Everything posted by Alex
-
Article: The Mysterious Lost Season of Aaron Hicks
We aren't talking about a prospect that was tearing up every level he'd been at. Even the season after his promotion was good, not dominating. As for BA, predicting who would be the opening day CF and what the Twins should have done are two different things. I think most people understood, the way the the front office was putting out information and talking about Hicks, even before spring training, that he was the front-runner.
-
Article: The Mysterious Lost Season of Aaron Hicks
The point was both could easily hold a spot for a month or two and certainly wouldn't have been worse than Hicks. They also could have signed someone -- they had the money to do so. In the end, they went with a combination of Thomas and, sometimes, Wilkin Ramirez. Definitely not a winning combination but it was better than Hicks and had they not locked themselves into Hicks, they certainly could have had better options. If you still think that calling Hicks up was the right move over that, I'm not sure what to tell you.
-
Article: The Mysterious Lost Season of Aaron Hicks
Easy to criticize now? A lot of us were criticizing it at the time. We've seen plenty of examples where spring training numbers don't matter and don't show anything, and certainly shouldn't be valued over a much larger sample like minor league performance. I also think they were planning on starting him regardless -- unless he was horrible. They had Clete Thomas and Antoan Richardson in the minors. There was no real reason they HAD to go with Hicks from the start, nor was there a reason they had to stay with him as long as they did. They could have gone with them for a month until they were sure Hicks would be ready. EDIT: I realize maybe you're referring to leadoff, that was a bigger team construction issue. They had a ton of unproven hitters in the lineup and very few on base guys that would fit there (and not in the middle of the order). Additionally, If Gardy is so stuck in his ways about lineup construction, I'm definitely ready for someone else's new approach.
-
Article: The Mysterious Lost Season of Aaron Hicks
In Nick Nelson's article about calling Hicks up, I mentioned a major red flag. There were other concerns but for me it was his strikeout levels. He's never struck out less than once every five PAs and I thought that was a massive signal he wasn't ready, especially a player with his skillset. At best, he'd be comparable, but jumping two levels it was far more likely that he'd end up striking out more -- and not just more a lot more. This turned out to be the case and in the majors, he struck out once nearly every three times at the plate. So, I'd agree with Shane that it wasn't as shocking or mysterious.
-
Game Thread: Rays@Twins 9/15 1:10PM
I'd forgotten what he looked like. Also, I wondered if they had to call him from home.
-
Game Thread: Rays@Twins 9/15 1:10PM
The finale to my own personal trilogy today (after these two games) will be the latest episode of Breaking Bad....somehow it seems fitting.
-
Game Thread: Rays@Twins 9/15 1:10PM
For Minnesota fans, currently just another opportunity to wallow in frustration and despair.
-
Game Thread: Rays@Twins 9/15 1:10PM
Fun with numbers: More posts here than fans at the stands by the ninth? FYI, Chicago Cubs in 1968 apparently did not score in 48 innings. They also were shut out 4 times in a row which has happened 11 more times since then. We're threatening now, though...but a K and DP should do the trick.
-
Game Thread: Rays@Twins 9/15 1:10PM
So, lose in the closing seconds in Chicago and back at Target Field the Twins now have how many scoreless innings?
-
Pohlad "Willing to spend any amount of money on a current year contract"
If the player is getting a qualifying offer, he probably is substantial and, as mentioned, the fact that they are attached to a draft pick becomes part of the game and, at least last year, lowered the haul that most of them got. I'd argue that people are overvaluing prospects. A 2nd Rd pick has something like of 49% chance of even making the majors. That's a 51% chance that they'll never see the big league field. I'm not sure what the chance they become a valuable player is but that's much lower. The Twins have a well stocked farm system and a lot of extra cash. I think giving up a 2nd round pick for a reliable, proven major leaguer at this point is worth the chance. I'm not saying they throw the money away, but at this point, I'd have no problem with it. If they get better, to the point where their first round pick is unprotected because they've moved down a few spots, this opportunity is lost (and frankly, I hope that's the case soon).
-
Article: Eddie Rosario as a Trade Chip
He's been great in the field all year. His bat has only been good a couple of months.
-
Article: Eddie Rosario as a Trade Chip
So, what's your limit?
-
Article: Eddie Rosario as a Trade Chip
The hype is relative, though. The hype on Buxton is that he will be Mike Trout or better. The hype on Sano is that he's going to hit 40+HR a year and will be one of the best power hitters the organization has ever seen. Both of the these players could fall short of that and still be regular players, though. Hopefully it's not the worst case scenario, of course, where they don't manage even that.
-
Article: Eddie Rosario as a Trade Chip
-3.6 UZR there last season in 80 games. Project that out to a full season and that a -7ish UZR for a full season. Those numbers would make him one of the worst three (qualified) SS this season.
-
Article: Terry Ryan Discusses Ron Gardenhire's Future
I don't disagree with the exception of 2B, C, and CL
-
Article: Terry Ryan Discusses Ron Gardenhire's Future
An interesting comparisons might've to look at last year's defense vs. this year's. The OF wasn't as good without Span and Revere, but up the middle infield was improved greatly -- best combo In the league by some metrics. So, I'm not convinced the "it's not the pitcher's fault" really flies.
-
Article: Terry Ryan Discusses Ron Gardenhire's Future
I agree. It comes across as pathetic excuse making and just not owning up. I'm sure it's because he can't just come out and say he made huge mistakes, but anyone should be able to read between the lines here -- that or he comes across as pretty mule-headed about the real reasons the Twins are terrible. I'd like to see how the Twins actually rank up when looking at injuries. I mean, relatively recent injuries (like those to Deduno and Mauer) occurred after the wheels had come off. The team has been incredibly healthy at almost every spot, especially when compared to two years ago. Willingham is the only exception, and he'll still end up with 500 PAs, not to mention he's not a 10 win guy. The bottom line is that there went into this season aging players who looked older this, hopes at 3B and RF that missed, a rookie CF who was not at all prepared, a 1B who was a shell of his former self, and a starting staff that was a lottery ticket where the max win was $10.
-
Article: Terry Ryan Discusses Ron Gardenhire's Future
So you're saying if he had better players he'd manage better?
-
What willl it take to make this year a successful year?
First, was that the primary purpose of the season -- especially as the front office was concerned? Second, developing players and being competitive are not mutually exclusive. The Twins could have fielded a more competitive team AND still had these players develop because -- as someone else mentioned -- most of them have nothing to do with the major league team. Most of those players would have had a chance to develop exactly the same way, especially the important ones (Sano, Buxton, Meyer), whether or not the Twins had brought in more talent at almost any position that merited an upgrade with the exception of 2B. Dozier had a rough season and looked replaceable but sticking with him has paid off and surprised many of us. Also, I don't think anyone has complained about the Twins minor league system. But, it would certainly have been nice to see both a more competitive team and/or a more active approach to make the team better.
-
Article: Why the Twins Will Spend This Offseason
Or you can be a fan regardless and share your frustrations about the way the team is run.
-
Article: Why the Twins Will Spend This Offseason
I believe they are getting that number from and interview and direct quote from the Twins organization, so it's probably a guideline for Ryan.
-
26 year old Cuban SS Alexander Guerrero
Cuddyer and Willingham have almost exactly flip-flopped OPS+ numbers (which account for park differences) between this year and last. I think it's worth caring about the value you get out of a contract when you have a team at or near its own cap. However, at this point, the focus of the team in FA should be adding better players. If they have to overpay a bit, they should.
-
Article: Why the Twins Will Spend This Offseason
I think the payroll for next year drop by 5-10 million but it's possible it will drop by $15M. At most, I imagine the Twins signing a decent FA and one or two journeymen types, but I wouldn't be surprised if their signings ar similar to last season. When combined with possible trades of veterans, I don't see the payroll even close to holding steady. I do hope I'm wrong.
-
Article: Why the Twins Will Spend This Offseason
If by success we mean basically doing nothing and waiting (mostly) for prospects that were acquired by someone else with a half decade or more of time between competitive seasons, I agree. He'll probably succeed.
-
Article: Why the Twins Will Spend This Offseason
Not sure how multiples work, but because they pick in the top 10 they lose a 2nd Rd pick instead.