Everything posted by dbminn
-
Is it time to recall Vargas?
Bring up Buxton. Sit Hunter more and give Rosario a day off against tough lefties. That gives the Twins a bat off the bench in either case. Won't kill Buxton to sit a day per week either. Plenty for him to learn from the bench once every 5-6 games. I suspect the Twins have 13 pitchers because May hasn't been available the past few days. Should change soon. Bring up Vargas on September 1st.
-
What to do with Kepler?
Depth is a key to a winning season. I have no problem with four players competing for three OF spots. Someone will get injured or may have an extended slump. I also wouldn't mind if one OF is included in a trade package for a young catcher. Hicks and Rosario probably have a higher trade value than Kepler since they have proven they can play in the show.
-
Mauer, what to do?
Good post. I would switch Dozier/Rosario and Hunter/Mauer. Dozier has more power and moving Mauer up one gives a R/L/R combo.
-
Aaron Hicks and the platoon
Ultimately, I agree with you. Kepler's BB/K ratio is hard to find in the modern game. And, with Hicks on the roster the Twins have a starting RF/backup CF if Buxton gets hurt. Finally, I think Rosario has a better trade value than Kepler right now. MLB experience is valued and GMs don't want to trade an MLB ready C or SS for a player that isn't visible to the fans for a year or more. I just have a higher opinion of Rosario than most (Fangraph's McDaniel predicts Rosario to be an "empty" .270 hitter for his career). Moving towards his career BB/K ratio would increase his OBP by .030+ (reduced Ks mean a few extra hits) and I believe he'll hit a few more homers as he matures. Just this reasonable improvement puts him pretty high up in OF productivity, maybe 120+ WRC. Bottom line: I too would prefer Rosario traded to either Hicks or Kepler. I would not trade him for less than what I believe is his future worth.
-
Aaron Hicks and the platoon
Hicks's second half has been remarkable, no doubt. His splits are wide but might improve with experience. (Nice to see him have multiple LH hits last night). In any case, I agree he has earned the right to play full-time this year, at least as long as the Twins are in contention. Rosario is more than hustle and grit - he has plenty of athleticism and baseball skills. He's a 23 year old rookie who's accumulated 1.2 WAR in less than 300 PA. That puts him slightly above "good" in the WAR world. As a rookie. I believe he will add a couple of percentage points to his %BB and to drop a few from %K in the next couple years. That would leave him with percentages similar to his long-term minor league history and improve his offensive WAR. I would be happy with Rosario, Buxton and Hicks as the 2016 starting OF. I think this is the most likely case at this point. I could see Rosario or Hicks being traded in the offseason for either a C or SS. That's fine too. Just don't trade Kepler.
-
Twins Should Call Up & Platoon Kepler NOW.
If you believe the Twins are in contention with the Blue Jays and Orioles for a wild card spot, bring up Arcia. Otherwise, make him earn his chance for now. (He can still come up in September to try to prove himself one last time.) Kepler is not a "marginal" prospect. He's easily top five in the Twins organization and has the tools to become a fine major league player. He puts the ball in play with authority, strikes out very little and is a capable OF. He's just not ready. Let Kepler continue through the minor leagues for now... along with Buxton.
-
Plan your work, work your plan
Thoughtful article and I generally agree with the theme. Just a couple of items: I think the plan has been to compete for the title in 2017. Prospects are starting to fill the major league roster but the Twins are still another year from having a full complement of seasoned young players. The Twins will still need to pursue a SS, C and a RP outside of the Twins system. The Twins need to make offseason moves to fill a couple of these positions with young, MLB-ready players. They have OF/DH/P prospects and a couple of veterans available for trade. I would keep Ryan through the end of the season. Ryan is and always will be a scout. He's developed a fine minor league system through both the draft and international signings. To me, he's less solid as a dealer. The big question is: Should he be the one to make the offseason trades and take the team into 2016?
-
Article: Regression Causing The Twins Problems
Thanks for the response, Spycake. I agree that we shouldn't close the book on Turner and also that his hitting this year is nothing to get excited about. Still, I'd like to clarify a couple of things: The article is about the major league team. Turner was never expected to be a major leaguer this year. He has advanced from A+ to AA and will need one more year at this level before he even appears at the edge of the MLB radar. No reason to use the word "fail" in this context. Just say the young man is not close to the majors.I argued that he was a college catcher. Only one AA catcher from your Fangraphs link was as young as Turner and went to college: Kyle Schwarber, a hitter who has failed to develop as a catcher. The others have had 3-4 years in professional baseball. Turner was a part-time, aluminum bat wielding baseball player who was also a college student.I probably wasn't clear enough on how I view young catchers. IMO, defense and game calling are more important than hitting at this phase of a catcher's development (23, 2nd year in pro ball). Catchers are notorious for late development as hitters. Here's Kiley McDaniel's scouting report from FanGraphs: "Turner isn’t the guy you get excited about at first glance, but he might turn into a big league starter behind the plate. He’s an advanced catch-and-throw guy that gives pitchers a big target, he calls his own games and has the plus arm to shut down the running game." Sounds like he hasn't failed yet as a defensive catcher, which, to me, is more important at this point.
- Article: Twins Minor League Report (7/23): Berrios Pitches Into The Eighth
- Article: Regression Causing The Twins Problems
-
doing the opposite
Thanks Brock. All a negative fWAR - ERA difference means for a young pitcher is, "If he ever gets command of his pitches, he'll be good".
-
doing the opposite
I don't think Arcia fits with the Orioles right now. They already have a weak corner OF defense. So... Let's spice this trade up - Rosario/Suzuki/Milone/Young Prospect for Wieters/Gausmann The Orioles get a legitimate OF defender who can slash and has upside potential. They need a #5 starter and I'd take Milone over Bud Norris. Suzuki can platoon with Caleb Joseph. Wieters becomes a FA at the end of the year, so they can still sign him to a long-term contract (probably unlikely). The Twins get a pitcher with upside potential. Put him in the bullpen and let him work with Neil Allen the rest of the season. May to the rotation for Milone. Either acquire an OF at the trade deadline or bring up Ortiz until Buxton is healthy. The Twins get two months of a top-flight catcher to appease the "win now" folks. There is no likelihood this trade is made, but it's more fun than assuming the Orioles will trade a SP prospect for a no-field OF/power hitting prospect.
-
Article: Twins Will Be Active Shoppers At Trade Deadline
A major league ready catcher would be my priority. Depending on the catcher, players to trade could include, as options, (not all) Arcia, Plouffe, Polanco or any from a list of the younger (2017 or later) prospects. Again, depends on the catcher. There are several teams with an established catcher and a younger second. Someone mentioned Cozart as a possible SS trade. Of course, he's rehabbing right now but I'd be willing to talk to Cincinnati about him in the offseason. I would not want to trade Buxton, Berrios, Sano or Kepler for either position. Rosario maybe for the right player.
- Article: Twins Will Be Active Shoppers At Trade Deadline
-
Over Under Contest (rest of the season) Answers due by gametime (July 21st)
Twins Wins: 37.5 OVER Mauer's OPS: .815 OVER Dozier HRs: 14.5 UNDER Sano HRs: 9.5 OVER Hicks: .350 OBP OVER Sano OPS: .900 OVER Hunter HR: 8.5 UNDER Perkins Saves: 22.5 UNDER Gibson ERA: 3.25 UNDER Santana ERA: 3.50 OVER Hughes ERA: 3.75 OVER Arcia PA: 150 UNDER Buxton PA: 150 UNDER Trevor May Starts: 5.5 OVER Mike Pelfrey Starts: 5.5 UNDER Alex Meyer IP: 6.5 UNDER Jose Berrios IP: 15.5 UNDER Kurt Suzuki OPS: .600 OVER RP acquired via free agency and trade: 1.5 OVER Catchers acquired via trade: 0.5 UNDER Trevor Plouffe OPS: .775 OVER Brian Duensing ERA: 3.80 UNDER Blaine Boyer ERA: 3.80 OVER Casey Fien ERA: 3.80 UNDER
-
Article: Examining The Shortstop Options
Stick with internal options this year. Rollins and Segura are not upgrades.Tulo is too old for his contract and for a young Twins team. Cozart is injured and won't return until next year.The Twins can explore trades for a younger SS in the offseason, if the deal is right. Cozart would be a possibility at that time. I would like to see the Twins follow the model of teams that have been successful for a number of years. The Cardinals, Pirates, Nationals and Giants all have everyday lineups that are primarily homegrown*. Both the Cardinals (Pujols, Freese) and the Giants (Sandoval) have replaced established contributors with younger players, all while competing for championships. (*Some of the players were obtained while either in the minors or while under control.)
-
1,000 baseball player thread
During the offseason, Dave Goltz would bowl in the Tuesday afternoon Farmer's League with my Grandpa Carl. (Northern Aire Lanes, Fergus Falls, Minnesota.)
-
Article: Interview With SI Writer Jay Jaffe, Thoughts On Mauer
The voters won't look at the team's record for the last four years. Mauer had very good years in 2012 and 2013. His struggles have only occurred in the last 18 months. Joe has looked like his old self the last three weeks. Hopefully that'll continue.
-
Article: First-Half Most Improved Twins
A fine analysis of the first half, Brandon. It's great that the Twins have improved enough that this article was possible. While May has shown improvement all year, Hicks is the player that has shown the most surprising gains. He still has a lot of rough edges at the plate but the light has turned on. His continued solid play is needed if the Twins are going to make the playoffs.
-
All-Star Break Thoughts
Congratulations to the Twins on a successful first half, from the field to the manager to the front office. Twins baseball has been fun again. I expected the starting rotation to be fairly consistent this year but I didn't see more than .500 by the all-star break. Until the last 10 days, the veteran hitters had provided most of the run production. Somehow, adding Sano has energized the other young hitters; Rosario, Santana and (wow) Hicks. They give me a bit more optimism about the second half.
-
Deolis Guerra
I'm sure the Pirates are thrilled about losing Miguel Sano.
-
Will Arcia ever see Target Field again?
I believe we'll see Arcia again this year. He just turned 24 years old and still has tremendous potential as a hitter. My hope is he comes up and subs more than occasionally for Hunter, who is beginning to look like a tired hitter. Give the old man a few more breaks! I wouldn't trade him until he has greater value.
-
Article: Is Ervin Santana Really A Midseason Addition?
Pelfrey to the pen.
-
Next Roster Moves?
For fun and discussion: Twins trade some combination of Plouffe/Pelfrey/Polanco to get Austin Hedges from San Diego (could be others included from both sides). Twins make the trade because: They need a young catcher to grow with the other prospects. Plouffe is blocking Sano from 3B and taking a roster spot from Arcia or Buxton. (I really like Plouffe but he is probably our most valuable non-prospect trading chip) They have reservations about Polanco playing SS. Dozier is blocking 2B.Padres make the trade because: They are still trying to win this year. The back end of their rotation is awful. They are getting zero production at 3B and 2B.Any takers? Is Plouffe too important to this year's possible wild-card team to better the team next year?
-
What would the ideal 25-man roster be to end the year?
The key thought from ttreadway, "My opinion is that the twins FO is doing things right, and I hope and pray that they don't trade away any valuable future prospects this month in an attempt to win 4 or 5 more games." I agree. My lineup would resemble the one put together by blairpaul715, except I would have a 25-man roster (not 24 - am I counting ok?). I would add Arcia, so we have a left-handed power hitter. 12 pitchers are enough. Since this is an ideal roster, I would have Berrios in the rotation as well. Realistically, I would keep Milone until Berrios is ready.