Everything posted by TwinsDr2021
-
Should the Twins Sign Jose Miranda to a Long-Term Extension?
To be fair to the Twins they also have had younger guys come up Buxton, Arraez, Polanco, Kepler, Sano, Berrios. It just seems like Atlanta guys have shined brighter. Albies and Acuna were young international signings, Grissom was a 11 round pick and Harris a 3rd rounder in 2019 both high school picks and completely amazing they were not affected by the Covid year like all the Twins prospects. Back on topic, It seems like a no-brainier to sign these young guys early for how many years were Kepler and Polanco for example considered great trading chips compared to the guys that didn't sign these contracts. Sure you might miss on a guy or two but the upside is so much higher that it seems like a gamble worth taking.
-
Sonny Gray not too happy with Rocco...
Not hard to admit because that isn't at all what the conversation has been about, you have tried to make it that, but my points have been how the Twins do thing compared to the rest of the league. I am not mad at all on how the Twins are treating starting pitchers. Do I hate it? absolutely! If I was the GM of the Twins would I being doing something similiar? Absolutely in the major leagues, not in the minors but that is a different topic. It should be super easy to prove the Twins are doing it exactly like other teams, but nobody has even tried to prove that, shouldn't that be fairly easy, shouldn't like 80% of the games be the examples? And when I have pointed out numerous games that happen daily the come back is the Twins pitchers are just not good enough isn't that more reflective of the job the FO is doing? I think the consensus on TD is that Berrios has been pretty terrible this year correct? On three occasions he has been allowed to face the number 9 hitter, and once face the lead off hitter 4 times (total times a Twins pitcher has faced the 9 hitter - Twice), 14 times he has faced 25 or more batters in a game, that is 3 more than the whole Twins team. Again I could do this exercise over and over and over, with pitchers that aren't Verlander, Kershaw and Scherzer) on just about every teamand you still going to try and save that it is 2 hitters a game? I get it that the average innings per start is going to be fairly close at the end of the year, but quite a bit of that will be a bunch of longer starts and a bunch of shorter shorts, but that isn't how the Twins get their average (they don't have a bunch of the longer games) But hey if you want to continue to mislead people into believing they the are doing exactly what everybody else is doing, you be you and other people can say generally understand what the Twins are doing at any given time, but there are teams and pitchers that wouldn't be taken out in certain scenarios.
-
Sonny Gray not too happy with Rocco...
Or the Twins just don't have the Stud pitchers needed to go further (innings, BF, innings per start) when ALL the pitchers in minors are pitching the same amount of innings or less than the major league club? I think Louie Varland the 24 year old pitcher recently promoted to AAA is averaging the most innings per start (5) (or at leas the most inning pitched in the minors) and went 5 1/3 in his first start while allowing 1 hit and 2 walks)
-
Should the Twins Sign Jose Miranda to a Long-Term Extension?
I would for sure don't see any reason not to. Not to get off topic but how the heck does Atlanta continue to turn out young stud prospects? (Age debuted) Harris (21), Grisson (21), Contreras (22), Austin Riley(22), Dansby Swanson(22), Acuna Jr (20), Ozzie Albies (20), Fried (23), Strider (22), Kyle Wright(22)
-
Sonny Gray not too happy with Rocco...
So we are talking pitches per start now and team records, young guys? I thought it was about TTO, limiting exposure? The goal posts seem to move every time something that might go against this comes up. The argument that Keller and lynch doesn't hold water, because I could point out game after game, where teams lost pulling the pitcher one inning earlier or facing less batters than Lynch or Keller, and just as many games where they pitcher went the same amount of innings or batters faced as Lynch and Keller and didn't give up any runs. I use Dan Dunning as an example because he basically is a 27 year old no name pitcher that has been allowed to face 25 batters or more 8 times this year (Which is 3 less than the whole Twins pitching staff). His team is 3 - 5 in those starts one was 3 -1 win, one was a 5-3 loss, one was a 6-5 loss, was one a 2 -1 loss, one was a 7-6 loss in extra innings, these are not blow outs ( 4 of them were prior to June 4th, so they weren't out of contention at that point) He averages more pitches per start, more innings per start and more batters faced per start than any Twins Starter, and my guess is if you asked most people on TD if they would trade him straight up for Ryan or Gray the answer would be a He!! no. Why is it so hard to people to admit how the Twins are treating their starters this year is mostly the same as everybody else but more extreme? And if the answer is because the Twins pitchers just aren't as good, we should be hammering on this FO, shouldn't we be? I mean how many years does it take to find one guy, just one like Dunning (or the dozens of other pitchers doing similiar things for example? I mean the Texas Rangers are paying Perez 4 million dollars to do things the Twins pitchers can only dream of doing? and yet the Twins are paying Bundy more, Archer just 500K less, They traded a first round pick to get Gray and their best pitching prospect/Rookie has completed 5 2/3 innings in 5 of his last 15 starts.
-
Sonny Gray not too happy with Rocco...
I love this statement, because it has been pointed out in this thread and others that what you said is not 100% true (absolutely teams treat starting pitchers very similiar and in some cases exactly the same as the Twins and I could point out multiple examples from any random night this season), But it also has been proven that pitchers on other teams on a nightly basis do face more batters pitch more pitches per start or more innings per game and earlier in the thread I posted the names of some of these pitchers and it isn't only the top few pitchers in the league and then the comeback is the Twins pitchers just are not good enough or they don't have a number 1 instead of just agreeing that yes the twins are doing something the league is doing but to more extreme way. I don't understand if you believe this how you are not calling for heads to roll in this front office? How many years have they run the Twins and they haven't came up with 1 starting pitcher that is even a bit better than league average? (When has the likes of Keller, Lynch, Martin Perez, Dane Dunning became #1 types?)
-
Sonny Gray not too happy with Rocco...
That is the question, if you are going to let your starter pitch the 5th against batters 1-4, why then all of sudden start throwing out TTO int he 6th, which I think everybody assumes are less batters than 1 - 4? Maybe we don't have all the numbers, and the top few guys in the lineup don't benefit from seeing a guy a third time, because they are so good every time or pitchers work them different and a third time isn't really an advantage and it is the lesser hitters that improve from seeing a pitcher the third time? I mean that isn't' what people are saying but maybe what the teams are doing? I feel pretty comfortable saying that nobody has said that, But based on the numbers the Twins are doing something a bit different. I mean when 24 different pitchers in the last two days have faced 25 or more guys (two days in a row against the twins) and the Twins have done it 11 times all year, you have to admit something is happening. Dane Dunning (who?) just did it for the 7th time today.
-
Sonny Gray not too happy with Rocco...
Brendan Rodgers of Colorado (.285/.338/.434/.772), Sean Murphy of Oakland (..251/.327/.450/.777), J.T. Realmuto (.258/.331/.436/.767) are the closest comparison to players to the TTO numbers. Jesus Aguilar, Kepler, Gurriel are examples of FTO. I hardly think it is fair to say facing a third time though is like facing Freeman, Betts, Turner and Smith every batter. Comparing what teams averages are doesn't make any sense what so ever to me in this context, I can't actually grasp the logic behind it. It makes me feel either you or the Twins can't grasp these numbers, because ever single Twins starter (minus Archer) averages facing the top 3/4 in the order every game and barely if ever above that, So they are letting the best hitters on the other team have a third go round with the Twins average at best starters then taking them out against the worst hitters? How in the world does that make any sense? It is like they are stacking the deck against their own pitchers or intentionally doing something to make them look worse?
-
Sonny Gray not too happy with Rocco...
It means they face less batters, thus they pitch less innings and this is proven by being 28th in the league in starter innings. If they were in the middle or top half it could mean they are more efficient.
-
Sonny Gray not too happy with Rocco...
I am not sure how ERA works in this (see previous post) but out of a 100 hitters that is 3 hits, 1 extra guy on base (2 if you round up) and looking at slugging it seems those extra couple of hits are homers? With the way people talked I expected the numbers to be way worse, especially since (I assume) the numbers shew heavily to the top of the order guys?
-
Sonny Gray not too happy with Rocco...
Honest question on 3rd time thru the batting order ERA or any time though the order. If the 7,8,9 hitters get on base (lets say their second time up) and the lead off hitter hits a homer, are the runs the 7,8,9 hitter counted to the second time though or the third time though? As for the question on apparent, I would say that is more of an assumption. For example George Kirby came out in the 6th inning (last night Seattle) with batters 5,6,7 due up he got the first two and was taken out after walking the 7th guy this after giving up two runs in the 5th, those two extra guys he faced helped bring his TTO numbers down as opposed to not letting him start the 6th. In the other game talked about Phillies/Reds, both pitchers came out for the 7th one to face the 6th (walked), 7th, 8th and 9th batter, the other to face the 7,8,9 batters. Both of those pitcher's TTO numbers improved by facing the bottom of the order.
-
Sonny Gray not too happy with Rocco...
To put this into a bit of context. Numbers of times facing the position in the battering order. 1 - 15 2 - 15 3 - 9 4 - 8 5 - 4 6 - 3 7 - 2 8 - 1 9 - 0 So they are asking him to basically face the first 4 guys in the batting order three times but nobody else, shouldn't the numbers be very badly shewed? That is like asking the pitcher face Arraez, Buxton, Correa and Miranda 3 times, but noting allowing him to face Sanchez, Gordon Celestiono, and the rest of the team. Which totally explains why his numbers are so terrible this year. I am not saying he should or should not go further but when pointing something like this out it helps to have context, don't you think? How many people know he has faced the first two batter combined more than the other 7?
-
Strikeout: 3 Long-Term Bullpen Problems for the Twins
You say that like it is True, I would argue that they are the more opposite then the same of the Twins. McClanahan started last year (24 year old Roolie) almost exactly like the twins treat all their pitcher for 8 games, but since has averaged facing 6 innings and over 23 batters faced. Kluber has average 5 1/3 and 23 batters faced. Rasmussen is similiar to the Twins pitchers but then they go with a starter for when their starter isn't great.
-
Twins Minor League Report (8/16): Wind Surge Blows Away Tulsa
thanks, good info!
-
Twins Minor League Report (8/16): Wind Surge Blows Away Tulsa
Out of curiosity are there any Twins minor league pitchers doing much more than this? (5 innings)
-
Bally Sports+ to Launch September 26, Without Twins For Now
I have lived without the Twins on TV for that last couple of years (HULU) and I will continue to do so, Won't pay anything more to watch them. If I want to catch part of a game I will head to my low brew pub have a beer or two with my wife and watch for an hour or so or head to planet fitness and walk on the threadmill for a hour. What baseball might learn is that looking at the box scores and talking about baseball is just as fun as watching some of the product on the field.
- Strikeout: 3 Long-Term Bullpen Problems for the Twins
-
Sonny Gray not too happy with Rocco...
Here is the list of pitchers for the Twins that have faced 26 batters in a game. Smeltzer (1), Bundy (3), Gray (1), Ober (1) that is it six for the whole year. Just yesterday here is the list of pitchers that pitched to at least 26 batters Lodolo, Suarez, Lynch (against the Twins), Contreras, Marquez, Valdez, Lauer, I would guess most people couldn't name half of the teams these elite pitchers pitch for? But lets move the criteria down to 25 batters faced in a game shall we, the Twins Ober (1), Paddack (0),Smeltzer (2),Archer (0),Bundy (3),Gray (2),Ryan (3) that is 11 for the year, now lets again look just at last night. Remember there were 7 that went 26 or more so will be just adding the guys that faced 25 batters to the list. Kirby, Quantrill, Scherzer, Odorizzi, Rodon. There were 15 games yesterday and 12 pitchers faced 25 or more batters and I think we can agree they all are not elite pitchers, the Twins have played 116 games and have 11. You can do this exercise every day and see the same results, two 2 days ago it was 12 pitchers that faced 25 batters, the Royals have two pitchers in a row do it. It is funny when people throw out statements like they are true without backing it up. Edit - Mahle had faced 25 or more 7 times before coming to the twins.
-
Sonny Gray not too happy with Rocco...
I will give you this game is similiar to the twins because both guys were pulled after 20 and 21 batters faced, And Stripling being pulled is very similar to Gray. EDIT: Which I have said over and over it is fairly common what the Twins are doing, it just seem they are doing it to the extreme or with all of their pitchers.
-
Sonny Gray not too happy with Rocco...
So the 1.1 of the time, got it. Lodolo had already faced 24 batters and Suarez 23 and Gray only 20 so not exactly the same thing, and the Twins were winnings so maybe the 1.1?
-
Sonny Gray not too happy with Rocco...
I was saying the numbers you threw out for those starters without adding the years was misleading. You are not wrong on Gray he hasn't been much more than a 5 inning pitcher since 2019 and his numbers would probably be closer to Ryan or Bundy if he was asked to go another inning each start. My point isn't to say the Twins are doing it right or wrong, just that not everybody does what the Twins do. Would any Twin pitcher have came out in the 6th like Lynch did today? In a 1-0 game today Philly and the Reds used 5 total pitchers any chance any Twins pitcher would have came out for the 7th like both did in that game? Or both pitchers starting the 7th in a 0 - 0 game between the Orioles and Jay?or would the Twins been closer to what the Cubs and Nats did today? I am betting 8.9 times out of ten it is option 3.
-
Sonny Gray not too happy with Rocco...
What you said is kind of misleading, Cobb signed a two year contract for 20 million, DeSclafani signed a three year contract for 36 million, Kikuchi also signed a 3 year contract for 36 million with the first year being 16 and the next two 10. Paxton signed a 1 year 10 million deal with a club option of 13 million or 4 million. JA Happ signed with the Twins for 8 million. One could argue pitches that are limited in innings are limited in earning, no? It seems the going rate for a good 5 inning pitcher is around 12 million, it seems much, much higher for guys that god longer and are better. FYI, I am not arguing for or against the Twins philosophy just pointing out facts.
-
Did the Twins Find Value in Bundy and Archer?
I agree with this statement it isn't Bundy's fault that everybody got hurt and forced him up the chain thus making him look worse than he is. I think most teams (maybe not the the top few) would say for $5 million I get a 5th starter that doesn't miss a start goes on average 5 innings with an ERA of 4.76 (knowing it is that high because a 1/3 of his starts are probably crap) would say sign me up.
-
Sonny Gray not too happy with Rocco...
Correct, it is about money and I don't see the Twins spending that kind of money and keeping to their philosophy and any pitcher that takes the Twins money instead of the money offered by a winning team who allows them to be who they think they are (assuming the money is close) I don't want anyway.
-
Sonny Gray not too happy with Rocco...
What is you are saying is not completely true, not all teams handle their pitchers the same way as the Twins, that just isn't factual. OR there are way more elite pitchers than we all believe. And/or the Twins pitchers in general are not very good but that might say more about the FO then the pitchers? All Twins starters average between 21 and 22 batters face (ALL of them minus Archer), yes depending on the game sometimes they go higher (NOT MUCH THOUGH and sometimes lower. I stopped counting at 30 guys that average 24 over more batters per game and yes they have the same starts at going higher and some lower, that is significant number. I am 100% agreement with you that players chase the money, but when the money is close to the same, many other things go into it and IMO how teams pitching philosophy players into that.