's probably true that no one is really legitimately blocked. That is different than finding out what players can do in the majors, and that would be worthwhile for players many have mentioned. It was, in fact, a major point people made in giving Dozier a chance to play this year. Carroll probably deserved the spot over him at 2B to start the season, but Carroll wasn't really part of long term plans and so ended up on the bench much of the season. I don't understand why the front office and the manager don't apply this philosophy in a couple of other spots.
  4. And all this goes back to the main question: How do you a grade a rebuild? The Twins have not done a good job turning over veterans for prospects at the right times, and those veterans haven't really helped them field an even somewhat competitive team during the rebuild. They haven't done a good job of signing free agents that will help them get out of the rebuild more quickly or even really bridge the gap to a future team. Besides Dozier possibly, they haven't properly identified/developed/given a chance to younger players that can take over a position and make use of valuable major league time. The most successful aspect of the rebuild is in acquiring talent by trading already cost controlled and relatively young players in Revere and Span. They've done a good job of making smart decisions in the draft. For me, measuring how well a rebuild goes is how quickly it looks like the Twins are going to get out of it. At this point, their decision making with the major league team has been painfully slow and awful, but they've done a decent job strengthening the minor league system. This makes the rebuild a passive one that will be a significant wait.
  5. The problem is, these Twins veterans that are being talked about are not playing much above an AAAA level themselves and they are regularly starting. Doumit is the biggest example of this because he is hitting the worst and has no asset to provide besides his bat (though he can sit behind the plate), but it includes Willingham and to some extent Morneau this year (but certainly includes any talk of re-signing him). It's baffling to me to argue that they should be playing over comparable players that are younger and could have a longer future with the team is the issue. What sense does this make? If they had any trade value this season, wouldn't we be arguing they should have been moved? Instead, since no one else wants them, the position is that they should play for the Twins regularly? Now, I'm not arguing we cut bait on all of them, but a team that is rebuilding should not have all three of these guys on their roster. Willingham will need to be a more permanent DH next season. This really squeezes Doumit because Hermann is far more versatile, is certainly a better backup catcher, and is hitting almost as well as Doumit. This leaves Doumit in the outfield, which is not really a position he's suited for, not to mention, Parmelee got sent back to AAA for hitting about exactly what Doumit is hitting now.
  6. Again, I'm not arguing that. But you've pointed what is arguably another mistake in what should have been part of the rebuilding process. They signed a 32-year old player to a two year deal in late June during a losing season. A great take here: Ryan Doumit extension shows Twins still living in the past | HardballTalk Here's a quote from it that sums it up pretty well: "Ignoring for a moment the fact that the Twins seem to be working to keep together their probable 95-loss team, smart clubs don’t give out multiyear deals unless there’s real upside to them."
  7. Not arguing that point, and I agree on the Twins use of him, but was debating the selling high point. Doumit had probably his second best season in 2012 and turns 33 next season? Of course, it wouldn't have been terrible if they got something for him,ast year and had Butera catching Mauer's off days the last half ofthe season.
  8. Selling high would have meant trading him last year. That's the problem, that the Twins in recent history haven't done a good job of selling players at their peak value with the team.
  9. Then we're in for a long wait. Ryan won't spend the money for one and I don't think they'll be willing to give up what it requires -- and neither will the fans if they can't stomach a Sano for Sale type trade that was floated hypothetically in the media last week or something similar.
  10. The fact that we didn't trade Morneau has nothing to do with those players. His level of play has been poor and the Twins didn't want to eat his salary, and thus were asking too much for him by hoping to get anything back. My point is if you really think The Twins are in a position where their best option is to play Doumit in the starting lineup on a regular basis over evaluating a younger player in the majors, the Twins are in an incredibly dire position. Colabello, at least, while having a rough 100 ABs had certainly earned a longer look with the dominance he showed in AAA. More than that, there are other reasons he should be getting as many ABs as possible against major league pitching.
  11. I like Doumit from a flexibility standpoint, but, wow, if we really don't have a player that is younger and more likely part of the future that we don't want to give playing time to on a regular basis over his putrid hitting and horrible defense, the Minnesota Twins are in an incredibly bad state.
  12. Oh, and the really frustrating thing is to see a future hall of famer prime years wasted during this rebuild that is going to take longer because of that low risk approach to free agency and an inability to sell high on veterans.
  13. I have a hard time with this rebuild. I like the depth of the farm system, but I've been very frustrated with the approach to free agency, which then bleeds into their trading. They don't acquire talent that might interest another team at the deadline and haven't really sold high on anyone in the last couple of years.
  14. And they should maintain that with another high pick next year (Last I saw after picks were signed, they were #2 behind the Astros, but not a big difference). I won't argue that Ryan has been bad, but a lot of that is because of inherited players (Sano, obv, and Rosario) and inherited situation, ie being bad multiple years and getting multiple high picks. To his credit, he did add May and Meyer, but at some point, he needs to make the big league club better, and that doesn't look like it will happen anytime soon.
  15. If I'm doing my math right, Hendriks has faced around 500 MLB batters and most of those were prior to age 24. I'm not saying he's going to be great, but he deserves a much longer look.
  16. And so is positional value!
  17. Interesting segment on FoxN in the pregame about the masks catchers wear and Hermann observed that many of the catchers getting concussions wear the same, light weight mask.
  18. You are really mixing the arguments and points here. The more games Mauer is able to play catcher the more valuable he is. There's a balance between what the right number is that will keep him healthy and effective. This really only matters if the Twins are competitive. It's when they are competitive that there is reason to play him at catcher. For now, there's really no point to putting wear and tear on his legs.
  19. Ryan of course did re-sign Capps instead of taking the supplemental pick. But the trade was still part of an organizational philosophy, one that Nick pointed out, and I think less about an individual GM than that overall approach.
  20. Fair enough. I agree that at this point it would be difficult to get concrete evidence about an inability to get trade value because maybe that's true of everyone, but that is just one specific concern regarding larger concerns that Ryan (and the front office in general) may be stuck, to some extent, in the past.
  21. No, but you made the comparison to other teams first. If you're going to make statements like "by far" and put "far" in bold, I'd assume you have numbers or read something somewhere that support your point. All I asked was who we were discussing as I wasn't sure who I could be missing in the current Terry Ryan era, or if we were talking about the previous, which, again, has no real relevance to me at this point -- and that was my main point.
  22. As I added in my edit, I assumed that you're talking about the past here, which is less relevant now for a lot of reasons. One of which, while not part of this discussion, is that teams are valuing prospects far more than they used to. Relevant to this discussion may be that teams are using better evaluative tools now then they were at the time. While I'll agree he was good at it in his first go round, I'd agree with ThePuck that simply calling it above average and using the words "far more" than other teams without a basis for comparison isn't really helpful, especially when you consider that the Twins were often trading away veterans they couldn't sign for prospects, not something that has happened here all that much lately. In fact, this is a major concern that a lot of people have that Ryan has done little to disprove so far: In a lot of areas (evaluation, free agency, trading), the landscape has changed but that Ryan hasn't.
  23. Help me out. Who are we talking about here? Or are we referring to his past tenure, which I think is becoming less and less relevant, especially in this discussion.
  24. I just want to add that it's a strawman argument to say those of us advocating more statistical evaluation means we want less scouting.
  25. Yeah, and it's pretty clear it's on his own. Diamond talked about how Perk was the one talking to him about that. It wasn't his pitching coach, it was another player that was taking the initiative. More evidence that it's not an organizational philosophy.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.