Everything posted by Jham
-
Souhan: Hunter better value than Mauer
I guess it depends on your definition of "solid and reliable". As far as solid goes, Mauer hit .277 last year, is hitting .274 this year with OPS of .732 and .699 respectively, and with 4 and 0 HR, respectively. These numbers are about on par with Nick Punto's best seasons with the Twins. Punto provided great defense, position flexibility and speed on the bases. Mauer is generously, average at first base and no threat to steal a base. We also batted Punto 8th or 9th, and not 3rd. Mauer needs to get on one of his patented 2 month terrors where he hits everything on a line, if he has that left in him. If he's a mid .270's type hitter with no power at a corner position, he's a liability, and that's without factoring in his contract (which means we will have to stay with Joe no matter the production while someone like Sano, Vargas, Pinto, or Plouffe will get traded).
-
Game Thread, Twins @ Tigers, 5/14 @ 12:08 pm CT
Why did we flip Milone and Pelfrey again?
-
Game Thread, Twins @ Tigers, 5/14 @ 12:08 pm CT
Just checked in on the score. What happened?!
-
Article: Time To Take Twins Seriously?
So, after last night's exhilarating win, the Twins improved their record to a surprising 19-15, four games above .500. Before the season, I compared this squad with the 1991 club that went "worst to first" mostly because I believed this team was not as far away from competing as many believed. Anyway, on this day, in 1991 the Twins defeated the Milwaukee Brewers to improve to 17-15. The Twns got a strong pitching performance from Jack Morris and a big home run from Chili Davis. Mollie must have had a tough time picking up that splitter as he went 0-4 with 2K's against the Big Horse. http://www.baseball-reference.com/boxes/MIN/MIN199105140.shtml Our pace is similar to the '91 team. We just need a 15 game winning streak. On paper, their roster is better than ours. But we are much younger, so I can't say our team is necessarily less talented. That said, I think our rotation can be as good as theirs once healthy. We need some guys to break out and have career years. And we need a rookie to break out like Knobby. Not particularly likely, but it's fun to compare and imagine. Also, our bull pen needs to continue to get outs. I'm still not sure how Boyer's is doing it. His peripherals are all around his career avg. (according to fangraphs he has a career BABIP of over .300, either lots of hard contact or a lifetime of unlucky). His K/9 is around half his career avg. so perhaps his success is sustainable, or perhaps he's lost his marginal ability to miss bats, which isn't good considering the career BABIP. Here's hoping it's the former. His stuff looks nice, he's been a pleasant surprise so far, and it's hard not to cheer for a guy like this: http://m.twins.mlb.com/news/article/124187556/pitcher-blaine-boyer-finds-groove-as-twins-heat-up
-
What to do with Arcia?
By "blanket statements" I mean speaking in absolutes. If the plan is to compete in 2016, then we need to consider whether a 40 year old Hunter is a better player than a rookie Rosario, or a Hicks/ Arcia. You've offered one solution: trade Hunter or let him walk and replace him internally. Hunter will bring back nothing if he walks and probably a very modest return if traded. On the other hand, a young promising major league player like Arcia or Rosario might yield significantly more in return. If Hunter produced at the level he has so far this year, and another team offered a few meaningful prospects and a bull pen arm for Rosario, wouldn't you consider that? We could potentially make our team better in the short, and long term. All options should be considered. Hence my comment of "no blanket statements".
-
JO Berrios is #1 starting pitching prospect, correct?
I remember that thread. I had to go back and see how I ranked them just 3 short months ago: I had Berrios, Meyer, and Stewart with Gonsalves actually ahead of Stewart based on left-handedness, apparent total make up and health. Since when is "control" not considered "stuff"? Alex Meyer gets a lot of swing and misses because he only occasionally throws the ball where touching it with a bat is even possible. 94 on the corner is harder to hit than 97 down the middle. Pinpoint control of multiple pitches is the hall mark of a big league starter. I again implore Meyer to mix in more off speed and work on adding and especially subtracting on his fastball in order to improve command. It also makes 97 a lot harder to hit. Finally, can we all agree that Chih-Wei Hu can't make it to the show soon enough, just for entertainment's sake? Who's pitching tonight? Yes. What? Hu's pitching tonight. That's what I just asked. I guess we'll just have to settle for Hu's one of the Twins top pitching prospects. I give up, who?
-
Article: Is The Rotation Turning Around?
Good thing Gardy's not here, he'd be saying how we have 8 number 1 starters. My thought is that the relative success of Gibson and May isn't all that unexpected. So far, Gibson hasn't struck out many. He hasn't had to. I've seen him mix in enough off speed to keep hitters off balance. I do think his K rate will go up as he learns to trust his change up more. But as of now, he's doing fine plugging away with fastballs. Nolasco's struggles are approaching lss at this point. Maybe he hasn't been healthy, but for some reason, I still think he'll be ok. Hughes is experiencing a predictable regression. That said, he doesn't have to duplicate last year to be a solid MLB starter. Pelfrey is the obvious choice to regress. Results aside, it still feels like he's eking by on smoke and mirrors, oh, and double plays. Nevertheless, he's still way better than I expected. If we intend to trade high and receive value in return, it would be wise to field offers on Gibson and May. Both of these pitchers would be attractive to other teams for the same reason they are attractive to the Twins. Obviously, either would have to bring back a haul, and I think either (especially Gibson) could.
-
Shane Robinson placed on family emergency list
Is that true even if they are signed to a minor league deal, like Robinson was? I guess I always wondered how that worked.
-
Shane Robinson placed on family emergency list
I hope Robinson's job is secure when he returns. He was having a nice season here before this happened. I'd hate to seem him punished for having a family emergency. Of course, the skeptic in me wonders whether there is an emergency and whether this is just a way to get him an extra week of severance pay before waiving or assigning.
-
What to do with Arcia?
Can we get past these blanket statements. Hunter is one of our best players, and very well could be again next year, a year we're expected to compete, unless you want to push the timetable back yet again. No one is or should be off limits on a team that has lost 90 games in 4 straight years. There is a distinct possibility that extending Hunter (or any other FA for that matter) and trading Rosario or Hicks or Arcia or whoever will provide more value than trading Hunter and holding on to our youths, some of which are bound to fizzle out and return nothing. Think moving Denard Span to make room for Aaron Hicks vs. moving Hicks while he had value and holding on to Span. It's all about returning value in the short and long term.
- Article: It's Time For Aaron Hicks
-
Article: Eddie Rosario Promoted To Twins; Arcia Placed On DL
Agree completely. When I talked about Hicks as a failed prospect, I wasn't trying to generalize the feeling of the entire forum. All I meant is that Hicks has been passed by Rosario on pretty much every single prospect list I've seen. As such, I thought this move was more aggressive than typical for a front office oft criticized for being overly-conservative. I thought it was a positive sign that they are willing to take some risks and go with higher upside guys over the obvious choice. Of course, as others have stated, it could just be that the organization had other reasons for holding Hicks back. Hicks has impressed me with the season he's putting together in Rochester. What a pleasant surprise it would be if he could turn his career around and live up to the expectations of a high draft pick! Even if he never hits, I think he can be a good defensive replacement on a major league bench.
-
Article: Eddie Rosario Promoted To Twins; Arcia Placed On DL
http://m.twins.mlb.com/min/video/topic/70087564/v104150183/oakmin-rosario-hits-a-homer-in-first-career-atbat Compare with: I do find it odd that this forum supports Hicks who many view as a failed prospect with maybe Shane Robinson upside, over Rosario who was tagged by many as a bona fide prospect. I really thought there'd be more celebration over him getting a chance over the more experienced Hicks. Alas the Twinsdaily forum is a tough audience to please... which I love. The Tommy Milone clip is just included for fun.
-
Article: According To Plan
I somewhat agree. I think expectations need to be realistic. I just don't think May 4th is the time to be declaring that we don't care about winning when we're playing well and in the hunt. I think our young players are getting valuable experience. Winning is not only more fun, it is also motivating. I think it gets guys to play harder and practice harder. The Lookouts seem to have phenomenal chemistry. Winning together has almost certainly furthered their development. Winning allows the flexibility to bring guys up when they are ready as opposed to throwing prospects against the wall and seeing who sticks. Yes, sacrificing player development for a couple more wins is probably not the play. I just don't believe player development requires losing on a big league squad with no chance night in and night out. When players need more development, we typically send them down to the minors, not promote them to the majors.
-
Article: According To Plan
I will say this, we've been fooled a hundred times over the years by spring training warriors and September call-ups who light it up when the games mean nothing. Experiencing winning and dealing with pressure has to be part of any learning curve. But not every player is ready for the failures that inevitably come with a major league promotion. It seems like most of us agree that young players are going to cost you some games. No one likes to feel like they lost a game for the whole team and about a state's worth of fans. There is value to allowing prospects to come up and follow in the footsteps of some veterans without feeling like they let everyone down if they boot a ball or strike out. Look how the shortcomings of Hicks, Florimon, Nishioka, and to a lesser extent Parmalee were magnified because we had to depend on them to play every day. They became local punching bags and had no where to hide because we had no one else. Sitting for a couple days has seemed to help Vargas, Arcia, and Santana this year. Could we have done that and kept winning if we didn't have Nunez, Hunter, or Shane Robinson on the team? Our young guys are getting experience, our veterans are playing well, our team is winning, and we're still complaining? Really? I think this is ideal. We aren't forced to bring guys up who aren't ready. We're (so far) winning games while allowing our young players to rest when they get overwhelmed. Learning to win brings us closer to the goal than learning to hold on to a roster spot. Find a way to help the team (IE take a walk instead of trying for a HR, make the routine play in the field even if you just struck out) even if you're struggling. That's called being a professional. That's what we're instilling. And to those who don't think our success is sustainable, I would ask this: Who is vastly outperforming expectations at this point? Robinson? Pelfrey? Maybe Plouffe after his awful start? Can we really call Gibson or May's success unexpected? Our biggest weakness is the pen, which happens to be the easiest/cheapest area to address via trade or waiver. If Buxton provides any sort of upgrade in CF, and E. Santana comes back at his career average, I can't imagine we'll be any worse than we are now, and we have a significant chance to be better. I hope that turns out, and I think that is and should be the goal. I VEHEMENTLY disagree with any notion that having Vargas, Arcia, Santana, Gibson, May, Graham, and probably Pinto, Meyer, and Buxton experience a major league pennant chase will somehow stunt the development of the team going to next year. Then we can supplement with guys like Sano, Rosario, Berrios, and Burdi to a team that has already shown an ability to compete. Funny, I see that as progress. I guess I just don't get it.
-
Nolasco to return to the Rotation, Milone to the bullpen
Only someone who had never been to a Special Olympic event, never seen the joy on the faces of the individuals who compete, and never appreciated the hard work of the thousands of dedicated individuals who make these events possible would ever mock it. So my advice would be A) go volunteer at an event, and be prepared for one of the more heart-warming and gratifying experiences of your life; Donate $10 to the Special Olympics for every off-colored joke or "R" word and encourage your friends and office mates to do the same; or C) choose a less offensive analogy. Also, Milone, Pelfrey, May, Hughes, AND Gibson have ALL looked pretty capable this year. So I would not agree with the analogy anyway.
-
Stick a fork in Hunter, he is done.
Seriously? We've almost run out of guys to promote. We're back to giving Hicks a fourth chance. Rosario got himself suspended. Buxton hurt himself in his first game back after hurting himself. Hick's hitting ability has receded faster than his hairline. Chris Hermann is actually on the team. Arcia is actually on the team. Colabello, Parmalee, and Benson were all given ample opportunity. Ben Revere was called up mid-season, ran with it, and returned fair trade value. We gave guys opportunities who earned them whether they were a prospect or not, and and now we've ran out. I am sure Ryan knew he was overpaying for Hunter. What choice did he have? Can you imagine what the thread would be if we HADN'T signed another outfielder and Hicks had continued his record-breaking career of offensive futility. And if you think Hick's MLB walk rate is sustainable given his utter inability to hit, then I just so happen to have a bridge for sale!
-
Stick a fork in Hunter, he is done.
I respectfully disagree. I heard Ryan talk about the signing. He admitted Hunter may not be an upgrade defensively, but he stated that the free agent market wasn't loaded with outfielders that could both field AND hit. Based on career numbers and last year's numbers, Hunter is a significant offensive upgrade, well not necessarily a downgrade defensively as we were already bad. Who should we have signed who would take a one year deal? I know playing prospects is a popular idea on this forum, but the average fan might be tired of the parade of failing minor leaguers. I'd rather see Hunter try to relive the glory days than watch a never-ending carousel of Parmalee/Colabello/Hicks playing themselves out of the league one by one. Bear in mind, most fans would rather see someone they've heard of than some fringe prospect they haven't. Doesn't make them worse fans, and their money is just as good as ours. Just because every hipster is guzzling down the latest greatest hop-heavy micro-brew doesn't mean the stadium should stop selling Miller Lite. Our fan base is more than Twins Daily. I don't believe Hunter is a problem on this team. I do not think he is the difference between winning or losing this season, and I do not think that plying Hunter this year will cost us any wins in the future whatsoever. We had extra money. We needed to fill out the roster. We have few vocal leaders. We have few veteran hitters. The free-agent market was week. And we had extra money. Is he perfect? No. Does he solve our defensive shortcomings? No. Is he an upgrade offensively? Absolutely.
-
Stick a fork in Hunter, he is done.
Can this forum please be less reactionary than the average fan base. Hunter has his limitations at this point of his career. I get that this will probably always be a prospect-heavy medium, but Hunter deserves more respect than he's receiving. On the field, I think the whole team is pressing, but we're seeing improvements. Of those who are struggling, Hunter is the least of my concerns. (Compared to Sano and Buxton, Rosario, Santana, Escobar, Dozier post-extension, Vargas and Arcia who were my two favorite players). Despite most of the team struggling to hit, and Hughes being 0-3 and playing some really good/hot baseball teams, we've actually hung in pretty well after a tough start. Let's calm down and put down the pitchforks. I mean, even Boyer is looking better of late.
-
Was This A Balk?
So I'm assuming you've seen this maneuver before? I never have. To me, given that the rule is open to interpretation, the argument that a gimmick is legal on a "technicality" is less persuasive to me than the common sense application. IE, if a pitcher delivers the ball in a way that no pitcher ever has, that is a balk. "Technically" Tom Brady's arm is coming forward. Common sense says he's not trying to throw it, it's a fumble. #tuckrule. That play fit the definition of a fumble and an incomplete pass. The refs chose to interpret a technicality when they did not have to. If the refs call a fumble, no one outside of New England remembers that play. I'm a lawyer, except when I'm posting here. Judges hate technical arguments. So should umps. Never should they decide a call based on a technicality if they can resolve it based on a simple reading of the rule. On a close call, who should we award? The pitcher who was caught napping, and made a panicked throw to the plate, or the heady base runner who picked up on the pitcher's cadence and made a smart play based on his belief that a pitcher couldn't do what he did.
-
Was This A Balk?
The knuckleball is an actual pitch. Many pitchers throw a knuckleball. How many pitchers throw pitches before they finish stepping? 0. Your comparison isn't fair. Obviously there is grey area in the rule. But throwing a knuckle ball is well within the rule, like getting pulled over at .05 Blood Alcohol. IMO, short-arming a throw before finishing your natural throwing motion is outside, or perhaps in the grey area, I'd argue a .22, but others may think it's a .08+- .01.
-
Was This A Balk?
Put it this way. In the many years, and many millions of pitches I've seen, I have NEVER seen a pitcher deliver the ball before his front foot touched down. That's a XXX,000,000/1 ratio. If that's not considered deception or an "alteration" then there is no such thing. Put another way, if the ump had ruled a balk and provided the explanation that the pitcher clearly altered his natural delivery beyond simply speeding up his usual delivery, would there have been a thread like this on the KC forum? I doubt it.
-
Article: What To Make Of Mike Pelfrey
Pelfrey really did not pitch all that well did he? He got into the same number of jams as usual, but then balls were hit at fielders instead of between them? If the double plays were just FC, wouldn't he have given up a good 3 or 4 runs and we would have probably lost? I've never been a big Pelf fan, but results aside, I need to see a bit more. I was fooled by Deduno last year. Luck is luck. Don't get it confused with stuff. At the same time, Pelfrey owes us, and Nolasco may be worse yet. Maybe Pelf really has turned a corner. If that's the case, I throw him 120 pitches every 3rd day until the wheels fall off or his arm falls off, whichever comes first. My bet is on the wheels, because I'm still not convinced he's even average.
-
How Long for Pinto?
I like Suzuki and think he has some value. I think he brings enough to the table to be a starting catcher, but probably is better suited toward splitting time at this point of his career. Obviously, we've seen all the "wild pitches" this year, many of which a better defensive catcher may have saved. I am really starting to wonder about Kurt's ability to call a good game. He seems to call for a lot of fastballs on the outside corner. Obviously, that's a good pitch, but after 5 in a row, it becomes a lot more hittable. Yesterday, with runners at second and third, no one out, up two, with the number eight hitter at the plate. We needed a strikeout or at least a ground ball to the left side to prevent the tying run from advancing to third. Instead, Suzuki called for fastball after fastball on the outside corner, until the batter timed it up and just shot one to Dozier, one run in, the other to third. He came in to tie the game on a sac fly. Royals later take the lead and win. Pinto could have done that I'm pretty sure. Pinto needs at bats when he comes up, and not at the expense of Suzuki. We have bigger problems than Zuk right now. Arcia's swing is broken, and Vargas needs some polishing. I'd send down Vargas as he hasn't faced AAA. Pinto can DH and spell Zuk without disrupting other positions.
- Article: Twins Minor League Report (4/13): Hicks And Buxton Power Wins