Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Dman

Verified Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Dman

  1. I have been waiting for that All-Star lineup at High A to break out and they finally did. Once those bats get rolling it is going to tough that group. All the guys I gave up on last year seem to be off to hot starts (i.e. Cabbage, Blankenhorn, Diaz, even English and Whiutefield seem to be surging). Here's hoping they keep it up and make this prospect group even better.
  2. I think a lot of us were hoping they would hang onto Austin longer but I am not sure I ever felt he would be a long term fit for this team. I agree there was a decent chance for his value to increase if we kept him longer and I think the Giants got themselves a deal. If he does make progress they might be able to flip him for something decent or hang onto him and have a nice power hitter on the cheap for a while. IMO I think he makes it but I question how good he will be based on K rate. I mean he just needs to hit around 250 or 260 with his slugging that will be a good deal for the team he is on. He is close to that right now but pitchers will adjust and can he adjust back I just don't have the confidence he will. If 30% to 35% of your outs are automatic (i.e. K's) and the BABIP average is 300 you are losing 30 to 40 points of batting average to the average hitter and the average hitter has trouble hitting 300 because they likely have a 10 to 15% K rate or higher. So if Austin does manage to hit the BABIP average of 300 the best his batting average can be is something like .240 and it will most likely be less than that if continues to strike out at those rates. He has to bring that down to put more balls in play so that he can bring up his average and OPS and create more value. I hope he does and like you said we only have a small sample size. He hasn't been given much time to adjust but looking back at his MiLB numbers he looks kind of like the same strike out prone player to me. Palka made it why not Austin? I just question how good either of them will be in the end.
  3. Yeah we pretty much agree then. I want to maximize value as much as possible as well but will sacrifice where it makes sense. I hope Austin decreases his K rate and does well. Maybe he will prove me wrong but at the same time I think we will be just fine without him.
  4. When you have a surplus of talent at one position and a weakness at another I agree pretty much every GM is going to trade that surplus talent for talent that can potentially make the team better as a whole right now. So I agree with you on that. While I think most GM's would agree with your thoughts on position player value ( i.e. right fielder more valuable than 1st base) it seems short sighted to me in some ways. Let's say for the sake of argument we believe that our weakness is 1st base and we have a player who plays in the outfield but his bat and defense will play at 1st base. Why wouldn't we use them there if he makes the team stronger as a whole? Even though that player has more value in right or left field they still provide more value at your current weak 1st base position. I just think there are more ways to think about a players positional value when they have the flexibility to play multiple roles. They can still make your team stronger even if they aren't maximizing their skill set at their strongest position. While I understand your position and it makes sense to me I just think that being more flexible about defining player value can be valuable as well.
  5. I agree both Raley and Kiriloff can play in the outfield but on this team who would they replace? Maybe if Kepler continues to struggle or Rosario gets injured they could replace them but their bats and defense would still play at 1st base. They could be rotated into the outfield as they have that ability but the guys that are there right now I think are pretty set as they are good offensively and defensively. You could argue that both Raley and Kiriloff can easily play the corners and they could trade one or two of the four corner outfielders for pitching if they wanted to, but I think if they can find another place where their bat would play why not use them there. As to your statement about which of those they would call up today probably none of them are ready right now. Raley might be but that is more of a guess than a statement. Rookers K rate and just plain swing and miss rate make him not ready and Kiriloff though talented could use more challenges\seasoning before making that kind of commitment to him. With Austudillo improving at catcher, Garver could play 1st right now as it looks like his bat would play at that position as well as catcher. Sano could also play first with Marwin or Austudillo playing third. So even with the lose of Austin I think we still have in house options. If all those fail there is always some grizzled vet out there that could be plugged in. We agree on a lot of things, even Cron to some degree. I just can't see Austin as that valuable with the K rate he has and you see him likely getting over the hump with more at bats. We will have to see how his season goes and then can find out which of us was more right or wrong. Fun discussion. Thanks!
  6. Good point. I never loved the Cron move but am OK with it. I guess I just see the future differently than you do. I think Raley, ROOKER, or possibly Kiriloff end up at first base with as much or more potential than Austin. I don't like Austin's K rate making 30 to 40 percent automatic outs does not bode well for his future success. If his K rate was lower I would be on your side.
  7. I think he will do slightly better than average BABIP so I think option His in play for him this year. It is a long season and an injury could impact his numbers but he is such a good hitter I can see him beating the average. Option A is the low bar he might do something in between A and B. I guess we will find out at the end of the year but he is off to a good start and that helps.
  8. His BABIP is .410 right now I believe so he going to regress to the mean there. His K rate has been around 15% for his career and never really wavered much so I don't see him being worse than option A and I think Option B is close to where he ends up. With some nice BABIP luck he could hit your option C number.
  9. I think a lot of us on this site wanted to see Austin get a chance at 1st base and I agree I don't see a huge difference in the players when it comes to OPS. The main differences appear to be K rate about 10% less for Cron in MLB if IIRC. Also the lefty righty splits are in Crons favor as well. If you feel the quality of at bats are an important indicator for future performance then I think you go with Cron. If you go with gut and hope a player improves on some known weaknesses then you probably go with Austin. The other thing you fail to mention is why is it that only Austin can improve? Why can't Cron improve as well? It just feels like there is some bias in your analysis to me. I like Austin and have said I believe he can make it in MLB but he has a number of warts and right now I would rather develop Raley or Rooker for that role as they are not that much different than Austin and they have Options remaining.
  10. At least they took one game from the Mets. Tough to just give a game away but I guess that is the way it works sometimes. Growing pains I guess.
  11. That was horrible at bat by Cron. Everyone seems to be guessing tonight. Ump is giving Thor the edges as well.
  12. How can pitchers not know how to throw strikes? Unbelievable!!!
  13. For love of god somebody take him out of the game. He should be a reliever not a starter.
  14. WHo walks the pitcher? I have lost all faith in Odo.
  15. Would be nice if Aududillo would work counts a little bit more. Seems like they are throwing him junk early hoping he will hack at it.
  16. Good in what way? OPS for the moment? I think that 41% K rate is going to catch up to him eventually. He also has a .750 BABIP I am sure he can keep that up all season. Don't get me wrong I like Austin but if you Like Austin then you should like Rooker just as much as they are the same player. Only Difference is that if you have a log jam at 1st base \ DH Rooker has options. Based on the numbers I think the Twins did the right thing here.
  17. I was never a Diaz backer. Thought it was a bad pick but what this guy is doing is changing my mind. He has really slimmed down which should help him defensively. He seems to have a decent eye at the plate and he makes good contact. I really like what he has done and it shows he is serious about trying to make it to MLB. I am cheering him on this year as he needs a big year to regain the prospect status he has lost. He is off to a real good start. I hope he keeps this up.
  18. Really like Garver and Austudillo in the same lineup together. Both have good bats and make the lineup tougher IMO. What a night for Garver. He will be hard pressed to have a more impressive night the rest of his career. Two HR's against one of the best pitchers in Baseball, Wow. I really liked that lineup and if you through in Cruz and eventually Sano it kind of becomes pick your poison for pitchers. If they stay healthy this should be a fun offense to watch.
  19. 34 pitches and no outs. That is not a guy you want on your team.
  20. Over time I have become a Cabbage Skeptic. There has been so, so much swing and miss to his game that I am doubting he makes it past High A. He needs to worry less about power and just contact the ball. If you don't put the ball in play you are an automatic out. He has already been passed by players younger than him drafted a year later than he was (i.e Miranda, Rortvedt, and Baddo) to name a few, Maybe he will be a late bloomer but IMO this is a make or break year for him. If he doesn't show improvement in his K rate his chances of making it are razor thin. I am glad he is off to a good start, but he needs to keep this up to move up IMO.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.