Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

jmlease1

Verified Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by jmlease1

  1. I assumed that the 4 points related to concerns about Donaldson's trade value were: 1. His health, 2. His health, 3. the health he is experiencing, and 4. How much health he has.
  2. Does Jax have good stuff, though? I'm increasingly unconvinced. He's got good command and control, but he doesn't have a ton of velocity or movement on his fastball and all of his off-speed stuff just seems...ok. He looks like a guy who needs to go back and re-tool something in the offseason to have any hope of surviving as a starter, and without a go-to out pitch I'm not sure he has much future as a reliever except as a long man/mop-up guy. I like the guy and he was worth giving a shot, but...right now he just looks bad. When Berrios was getting his brains kicked in, he still had a lively fastball and a plus curve to work with. Not sure jax has the weapons to compete. I'm confused as to why Moran got sent out for that long of an outing as well. Do they really think he's a 2+ inning guy? With his change-up I still think he's going to be fine, but I'm not sure that 30+ pitch outings are in his wheelhouse
  3. He's struggled a bit at the plate this year, had a horrid July and been on a tear every since. But his OPS+ is sitting at 103 and takes into account park effects. He's probably going to finish with a bWAR of 3.5-4 but with with his D sliding back a bit from Gold Glove levels and the hot market for SS's...he might not get the deal he's looking for. Maybe he will, but if it's not there and he wants to show that he can get it done outside of Colorado at the plate...there might be a bridge deal available. Figuring out the SS market is going to be interesting, but there definitely should be enough options that the Twins don't have to trade for a guy like Torres.
  4. I'm a no on this kind of deal and Torres as a good fit for us. the FA market on SS is going to be a really good one this off-season and I'd rather get a guy there than buy low on a Yankee, especially one who is stretched at SS. we already have a bunch of guys who are stretched at SS; if we trade/sign a player for SS they need to not be stretched there. (Trevor Story is the guy I really like right now, but I suspect someone will give him the 4 year $20M deal he probably is looking for...but if it's not there and he wants to go short term to build up his value again away from the Rockies? yes, please.)
  5. Good to see Strotman have a solid outing. I still have a lot of questions about him, but I wouldn't mind seeing him get a shot before the season ends to see how he reacts to MLB hitters (it's not like Andrew Albers is blocking him). I suspect he'll get a chance to impress in spring training next year and likely start in AAA as one of options 6-10 for the rotation as the season goes on. be interesting to see how he continues to adapt to the organization. If they can make good adjustments with him the way they have with Ober... Any reason Woods-Richardson came out after only 3 innings? I like him as a prospect, but starters only throwing 3 innings in AA doesn't exactly make my socks roll up and down. I think it's fair to rank celestino where he is; should he be up a few more spots? maybe, but I don't know how much difference there is between 10-15 on the list, really. He's bounced back well after being thrown into the MLB lineup too early: could be a great fit as a bench OF next year with defensively flexibility and being a RH hitter helps him as well (an OF rotation of Buxton, kepler, Kirilloff, celestino, and Larnach could be pretty great)
  6. So happy to hear that the x-rays were negative. Maybe he'll only have to skip a start and can finish the season strong and healthy.
  7. same, let me know the horrible details.
  8. Guys, can you check the prospect summary? Once again, Noah Miller's stats are getting reported as "Did Not Pitch". Now, 1-5 with 2 K's is not exactly exciting, but I know people are still interesting in seeing how he's doing in rookie ball since he's on the top 20 list.
  9. Noah Miller appears to be off to a decent start playing professionally? (even if on the top 20 prospect list he keeps showing up as "did not pitch", which is accurate, I guess, since he plays SS) Hitting for average and a bit of power, getting on base a respectable amount...and plenty of Ks, lol. Be really interesting to see the evaluation on him at the end of the season, especially to hear what people think about his defense. It's rookie ball, so who knows if the stats mean anything, but glad to have him playing!
  10. He's doing great so far. Hope he continues to have this kind of success. He does still need to keep working on his off-speed stuff, but it does look better than initially advertised, and the curve/change make him more than just a 2-pitch guy. He's definitely had some hard-hit balls and big flies that have landed in gloves already...if a couple of those warning-track flies against Cleveland had gone in the seats we would be talking about him very differently. But I do think the fastball plays, and getting tape on him isn't necessarily going to fix that for hitters. It's one thing to know a guy has different action on his fastball and still another to hit it. I like his command so far (impressive for a rookie), I like how fast he works (not a fan of guys who meditate on the mound, contemplating the universe), and I think if he can keep working on the edges of the zone he'll be very successful. And if he can tick up the comfort level and action on that change? Could be fun. He's going to have a few bumps. Not going to be shocked at all if he has a blow-up start in Sept, but that won't change my opinion on him: he can start in this league and unless he totally collapses the rest of the way he should be penciled in to the rotation for next year.
  11. Yeah, I'm not sure Simmons makes the top five worst signings? He's been bad, but Nishioka was worse and was a multi-year deal. I tend to agree that 1 year deals limit how "bad" it ever is. You're much worse off when you sign a guy to a 3-5 year deal and he bombs than having a bridge signing (which Simmons clearly has been) to a 1 year deal. Nolasco's deal was ugly, though I'm sure I was hopeful at the time. But he was awful and we had to give up on a prospect that we still liked to get rid of his contract. (Meyer busted out too, but at the time it was hard to be happy about seeing him go...was even worse when Icky Nolasco was good for half a season for the Angels...)
  12. Velocity isn't everything, though. We've seen enough guys who throw mid-to-upper 90's whose fastball was as flat and straight as can be and those guys get crushed. Ryan's fastball has good life and movement on it, which should make it harder for guys to consistently catch up/square up on it. Jury's still out on his secondary stuff, but he's not just a fastball/slider guy: he does throw a change up and a curve (and definitely had a few nice ones that he dropped in for strikes early in the count). The big flies he gave up could be troublesome against better hitters, so we'll see how he does, but if he can stay out of the heart of the plate and away from 3-ball counts, he can be a quality pitcher.
  13. I mean, Cleveland has a garbage fire of an offense...but you can only pitch to the batters in front of you. I look forward to seeing how Ryan does against a good offense. I think he'll do ok. A few more starts like this and the pencil being used to put him in next year's rotation will become ink.
  14. Terrific outing from Joe Ryan. Might have a future in this league! I got a little nervous on some of those deep flies, but Ryan sure didn't look nervous about it. Looking forward to watching more of his starts and seeing how he lands. Loved the defensive play by Jeffers late holding on to that foul tip. That's a great job and I love seeing it. Big bomb from Sano too.
  15. Kepler hasn't been great this year, but despite the low BA he's been an average hitter because he draws walks and hits for decent power. Throw in his good defense (good in right, average in CF this season...down a bit, probably because of the injuries) and he's basically an average starter. Astudillo is...not. Simmons has been good defensively, but so bad on offense that Kepler has still added more value to the team despite playing abut 20% less. Cave has been awful this year, but also literally broke his back. While I don't want him back...I'm gonna give him a bit of a pass.
  16. On what planet? Astudillo is a poor defensive catcher. His value at the plate has been basically exactly the same as Jeffers and Jeffers is getting killed for sucking at the plate. Just because Astudillo has a better BA doesn't make him a better hitter, and his utter inability to draw walks means that unless he's hitting close to .300 he ain't good. His value is in his versatility, but he's a poor defender at basically every position. Look, La Tortuga is a fun player...but he's not a good one. Jeffers is a having a tough go of it, but this is his rookie season; despite playing 26 games last year he still meets the requirements for RoY in 2021. (obviously, he won't win)
  17. 7 will likely be with the organization in some fashion: Rooker, Larnach, Sano, Jax, Dobnak, Celestino, and Jeffers will be with the Twins. Rooker, Larnach, Celestino, Jax, and Jeffers all have options left; Jeffers might make it out of spring training as the backup, but we'll see. Celestino might compete for the 4th OF spot...and actually might be ready to be a good contributor now that he's had time in AAA (where he should have been for most of the season). Jax is going to be battling for the 5th spot, might have a chance at a bullpen role, but will probably be in AAA starting. Sano is 1.1 bWAR right now and if he can avoid another horrid start is a useful player. Larnach needs the AAA time to deal with constant off-speed stuff and get a reset. Rooker...is probably a AAAA player and will likely be battling for the last spot on the roster. All of this seems ok to me. we need the FA bets next season to not completely implode like Happ, Simmons, Colome did (and Colome has been fine since his dreadful first couple of months; if he wasn't inducing PTSD in the fan base I'd consider picking up his option)
  18. Polanco is not playing SS next season except as an occasional backup. That's pretty clear, and if it keeps him healthy and performing like he is right now it's 100% the right decision. Gordon is not an option at SS next season, or he'd be playing SS right now. And everyone is going to scream bloody murder if Drew effin' Maggi is handed the starting SS job. (You think the tired "Pohlads are cheap!" refrain is loud now? You could pump the payroll up to $180M and people would scream that if Maggi is the starting SS) Any analysis that includes Polanco getting slotted in at SS next season needs to just stop. It's not going to happen.
  19. This. Keep in mind they acquired Gant for the bullpen and pressed him into service as a starter because he was already stretched out and between trades/injuries/ineffectiveness the cupboard was bare in what was already a lost season. Albers will not be a Twin next season. What he does or does not do in playing out the string this year is meaningless for next. Barnes is AAA filler but is getting a shot the same way Gant is, because why not? Even if he stays with the team, he'll be behind Duran, Balazovic, Strotman, Woods-richardson, and Winder (not to mention Ober, Ryan, likely Pineda, Dobnak, and 1-2 FA/trade acquisitions) at best. Frankly, I'm doubtful Dobnak is in the rotation to start the season. I think they re-sign Pineda to bridge the gap on some of the younger guys who might not be ready out the gate, sign a quality starter in the $15+M range, and trade for another guy. But no matter what: Ober is the only guy to write in ink for the rotation at the point, with Ryan in pencil, and Pineda using dry-erase.
  20. Sano has actually been a solid performer overall this year and has been very good after a horrific start. he was very good in both July & August and wasn't bad in May & June. The trick for Sano next season is going to be how to have an acceptable start to the season, rather than wait 2 months to get going...
  21. I'm actually not all that optimistic about Jax as a reliever for reasons described above: no out pitch. I think his command is actually pretty good for a young pitcher, but he needs to be really on to be effective and I don't think he can do that at this point in his career. He either needs to tweak a pitch in his arsenal for increased effectiveness or add another pitch that he can command to be more than a spot starter/long reliever. This was only a "good" start in the context of his previous couple, and continues to show that his margin of error is really fine. I do agree that he should stay in the rotation through the end of the year: give him the innings. Let's see if a) this is who he is, b) if he can adjust, c) if he can improve.
  22. whoof, that's a rough night for the prospect list: only 1 guy in the top 11 played, only Urbina had a particularly good night among the top 20. Strotman has got some work to do. He was never the key piece in the Cruz deal to me, but if he can't figure out his command, he's going to wash out pretty fast in the organization. The talent is there, but the execution isn't coming through very well at all. Which guy is he, the one who was nearly ready for MLB in Tampa or the guy who looks like a hot mess in MN? And frankly, his utility as a reliever isn't all that high if command is his constant issue. He looks like he needs a reset right now, and I don't know how he gets it right now.
  23. I do think it's possible to build a functional rotation for next season that doesn't rely on 3-4 rookies being ready to go from Day 1, but it's not easy. Ober increasingly looks like a guy that can be counted on. The fact that he's making adjustments to stay ahead of major league hitters and scouting speaks really well of him and suggests that he's less likely to take a step back before settling in. The peripherals look good. He's still got some work to do in mastering lefties, but he should have the weapons to get through. Pineda makes sense to bring back. He likes it here, the team likes him, and after the injuries he'll probably be fairly affordable (1 year 6-8M?). You have to expect that he'll miss some time for injury (and be happy if it doesn't happen) but he's a solid rotation guy when he's available and should take a little pressure off. We'll see how Ryan finishes the year, but he seems like another guy that you can pencil in. He'll have some bumps along the way, but there's not much left for him to do in AAA and sometime you just have to ride with a guy. They'll need to sign at least one FA and spend some pretty good money on them. But they'll have the money to go there. They'll be able to drop $15-20M on a starter without impacting the budget significantly or even needing to deal Donaldson. That should be enough to get a #2/3 guy. The trade option makes sense. The Twins have depth in their system and a potential 40-man crunch, so why not package a couple of guys together (and consider a major league asset) to go get an experience starter? Yes, they'll have to give up something quality to get one, but it won't have to be Martin or Lewis or Balazovic. You'll need 4-5 more guys to be ready to get starts. That leaves Duran, Balazovic, Dobnak, and Winder to step up when Pineda goes down hurt, someone else gets a ding, Ryan is ineffective, etc. Maybe Canterino is ready & healthy. Strotman. Woods-Richardson. Still enough in the budget left to get a bridge SS and spend a little money on experienced bullpen help.
  24. Without looking: who's the better pitcher, Brusdar Graterol or Jorge Alcala? Who has the better career ERA, ERA+, WHIP? Does that change your perspective on who Graterol is as a player? Relievers can have really high variance from season to season. It's why I get twitchy about investing big salaries in them: they can go from dominating to being just another guy in the blink of an eye...and then be really good again without injury coming into play at all. It's also a reason why starters have more value than relievers. but the Dodgers needed relief help and were long on starters at the time. In terms of absolute value, the Twins still probably "win" this deal because starters are "worth" more, and even with Maeda missing next season because of injury, if he comes back and throws an mostly healthy season, then the Twins will almost certainly end up getting more value out of him over the same 4 year period. (in the last 2 years, Maeda has put up about 1.5 bWAR; Graterol is around 0.1) But need is need.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.