Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

jmlease1

Verified Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by jmlease1

  1. are you just trolling in every thread now? Jeffers is a far superior defensive catcher by basically any possible metric, including the eye test. Astudillo got few chances at catcher this year because the Twins know he's not really any good back there. (Jeffers, even through his struggles, was a more valuable hitter at catcher as well) Astudillo is a fun player and obviously a likable guy, but he's not any kind of solution at catcher and doesn't hit or defend enough to deserve a spot on the 40-man, let alone the MLB roster.
  2. I'm a Trevor Story fan. I'd love to add him to this team at anything resembling a semi-reasonable price, especially if Buxton doesn't get extended/is traded. (I love Buxton and desperately want him on this team, but I recognize that might not go) He's a fine defensive SS who can swing the bat and I expect his home/road splits might normalize a bit once he gets clear of Coors. I think he's going to be worth at least 12-18 bWAR over the next 4 years and how many seasons of 3-4 bWAR have we compiled at SS in the last decade? (It's 1.) I'm in on Story. I think he'd be a nice fit, he's a bit of a "buy low" candidate right now, but even if this is who he is going forward...there's a lot of value there.
  3. I'm in on #1: I like Ryan a lot and while I think he's going to have some bumps along the way, I also think he will be a very good starter. The off-speed stuff looked better than advertised and the fastball plays. Do I think he's going to be contending for the Cy year-in and year-out? No, but could he be a dependable starter who gets a little all-star love in a good season and never really has a bad one? I think so. I have no idea how anyone defines "front-line starter" or "ace" or any of that any longer. I'm out on #2: Just not sure Jax has the stuff to be impactful at the MLB level. Maybe his fastball ticks up if he moves into a full-time relief role and plays up a bit more...but I wouldn't see him as anything more than a long man in the bullpen at this point, and that's not going to have a significant impact. I would love to be wrong? I'm in on #3, though I don't think it's going to be at 1B for at least another season. I'm all in on Kirilloff's hit tool if he can stay healthy. He's good great bat skills, makes great hard contact, and I think he understands the strike zone (it's just hard to lay off a pitch when you know you can still hit it). I see a lot of line drives in his future and I'm happy to see him start in one of the corners next season. I'm out on #4,,.for now. Not because I don't like Royce Lewis, not because I've already decided he's not a SS...just think that despite his talent it'll take him half a season at least to knock off the rust and get up to game speed. but I still like Royce.
  4. Wallner is probably the only real prospect here. The rest look like "show us something, kid' guys. Hopefully Wallner works on cutting down his Ks; if he can drop that down a bit while doing damage when he makes contact, he's got a chance. he does draw walks at least.
  5. Possible the COVID stuff with Simmons kept the Yankees from doing anything more than mentioning his name during a conversation? I could see them kicking around names to add D, and then after making a call saying, "wait a second, what if this schmuck gets some of our guys sick?" A COVID outbreak nearly torpedoed the Red Sox season.
  6. I think people have pretty well covered the Simmons issue, lol. (I'm in agreement: his defense was worth, his offense was too putrid to be allowed near a twins lineup again, etc) I'm a 100% no on signing Cruz, much as I loved him as a player here. Age is undefeated. Eventually it gets all of us, and as special as Cruz is, he's going to hit that wall too and I'd rather not be holding the bag when it does since he's already off the team (and we got spectacular value for him). We've got plenty of guys worth rotating through the DH spot, so I'd rather keep it open to ensure that someone like Arraez has a spot to hit in, Donaldson can take a break without losing us his bat, Kirilloff can take some reps at 1B without Sano being forced to take a seat, etc. Better chances of keeping some of these hitters healthy and productive, while still giving opportunities to young guys like Miranda too. Beyond that, he's going to command $10M if the NL adds the DH easily, and I'd rather spend that on pitching/SS. I loved the Boomstick. Great guy, great signing, great player...but this would sadly be a reunion that i think would end in tears rather than cheers.
  7. Will you come back an apologize when he doesn't sign a long-term deal with Toronto this off-season? Berrios wants to test free agency, and has made that clear. They didn't trade him because he wanted a market-rate deal; they traded him because the only way to lock him up long term was to offer something well above market rate, otherwise they were risking him going elsewhere for nothing. We have an excellent chance to compete in 2022 if we can add the right pitching moves and at least one of about 5 quality pitching prospects steps forward. The lineup is good enough to compete. The idea the franchise has "no belly to spend" is a canard: did you forget Josh Donaldson? Coming off an excellent season they spent significant money to take an very good lineup and try to make it a great one. But never let reality get in the way of a chance to call the Pohlads cheap or the front office incompetent...
  8. I don't think it's all that hard either, but it's more of a question than Astudillo at this point, or least it should be.
  9. I think Refsnyder is a harder decision than Astudillo at this point. La Tortuga may be a fun player and fan-favorite, but he's also not all that good. If the Twins think Refsnyder figured something out that unlocked him for the first half and the poor performance in the second half was all injury-related...he's got more value than Astudillo. (That said, I think he's still a cut with the option to sign a minor league deal as depth)
  10. I would have loved to have a real debate between a healthy Kirilloff and Ober for RoY. shame about that wrist injury and I really hope it doesn't chase him throughout his career, because he can really hit. but Ober is the easy choice and looks like he's got a nice future starting games for the twins.
  11. I'm not thrilled about this either because I'm not sure why this is the time to try and slip someone through waivers? But it sure sounds like the Twins don't think he's going to be pitching much if at all in 2022 either, and if that's the case...how much does this matter? the velocity is fantastic, but it hasn't translated to results very well for him and he's been injured/not playing for quite a while. But this may be an indicator for how some teams are going to play their fringe 40-man this off-season: they'll take flyers on guys with no track record, lengthy injury issues rather than carry a veteran at a higher price. If that's the case, the FA market might be very slow to get moving indeed, and there could be a lot of guys on the carousel. Could we be getting an early indicator that there's going to be a glut of veterans dropped from a team's 40-man who are: middle relievers, 4th-5th OF types, 1B/DH guys, and utility INF? Hmmm...
  12. Honestly, it comes down to whether the change-up is for real, a pitch that he can throw for strikes (or get hitters to chase) so that he doesn't get his brains kicked in by lefties. he was death against righties this year: clearly his fastball/slider mix works great against them and he can hurl both effectively. His problems was entirely against left-handed hitters this year, where while they didn't get tons of hits, when they did they hit the ball a looooong ways. I'm excited about Alcala for next year. Despite how bad the bullpen started the year, it was pretty solid by the end of the year and if Taylor Rogers is back and healthy, I'd feel pretty good about this bullpen if they signed one more good right-handed arm.
  13. Probably a B- for me? Maybe C+, if I'm feeling really ornery. I'm of the opinion that managers get too much credit when the team does well and too much blame when the team does poorly most of the time. I mean, here's my grades for Rocco's three seasons: 2019: B/B+. team played hard all year, seemed to come together and be a pretty close-knit group, few objectively awful tactical decisions, some lineup/bullpen useage that seemed sub-optimal at times, but overall did well as a rookie manager. 2020: B+/A-. With the pandemic, it was just harder in almost every possible way to run a baseball team, so the fact that the Twins did well again, you have to give him some credit for keeping the team together and focused. 2021: B-/C+. not much worked this year, but injuries and FO roster decisions takes some of this out of Rocco's hands. Took too long to find solutions in the bullpen, and some of that is on him. not giving Maggi some field time or an AB is an unforced error that's small potatoes but a bad look, continuing to play Jake Cave late in the year seemed like misplaced loyalty. but the injuries and poor performance were what killed this squad, not the manager. he's...fine. i think staffing up will help (Mike Bell was missed), but bounceback performances and a less awful start to the year will make him look a lot better. I mean, we had a stretch in April where the team went 2-13.
  14. You think brent rooker is as good as tyler austin? or that rooker's spot gets taken by tyler austin? The second one I probably agree with, the first I think is basically insane...
  15. Hang on, I'm not really tracking here. Is it really a problem to carry 8 "corner guys" when you're counting RF, LF, 1B, and 3B (and DH, really)? Lewis isn't a corner guy at this point; even if he can't stick at SS (jury is out), CF is the next most likely option for him. Arraez does have positional flexibility at 2B as well (he's a limited defender at any position, but you can live with him at 2B if you don't force Polanco to play SS) I also have a lot more confidence in Celestino as a CF option next year after he played so well at AAA, so maybe that's coloring this for me? If Buxton is gone/hurt, I have more confidence in the twins minor league options to fill in now between Celestino, Lewis, Martin (with kepler being an option as well). and if Buxton is traded, well that opens a space on the 40 man. I think there's room for Rooker (especially when you clear out Cave, Astudillo, Garlick, etc) but his rope is short. And it should be.
  16. I would do the Graterol for Maeda trade again even knowing that Maeda would get hurt this year. Graterol has been just meh for the Dodgers and Maeda has been more valuable in 2021 than 2020 & 2021 combined for Graterol, even getting hurt. Graterol has been closer to Hansel Robles than Jorge Alcala. I'd say the Twins understood the talent just fine on that one. Pressly has been very good for Houston, and I'm sure they're happy to have him. Of course, they had to spend $17.5M to keep him and he might be a FA this year (unclear if his vesting option hits for next season at $10M?). So you have to factor that in too: we dealt 1 year and a bit of Pressly for Celestino and Alcala, who are cheap and under team control. Alcala looks like a real reliever: he's death against righties and appears to be figuring out a way to not get killed by lefties. he was excellent in the second half of the season. Alcala looks poised to be a significant bullpen piece next year and doesn't hit his first arbitration year until 2023. Celestino should be competing for a spot as the 4th OF next year. When the twins dealt Pressly, they were 7.5 games back and hadn't had a month over .500 all year. (notably, they needed to win 6 straight to finish the season in order to achieve that mark one time during the season, by beating up on a pair of terrible Central division opponents who had given up on the season months earlier) Context matters, and the Pressly deal looks fine.
  17. I'm just not sure that Rooker is where the inflection point is on the 40-man? he's a fringe 40-man guy at this point, but probably doesn't need to be ejected immediately. he's unlikely to develop into Adam Dunn (which sure looks like his ceiling), but there's still a chance because of his power. But if asked who would I keep out of Ralph Garza, Yunior Severino, Charlie Barnes, or Brent Rooker...I think I'd keep Rooker, for now. And I think that's essentially the kind of player he's competing with for a spot on the 40-man. And to me, any of those guys are easy enough to move on from if/when better players are traded for/signed.
  18. Mostly agree with the OP's projections, as things stand. the adjustments are on the fringes: I think there's a real chance Javier & Vallimont get protected over Garza and Garlick. Garza at 27 as you note doesn't have a ton of upside and could sneak through waivers; he looks like one of those relievers that's pretty fungible from year to year. If he's hot, you can ride him for a while, but should also cut bait when he blows up. (which sucks for him to be so mercenary about it, but that's the reality with fringe bullpen guys). Javier plays SS at least adequately, so a rebuilding team might take a flyer on him in the Rule 5, whereas someone like Garlick is just a guy who could be re-signed to a minor league deal (and if not him, someone like him). Vallimont would probably get swept up by someone who would immediately put him in the 'pen and try and work on his command/control. Since I think he's almost a sure thing to get drafted in the Rule 5, I'd probably add him. That's where I see the "risk" on Rule V guys: upside arms with big K numbers that you could stash in a bullpen, and position players at a premium defensive spot: catcher, CF, and SS. A bad team could either run them out and hope they hit enough and a better team might just stash them on the bench for defense if it's good enough. There's plenty of guys on the fringe though who could get dropped fairly painlessly when FA signings come flowing in.
  19. I really appreciate the graphs here, but wish the progression on the X-axis were reversed. I think most people read left to right, lowest to highest naturally in English so when I looked at that first exit velocity graph I thought "so, Rooker's below average" before spotting that he was actually on the high side of the curve.
  20. I think the Twins have more interest in Gant as a reliever, but he's been starting for us because we're short on other options. Agree that Jax likely doesn't have it as a starter either.
  21. An all-timer for me was when Morneau & Cuddyer went back-to-back in the playoffs at the Dome. That's the loudest I've ever heard anywhere, ever...and after the first dinger (which nearly blew the roof off) I turned to my friend and said "Oh my god, they're going to go back-to-back, I can feel it!" My best called shot ever, lol.
  22. This is why the only position player spot I want us making a FA signing in is SS. we have options to fill out what can be an excellent lineup. 4th OF could be a competition between Celestino and Martin, both of whom can play CF effectively and would provide superior D in the corners if they slot over there. both are RH, which makes them good options to back up Kepler and Kirilloff. I'd like to see 13 guys at the position slots: OF: Buxton, Kepler, Kirilloff, Celestino/Martin Corner INF: Donaldson, Sano, Miranda Middle INF: FA SS, Polanco, Arraez, Gordon Catcher: Garver, Jeffers Then you mix it up at DH with Donaldson, Arraez, Miranda, any OF that needs a day off in the field, etc, Kirilloff can get some time at 1B and give Miranda time out in the OF. Should be enough ABs to go around. Larnach and whichever of Celestino/Martin doesn't win the battle in spring training are the first two OF bats to call up, and Martin could move around into the infield if needed. Maybe you let Gordon be depth in AAA (he has an option left) and make sure you have a better defender backing up SS. There's room for Miranda when you dump Jake Cave & Astudillo's ABs.
  23. I'd bring him back. He's pitched well for the team, likes it here, is well-liked by the franchise, and could probably be had on a 1-2 year deal for a pretty reasonable price. (1 year at $8M?) He'd be good to help bridge time with the younger starters coming along. If you plan for him to only throw 100-150 innings, you should be fine.
  24. i think there's room to get Miranda reps regardless: Donaldson is going to get some reps at DH, likely miss some time due to injury/rest, and there's going to be reps available in both corner OF spots and at DH as well. Kirilloff is going to likely get a starting spot, but Miranda fits well as a bench bat who can play multiple spots. but good lord, can we stop putting out any articles on next year's lineup that have Polanco playing extensive time at SS? It is literally never going to happen, absent massive injuries to: a FA signing at SS (almost certain to happen), Royce Lewis, Austin Martin, even Nick Gordon, etc. The Twins want Polanco at 2B. Of course they do: he's an all-star there and it looks like he can stay healthy there too. I swear, any article that has "if the Twins slide Polanco over to SS..." in it is automatically invalid. Please stop. Polanco is a poor defensive SS, the position appears to negatively impact his health, the Twins have repeatedly shown they don't want him playing SS full-time, and he's an elite player at 2B. Trying the slot Polanco in at SS is a strat-o-matic play, not real baseball.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.