Everything posted by TwinsDr2021
-
Do we want parity in baseball? If so, how do we get it?
Am I missing a team that has went from the bottom to the top in the NFL fast or vice versa?
-
Do we want parity in baseball? If so, how do we get it?
Generally signing players to long term contracts ends up hurting the team at the end, so unless the Dodgers change course in the next couple of years they will end up with overpriced not so good players. Now if they can continue to fill these issues from within this run will end and they will have to start over in some fashion, similiar to the Yanks or Sox, and to a less extent the Braves (they have had their own up and downs the last 20 years. Who is saying the Twins should spend hundreds of millions more per season? My guess is no one, but they bought the team for 35 million in 1984 and today is worth close to 1.4 billion. If they would have spent 10 million more every years for the last 40 years they still would have gained 1 billion in value, correct? I am not against putting some sort of caps or floors into MLB, but to expect the results to be much different than what is happening or different than what is going on in other sports IMO is crazy talk. At the end of the day baseball is about building from within and supplementing where needed and they terrible run teams are still going to be terrible. I believe I have read there is 2 new teams to the NFL playoffs on average per year, the NBA is about completely about the mega stars; teams have tried tanking and rebuilding and it only works if you draft a mega star and in a city they want to stay in or the star force trades to cities of their choice. The NHL is about mega stars and giving the contracts to right players and if you mess up and give a contract to the wrong players (Suter and Paraise for example) if takes years to get out of cap hell, which I believe is they path MLB would end up going down with a hard cap. Salary caps benefit the super stars because they are always going to be paid. I believe the path the Twins FO took is the correct path building a pipeline of prospects that can replace players looking for long term contracts, the problem with this path is you have to be lucky with injuries and guys fulfilling their potential or it requires more time. (example Balt and Pitt). Ultimately I will ask the question again, are teams really loses players they want to sign to larger contracts to big spending teams? Or are teams realizing other teams will give them multiple pieces that as a whole will be better for the team in the future than that one or two guys?
-
Twins Minor League Report (9/26): Woods-Richardson, Jeffers Carry Saints to Victory
He should be pitching in Target field tonight and not in St. Paul yesterday. ?♂️
-
In Another Lost Season, Royce Lewis Is Reminding Us Who He Is
Royce seems like an amazing person that should be considered a role model for all youths (and adults) for getting though adversity and tough times like a champion. I hope he goes onto to have a amazing career, hopefully for the Twins. Yes, he missed a year covid and has had two nasty injuries, but can we get over the he is still young. He'll likely will be 24 when he sees target field and in no time in history of baseball is that considered young for a prospect (unless you are a catcher). He needs to get healthy and start producing for the Twins ASAP. For reference (age of their first full season) Gary Sanchez 23, Miranda 23, Correa 20, Polanco 22, Urshela 23, Kepler 23, Arraez 22, Buxton 22, Sano 22, Jeffers 24, Larnach 24, Gordon 25.
-
Do we want parity in baseball? If so, how do we get it?
One could argue beside the international FA that is where MLB is at, they all start with the same draft, same minor leagues and the ability to sign/retain whatever FA they want, correct? Sure some teams are unwilling to pay the price of some free agents but many times there are more things than money involved in that decision. Fans like to complain about the twins being a mid market team but what player have they not been able to retain solely because of salary, I can't think of any. In reality there are very few players that teams can't retain because of Salary. Yes I understand teams trade players prior to FA because they likely aren't signing them (because they can't, because long term contracts are dangerous, maybe the team isn't ready to compete) but in return they get something a value. If you gave 50 million more a year to Tampa or Oakland do you think they would start spending it on big time players for long term contracts, I would say no.
-
Do we want parity in baseball? If so, how do we get it?
Are you claiming there is parity in the other three sports? (NBA, NFL and NHL) The warriors have been to 5 of the last 8 NBA finals, The lightening have been to 4 of the last 8 cups, and the NFL has basically been the Rams, Chiefs and Tom Brady for how many years. (The NFL and NBA are star driven leagues and the salary caps only hold the bad teams back by not being able to outbid for players. ) Big cities and great management win in salary cap leagues and bad management and undesirable locations fall by the way side. To me this sounds like a Twins fan complaining about a cheap and not so well run team for 30 years.
-
Angels 10, Twins 3 Halos secure series victory over Twins
The only rational reason Bundy is still on the Twins is the FO is trying to lose. And just like last September guys that should be getting their feet wet in the majors are toiling away in the minors while a guy like Bundy who should be hitting balls on the golf course is pitching for the Twins.
- Twins Minor League Report (9/25): Wind Surge Walloped
- Twins 8, Angels 4: Bullpen and a Sanchez Blast Lead Twins to Win
-
Dalton Shuffield is Flying Through the Twins’ System
Confused on the point of your message. Hildenberger didn't play at California until he was 21 (not sure what took so long, injury? Red shirt?) Then was drafted at 23 and played at two rookie teams. At age 24 he A, A+ and Fall league, at age 25 He played A+, AA and AAA. At age 26 he started in AAA and came to the majors. And like I have been saying about guys that debut at that age he was in the pen and basically had how do I say this nicely, a less than stellar career. Which goes back to the point of my previous message, which you confirmed saying basically has no future in the majors. "The only reason to put a 5 year senior that is 24 in A ball is because you think he has no future with the Twins "
-
Could Bailey Ober Move to the Bullpen?
He will be 28 years old on July 12th, if the Twins are still using kid gloves on him that is ridiculous. I hate to be cancelous but he is at the age they should use him until his arm falls off or he establishes that he is more than a 5 inning pitcher. Would anybody really care if the Twins "abused" him ( you know pitched his average inning up a whole inning or let him pitch to dare I say 100 pitchers?) and he ended up with TJ surgery or hurt? I wouldn't, it would prove his body can't handle being a starting pitcher. Sure they could move him to the pen, but it better be a role that is pitching 2 to 3 innings, he has proven he can dominate a lineup one time though.
- Dalton Shuffield is Flying Through the Twins’ System
- 3 Twins Players with Something Left to Prove in 2022
-
Planning for a Post Correa Reality in Minnesota
Here is the list from MLB - Trea Turner (29, 12.1 WAR) Xander Bogaerts (30, 10.2) -- Can opt out Carlos Correa (28, 9.7) -- Can opt out Dansby Swanson (29, 9.1) Tim Anderson (30, 6.7) -- Can opt out Elvis Andrus (34, 4.2) -- Can opt out José Iglesias (32, 3.0) Alcides Escobar (36, 1.1) Andrelton Simmons (33, 0.6) Marwin Gonzalez (33, -0.1) Dee Strange-Gordon (35, -0.3) Didi Gregorius (33, -1.1) I am not sure where they are getting the WAR from?
-
Planning for a Post Correa Reality in Minnesota
Isn't that how 23 looks next year If Buxton is healthy, if Miranda figures it out, If AK comes back, If Larnach is the good player we seen for a minute, If Ryan improves, if Ober/Winder/Gray/Mahle aren't hurt, If Maeda comes back like 20 and not 21. If Jeffers can actually hit. If Polanco stays healthy. Lee is either going to be a stud or not, the longer he spends in the minors the less chance that is likely to happen. Start him in AA and if he gets hot get him up. (Like Atlanta has done with their prospects, minor league prospects don't have to spend years in the minors) It wouldn't be the end of the world if he is not up next year but he better be playing well enough that he is in the plans for 24.
- Planning for a Post Correa Reality in Minnesota
- Planning for a Post Correa Reality in Minnesota
-
Reasons for hope in 2023
I agree on the pitching side for the most part (They did have Berrios, Maeda, Pineda, Dobs, Happ), but they went into 21 with Garver, Sano, Polanco, Simmons, Donaldson, Buxton, Kepler, Arraez, and Cruz (With Larnach, AK and Lewis waiting in the wings). Not sure next years projected lineup is better than that projected lineup, I sure hope it ends up better but going into 21 that felt like a pretty good lineup and a fairly decent starting 5.
- Royals 5, Twins 2: Wallner Delivers, but Twins Falter Again
-
2023 Rotation
This started with baok0010 stating this - "Maeda is a solid number 2 who pitches like a 1 somedays. ' I pointed out that besides 11 starts in 2020 that has never been the case and also said People seem to forget his 21 season, where he was a 5 inning pitchers with an ERA of 4.66. wabene came back with - "His UCL was hanging on by a few threads at that point." My response was "OK, does that explain 17, 18 19? " So you are either saying he is a solid number 2 who also pitches like a 1. (Which the stats and data you put out doesn't back that up at all and claim he is a solid #3) or you missed how this started out. I will assume the second one? People make ridiculous claims like this all the time without backing it up with data. (Not you! but I like to point out the flaws in statements like this because others grab onto them and say them as true) One could argue he barely pitched like a 2 in 2020 let alone a 1, but that didn't seem like a discussion worth having.
-
2023 Rotation
OK, does that explain 17, 18 19?
-
2023 Rotation
In the majors Smeltzer really only had two bad games, the 6 ER he gave up in 4 1/3 on 6/26 and the 7 he gave up in 3 1/3 on July 9th. Since that game he has went 10 2/3 and gave up 3 runs. He has 6 quality starts in 12 starts. Bundy has 2 in 27, Archer 0 in 25, and Ober 1 in 9 starts. With that said I don't think he should be anything more than a plan B or C for a Twins starter. IMO I don't think Enlow deserves to be on the 40 other than he was a 3rd round pick back in 17, He is already 23 and hasn't done much of anything in the minors to this point. Henriquez doesn't do a lot for me but he is a young 22 and can strike out guys, which translates into a really good bullpen arm iMO. I have never been on a Sands fan ( I do wish him well) but I don't see a need for him to be on the 40 if there is a need for somebody else. I don't know much about Headrick other then he will be 25 in December which translates to relief pitcher, so I don't see a need to protect a 25 year old relief pitcher. I do like that he has been healthy enough to pitch over 100 innings.
-
Thoughts on 2023
What makes you think I expect more starting innings from Maeda, Ober or Winder? I have a feeling Ober will be on some sort of inning limit is whole career as a Twin, unless he magically stops getting hurt. I also expect Winder will be on some sort of innings limit since he only pitched 72 in 2021 and is very likely not going to make it that far this year. Maeda coming off a year off except he would be on a limit as well. Now the Twins could do what some have begged for this year and make them 40 game 3 inning pitchers to piggy back off of 5 innings starts or they could have them start 25 games and pitch 5 innings and burn the pen out again. I don't have any idea what how the Twins will do that. Maybe they let Ryan, Mahle and Gray being pitch into the 6th or 7th inning guys and they have the last two spots be piggy back type starts. IDK IMO I don't see the Twins changing much, I think they might let a few select starters go a bit deeper next year, but they better be damn near perfect, not let runners on after the 4th and have a low pitch count to boot. (Similar to Ryan's last two starts)
-
2023 Rotation
Gray, Mahle, Ryan, Ober, Maeda, Winder, Varland, SWR, Balazovic, Enlow, Henriquez, Sands, Smeltzer, They have 13 currently on the 40 or IL and Paddack coming back at some point. I am not sure if there are other starters that need to be added, but at some point if they add more they have to subtract some as well and the only one I see right now is Sands unless they think Smeltzer can be dropped and resigned.
-
2023 Rotation
Maeda had 11 starts in 2000 that would qualify, other than that has never shown he is anywhere near a number 2 starter. He has pitched 6 seasons (135 career starts) in the majors and has a career WAR of 7.4. And since his rookie season has innings of 134.33, 125.33, 153.66, 66.66, 106.33. People seem to forget his 21 season, where he was a 5 inning pitchers with an ERA of 4.66.