Everything posted by dbminn
-
Grading the players not the teams
Thanks for the thoughts, Mike. I think Downs is a winner. He's slated to be at 2B when he reaches the majors. Red Sox need a second baseman to replace Pedroia. He only has to beat out Michael Chavis next season. He was buried in LA. Your comments about Graterol are spot on.
-
Take Two: Pending Physicals, Twins and Dodgers Agree to Trade
My two cents worth: I think the Dodgers improved their lot more in the revised trade. The Dodgers are rich. They can afford the downside risk of Graterol. As ChrisKnutson said, this trade could be bring them World Series success in 2020 and a fantastic SP in later seasons. Graterol is 21 years old. He was throwing hard with a crisp slider at the end of last season. His concerns are long term. The problem is either genetic or something is fraying in his shoulder. Neither is a death sentence as a starting pitcher. It's a risk. One that the Dodgers can handle. They Dodgers threw $10M at the Twins with nothing more than a sigh. They picked up Raley as depth and a draft pick worth less than $5M. They traded Jeter Downs, a top 100 prospect who might end up at 2B. They kept Graterol, a pitcher ranked in Driveline's current Top 10 list of "stuff". The Twins did well too. Maeda is a solid #3 pitcher who may be better as a full-time starter. His ERA was 3.94 for the past two years in 279 IP. He made 46 starts and had 30 relief appearances. He's durable and flexible. He's posted 4.9 WAR while being shuttled between starts and the pen. Maeda might be the lowest financial-risk pitcher in the majors and he's under control for four years. The Twins traded from a 2020 RP surplus to meet a current SP need. Raley is 4th in line as a Twins corner OF prospect. Graterol may end up great but he was only going to be a RP in 2020, no matter how his career moves in the future. They got $10M to boot. I like it.
- Report: Twins Willing to Back Out on Blockbuster Deal
- Report: Twins Willing to Back Out on Blockbuster Deal
-
What others are saying about the trade
FWIW, Here's Bowden's take from the Athletic: "Bottom line is I don’t like the actual trade long-term for the Twins, but it’s easy to see why they made it. They needed another starter, and they have a legitimate chance of doing damage in October."
-
What others are saying about the trade
FanGraphs has already posted Graterol as Boston's #1 prospect. Here's some commentary from Jay Jaffe at FG: "Graterol will again appear somewhere in the middle of our Top 100 list, which will be published next week. He instantly becomes the Red Sox’s top prospect, though their plans for his role remain to be seen." Here's an excerpt from Aaron Gleeman at the Athletic: "Graterol is an awfully big chip. Next week, The Athletic will publish our rankings of the Twins’ top-40 prospects, and Graterol was slated to be No. 3, tops among pitchers... There is no question that the Twins are opening themselves up to be second-guessed for years to come." I'm not a big second guesser on trades. I either like or don't like the trade up front. After that, it's a matter health, development, etc. The Twins FO paid a lot but needed to get a SP. I'm looking forward to the season.
-
Twins Daily 2020 Top Prospects: 11-15
Alright, I was kind to you folks for one day of rankings. I can't put Colina behind Canterino, Wallner and Javier. I can't put Canterino behind Wallner and Javier. So there (ha)! On a serious note, I think Celestino is an untradeable prospect at this point. He's a true CF with hitting potential. He's the only one in the organization unless they move Lewis.
-
Twins Trade Graterol to Dodgers for Kenta Maeda in Blockbuster Deal
I hear you, but I disagree about the concerns. They tabbed Graterol for the bullpen only for this year. He's 21 years old with two different 100 mph fastballs and a plus slider. The Red Sox have nothing like him in the pipeline. I like the trade but I wouldn't sell Graterol short. The Twins got a very good pitcher for him at great value. Maeda will help the Twins this year and next. He has no potential to be great. Graterol has that possibility.
-
Twins Trade Graterol to Dodgers for Kenta Maeda in Blockbuster Deal
Emotionally, I hate this trade. Watching Graterol come up through the system with real talent, I was excited to see where his potential would take him. He is not the first pitcher to miss time and turn out well. To say he'll never be more than a RP is a bold statement about a 21 year old. OTOH, I understand why they made the trade for Maeda. A four-year incentive based contract with a proven major league pitcher. He gets $3M per year if he washes out... ridiculously risk free. He's a valuable player for a team in need of established starters. He's been very good in the playoffs too. I think the Red Sox are the real winners of the deal. Chaim Bloom put his mark on the team before his first spring training. He took most of $58M of salary (plus tax) off the books this year and added two blue chip prospects ready to play in the majors. All for a team whose owners wanted to lower salary and add youth. Job done. I'm sad and excited all at once. I give credit to all three teams for taking the risk.
-
Twins Daily 2020 Top Prospects: 16-20
That's a nice group of prospects for 16-20.
-
3 Recent Extensions That Could Compare to a Possible Jose Berrios Extension
Yeah, I would do that for Clevinger. His problem last year was health - back muscle strain. I thought it was shoulder-related, which I'm always afraid of. Berrios is right at Syndergaard's level and two years younger. At that point, it's a matter of opinion, not one clearly better.
-
3 Recent Extensions That Could Compare to a Possible Jose Berrios Extension
Two of the five are close but debatable. Berrios was dead even with Clevinger and Syndergaard last season. I disagree with the Dodgers comp. He was clearly better than Kershaw last year and, with health, will be better this year. There are only two clearly better.
-
We Probably Should Still Be Worried About Cleveland
Wow.
-
The Twins Have too Many Good Outfielders; Can They Make Room for Them?
The Twins OF looks deep. The bench is ok too. Cave is a good 4th OF and Marwin is solid if he isn't needed elsewhere. Kepler is an elite RF and an above-average CF when Buxton isn't available. Things rarely work out as planned. Buxton played 87 games in 2019. Kepler and Rosario reached 130 games each. Buxton had offseason surgery. Rosario played with a damaged ankle from June to the end of the season. Kepler needed physical therapy this winter. The prospects had physical problems too. Rooker and Raley combined for 400 PA. Kirilloff suffered two wrist injuries. Lewis missed the 1st month of games. Larnach was the only one who played a full season. There is enough depth if the Twins trade Larnach or Kirilloff for a front line starting pitcher. There's no need to trade either of them if the right pitcher isn't available. Injuries will happen. If one of them tears up the minors and is healthy, they'll find a spot with the Twins. Rooker isn't on the 40-man roster. Wade has options. Raley is the only OF the Twins need to make a relatively quick decision about because he's on the 40-man roster and may not fit into their plans in 2020.
-
Starting Pitcher Analysis: Randy Dobnak
The Twins would and should move a AA pitching prospect for Jon Gray. He's a pitcher with the upside of Berrios and the same pay grade. Two years of Gray would cost either Duran or Balazovic, along with another prospect. They should do it in a heartbeat. The only problem is the disfunction of the Rockies front office. The Twins just signed Donaldson. Like Brock said on Twitter(?), might as well put the pedal to the floor.
-
Will Randy Dobnak or Lewis Thorpe Give Minnesota More in 2020?
I like Thorpe better than Dobnak. All of Dobnak's stuff moves in the horizontal plane. Hitters don't have to adjust the vertical plane of their swing, just their timing. I think they figure him out. Thorpe has more variation in his repetoire. I like Dobnak and I could be wrong. But if I have to pick, it's Thorpe.
-
César Tovar and the Twins Hall Of Fame
From 1968-1972, Tovar racked up 16.8 WAR, or an average of 3.3 WAR per year. But it's not a Hall of WAR, its a Hall of Fame. In 1968, he played five positions about the same amount of games. In 1969, he split time between 2B, 3B, LF and CF. And if you like WAR, he was a 4 WAR player both seasons. Name another player on the Twins who has done that. In 1970, he played LF. In 1971, he was in CF. Both seasons, he was above average. He was incredibly important to the team. He played with flair. You like Arraez? Imagine hitting almost as well over several years and doing it at most of the positions on the field. He should be in the Twins Hall of Fame.
-
12 Prospects Who Could Shape the AL Central for Years to Come
Tarik Skubal is another Tiger SP prospect in the Baseball America Top 50. He will be in the MLB Top 50 after they reveal their list this afternoon. He's already shown as their 4th best LHP prospect for 2020. Skubal started nine AA games at the end of 2019 and averaged 17.5 K/9. Add Spencer Turnbull and Matt Boyd to Skubal, Mize and Manning and the Tigers will have a high upside rotation in 2021. Thankfully, their position players will still be bad.
-
4 Options for Twins' Final Bench Spot
There is no need to sign a backup OF and lose a player from the 40 man roster. Kepler is an above-average CF. Marwin and Cave are fine in the corners. Wade can come up from AAA if there's an early spate of injuries.
-
How Jorge Polanco Can Develop into a Better Defensive Shortstop
I have no comment on this article in particular. I just want to say how happy I am to log on to quality articles by Nick, Cody and Matt this morning!
-
Is Eddie Rosario Facing a Make-or-Break Year With the Twins?
I don't think the Twins keep Eddie beyond 2020 because of Larnach and Kirilloff. Only one needs to be ready by 2021. That said, the Twins need a healthy Rosario this year. Word is that Rosario had a bad ankle in 2019. Probably so, since his statcast speed data shows a full ft/sec drop - not normal for a 27-yr old. As a result, he dropped about 0.8 WAR just on baserunning between 2018 and 2019. With health, I expect his defense to be a bit better in 2020 too. His glovework has never been great, so I don't expect his upside to be more than an average OF. (Note: baseball savant OAA doesn't include "arm". He has saved between 5-7 runs per year with his arm, according to DRS). Even with improvement, I don't think the Twins will want his salary on the books in 2021. And with a better 2020, he'll become a viable trade chip for a SP in the offseason.
-
In Win-Now Mode, Twins Keeping Graterol in Bullpen
I've been impressed with the Twins approach to communicating expectations for players. However anyone feels about the choice, at least Graterol can prepare for camp understanding their plans for him. I hope they avoid using Graterol as a "fireman" to start the season. IMO, irregular work might be as hard on his arm as starting. I'd rather see him pitch multiple innings in tandem with the 5th starter. It would be fun to see Graterol in combination with Smeltzer to start the season. Smeltzer throwing low velocity, high spin fastballs mixed with three offspeed pitches. Graterol following with 99 MPH sinkers and ferocious sliders from the right side. I can't think of a more radical difference in styles. Either one could start and the change would be jarring to hitters.
-
The Evolution of Trevor May
Sorry about that. Yes, I'd extend May right now. I think he's worth the gamble.
-
The Evolution of Trevor May
Again, you are right. May is the better RP. But May isn't a free agent yet. He has one more year of risk before entering the market. I'd make the offer now. $15M is life changing money. The worst that happens is he refuses and enters free agency next offseason.
-
The Evolution of Trevor May
See above, Brock. Somehow, I forgot to hit the quote button.