Everything posted by mnfireman
-
Locking up Louie: Should the Twins Extend Luis Arraez?
MI Depth between MLB & MiLB: Polanco, Arraez, Gordon, Sano, Lewis, Martin Miranda, Cavaco, plus some lower level prospects that may or may not pan out. Arraez is a known commodity and if he can't be traded I think it makes more sense to go year to year in arbitration, much like the team did with Rosario. His knees are bad and his stats are trending the wrong way.
-
MLB Expansion
From Wikipedia, concerning the 1997 expansion draft: For the first round, 15 players from the rosters of their entire organization—both their 40-man roster, plus all minor league affiliates.[4] Each team could add three more players to its protected list after each round.[4] All players in an organization were eligible to be drafted, except those with no prior major league experience who had less than three years service if signed at age 19 or older, or had less than four years of service if signed at age 18 or younger.[5] Players who were free agents after the end of the 1997 season need not be protected.
-
MLB Expansion
I would be for expansion if for no other reason than to even out the leagues and eliminate/minimize interleague play. Pitcher development would become extremely important, but I think the days of 6 inning starters would become a thing of the past and the 3 true outcome hitters would become more the norm. However, one question has not been asked: Which player/prospect(s) are you prepared to lose? If teams can protect only 20 players, which 20 do the Twins protect first? They will be able to add to the protected list anytime a player is chosen, but could still run the risk of losing of a top prospect or MLB starter. Looking back at the past drafts, teams lost some very good players/prospects including Trevor Hoffman, Vinny Castilla, Carl Everett, Brian Harvey, Joe Girardi, Bobby Abreau, Ruppert Jones, Jim Clancy, Ernie Whitt and other past and future all-stars.
-
Could the Twins Weather the Blowback of a Luis Arraez Trade?
Yes, are you? His 3 year splits are trending the wrong way: '19 - .334/399/.439 '20 - .321/.364/.402 '21 - .294/.357/.376 AVG down 40 points, OBP down 42 points and SLG down 63 points. And he has bad knees, which will not get better as he gets older. Buxton's (your comparison) 3 year splits are trending up: '19 - .262/.314/.513 '20 - .254/.267/.577 '21 - .306/.358./647 I don't think his numbers will stay at the '21 level, but probably somewhere around the 3 year average - .277/.321/.575. And Buxton's injuries have not included bad knees, but have nonetheless limited his playing time. Gordon, Lewis, Martin, Miranda, or FA signings such as Jonathan Villar, Josh Harrison or Matt Duffy could step in and do what Arraez does.
-
Could the Twins Weather the Blowback of a Luis Arraez Trade?
Arraez should be traded this off-season before any trade value he has goes away. He has no power, no speed. no defensive position and he has been injured too often. He could be easily replaced by any one of several players with more upside as a defender or hitter or both. I don't think he will be one of those players that we (the fans) will look back on and say "if only the Twins had kept him."
-
What Will the Twins do with Miguel Sanó?
The Twins will put him in the line-up at 1B & DH, trying to maximize match-ups, as $9.25MM is a reasonable amount to pay him. They will try to move him at the deadline, and, if they get a good offer, will trade him. If unable to trade him, they will look at his numbers and decide whether to exercise the $14MM option for 2023. He has only had 1 season (2018) where he wasn't above league average in OPS+ and compares favorably to some good MLB players through age 28 according to Baseball Reference: Similar Batters through 28 Kyle Schwarber (966.1) Dave Kingman (942.8) Chris Davis (941.8) Greg Vaughn (938.3) Carlos Quentin (934.1) Nick Swisher (932.9) Randal Grichuk (932.0) Michael Conforto (930.3) Joc Pederson (926.1) Max Kepler (919.4)
- The Biggest Mistake the Twins' Front Office Made This Offseason
-
MLB Trade Rumors & the Outfielder That Got Away
Hindsight is always 20/20. Badoo was a 22 year old who had missed 2020 due to no minor league baseball that season and had slashed .214/.290/.383 in 29 games in A+ in 2019. Nobody foresaw him being picked in the Rule 5 draft, much less having the season he did. If the roles had been reversed and it was the Twins who had picked him, TD posters would have been going insane saying how bad of a signing this was because he would have had to stay on the MLB roster all season. Wade had showed very little in his time with the Twins, slashing .211/.336/.347, Cave slashed .248./.328/.431 over the same period (.254/.321/.451 if you include 2018). Cave had a better track record in MLB and the Twins were hoping he would bounce back from a disappointing 2020. He got hurt early in did not. If I recall, there was some dissent here on TD about trading Wade last off-season, but nothing too bad. Until he started hitting in SF. If both continue to produce at the level they did in 2021 then yes, they can be added to the list of "The one that got away", but if they regress (see Goodrum, Niko) we will not be talking about them at all in a couple of years.
-
Twins Future Position Analysis: Relief Pitching
Twins relievers had a 3.45 ERA in August & September, and this was after they lost Rogers to injury and traded Robles to Boston. I think roles were figured out and the players made the necessary adjustments to be successful going forward. Does this mean continued success? Possibly not, but I think the BP is not of concern on the level of SP, SS and to a lesser extent, LF.
-
Falvine still on pace with their plan... whatever that may be.
You keyboard warriors run a pretty good front office from your home home office...
-
Bring on the computer, knock off the framing
https://www.thebiglead.com/posts/mlb-robot-umps-are-bad-red-sox-astros-human-error-01fjez51ne91
-
Falvine still on pace with their plan... whatever that may be.
Falvey also elected to develop pitching instead of signing big name FA's in Cleveland also. Some of those guys turned out okay, maybe it will happen here....
-
Bring on the computer, knock off the framing
Typical reply from you, cherry pick part of a statement to suit your argument. Of course I know/realize the home plate ump doesn't make all calls on the field. Read the examples I listed.
-
Bring on the computer, knock off the framing
I am not interested in watching baseball games umpired by robots. I think it will lead to even more bad calls on the field because the umpire will not be as involved. Look how many "bad" calls are made because the umpire knows it will be reviewed anyway. If the umpire isn't making the ball and strike call, he may be disinterested when needed to make the foul tip, hit by pitch, foul ball off the foot, catchers interference or similar call. And just like those advocating for it, my opinion will not be changed by any amount of lobbying by those in favor.
-
If the Twins want to trade Josh Donaldson, where does he go?
Probably LF, unless they can move Hosmer (his contract goes through '25, but falls to $13MM a year from $21MM a year after this year). Otherwise they could rotate guys through the DH spot and he could play OF, 3B and 1B.
-
If the Twins want to trade Josh Donaldson, where does he go?
They already have a power hitting 3B with a big contract (Machado).
-
If the Twins want to trade Josh Donaldson, where does he go?
Pohlad's calling: You are hired to run our baseball investment. You clearly are forward looking and have a keen eye for investment possibilities. Name your salary.
-
Twins Future Position Analysis: Second Base
They also had Rosario in LF, a decent starting pitching staff, a usable BP and a Kepler who could hit....
-
Would you sign Andrelton Simmons to a one-year, $5m contract?
He's probably talking about Larnach, Rooker, Kirilloff, Gordon, Rortvedt and the revolving door of pitchers that didn't perform well in MLB and that we (fans) shouldn't pin our hopes on this years AAA players contributing a lot this season.
-
Would you sign Andrelton Simmons to a one-year, $5m contract?
Sano, Astudillo, Gordon, Colina, Thielbar, Kepler, Garlick, Happ....all Twins players who lost time due to Covid-19, bad teammates also? The AP also said that Simmons case was unrelated to all other cases. As I said, like him or don't like him, leave the Covid, the vaccine and the politics out of it.
-
Would you sign Andrelton Simmons to a one-year, $5m contract?
So when did they start letting posts go into politics (vaccinations). I've seen threads get shut down for less, but now its the admins and moderators going against community standards so it must be OK. Like the guy or don't like guy, that's fine. Keep the politics out of it.
- The Twins NEED a Shortstop
- The Twins NEED a Shortstop
-
Do the Twins Have Tradeable Assets?
This team has several tradeable assets, however, most of them are also key pieces to this team competing in the future. Unless team options are picked up, Sano is a FA after 2022, Kepler and Donaldson after 2023 and Polanco after 2024 (he has a vesting option for 2023). In addition, Rogers and Duffey are FA after 2022 and Maeda and Garver are FA after 2023. That's a lot of positions to fill. Some (most?) will be filled from within, so that takes Kirilloff, Larnach, Lewis, Miranda, Martin, Jeffers and most any pitcher off of the "tradeable asset" list, unless included in a package to fill a need long-term. If the universal DH gets voted in, Sano and Donaldson become tradeable, but most teams will choose Sano because of age, contract and upside. If Kirilloff and Larnach prove they can play, Kepler and Sano become tradeable. Miranda and Martin may prove to be good UT types, making Arraez available. If Rortvedt shows he can hit, then Jeffers, and to a lesser extent, Garver, become available. Rogers and Duffey may best be used in trades to bring in more prospects. Donaldson either performs like last season, almost earning his contract, or doesn't and is DFA'd (think Pujols). I would hope a combination of 3B, DH and an occasional game at 1B could keep him on the field for 135 games or so. Miranda and/or Martin could make Polanco available, but I like him for 3 more season at 2B. Unlike some teams, the Twins don't have much margin for error, the prospects need to pan out or the the reset button needs to be hit. Falvey and Levine's kids need to show that they are ready to be prime time players.
-
Your Top MLB Rule Change
1, Pace of play - in addition to the pitch clock (and I like the penalties), institute a baserunning clock. Let the player celebrate his HR, but make him run the bases in less than 25 seconds (I think the average is just over 22 seconds, but we all have seen 30-35 second HR trots). Also, no slow walks from the BP on pitching changes, these guys are professional athletes. Shorten time between innings, that last TV commercial can be shown on split screen. 2. Start night games at 6:30 or 7:00, not 6:40, 7:10 or 7:20. A "normal" game will be done by 10:00. I cannot get onboard with changing to electronic strike zones, just as many variables as (or more than) human umps, up to and including the system going off-line or being hacked. We have all watched games where the replay system was down, the bullpen phones weren't working, the scoreboard quit working, the tv and/or radio feed was down, etc... That and I like the human element part of the game, the players need to figure out the ump and adjust to him (though I guess they can't adjust to a shift).