Everything posted by TwinsDr2021
-
Twins Daily 2022 Top Prospects: #3 Jose Miranda
So do you think the Pohlads send people to this site to see how the wind is blowing, and those people report back, hey we might have finally convinced the fans to save you money, and the Pohlads laugh like the Duke brothers? (trading places reference) Currently now they are sitting 44 million under last years payroll with options(based on numbers from Baseball Reference), and there is talk to trade Sano (10 million) to save money, Donaldson for sure (50 million over 20 years with buyout), and some have suggested Kepler (about 16 over 2 years with a buyout). And others are worried about spending money on a 29 year old SS, who was a top 12 MVP 3 of the last 4 years, and the year he wasn't only had a 4.2 WAR, because he makes too much or might possibly be blocking a guy that hasn't played in two years and never has hit as good as Story even when Story hasn't been great. If people aren't willing to spend money on a 29 year old offensive player, who are you ever going to be OK with signing?
-
Twins Daily 2022 Top Prospects: #3 Jose Miranda
IMO it comes from, fans love the hope of a prospect, they dream of the prospect being a yearly all star stepping in taking over the position with very little struggle. Then when that prospect gets real close to be depended on, we fans start pointing out things that have probably been there the whole time, but we have to temper our expectations to as not to be let down by the player, because we are already dreaming on the next prospect. Look at the wild up and downs on Lewis for example. Two years ago he was the Twins SS of the future, he started getting close last year and we fans were talking about him moving to the OF, maybe staying at SS. Now that it is likely he will be in the minors all year, we fans are talking about how he might be the SS of the future again, and my guess is if he bat is decent, going into next year we fans will be saying maybe LF is his position until Buxton contract is up, traded or injured.
-
Who goes when making room for prospects on the 26-man?
Rooker and Gordon seem like the only two that could be cut. Carrying 3 catchers seem fine, and if somebody gets hurt you are adding another anyway. Celestino and Larnach are the unknowns and probably could return something young and decent. Trading Sano or Kepler, probably make the team worse in the short-term unless all the others play well. Arraez seems like the best trade piece but also the best plan B and C for some other positions. With that being said it looks like Martin could be this years Miranda, should be called up but probably won't.
-
MLB Talks ... latest news
The opening day left fielder was Cave (600k), game three was Kyle Garlick (570k), game for was Rooker(300k), all three players worse than Eddie. The twins saved around 7 million dollars by not signing Eddie, and where did they spend that 7 million (Simmons maybe)? Sure it might be a bit more complex, and it was probably the right thing not signing those players, doesn't take away from my point that I was trying to make about the players hopefully seeing their future and doing what they can to change it. Berrios was traded because they wouldn't pay him what he wanted, and where did they spend that money they saved? (or the belief could be he hated MN so bad he there was no amount of money that he would have signed for) We will see this year, if Martin is up right away or if SWR sees the majors, then it might not look like a money deal, but if Martin is good and isn't added to the 40, or if SWR looks like he could be brought up and isn't well.....
-
MLB Talks ... latest news
You are probably correct, which explains why nothing really got done. It looks like they get paid only during the season, not spring training or the playoffs. IMO, the owners see what these new age FO are doing (Keeping costs low) and don't want to change that, I am sure they know there will be some price to pay for it (like less people in the stands), but at the end of the day it can save millions of dollars (for example not signing Eddie, ODO, and trading guys for prospects a few years out) Look at the Berrios trade for example. they save 10 million this year (assuming SWR and Martin don't play in the majors), they get to put a rookie in the starting rotation to replace him, and they control Martin until he is 30, they can hold back SWR until probably 2024, thus controlling him until he is almost 30. If they turn out better than decent they can offer a less than value extension bringing them to wrong side of 30. It is a great business model for the owners and a horrible model for the players and fans (well unless the FO is magical and is always churning though players and the ones that come up are almost as good) Imagine if all teams did something very similar, most 30+ years olds would be hired guns and don't have a bad or down year. IMO, this is what the players need to worry about.
-
Twins Daily 2022 Top Prospects: #4 Jordan Balazovic
Love the optimism, it seems weird that the FO didn't think they could do that in September last year, but would be able to do it at the start of this year. I think Balazovic needs 10 - 15 big league stars this year at a minimum to, if there is hope he is Shane Bieber like. I believe Winder needs 15 or more since he is much older.
-
MLB Talks ... latest news
Both sides know there is no real pressure to finalize a deal until it starts hurting the others pocket books. In negotiations one side always has the leverage, The players knew they had it in the offseason because I believe they aren't getting paid anyway, so they can ask for the world. The owners know they have no real leverage until it starts hurting the players (development or Pocket books) so they ask for the world and pretend to make concessions on things they started higher than they wanted anyway. IMO the owners don't care much about spring training, I am assuming that isn't really a money maker for them, I might be wrong, but I assume the money being made is in the cities they teams play. The owners will get more serious if they TV money stops or revenue from the regular season stops, the players will get serious when they aren't getting their paychecks, and right now if I was an owner I would be betting on that I have deeper pockets than most players and the players will start pushing their leadership to get this done. Also if I was an owner I would be telling the players leadership, how much money is it going to cost guys like Lewis, Winder, etc with a short season and them not getting big league time to start their clock? If you are the Pohlads for example and most of your pitching prospects are already getting older (in terms of pitching prospects) delaying their service time another year, how much money you can save in the long run? Half of these prospects will be on the wrong side of 30 when they become true free agents and more than likely unless they are awesome will never see the big contract with lots of years, this philosophy could actually help lower revenue teams compete until the next contract is due. On the players side, they have to see the writing on the wall, teams are overprotecting their pitching prospects by slowly bringing them along in the minor, thus getting to the majors later, reducing the time to earn big money, and on top of that not training the pitcher to be actual starting pitchers again reducing the money they can make, all in the name of injury protection. Look at this site and how many people have talked about the idea of a pitching staff of innings (starters, stacking, no real roles) , you don't think the players see this and think, this isn't so much about a philosophy but an amazing way of keeping cost down? For the hitting and defensive side the stat analysis have made a ton of players expendable when they are getting close to free agency as well. (Look at Eddie for example, a 29 year old coming off two top 20 MVP years and basically hitting 25 plus homers for 4 years in a row, he got a 1 year 8 million contract) the players have to see that and say WTF, unless you are future HOF, you are might struggle to get contracts after you become a free agent, so they basically sign less than the value extensions, putting them on the wrong side of 30 again. (again on this site the Twins signed Donaldson at age 34 coming off a top 11 MVP and people were complaining he was too old, and since that day trying to figure out how to get him out of town for somebody cheaper and not necessarily even as good) (I understand this stuff doesn't really affect the best of the best, teams will always treat those players different) That is my long winded rant for the day, have a good one.
-
Twins Daily 2022 Top Prospects: #4 Jordan Balazovic
Agreed, if there was no lock out the AAA rotation should be Balazovic (23), Winder (25)/Strotman (25) (one in the majors), Canterino (24), Varland (24), Sands (24), these pitchers are all too old to be starting anywhere but AAA, I don't care about innings or injuries, unless the plan a head of time is to give them 3-5 in AA and bring them directly up to the majors. Duran should be in the majors pitching out of the pen. And if the Twins start Jordan in AA because of these other pitchers, #4 is too high.
-
Was the Miguel Sanó Extension a Mistake?
The Twins have better defensive of options? Who AK? he has played 64 games at first since 2016. or JD moved over from 3B. The extension was fine, he hasn't blocked any prospect from coming up or hindered the team from signing anybody. Why are people worried about 10 million of Polhads money?
-
VIDEO: Keith Law: Twins Pitching Prospects "Not Above The Median"
I am not defending Law, way back when he was free on ESPN I read all of his stuff. I think it was in one chat where he said something a long the lines of younger pitchers are hard to project, so you take size, arm motion and stuff and project what they could be, thus why you see pitchers like Kohl Stewart so high on lists, but the older they get the closer they are to what they will be than would they could be. And besides SWR none of the Twins prospects are all that young. Shane Bieber was getting his feet wet with 20 games as a 23 year old, got better at 24, awesome at 25. I remember a debate about the NY Mets maybe assembling one of the best pitching staffs in history. Thor, Harvey, De Grom, Martz (and maybe wheeler, don't remember all of them) around 2014 and it was pointed out most them were already in their mid 20's and weren't likely to get much better than they already were and shouldn't be mentioned in conversation, because they hadn't really accomplished anything at that point, 7 years later to this point besides De Grom and Wheeler (in Philly) as a group they didn't get any better. I don't really think the Twins need their top prospects to get better (except SWR) than they are they just need to continue what they have been doing in the minors in the big leagues. So we can hope one of them magically becomes amazing in the majors or just be happy that 5 or 6 of them will be solid and maybe a bit better for a few years in the majors.
-
Where does Baldelli rank among MLB managers?
Maybe that is why there is not a huge uproar for what is happening in MLB right now, besides from the hard core fans and journalists. None of my casual baseball fans really care if or when the baseball season starts. If you aren't a fan of the twins (meaning the need for a few young guys to get some reps, Lewis and Winder for example) do most casual fans care if the season is shorter/delayed cancelled? I have talked to friends about the idea of stacking pitchers and starters with the young Twin pitchers and they are like cool, maybe in a couple of years I will tune in and watch if they are good. (SSS I know)
-
Twins Daily 2022 Top Prospects: #5 Joe Ryan
To me the only reason he isn't number 1 is that he is already 25. He didn't even pitch in the minors until he was 23, but that year TB didn't waste time and had him pitch at A, A+ and AA. Then after 2020 moved him right to AAA. So in less than 2 years in the minors he was pitching in the Olympics and in the majors, that is great. With him turning 26 in June he doesn't really have the luxury to not be pretty darn good most of the time, which I believe he will be with his age, ability and experience of the Olympics. Him and AK are the only two plug and play young guys, all the others are fingers crossed .
-
Where does Baldelli rank among MLB managers?
Not arguing with you but who do we blame what Shoemaker said about the Twins? The organization? He didn't pitch great for Sacramento (SF) but his walks and K's were way closer to his norm than in MN where walks were way up and K's were down. I can't stand Rocco, his in game annoys me and his post game annoys me (and I know that is on me), and maybe it wouldn't matter who this FO hires it would the same. When I see guys on 1st and 2nd and a left handed batter roles one over to the right side (when basically nobody is on the left) and hits into a double play, it makes me not want to watch and I blame Rocco for not installing/coaching situational awareness, or when Sano is one of his droughts and it is later in the game with guys on base, I want him pinched hit for and he is not and wildly swings at balls. Or a pitcher cruises though five innings with a mediocre but not high pitch count and he brings in a relief pitcher, knowing you still need 4 innings and will be required to use two pitchers not as good as your starter. Maybe that is not all on him, but he is the Manager and ultimately that falls on him. IMO a manager has to have a feel for the game and players and I don't see it, others may and that is fine.
- Twins Daily 2022 Top Prospects: #6 Matt Canterino
-
Projecting the 2022 Twins Opening Day Roster: Version 1.0
Miranda is on the 40 man, so I see him making the team out of spring training before Rooker, unless Rooker takes the 4th outfield spot over Laranch. But anyway you look at it this team could easily be as bad as some of the worst Twins teams ever, question marks at every level, no chance I would pay to see this team, or even watch it on TV. I am not sure how a team could come up with a worse pitching staff than this, there is really only one for sure pitcher in Rogers (and he was injured at the end of last year). Every other pitcher is a question mark.
-
Twins Daily 2022 Top Prospects: #7 Jhoan Duran
I just don't see this happening. 100 inning relief pitchers for a bunch of reasons. Scott Proctor was the last pitcher to do it at age 29 for his career basically last one more year. Dellin Betances pitched 90 as a 25 year old rookie went down each of the next four years, and has been hurt or terrible the last 3. Also, I can't imagine union or at least player agents being OK, with bringing up pitchers on the cheap to pitch 100 innings and then basically their career being over or not have a chance for a multiple year contracts. Also I see agents steering their players away from teams setting up their minor leagues system to implement it. But all this just my opinion.
- Twins Daily 2022 Top Prospects: #7 Jhoan Duran
-
Twins Daily 2022 Top Prospects: #7 Jhoan Duran
I agree with this, IMO he is rated too high. He will be 24 this season which isn't horrible, but having pitched only 16 innings the last two years isn't a good. IMO if he is running out of options, it makes no sense to waste any time in the minors, he can pitch out of the bullpen (starting with low stress situations, maybe have a starter and have him planned to pitch two innings, or coming in for a couple innings if a starter goes bad) in majors and keep his innings down and be around major league coaches. I seen no reason to be wasting 100 mph fast balls from a 24 year old pitcher in AAA. Or trade him and let the other team worry about the 40 man roster spot, like TB did with Strotman) Not to change the subject but are all the other teams having issues with pitching injuries based on the missed 2020 season or are the Twins fans (me included) just wanting to make excuses?
- Do the Twins Have a Shortstop Development Problem?
-
Manfred Announces Universal DH: Will That Result in Sano or Donaldson Being Traded to an NL Team
Sorry to be clear I was saying JD (3B), some SS, Polanco(2B), Sano(1B), AK(LF), Buxton(CF), Kepler(RF), Garver(C), and Arraez (DH) and a rotation of AK, Sano, Garver, Polanco (with Arraez and/Gordon getting playing time at second) at DH. You know be creative with the players. And if Miranda tears it up in spring training there will be plenty of playing time in this rotation for him, 3B, 1B, DH. You can always fine spots for guys playing well, Rocco should be able to figure that out. Rooker is 27, there is just as good a chance that Sano's gets "it" than him. If Rooker was a few years younger I might be willing to bet on him over Sano, but no chance I do now. And now people are talking about bringing up Austin, I would hope the FO has learned a little bit from that. (bringing guys up to early, or leaving Plan B as bringing up guys to early) Are you saying there can be a plan A and a plan B for the offense going into the season? Instead of just throwing out rookies and crossing your fingers, and if they fail plan B would be the Cave's, Broxton and Telis's of the world being run though MPLS?
-
Manfred Announces Universal DH: Will That Result in Sano or Donaldson Being Traded to an NL Team
I usually am not worried either, but I see the chance of them using quite a bit of spots on pitchers this year, IMO I think Martin is going to have to show his bat is better than Celestino was last year.
-
Manfred Announces Universal DH: Will That Result in Sano or Donaldson Being Traded to an NL Team
If Sano is gone, You could put Miranda at 3B, Kiriloff at 1B, JD at DH, and one of the other 3 has to play left, and Martin isn't even on the 40 man yet, so lets say Arraez in Left, with Larnarch, Rooker, Celestino and Martin as backups, which I guess you could believe they all will be at least average, but with that you have two unknowns starting in the infield, and backs are unknown as well, if you are the FO are you really betting your career on that all the while banking your pitching staff on rookies. I wouldn't, unless of course somebody was willing to pay quite a bit for Sano (I mean like the Cruz trade good). If I am the FO, I am starting JD, some SS, Polanco, Sano, AK, Buxton, Kepler, Garver, and Arraez at DH (with JD, Sano, Garver, and others helping out there), and forcing Miranda and Larnach to prove they belong by tearing it up in AAA.
-
Manfred Announces Universal DH: Will That Result in Sano or Donaldson Being Traded to an NL Team
If his bat is even average that might be the best solution, of course he isn't on the 40 yet, so that means somebody has to be removed, unless of course they use Maeda's, which I kind of assume will be used on a pitching prospect, but maybe not.
-
Manfred Announces Universal DH: Will That Result in Sano or Donaldson Being Traded to an NL Team
If the depth you are talking about is Rortvedt (Catcher), Gordon (middle fielder and should never DH), Lewis (in the minors), Celestiono (4th OF as of now), Larnach (Not sure where he even starts) and Rooker (DH), I would argue that isn't really any depth, let alone plenty. Do people realize Rooker is only a year and half younger and has less than 2200 MLB at bats than Sano. At this point I don't give two rips about the Twins payroll, for the reasons others have said.
-
Manfred Announces Universal DH: Will That Result in Sano or Donaldson Being Traded to an NL Team
I don't think you should trade guys to make your team worse, trading Donaldson for sure does that, Sano before the season is a real possibility. I love me some Arraez, I hate, hate him as the everyday DH as plan A. No team should ever, ever trade away a well above average MLB player so you can get playing time for Rooker or Gordon. IMO you don't need to trade away players because you are blocking prospects, if Miranda starts out in AAA like he did last year, you make the adjustments at the major league level to get him at bats (guys will get hurt or just not be good, or you could always trade Donaldson at that time), same with Larnach, Lewis, Martin. If you start the season with Miranda at 3B, AK at 1B, and Larnach in LF, what is plan be if they get hurt or aren't good. Rooker, Gordon, or being forced to call up Martin or Lewis if they aren't ready? Sounds like a plan to fail. (On top of the Twins as of now are already planning on doing that with their pitchers) If the twins want fans to show up this summer, they better be at least decent on the field to start.