I trust the eye test. My eyes tell me that Eddie was OK this year. -too often he tried to throw home, when he had no chance, and allowed a runner to move to second. -His throws to home and to 2nd base were generally VERY accurate. -too often he tried to catch a ball that was out of his range, which allowed runners to advance while the center fielder chased down the ball. A little discipline here might go a long way. Eddie, isn't superman and shouldn't try to be.