Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

dbminn

Verified Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by dbminn

  1. The good team/bad team split between the two leagues is remarkable. The six teams projected to have the fewest wins are all in the NL. The AL Central will be a dogfight, with the Twins finishing either 3rd or 4th. I still can't project the Sox above the Twins and the Tigers have too many key players with injury risk. That being said, all five teams are flawed and all have potential. Should be an interesting year.
  2. One reason to be excited about Twins Daily in 2016: Spring Training is going to be incredibly controversial. Bullpen prospects will get a good look, the Arcia/Vargas competition, a clogged rotation, Sano in the OF, Joe Mauer... Should make for a lot of commentary.
  3. Cody, I like your list. I would probably rank Kohl Stewart lower than all of the others listed. ExpectMore, I hope you're right about ABW II. I will contribute two names: Nick Burdi and Mitch Garver. I think Burdi has a good chance of reaching the majors this year based on his improved mechanics in the AFL. Garver is my long-odds choice for a breakout season with the bat.
  4. The hitch in Arcia's swing is monumental. His head moves all over the place. I don't even love to hate to love that swing anymore. I hope all of Wade's swings look so good. And Kepler... wow.
  5. About 70 percent of pitchers who ranked as Top 50-100 Prospects gave their major league teams less than 3.0 WAR total during their 6 years under control according to this research: http://www.thepointofpittsburgh.com/how-much-an-mlb-prospect-is-worth-updated-trade-surplus-values/ Gibson and Duffey have been reasonably successful and should end up contributing well above average WAR while under control. Too early to tell about Burdi, Reed, Cederoth, Williams, Jay and others drafted in recent years. RE: RP and aging. I have a real problem with the aging curves put together by FanGraphs. A lot of RP have one good year in middle relief, get a couple more years to prove themselves but can't continue to develop. Instead, look at last year's top 30 RP, either by WAR or WPA (preferred, IMO). Average age was 28.6 years old. Only Ken Giles was under 25 for WPA. Add Osuna at 20 years old if you prefer WAR. http://www.fangraphs.com/leaders.aspx?pos=all&stats=rel&lg=all&qual=y&type=c,4,5,11,7,8,13,-1,36,37,40,43,44,48,51,-1,6,45,62,-1,59,63,3&season=2015&month=0&season1=2015&ind=0&team=0&rost=0&age=0&filter=&players=0&sort=20,d
  6. Too bad he wasn't available back when the Twins had Boof Bonser.
  7. I sympathize but Ryan (and his staff during the Smith era) has been in Group 3. Here's a recent article at Hardball Times that looks at BA Top-100 prospects and their correlation with winning percentage. The last two times the Twins had playoff runs fits nicely with this theory (see figure). Basically, the author shows that having an average of five prospects per year for three years leads to a good five-year run. That's where the Twins are at right now. Other teams are the Red Sox, Rangers, Cubs and Pirates. D-Backs have had 14 prospects in the last three years. http://www.hardballtimes.com/a-visual-history-of-baseball-americas-top-100-prospect-lists/ I agree that Ryan hasn't been able to take the last step when they arrive at the playoffs: sign a key free agent. It's my biggest concern. PS - I wouldn't call the Revere trade a failure just yet.
  8. I would've liked the Twins to have made a play for Soria. Otherwise, I'm with Shane - trade for a LHRP. It doesn't have to happen this week. In general, the Twins have two options moving forward: Win this year. Sacrifice future payroll by signing FA or future depth by trading prospects. This could include a multiplayer trade. Try to build for beyond 2016, with a roster primarily from within (at least for now).Seems to me, the Twins have opted for Door #2. This doesn't mean they will "stand pat" for the next five years. They will probably proceed as announced this year, picking up an extra OF and RP. Next year should involve bigger moves after they see what the prospects bring to the table. I've been a supporter of building from within. Lately, I've wanted to see a blockbuster trade. Probably just getting bored with the off-season
  9. You pose a fine alternative. I would actually rather see the Twins move in your direction (I would add Span to the list of possible OF). I posted this scenario just to get some discussion other than Nolasco for Shields, which is a non-starter. But to further the debate, I don't think it's such a crazy trade. First, I agree the Twins would be taking a risk, just not as doom and gloom as your assessment. Upton was a 110 WRC+ last year and he's a good defender (1.6 WAR in 228 PA - equals a little less than 4 WAR for 600 PA). Shields is a risk but I see a pitcher who tried to do too much last year (High BB, K and HR). FanGraphs has him for 3 WAR this year. The Twins have players well above replacement value to play 3B and middle infield. They don't have a full OF unless everything turns up roses.
  10. Good post. Just for discussion - I think Upton will be more valuable than 0.5 WAR and I don't use WAR for relievers. Finally, we have to look at who the Twins have as replacements. I wouldn't make this trade if we were short at 3B or middle infield. Still, you make a good point.
  11. Plouffe, Polanco and Nolasco for Shields, Pomeranz and Melvin Upton. Payroll Change (Shields + Upton) - (Plouffe + Nolasco) 2016 - ($21M + $15.4M) - ($7.7M + $11M) = $17.7M 2017 - ($21M + $16.4M) - ($13M? + $12M) = $12.4M 2018 - $23M = $23.0M TOTAL PADRES SAVINGS/TWINS COST = $53.1M or $17.7M per year Twins get a LHRP, a 3.0 WAR starter and a veteran OF.Padres get salary relief, a solid middle infield prospect, a 2.0+ WAR 3B/1B and a questionable starter. (Plouffe could be spun at some point for a couple of prospects)I'm more bullish on Melvin Upton than Fangraphs and probably everyone on this site. I expect him to repeat 2015. Twins get 1 yr Shields, 2yr Upton and a LHRP for $9.1M if Shields opts out. Not saying I'm all for this trade. Just trying to be creative.
  12. Great question. Sophomore year is tough to predict. IMO, the FanGraphs Steamer projection pretty much reflects my thoughts on Sano: 29.5%K/11.5%BB and .255/.304/.544. Most of the decreased production from 2015 is based on a lower BABIP. I think he might walk a bit more than projected. Rosario is a real wild card for 2016. Steamer projections are not good: 20.8%K/4.4%BB and .258/.292/.412. BABIP drops to .305. The projections do reflect an improved K rate. I'm more bullish on Rosario than Steamer. His BABIP will be about .320 because of his speed. Not unusual.He's already had to make adjustments. Rosario had a tough August 2015 (.228/.245/.416). He came back in September to be a league-average hitter, even though his BABIP was .288.I predict K rate will be down for both players and both will be productive. Rosario definitely has more downside risk because he's such a free swinger.
  13. I think the Twins need to sign or trade for better than a backup OF. I believe Plouffe will be traded. That leaves Rosario as the only established OF and he has only one year of experience. What are the odds that one of Rosario, Kepler and Buxton are either not MLB-ready or get injured? There is no harm having four good OF in the best case. Beats the current risk of ending up with less than three good OF. Three Winter Meeting Options: Option 1 - Easy Span - 2 yr/$28M (Fangraphs says 3/$36. At today's prices, still not so bad) Option 2 - Youth Ozuna - Trade Duffey, Jake Reed and a third player to Miami. (3rd player depends on what you think Ozuna is worth) Option 3 - Never Gonna Happen but would be Fun Heyward - 9 yr/$207M with a 4-year player option. What if Kepler, Buxton and Rosario all turn out perfectly wonderful? Trade either Ozuna/Span, Rosario or Kepler next year. What if Plouffe isn't traded? Well, just sign Gentry or some other 4th OF and see what happens, I guess.
  14. He looks larger than ever... but that swing! http://www.fangraphs.com/blogs/instagraphs/this-is-grainy-footage-of-miguel-sano-homering-minutes-ago/ https://cdn.streamable.com/video/mp4/4scy.mp4
  15. Signing Nunez is perfectly fine. Reserve utility infielders who hit league average with some power are worth at least what he'll be paid. He can be traded later in the year if the Twins think they have a better option for his role. I'm surprised they tendered Fien. I would've let him leave.
  16. My guess is Santana will be on the Twins bench or in CF to begin 2016. Others on the bench will include Suzuki (ha!), Nunez, and either Arcia or OF to be determined. (Both Arcia and OF TBD will be on bench if Buxton isn't ready).
  17. I think Plouffe will be traded only if the Twins get a reasonable return. Since a trade isn't guaranteed, Ryan has to plan that all four players will be on the roster. I don't like the idea of Sano playing the outfield. I'm not as worried as some are about injury. I just want to see good OF defense backing a pitching staff that puts the ball in play. Still, having all four players is not a bad scenario. Added power is needed and at least one of the four will get injured during the season.
  18. Great reporting, Parker. A lot of fragments from the past put into context. Watching the three Valencia swings, it seems that he finishes on his heel in the first two and more on the flat/ball of the foot in the Toronto video. Seems he's in better balance now.
  19. Rosenthal quote: "#Twins’ signing of Park reinforces unfairness of posting system. Player has no leverage if he burns to play in majors. At MLB team’s mercy." Low dollar signing takes pressure off the player as well, IMO. No one should be screaming if doesn't perform from day 1. Four years to recoup $25 million is a pretty safe bet.
  20. That's what happens when a person just jumps to the table. I'm guilty.
  21. Agreed, Mike. Here's a link to Chris Mitchell's "KATOH Primer", which people should read before slamming the rankings: http://www.fangraphs.com/blogs/a-primer-on-a-new-and-improved-katoh/ I can't remember who said this... and I paraphrase: Scouting and stats are like beer and tacos. Both are great on their own but they are better enjoyed together.
  22. I was quoting Dave Cameron of FanGraphs for the Freese contract. I agree the actual terms of his new contract could vary from either estimate.
  23. I still think the Twins need to add a late inning LHRP. Otherwise, the youngsters are the best hope for elite bullpen depth. Here's a link to a new MLB article that provides some data to support Nick about bullpen use: http://m.mlb.com/news/article/157383440/starting-pitchers-should-throw-fewer-innings
  24. Here's a little math for the conversation. Data from FanGraphs. Plouffe: Has been estimated by MLBTR to cost 2yr/$18M. Freese estimated at 3yr/$33M.Has outperformed Freese the last two years (6.1 to 4.3 fWAR).Is 3 years younger than Freese.With 3 years of Freese and 2 years of Plouffe, assume total WAR will be similar. That means the difference is $15M. If you believe aging curves, Plouffe's relative value increases. (If you don't believe in WAR or WAR dollar value, I'm sympathetic.) Plouffe should be worth about $15M of baseball player value compared to Freese. That would be a good reliever under team control for a few years. At a minimum. I would want an additional prospect as well.
  25. The Twins should be able to get a mid-level prospect with a solid RP if multiple teams are interested. It all depends on the RP acquired. Years of control, current value and upside will affect the final trade.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.