Everything posted by dbminn
- Article: Twins Trade Kintzler To Nationals
- Article: Twins Rumor Central: Sunday Edition
- Article: BREAKING: Twins Acquire Garcia From Braves
- Article: Twins Minor League Report (7/17): Slegers, Ynoa Toss Gems
-
Quintana to the Cubs
Good comments. I was looking at the Twins likelihood of winning v. the White Sox. The Twins are later in the cycle and we know 7 of them can compete in the majors. Maybe most of Chicago's prospects will become starters in the minimum amount of time. It usually doesn't happen so smoothly, especially for pitchers. Only time will tell.
-
Quintana to the Cubs
The White Sox are 11 games under .500 and headed south. They are doing what they need to rebuild. They will be strong about the time the Twins core group is eligible for free agency. (Maybe earlier, depending on who they get for Robertson and Frazier) The Twins have five position players age 25 and under and are headed up. Two Twins starters are here to stay and are 23 and 24. There should be at least two more new relievers up later this year. Granite and Garver give the Twins some depth. They also have enough farm talent and available cash to acquire players and compete for the next four years. I'd rather be the Twins than the White Sox. Of course, we could trade our MLB talent and build for 2021...
-
Quintana to the Cubs
The top two prospects in the trade have serious potential. Still, I'm surprised the Cubs didn't have to add a third prospect from their top 30. I would've traded the four Seth mentioned for Quintana.
-
Article: Deadline Primer: Should Nick Gordon Be On The Table?
Nice to see a big debate about going after a very good/excellent SP with top prospects. The team is finally getting better. Gordon has to be on the table to get the talent and control the Twins need in a SP. The bigger question is: Are the Twins willing to include Kepler and Gordon (+ others) in a trade to get one of the top four mentioned? I'd say yes to Archer, who is under control through 2021. I've been assuming in previous TD posts that the Twins won't go that big - but I'd like to see them try.
- Article: The First Half Of The Twins Core Four
-
Article: The First Half Of The Twins Core Four
Agreed. I was responding more to the idea that Rosario can be traded because he is blocking Granite. I'd be ok with moving Polanco or Gordon and other prospects if the Twins go after a Sonny Gray-type. Gotta give up something to get a talented SP. Esco can handle SS if Polanco is traded. But if the Twins trade Rosario mid-season they would be left with a rookie LF and no depth to cover injuries. If they have to add Rosario to get a deal done, so be it. But there is a good chance it would be a step back for the rest of this season. I'd rather give up Polanco/MiLB prospects or wait until the end of the season to make a big trade for a SP. The Twins will have a better idea about Granite after a few months in the majors.
-
Article: The First Half Of The Twins Core Four
There is room for all five, at least for this season. There is no other depth at AAA if someone gets injured. All of the top teams have depth. They're giving Garver some time in the OF at AAA but he's not a full-time solution. In the meantime, Rosario has been very good since May 1 - .295/.338/.497. His K Rate has been down all season (19%). He still hasn't reached his peak, IMO. Granite is a superior fielder but we won't know if he can hit MLB pitching for a while (months, not weeks). If they do make a deadline trade, I'd rather see Grossman go than Rosario. Grossman has value as a bat for a contender and Vargas can hold down DH with Garver as a second option.
-
Article: Deadline Primer: Are Twins Buyers Or Sellers?
I wouldn't trade prospects at the deadline for a short-term pitcher even if the Twins stay in the race. The premium will be too high. I'd continue to keep an eye out for veteran SP/RP that might be salvaged. There are a few players that could be traded if the Twins fall back. Utility players are usually in demand so Escobar could bring back extra mid-season value. Same with professional hitters. I could see Grossman traded at a premium as well. Grossman and Escobar are under 30 years old and relatively cheap. They could help the Twins if they make a serious run next year. I'd only trade them if we get near-ready pitching in return. Gimenez might have value if a contender loses a C to injury. He's kind of a favorite of mine but Garver is ready to step up. Santana and Kintzler are in demand but the Twins are already short on pitching. I think the Twins can contend next year so I'd only trade them this mid-season at a very high premium. Sign Kintzler for two years, if necessary. Bigger trades can be made in the offseason. The Twins may have to trade a young OF, Gordon and/or some of the very young prospects to get a controllable SP. Or maybe they could open the Pohlad pocketbook and sign FA Tyler Chatwood (28 years old).
-
Article: Twins Minor League Report (7/9): Gordon Stars, Garver Hits Three Out
Three players reached base by K/WP for three different Twins affiliates and they all contributed to runs? Must be a new strategy decreed by Falvine.
-
BA Midseason Top 100
Gonsalves needs to be on the list. He's struck out 30% of all batters he's faced in AA, his BB/9 are less than 2 this year and his career MiLB ERA is 2.19. He's making AA look easy and he's still just 22 years old. But as long as he doesn't throw 97 mph, he won't be ranked.
- Article: Should Twins Usher Youth Movement In Rotation?
- Article: Twins Minor League Report (6/27): Miracle Walk-Off, Lewis Drives In Four
-
Article: Twins Minor League Report (6/23): Albanese, Kendrick Lead E-Twins To Walkoff Win
If Garver is going to replace Gimenez, he should have at least four relief appearances instead of four starts in LF.
- Article: Twins Minor League Report (6/19): Rochester Dominates
-
Article: Twins Select Brent Rooker, Landon Leach On Day 1
Here's a scouting report for Rooker from John Sickels: "Performance-wise, there’s nothing not to like here: his numbers are outstanding and the SEC is the premier circuit in college baseball. Lest you think the gaudy numbers are a result of the metal bat, Rooker has also hit very well with wooden bats in college summer ball, hitting .360/.413/.604 in the 2015 New England Collegiate League and .305/.335/.426 in the 2016 Cape Cod League. Wherever he goes, he hits."
-
Zach Granite
Vargas should be recalled if the Twins go back to 12 pitchers. Zack Granite is most likely the next Twins OF if one of the regulars gets hurt. I'm all for him coming up if he's needed. He has a lot of positive tools: defense, speed and contact. In the meantime, Granite has had only 100+ PA at AAA. Another month or two in at Rochester will probably help (yes, 25 year-olds continue to learn).
- Article: Twins Minor League Report (5/27): Granite Gets Last Laugh, Hits Walk-Off Winner
-
How long can two players carry a team?
I'm not so worried about the Twins position players. Dozier will have a streak or two and I believe at least one of the youngsters other than Sano will take a step up. One point of optimism is the defense. All of the starting position players are at least competently fielding the ball. That hides a lot of pitching deficiencies. The back end of the rotation needs help but the biggest problem is the bullpen. Let's hope the prospects can finally stay healthy. IMO, there are four relievers to choose from as the year goes on: Burdi, Melotakis, Curtiss and Bard. Gotta hope two of these guys will be ready come July 1. Regardless of the results in 2017, the team looks like it's shaping up to be very competitive in 2018. Mejia, Berrios and the RP prospects will have more experience under their belts. Falvey will be able to sell FA pitchers on the team's defense. And maybe Lamonte Wade steals the LF position next year?
-
Article: Game Thread: Twins @ Indians, 5/12-6:10pm CT
Hah! Class of 78. We're all scarred.
-
Article: Game Thread: Twins @ Indians, 5/12-6:10pm CT
Seriously? Me too. Population slumped after the Great Otter Harvest of 1932.
-
At what age do you start to discount prospects?
If by "prospect", one means a player who could become above average over several years, I'd say 25 is the last year of prospect status if they have at least 500 PA in MLB. I'd say 26 for the rest. I wouldn't necessarily give up on other players who have physical talent and are committed to improvement until 28. I'd be very careful using Zimmerman's aging curves for prospects. His method addresses a very limited question and suffers from the different number of observations in each age cohort. There are far fewer 19-21 year olds playing ball than those in their mid-late 20s. There are a lot of players who make the show in their mid-20s who stay in the league a very short time. They are quite likely to show an immediate decline in performance. Anyone interested in aging curves should look at a series of articles by Brian Henry. In the last of his five-part series, he shows that above-average players - defined as those who make it 10 years in MLB - show a very shallow aging curve until about 32 years old for hitting. By that measure, a talented prospect can still give you six good years from the age of 26.