Everything posted by Taildragger8791
-
So what exactly do we do about the catcher spot?
We shouldn't ignore 2013 where he had 10 starts, with mostly rough results. The fact he's regressed since 2015 is a signal that this is what Gibson is. Most likely something more like 2014. Expecting his best season to become his baseline isn't all that reasonable. The reason I say it's misleading because it ignores the innings component. He gives up a lot of good contact and gets knocked out after 5-6 innings regularly, putting his team on their heels. Calling every game with 3 runs or less "good" is painting with a broad brush. Reviewing his game log I'd call 3-4 of his games no-doubt good (7-8 innings with 3 or fewer runs didn't give up a lot of runners). The other 3-run or fewer games he still gave up 8, 9, 10 runners, went only 5-6 innings, and generally put pressure on the defense, bullpen, and offense to all pick him up. I have hope for Gibson but I'm not thoughtlessly slotting him in as my #4 and moving on. Their needs to be a contingency plan for him if he continues pitching to a 4.50-5.00 ERA into next year. I could see him having better results with a gold glove infield defense to vacuum up the ground balls, but considering the adventures at 3B and SS right now I don't think he has that luxury.
-
So what exactly do we do about the catcher spot?
The issue with league-wide stats is 1/3 to 1/2 of teams aren't playoff caliber and drag down the numbers. If you're looking to compete you need to look at the teams in contention and match up with what they have. I don't have time to research today but I'm guessing they don't fill most of their staff with 4.31+ ERAs. On a good team even a number 5 should give you a chance to win most nights. Gibson does that every 3rd or 4th start, maybe, but most nights is giving up 4 runs over 5-6 innings and leaving with runners on base. Hard to win those games (unless you're playing the Indians and have a Max Kepler).
-
So what exactly do we do about the catcher spot?
That's a misleading way to look at it because he often gets pulled after 5 or 6 innings when he's struggling, limiting the damage. 4 earned runs is workable if you go 7-8 innings, but hurts when it's only over 5 or 6 and he's turning it over to the bullpen with runners on base. He's made it through 7 innings 3 times this year. He's a borderline #4 or #5 on a good team when he's going well and has a good defense to vacuum up all the contact he gives up. But he hasn't reached that level consistently other than a decent 2015. A winning team would have a plan for 4 pitchers better than him and be keeping an eye out for a replacement in the event he turns into a human Juggs machine again.
-
So what exactly do we do about the catcher spot?
I don't think you have a choice but to go into next year with those rotation candidates, since you don't want to block prospects, but I'm not going to pretend that isn't a rocky rotation either. You'd be fortunate to get 2 pitchers under a 4.00 ERA and one pitcher under 3.50. Santiago is a wildcard but we'll get a good look this year to evaluate him. But Gibson and your #5 are likely to be adventures who could need replacing, and you'll need another prospect or two ready at that point. That could cost a lot of games while it shuffles out. Next year is a big development year for our pitching, similar to what our hitting has been going through lately.
-
So what exactly do we do about the catcher spot?
Other than a hot stretch for the first couple of weeks in June he's been a disaster. In July he hit .191/.219/.221. Woof. He could bounce back next season but I wouldn't bet the position's future on him, Garver, or Turner being ready in April. I think you have to pick up one half-decent catcher for next season, even if it's resigning Suzuki for a year. We saw what happens earlier this year when you just throw a bunch of stuff at the wall hoping something sticks. Most of the time you just end up with a mess at your feet. Good teams build in insurance and make players earn their job.
-
So what exactly do we do about the catcher spot?
That doesn't sound like someone I want to slot into a starting position, however. There needs to be at least one competent catcher on the roster to stabilize things in the event Murphy doesn't bounce back. The Twins need to stop putting lottery tickets into can't fail situations.
-
Article: Twins Minor League Report (8/2): Walker Homers, Plouffe Rehabs
Chargois reportedly has three above average pitches, including a power changeup and breaking ball. I don't think that's the issue.
-
Article: Twins Minor League Report (8/2): Walker Homers, Plouffe Rehabs
Mystefied as to how Chargois is still in AAA with an ERA of almost 1.
- Game Thread: Twins @ Indians. 8/2 @ 6:10pm CT
- Game Thread: Twins @ Indians. 8/2 @ 6:10pm CT
- Game Thread: Twins @ Indians. 8/2 @ 6:10pm CT
-
Game Thread: Twins @ Indians. 8/2 @ 6:10pm CT
This gave me a flashback to yesterday when I was doing some online training. A couple of pop quiz questions provided only true/false answers but it wasn't a clean true or false situation. After answering it comes back "It depends." with a long explanation. Wanted to throw the monitor out the window. Can't believe someone got paid to write that.
- Game Thread: Twins @ Indians. 8/2 @ 6:10pm CT
-
Game Thread: Twins @ Indians. 8/2 @ 6:10pm CT
Gotcha. I haven't followed the Dodgers closely so I don't know what he's been doing throughout the year. Just skimmed his stats page and saw he wasn't a total trainwreck, which is what I assumed it would take to demote him. I wonder if he's been hot dogging on defense again too? That was a sticking point with him early on.
- Game Thread: Twins @ Indians. 8/2 @ 6:10pm CT
- Game Thread: Twins @ Indians. 8/2 @ 6:10pm CT
- Game Thread: Twins @ Indians. 8/2 @ 6:10pm CT
- Game Thread: Twins @ Indians. 8/2 @ 6:10pm CT
- Game Thread: Twins @ Indians. 8/2 @ 6:10pm CT
-
Max Kepler
On a surprisingly related note, Wikipedia lists a new owner of the Cleveland Indians. http://m.imgur.com/NvBtkjo
-
Article: Monday Funday
The Angels probably figured they can't or won't resign Santiago after '17 and won't compete next year anyways, so they flipped him and took on a bad contract in order to gamble on Alex Meyer. Their farm system is barren and they took a chance on finding a new stud pitcher. Santiago isn't going to nab a big return but he could certainly net something if we don't need his services next year. He's far more serviceable than Nolasco, Milone, Hughes, or Duffey.
- Article: Official Trade Deadline Day Thread
- Article: Official Trade Deadline Day Thread
- Article: Official Trade Deadline Day Thread
- Article: Official Trade Deadline Day Thread