Everything posted by TwinsDr2021
-
Florida got a C from Pittsburgh.....
I much rather have the two prospects and Garcia at 53 (4 years) million, than kepler for 25 (3 years) If I am Miami. Tim - don't get me wrong as a Twins fans I would love to have them trade for those two prospects and I would give up Kepler to get them, I just don't think Kepler or at least him alone is going to get them, that has been the point I have been trying to make, very badly I admit.
-
Florida got a C from Pittsburgh.....
I just don't see Miami taking Kepler for these two. I mentioned he will be 24 when he pitches next because he pitched 58 innings in 2018, 54 innings in 2019, 20 innings in 2020, 71.1 in 2021, normally next year would be 100-110, but it will be 0 again. so it will be another 3 years until he gets to 100-110 innings in a season. This is they way teams are bringing along pitchers these days, watching their innings. People get mad when you point it out, but the data is there. So if he is to become a MLB starter it will be closer to when he is 27, if he is going to become a relief pitcher he could be in the majors by 2024.
-
Starting Pitching Trade Partners: Cincinnati Reds
Hard pass on the Sonny Gray trade, no way I am giving up the years of control and IMO the gem of the minor league prospects for 2 years of Gray, I would be willing to trade Jeffers and a much lower ranked and older pitching prospect for Gray. Would be willing to do the Mahle trade as long as there was decent FA signed as well. Also a hard pass on Luis Castillo, not giving Lewis up for two years of control. Might be willing to do it for Martin who I think might end up better than Lewis but IMO has no real chance of being a major league short stop (since he has only played 45 games at short in the last 4 years)
-
Florida got a C from Pittsburgh.....
So you want the Twins to trade Kepler for a relief pitcher and a pitcher that is out next year and will be 24 before he pitches in the minors again?
- Probable Work Stoppage Pushes Free Agent Frenzy
-
Florida got a C from Pittsburgh.....
Why would Miami trade one of their top prospects, a 23 year old lefty handed pitcher in AA (1.77 ERA in 15 games, with 99 K's in 71.33 innings) and another 23 year old pitcher and top 2 prospect that was a top 81 prospects going into last year for Kepler? That would be a better return than the Berrios trade. If the I was Miami, I would be asking for Lewis, AK, and Balazovic for them, not a 29 year old Max Kepler.
-
Probable Work Stoppage Pushes Free Agent Frenzy
Remember when the Tigers were so bad they picked up the Twins scraps, now? To be honest all those deals minus Scherzer and Verlander were less than I was expecting, and the Twins could have done one or a combo of a few of them. I don't think Stroman is worth 20 million a year, and I am guessing others don't either or he would have signed a 5/100 already. I think he swallows some pride and takes a 1-2 year contract with the Mets.
-
Pitchers that are available
why sign Pineda for 3 years, his last two contracts have been for 2 years? On top of that he will be 33 in a month or so, and never has had a season with a WAR higher than 2.7. Also I can't imagine Stroman would take 3 years, when Ray(5), Gausman(5), Rodriguez (5), Gray (4), Matz (4), 37 year old Scherzer got 3, and soon to be 39 year old Verlander got 2. I would love to get Stroman for 3, but is is realistic? and I would give Pineda 2, not three, because the prospects should be than him in by the time the contract is done.
-
FO's tentativeness is killing the team
They better hope it isn't 24 before they are good again. No fans 20, 16K a game in 21, and if they are terrible again and running bullpen games out there nightly, it will be even lower in 22, by 23 they will have to be giving away tickets. And if they can't figure out a way to get their games on streaming, well.....
-
Twins show patience
So locking up a good pitcher for 4 years at a reasonable price (barely more than they paid for Pineda the last few years) is a bad idea because they don't have a SS right now? By the time the savior is up he would still have two years left on the contract and either be a back end starting pitcher (because the pitching prospects will be up) or a wipe out relief pitcher, still relatively cheap.
-
For The Future: A Possible 2025 Roster
Like all the work you did, and if you even get 30% of those prospects hit, this FO will be winning all sorts of awards.
-
Twins show patience
Matz signed with the Cards for 4/44 with the possibility to earn 48. Seems like the twins could have done that.
- Should the Twins Trade for Athletics Starter Sean Manaea?
-
FO's tentativeness is killing the team
Not sure next year is the year to go after FA pitchers. Chris Bassitt, Matthew Boyd, Carlos Carrasco (club option), Mike Clevinger, Jacob deGrom (opt-out), Zach Eflin, Nathan Eovaldi, Chris Flexen (club option), Kyle Gibson, Sonny Gray (club option), Andrew Heaney, Dallas Keuchel (club option), Sean Manaea, Wade Miley, Mike Minor (club option), Charlie Morton (club option), Joe Musgrove, Aaron Nola (club option), Jake Odorizzi (player option), David Price, Chris Sale (opt-out), Luis Severino (club option), Ross Stripling, Noah Syndergaard, Jameson Taillon, Taijuan Walker (player option)
-
Report: Rays, Wander Franco agree on 12-year extension
Just think in 10 years we will be talking about Tampa has to trade their best players before then become free agents, j/k Congrats Kid!
-
Which new 40-man addition will be the first to the Twins
Hopefully you are correct they will jump the prospects inning a large amount this year. I mean why not it isn't like any of those guys are young from a prospects stand point. Winder was coming off 86.1 and 107.2 out of college and then 123.2 (combined in 2018 85/38.2), then 125.2 (his only year with a 100 professional innings), then 0, then 72 last year. and was shut down for shoulder fatigue, if that doesn't scream workload management not sure what else would. For the most part the Twins haven't jumped prospects innings a bunch from year to year. The college guys pitch a few more innings than they did in the college the next, the high school kids go up by 20-30 a year.
-
Which new 40-man addition will be the first to the Twins
Name(2018,2019,2020,2021) Winder - 123.2, 125.2, 0, 72 Sands - 75.1, 97.1, 0, 80.1 Vallimont - 109.1, 127.2, 0, 94 Ober = 75, 78.2, 0, 108.1 I guess I don't see a huge difference with any of them (and not one of them pitched as many innings as Ober last year), I would not expect then to double any of those pitchers innings, Maybe Vallimont could see a jump up to 130-140 innings, but he was also terrible last year in AA. Maybe the Twins think these guys are old enough that they don't have to worry about innings anymore, and I would be fine with that.
-
Which new 40-man addition will be the first to the Twins
Couple of things, all the pitchers listed (minus Enlow) will/should be on the same inning count as Ober was this year, so I don't see any starting in the MLB rotation, they could make the team out of the pen, but that doesn't make sense either if they believe them to be starters in the future. As for service time, if the Twins are worried about that with these guys that seems weird, since the youngest is Miranda and he will be 24 in July, the rest are already 24. (again minus Lewis and Enlow), can't imagine either of them being in Mpls this year.
-
Jake Cave's contract is guaranteed
agreed, they are paying Colome 1.25 to not play, 800K is nothing in the grand scheme of things. The only way it really turns bad for the Twins is if they suck and they keep playing him over a prospect. I don't want Laranch/AK or Celestino being the 4th outfielder, so hopefully the plan is to let the young guys play in the minors and Cave ride the bench until they are ready. Why pay any more than 800K for a guy to ride the bench? Or they know he is still hurt and they are being kind to him knowing insurance will cover most of the 800k? (At least I hope that is what the FO is thinking)
-
Am I wrong? I'd rather the Twins have Martin, Woods Richardson, and $20M per year to spend than Jose Berrios?
Didn't Winder pitch 85 for VMI in 2018 as well? and Varland pitch 55.1 for Concordia in 2019? and didn't Ober pitch 56 for Charleston in 2017, 75 in 2018 and 78.2 in 2019, then 108 in 2021? I have never heard that pitchers get promoted based on the amount of innings pitched, so I guess that's on me? I thank you for pointed out examples to back my case. SWR pitched 17.1 professional innings in 2018, then 106.2 in 2019, then 53.1 in 2021 and got hurt (You pointed out the obvious that he got hurt, and if players don't get hurt they generally pitch more innings), you don't think the Twins are going to take it slow with him? Most of us were pretty good with taking it slow with Ober, but with a 21 year old prospect they just traded for Berrios they are going to rush his innings count? With jordan balazovic, they went 32 in 2016, 40.1 in 2017, 61.2 in 2018, 93.2 in 2019, and he pitched 97 in 2021 (again he was hurt at the beginning of the year, so we don't really know what the Twins plan for innings was, but Austin Schulfer had the most innings in all of the Twins minor leagues (110) Edit: FYI, I never said he won't be in the majors before 2024, I think there is a good chance he is in MN next year by mid-season or a little later, because he pitched so well at AA and AAA, I was trying to say he won't be a full-time 5-6 inning full season guy until them. (so maybe now you will quit arguing against yourself though me)
-
Am I wrong? I'd rather the Twins have Martin, Woods Richardson, and $20M per year to spend than Jose Berrios?
In August was terrible, .200,.280, .480, if they could of they probably would have sent him down. But he picked it back up a bit in September, .340,.395, .736 Would I trade Martin for Baddoo, nope, because I think he CAN be better than Baddoo in the future. Would I trade Baddoo for just about any non-pitching prospect in the Twins system, yup.
-
Am I wrong? I'd rather the Twins have Martin, Woods Richardson, and $20M per year to spend than Jose Berrios?
Which is exactly what I was trying to say, SWR pitched: 106.2 in 2019 0 in 2020 53.1 in 2021, So I can't imagine in the next two years they will let him go over 120, so it would be the third year where he goes over that level. (Maybe I am off by a few and they let him go 130ish in 2023, but it is basically the same thing, he won't be a 5-6 inning starting pitcher for 25 plus starts until 2024) I didn't say that the FO is wrong for doing this, I was just pointing out this seems to be their MO. I was just trying to temper expectations that he was going to be savior for the major league staff in the next two years.
-
Am I wrong? I'd rather the Twins have Martin, Woods Richardson, and $20M per year to spend than Jose Berrios?
Agreed, at this point aren't we hoping Martin at age 23 does what Baddoo at age 22 did in the majors? With Martin in left/center I love his OBP and hate is SLG, with Martin at SS playing above average defensive, I absolutely love his OBP, and am happy with his SLG. Just to clarify, I am talking about his minor league SLG, not his college SLG. ( I get all the reasons people might say about why that happened, he was young for AA, he started in AA, first year with a wood bat, but won't that all be true next year (minus the first year of a wood bat?) I also just looked and Martin has played a total of 45 games at SS since 2018. Compare that to with Royce Lewis who has played 275 since 2017. I can't image any team throwing a young kid with 45 games at SS under his belt to the wolves, so if the FO thinks he can be a major league SS, I see him starting in AA next year (possibly AAA).
-
Am I wrong? I'd rather the Twins have Martin, Woods Richardson, and $20M per year to spend than Jose Berrios?
Making crappy assumptions is tired as well, I NEVER mentioned moving prospects along though the system slowing, I was talking about innings pitched, and some of your examples above prove my point. Now maybe you could enlighten us with examples of pitchers they jump large innings? "Twins bring pitchers along it could be another three years to get him to 120+ innings a year."
-
Am I wrong? I'd rather the Twins have Martin, Woods Richardson, and $20M per year to spend than Jose Berrios?
I will take the Blue Jays side of this deal, I would easily give them back Martin and SWR for Berrios and his contract. I would also take Berrios and his contract over the assumed contract the older guys (Ray and and Gaussman) are going to get. Now if you told me the Twins are going to sign Ray or Gaussman, and their contacts is going to be between 3 - 5 years, that might change my mind. But I am also the type of person that would trade SWR and Martin for a consistent 3+ WAR pitcher. I love SWR as a prospect, but it also worries me a bit he has only pitched 177.1 innings since 2018, and with the way the Twins bring pitchers along it could be another three years to get him to 120+ innings a year.