Everything posted by jmlease1
-
Minor League Report (8/1): Tyler Beck Dazzles for Kernels, Surge Win A Thriller
I looked at the recap of the Saints game and there was no Jose miranda 2+ hits reported and I was so confused surprised...and then saw he got the day off. lol. He's delightfully increased the expectations rather significantly. Vallimont is clearly struggling with his control, and this is the big concern with him. Hopefully they can find a way to get him going, whether it's a mental or physical change that needs to happen. the talent and stuff are there, but until the control comes along, he's going to hang in the minors.
- Twins Minor League Hitter of the Month - July 2021
-
5 Things To Know About New Twins Pitcher Simeon Woods Richardson
The stuff is clearly there with him; now it's all about refinement and command. The move to put him in AA after a year where he didn't get to pitch was an aggressive one by Toronto and I'm sure it's a big part of why his numbers have suffered. Looking at his game logs is interesting; he started a game on June 15th, struck out the side and left the game. I would presume he tweaked something? He didn't miss a start, but he's definitely struggled after that short game with some real stinkers in there. Makes you wonder if he hasn't been able to get comfortable out there and should have gotten shut down for a couple of starts? All speculative, but he was very effective until then and the BB/9 was pretty manageable. Prior to these rough 4 starts, he was keeping the ball in the park quite well too. Not a finished product, but the way he hunts Ks is impressive and he looks like he has the kind of pitch mix and stuff to be a top of the rotation starter if he can command his pitches effectively and consistently. Ton of potential at age 20. Hope he has a good time at the Olympics with Joe Ryan and they both come back ready to roll!
-
POLL: Grade the Deadline
I'd go B+. I would have liked them to move on from Donaldson (mostly so they could use the savings to invest in pitching and open up a spot for Miranda) and would have thought moving Pineda would have brought a good return for a guy who is a FA next year. But I'm increasingly thinking they plan to bring back Pineda to give another anchor for the pitching staff, so it bothers me less. Really thought Rogers was going to get moved; I'm guessing the injury shut down getting the return they thought he was worth, and I approve of not letting teams take advantage of us or starting a true fire sale. I like the return from Cruz & Berrios a lot. I like that we got rid of Happ and got something, anything. I would have preferred to keep Berrios and extend him, but he's just not interested in an extension and I think on the FA market we'd struggle to sign him. The starting point is going to be Wheeler money, IMHO, and even if the team is ok with that kind of number...someone else could easily kick in another $5-10M or more to take him away. I might have kept him anyways, but this return was excellent because I really like Martin. I'm not buying that his power will never develop, and I think he's going to make the people downgrading him for not hitting for power in his first professional season while dealing with a hand injury are going to look very very dumb.
-
Minor League Report (7/31): A New Prospect Approaches
We'll see where Strotman ends up at the close of the year. They've got some work to do with him, but Ryan was the better piece in that trade to my mind. Looking forward to him joining after the Olympics. Palacios is a great story. He's getting a bit old for AA but has done a nice job in rebuilding his confidence at the plate after 2 very rough years in the TB system. Is he really a prospect or organizational depth? Probably still a little unclear, but he should contend for a spot on the 40 man and might be a nice INF option to have in AAA next year. Would love to know more about his defense?
-
Did the Twins Win or Lose the Trade Deadline?
I think the Twins did pretty well at the deadline. They did well in their trades of Berrios & Cruz, getting real value and quality players that are already playing and showing success at higher levels of the minors. They got rid of Happ, who had declined from being a solid pitcher in the first month or so of the season to a trash fire. The demerits are not moving Donaldson, Pineda, and Rogers (arguably Simmons too) but there are reasons for all of them, I think. We just don't know if there were good options for Donaldson that didn't require them eating far too much of the contract. He's still an excellent player when healthy and he's been pretty healthy this year so if they had to eat the rest of this year's salary (ok) and a big chunk of 2022 & 2023...then maybe not ok. Pineda is a guy they might be looking to keep to help anchor the rotation. Rogers was hurt and it probably tanked his value. Simmons is still a fine defender, but it didn't look like SS defense was an area of significant interest among contenders. I'd say they were slight winners by getting excellent value in the trades they made. It gets pulled back a little by not being able to make additional moves that seemed to make sense, but the net is still a positive for the Twins at the deadline. ESPN pegged them as losers...but most of that grade is influenced by the rotten season as a whole. That's fair, but looking at just the deadline moves, I'd say they "won" as much as you can when you're selling.
-
Big Mike Pineda staying.
I'm surprised that Pineda didn't get traded, but maybe the offers just weren't there. If all you were going to get is a couple of marginal prospects that you'd need to protect on the 40 man (and we're going to have a bit of a 40-man crunch this year with our system depth), then maybe it's the right call. Especially if they're thinking about bringing him back in 2022; as seen in the case of MN Twins v. Escobar...if you trade a guy it's hard to re-sign him. But I'm surprised a team like the Padres didn't make a good offer on him. But if they didn't, they didn't. It takes two to tango. More importantly, we got rid of JA Happ.
-
5 Things to Know About Twins Deadline Centerpiece Austin Martin
As noted by KLaw, the power drop this season can likely be attributed to a change in swing approach sparked by a hand injury. I'll worry about that if he keeps inside-outing his swing after getting fully healthy. (I've bashed FanGraphs a bit lately for downgrading Martin right now, but I think it's justified because they seem to be ignoring the injury to downgrade the player. In their write-up on Martin as part of the trade they again ignored the issue which I find baffling.) He's a really good player. Fits in a lot of different positions. Would love to see how he plays a short, since Lewis won't be ready in 2022 and Simmons might/won't be back and Polanco should stick at 2B rather that float him back to SS as anything other than an occasional fill-in. If Buxton gets dealt in the off-season (please no?) then CF sure seems like an option too. I'm enthusiastic about this guy and don't think he's far off at all.
-
Minor League Report (7/27): Saints Hold Serve
I love the guy, but who does he bump in MLB? We need to give Rooker ABs to see if he's a real player, we're paying Donaldson a lot of money to play 3B, Polanco & Arraez are proven at 2B, and frankly we need to have Sano get ABs and hopefully perform well to stabilize his value as well. Better to have Miranda play every day at AAA and be ready to compete for a job in 2022 than come up and sit on the bench. He's crushing it and already jumped a level. He gets called up if there's a injury need, otherwise he simply goes wherever he can play every day. It's not like we need him to "save" the season.
-
Twins Acquire RHP John Gant for J.A. Happ
Getting rid of the corpse of JA Happ makes me so happy I could plotz. It was a perfectly reasonable signing in the off-season that crapped out completely after 5 starts. The last 12 have been basically a nightmare and getting rid of him for anything is awesome. He's been absolutely destroyed too many times in the last 2 months for me to ever want to see him in a Twins uniform on the mound ever again. I will be checking out Cardinals box scores just to see if he has a Lance Lynn-like rebound...but I don't think he will.
-
José Berríos Traded to Blue Jays
They're dropping him based on his power drop in half a season. After five minutes of digging, I found out his power loss was due to a change in swing after a hand injury. I think that's a pretty stupid reason to change your ranking on a guy.
-
The Berríos return - Austin Martin and Simeon Woods Richardson
KLaw is definitely a fan of Martin. #12 on his prospect list as of a week ago, and he's a tough grader. Noted that his drop in power is likely due to a change in approach after sustaining a hand injury in May. That makes a lot more sense to me than deciding that he's not going to develop the same power potential originally projected!
-
José Berríos Traded to Blue Jays
Fine, instead of nefarious I'll just call it stupid. What if Martin has a minor injury that he's playing through that they're not disclosing? The guy had plenty of power at Vanderbilt (against good competition); to suddenly drop him down now after half a season at AA (and going straight from college to AA ain't easy) based on second-hand reports is arrogant and dumb.
-
José Berríos Traded to Blue Jays
Sabato is waaaaaay too high. I'm sorry, he's been terrible at the plate in low A. His value is entirely in his bat and all he can do is draw walks right now. Just no.
-
José Berríos Traded to Blue Jays
Name names for who they talked to, or I'm calling BS. What if the people they talked to were from the Toronto FO looking to cover their asses on the deal by trying to cast some shade on the guy they just gave up? Halfway through the guy's first professional season and they're gonna re-do his ranking? I hope he hits a bunch of dingers immediately and they flip back again, that'd be pretty funny. We'll see how this turns out, but the value seems pretty good here in the deal. I'm sure plenty of people will find reasons to have the entire Twins front office dismissed.
-
Minor League Report (7/27): Saints Hold Serve
Not great for Sabato to leave game one. Hope it's nothing serious; he needs ABs and this has not been a great year for him. (I think he's rated too high on the prospect list, personally. He takes a lot of walks, but isn't making much contact when he swings and isn't doing damage when he actually makes contact. Basically he's showing one skill as a hitter right now and that's not enough. He looks like a guy who was clearly harmed by losing a year of MiLB development.) Javier is having a decent bounceback year but he still needs to work on some things at the plate. Still a ton of Ks and not enough BBs, but considering he moved up a level after not playing last season this is pretty good progress. Let's hope he finishes the season strong and continues to progress.
-
Five Takeaways for the 2021 Twins
Bit revisionist history, yes? Baddoo was coming off a significant injury and the missing pandemic minor league year and in his last organized play year hadn't actually done anything of note (slash line of .214/.290/.393) and hadn't taken a single AB above A-ball. The decision was never "protect Cave or Baddoo"; Cave was someone who had 2 years of success at the MLB level for the Twins (and a poor pandemic year) and was well-suited to be a 4th OF...and broke his back this season. How can you let Baddoo go? Because you're betting that no team is going to be willing to keep a completely unproven player on the roster for a full season when he missed 1 1/2 seasons of development. It's the same kind of bet that they made on Miranda, and it went well. But the choice at the time was keep Baddoo or keep one of Celestino/Rortvedt, both of whom were more likely bets to be taken in the Rule 5. (backup catchers who can field and call a game can be stashed on a roster even if they can't hit, and proven defenders in CF are easier to hang onto as well because both can still add value even if they're not ready to hit at MLB) I'm happy with Gordon's development so far and pleased to see him get the chance with the Twins. He's never going to hit for power, but he's got a good feel for the strike zone and if he can get on base at a good clip, give speed and positional flexibility off the bench, then he'll be a nice utility option.
-
Trade Deadline Tracker: Twins' News and Rumor Roundup
I think the Twins FO is screwed. If they make a deal for Berrios, they're going to get buried for "giving up on 2022" and will likely get pilloried by the fan base for not getting enough, because there won't be a proven MLB player in the batch. If they don't make a deal for Berrios, they're going to get buried by the fanbase for not getting something for him while getting destroyed for not locking him up to a long-term deal (with the usual cascade of "the Pohlads are cheap" cries). Because this season has gone so poorly with expectations being fairly high, you have a lot of loud voices who no longer have any faith or trust in them, and I really am starting to think there's nothing that will satisfy, absent a trade screw-job so monumental it'll make Larry Anderson for Jeff Bagwell look even. It's interesting how fast things can turn here.
-
Game Score: Tigers 17, Twins 14
Please cut JA Happ. It's time. We have enough healthy starters right now and there's just no excuse any longer for running out a terrible pitcher that gives your team no chance to win. He had a fine career, but he's cooked at this point. Happ can't get anyone out and is getting drilled by anyone who happens to be right-handed. He can't really get lefties out either, they're just not crushing the ball against him. He's had 7 starts where he's given up runs equal to or greater than innings pitched. He's only had 7 starts all year with a Game Score over 50...and you start out with 50 points in Game Score. 4 of those 7 were in his first 5 starts. A solid start every 3-4 starts isn't acceptable. The signing was reasonable at the time and it looked good at the start of the season, but this is why you have a 1 year deal: so if it goes bad (and this has gone hideously bad) you can cut bait and move on. What do you gain by running him out there to get his brains beaten in for another 10 starts? Let's see what we have with Strotman, Barnes, Jax, etc. Happ got destroyed by Detroit, a bad team going nowhere, twice in 10 days. He has zero value. Time to cut bait, please.
-
LaMonte Wade Jr.'s Giants Performance
Thank goodness we let Rosario go. As fun as Eddie was and was a decent enough player for us, he's been pretty poor for Cleveland. For all that Larnach has really struggled to adjust to the constant flow of off-speed stuff, he's been at least as good as Rosario at a fraction of the cost and with substantially more upside. And even with the injuries that have clearly reduced his defensive capacity, Kepler has been better than Rosario. Baddoo is something of a CF; he wouldn't have gotten taken in the Rule 5 draft at all if he no ability to play there (even if he plays it rather like Jake Cave...adequately at best, poorly at worst). Not sure he really fits in here. A lot of people liked him, but it took a team overtly not trying to win at all this season that also had some deep Twins connections for him to get taken in the Rule 5 draft. Kirilloff looks great when healthy, and pretty solid when fighting an injury. Larnach has a little ways to go but has terrific upside. We also still have Wallner coming along in the minors, who has shown tremendous power in high-A and will certainly be in AA next season, even with a lot of Ks. Even if Cave leaves, we still have pretty good organizational depth in LH corner OFs...a position that's pretty easy to fill at the MLB level for $5-8M. This year has sucked because almost every bet the FO made has come up craps this year. (they were right no one would pick Jose Miranda. They were right to let Eddie Rosario go. But there have been a lot of misses this year, especially on the pitching side) The previous two years had a lot of success. Is the failures this year because of arrogance and stupidity, a failure of process? Or is it literally terrible luck? That's a really hard call, IMHO, and shouldn't be judged solely through the lens and emotion of a rotten season.
-
Game Score: Tigers 6, Twins 5
Robles started out the season great, then settled in as a decent bullpen option. He's been flammable in July, which happens to coincide with the period where the team is trash and has had very few bullpen options so he's getting run out there maybe a bit more than he should. (does it make sense for him to appear in 44% of the Twins games?) But the acquisition was fine. Don't let recency bias and the groupthink that "the FO is trash and can't do anything right" overrule reality: Robles shouldn't be going out on back-to-back nights right now; it isn't going well. Hope Garver is ok.
-
LaMonte Wade Jr.'s Giants Performance
Look, this sucks for the Twins and is great for the Giants (Wade has always seemed like a great dude, so good for him). but could someone tell me where in Wade's history anyone saw this kind of slugging coming? In his limited time in the majors with the twins he showed a discerning eye at the plate and no power to speak of. In his whole minor league career his SLG % was .409. outside of rookie ball and a short stint in A+, he's never hit for power. Literally never. His value at the plate before this season was primarily tied to his ability to get on base (decent average plus plenty of walks). If his SLG% this year was around his career average we'd be saying "Hey, good luck LaMonte but you're who we thought you were". The retro-grade on the trade right now sucks, but I don't recall a single person saying LaMonte Wade was going to turn into a power hitter. The organization kept Cave over Wade because they saw them as being pretty comparable value overall as hitter but were more comfortable with Cave in CF. (Seeing as how SF has only had Wade out in CF twice this season, I suspect they don't see him as anything other than an emergency option out there too.) And literally out of nowhere Wade is slugging .581. If he slugs .415 does anyone care? there's also zero question that Cave was better than Wade in 2019. 2020 was a down year for Cave, but Wade didn't show a lot in his limited chances with the Twins either. So betting that the guy with 2 years as a quality 4th OF would bounce back after a weird pandemic year was a pretty reasonable bet at the time. If the twins had said "We're keeping Wade over Cave because we think he's about to have a big power explosion" everyone here would have laughed at them. everyone.
-
As Buxton Hope Fades, Front Office Goes
I'm hearing this opinion a lot on the boards, but what we're hearing now is that it wasn't the guaranteed money that was the sticking point on the extension, it was something related to the structure of the incentives. So from a reasonableness perspective, the issue is apparently not the guaranteed money at all. but never let the truth get in the way of calling the Pohlad Family cheap...
- Minor League Report (7/25): Fantastic Feliz!
-
Minor League Report (7/25): Fantastic Feliz!
If you're not enjoying the Jose Miranda Experience, I just don't know what to tell you. I love seeing a player figure things out like this and really seize an opportunity. the question then becomes how it will translate in MLB, where there's no question it's much much tougher. This is an absolutely monster power surge from Miranda that's coming without him sacrificing anything on his K rate, so it's going to be really interesting to see how sustainable it is.