Everything posted by dbminn
-
The Evolution of Trevor May
You are right. It will take more. I was rolling with the author's estimate, which I would surely take. I think it he might agree to a little less than your estimate if they got it done now. Maybe 2/$15.
-
The potential for success - Josh Donaldson contract
A fun way of looking at Donaldson's future, Mike. I'll add a couple more that I liked to watch play. Adrian Beltre was really consistent from ages 34-37. Hit 99 HR and put up 20.6 fWAR. Chipper Jones hit 95 HR and put up 20 WAR as well. Odds are good he won't equal Beltre's run. Donaldson stays in great shape, so his biggest risk is injury. His skills will slide a bit but I don't believe they will completely fade away.
-
The Evolution of Trevor May
I'd extend May for 2/$11M. RP can have up/down years. Having Rogers, May and Duffey all under control improves the odds of having a couple of solid RP every year. It's not big money.
-
Front Page: Looking Way Ahead: Who Needs to be Added to the 40-Man Roster... in November
Depends on how the season goes, but I think Rortvedt and Rijo will join the top four. I'd have Rijo at the top of the "possibles" list for now.
-
Front Page: With Donaldson in the Fold, Can the Twins Afford to Wait Until the Deadline to Trade for Starting Pitching?
The 2020 Twins will have a powerful offense and an underrated bullpen. The FO just signed an expensive, win-now third baseman. Seems silly to have a rotation so uncertain that the first 40 games are described as a "weatherable storm".
-
Front Page: Do the Twins Really Need to Add Another Starter?
Gambling on two unproven SP, good health and Homer Bailey for the first 40 games is risky. They can make the odds better by trading for a proven young starter. Don't sell Cleveland short. They won 93 games last year and now have Carrasco back in the rotation. They too are gambling on some young players, including Orlando Mercado, Jake Bauers and Franmil Reyes. But why take the risk early in the season? Go get a SP.
- Front Page: FEINSAND: Twins to Sign Josh Donaldson
- Front Page: FEINSAND: Twins to Sign Josh Donaldson
-
Josh Donaldson Signs with... The Twins
Aaron Gleeman's twitterverse just shared the news. A 4-year contract. Feel free to delete, TD staff!
-
Front Page: Should the Twins Trade for Kris Bryant?
I wouldn't trade Lewis/Kirilloff plus Graterol/Duran for two years of Bryant. That's a big overpay. Bryant Value Using FanGraphs WAR Values and Schwarz Arb Estimate for 2021: 4.7 WAR in 2020 x $8.2M = $38.5M 4.7 WAR in 2021 x $8.4M x 0.92 = $36.3M (8% discount rate, 3% WAR inflation) $18.6M contract in 2020 $26.0M contract in 2021 (60% of WAR Value) Total Excess Value: ($74.8M - 44.6M) = $30.2M Twins FG Prospect Values: $55M - Lewis (60FV) $28M - Larnach, Kirilloff (50FV, Position Player) $21M - Graterol, Duran, Balazovic (50FV, Pitcher) At retail, Bryant is worth maybe (Duran + Jeffers) for two years of control. Probably have to add one or two young prospects due to demand. I wouldn't trade six years of Kirilloff and Graterol for Bryant, let alone Lewis+. I'd rather overpay for Donaldson and save the prospects for a controllable SP.
-
Front Page: Homer Bailey Could be a Solid Upgrade to the Twins Rotation
I'm okay with Bailey as a value pickup, although I would have preferred Porcello or Gausman. Twins needed a #4/5 veteran SP and Bailey is cheap and relatively low risk. Steamer projects Bailey for 153 IP and a 5 ERA. He'll probably be about as good as Gibson was struggling through e coli and ulcerative colitis last season.
-
Baseball Savant - Infield Outs (Below) Average
They also show percentage success rate v. "expected", which is an average for all players at that position.
-
Baseball Savant - Infield Outs (Below) Average
Defense is important. I looked at the new Statcast data for Andrelton Simmons. He had 300 balls hit to him in 2019. He made 16 OAA - that is, he converted 16 more outs than the average SS (not average defender). Doesn't sound like much? An average American league hitter hit .253 in 2019. That's equal to 76 hits per 300 AB. Add 16 hits to his season (92 for 300). That comes out to a batting average of .307. We'd all say that the .300 hitter had a far better season than the average player. (Simmons played only 103 games in 2019. He had 398 plate appearances)
-
Front Page: Top 20 Minnesota Twins Assets of 2020: Part 3 (6-10)
Nick, you're doing a great job at a difficult task. I have a comment though... Nick's question: "Which current players in the organization are most indispensable to fulfilling the vision of building a champion?" Seems the answer depends on when you think the Twins can be a champion. If it's the next two seasons, I'd rate Sano and Buxton higher than Lewis, Balazovic and Kirilloff (IMO). Maybe put Rogers higher on the list too. If you're shooting for 2021 and beyond, the prospects move right behind Berrios, Polanco and Kepler. This is my problem with the Twins FO. They say they want to win it all now but they act like they're looking at 2021 or 2022. If it's now, they need to trade top prospects for a SP (and maybe a corner bat). If it's later, they could trade Sano, Rosario and May for AA prospects (or sign Sano and May to long-term contracts). The FO keeps hedging their bets. At some point they have to commit to a plan. There's still time this offseason. Maybe at the trade deadline. Maybe when they have to adjust their 40-man roster next offseason. Ugh
- 4 Twins Prospects to Watch in 2020
-
4 Twins Prospects to Watch in 2020
I like your picks, Cody. Here are my alternates: Brusdar Graterol as a contributor. Can he stay healthy? Will his change-up develop enough to be useful? I can envision him as either a SP or RP with the 2020 Twins. Depends how the FO sets his calendar. Gilberto Celestino as the riser. He plays a premium, up-the-middle position (CF) and took off the last two months of 2019. He'll start the season at Ft Myers but I think he'll break out and be in Pensacola by mid-year. A true two-way player. Nick Gordon as the faller. Not an exciting pick but he's a call away if a rash of injuries hits the middle infield. I'm not optimistic but he's still young. I haven't given up all hope. Cole Sands as the one to watch. Too many injuries in his short career. From what little I've seen of him, he has three legit pitches, including a change up. Moved from Cedar Rapids to Pensacola in one season, even though he made only 18 starts. I'm a fan of SP prospects who have good velo and show command with multiple pitches.
-
Front Page: Will José Berríos Be an Ace in 2020? What History Tells Us About the Age-26 Season
Yes! It would be like the old days with chicken pox. Send your kid down the street to the house where someone is already sick. Catch the virus and move on. Too bad it's not that catchy.
-
Front Page: Will José Berríos Be an Ace in 2020? What History Tells Us About the Age-26 Season
The question asks if Berrios can become an ace. The data blob is a good first look. The second look is at who are the aces? The answer is a lot of SP over the age of 26. The more relevant question is why are there so many "old" aces if the data blob provides a different answer? This type of analysis is similar to what epidemiologists use to identify the sources of viruses or bacterial illness. They would get nowhere just looking at "on-average" data.
-
Front Page: Will José Berríos Be an Ace in 2020? What History Tells Us About the Age-26 Season
You forgot Gerrit Cole as a free agent SP. He has become dominant after age 26. He's put up 13.8 fWAR the past two seasons. Better to look at who the top SP are right now: Seven of the 2019 Top Ten SP by fWAR were 30 or older. Eight were over 26. 14 of the top 20 were over the age of 26.IMO, three characteristics separate "aces" from the masses: TalentHealthContinued Improvement (learning how to pitch)Berrios has a lot of talent and has been healthy. He has a great work ethic. He can get better. He probably won't be a top 5 SP but he has the potential for a Top 10 season or two. His one potential drawback is his small size. All of the eight older SP in the 2019 Top Ten are 6'2" or taller. Six are at least 6'4".
-
Front Page: 4 Logical Trades That Would Improve the Twins' Rotation
The Boyd trade is interesting for both sides. I'd make the trade if I was in either front office. Too bad they're in the same division. That's a big PR hurdle for each team. Chris Sale for three top-ten Twins prospects? NO! I don't care how much cash is involved. I'd make the Archer trade for Rooker and Gordon but that's not enough for Pittsburgh. Archer comes with little risk - $9M for one year, with a club option if all goes well. Two predicted bench players aren't going to get the Twins up to two years of a good SP with only $9M on the line. Syndergaard for Buxton straight up could be a good trade for both teams. Two years v. three. Buxton comes really cheap this year. Both have injury risk and upside. I don't think I could pull the trigger as GM for either team, but it would make the next few years very interesting. Gray still makes the most sense to both teams. Twins have prospects with AA experience to offer. Unfortunately, Colorado still believes they can compete in the NL West.
-
Front Page: Can Lewis Thorpe Translate Whiffs into Results?
Thorpe's stuff is a little below average across the board. On the positive side, he has four pitches that are usable. He needs to improve his command/control a bit more and maybe fewer FB. Thorpe didn't have much luck last season either. He had a .438 BABIP in 2019 (batting average on balls in play). At worst, that'll drop to the .320s over an entire year. I think he'll be ok - a league-average SP in the long run.
-
Front Page: Is Homer Bailey the Next Martin Perez?
"He's likely to be an upgrade over Perez, but right now, that isn't the guy he's replacing. It's Kyle Gibson, who signed with Texas for $30 million early in the offseason... It's Gibson's spot the Twins should now be seeking to upgrade, and hopefully in a very significant way." Nick nails it. Signing Bailey was a good move considering price and availability. Now they need to trade for a SP at the level of Odo or Berrios. Jon Gray makes the most sense. The Rockies are going nowhere and have a lousy farm system. The Twins have the prospects. Two months to get it done.
-
Donaldson contract discussion - 4/100? 4/110?
Twins need a corner IF and it would be nice if they improved IF defense. Donaldson provides both. Right now, 1B is a combo of Gonzalez and Adrianza. Marwin is a solid league-average hitter and a very good defensive 3B and LF. That is not a profile for a starting 1B. Same is true for Ehire and he's needed as the backup SS. Donaldson will cost a lot. He's not a "value play". The question is: do the Twins want a good $/win ratio or a competitive team? Donaldson is projected for 4.5+ WAR in 2020. He adds at least 3 wins to the current Twins lineup. That is a big difference for one player. Odds are good the Twins don't sign him, but I'm happy they are making a play for him.
-
Front Page: Crystal Ball: Who Is Ready for Stardom?
My guess is Sano will be the biggest Twins star in 2020. He was pretty healthy for the last 4-1/2 months of the 2019 season. I think he'll report in shape and ready to go. Kepler has just entered his prime years. I think he has another gear left in him at the plate. Hit a lot of pop-ups last year. More likely his year will be similar to last season, but that ain't bad. Buxton still has the highest upside but he hasn't proven he can stay on the field. I can't bet he'll stay healthy this year either. I hope I'm wrong. Trevor May will give the Twins a solid 1-2 punch in the bullpen. I'd extend him for two years right now if he's open to it. Luis Arraez is my longshot candidate to be in the top 3. He has so much talent with the bat. In 2019, he had a fair amount of pull power (.171 ISO), but hit too many grounders to the same direction. I believe he will learn to lift more balls to RF in the future. His upside is 4.5 WAR, maybe a little higher if he improves his fielding. His 2020 downside risk is fairly high too, since other teams have a book on him for the first time.
-
Front Page: Practice Pragmatism
The Twins will play the first 45 days or so with two veteran SP - Odo and Berrios. They will still have two open slots after Pineda returns. They need at least one ok veteran to start the season. The Twins core rotation started an unusually high number of games last year. Don't expect it to happen again. If Berrios or Odo go down, they will be in trouble. I'm confident that at least one of Dobnak, Thorpe, Graterol and Smeltzer will take control of a starting spot. Not three. The FO has allowed this problem to happen. I agree Ryu isn't necessarily the solution. Problem is, the FO also let short-term bounceback candidates Porcello and Gaussman go off the board too. At last year's deadline, the FO offer to Toronto must have been pretty weak. They said the Jays didn't even bother asking for a Twins final offer for Stroman. Don't sleep on Cleveland. They won 93 games last year without Kluber and could do it again. Clevinger, Bieber and Carrasco will still be at the top of the rotation. I doubt Lindor will be traded. If the Dodgers come through, Cleveland will likely get Lux in return. There's still plenty of time for the Twins to solve the issue by making a trade this offseason. I'm willing to give the FO the benefit of the doubt until then. But a pragmatic view of the current rotation should be one of concern. Only a romantic hopes Cleveland will be worse, at least two young SP step up, and they will solve any problems at the 2020 trade deadline.