Twins fans (myself included) have been down on Ryan Jeffers most of the season. He's hitting below the Mendoza line. It sometimes seems like the opposition can put runners on auto-steal. He's even recently had some issues with passed balls. I decided to do an exercise comparing all the primary AL catchers so far this season. I labeled the primary catcher based on the most innings behind the plate on each team. I did make one exception and placed Adley Rutchman as the Orioles primary catcher, since he's taken over and won't be giving that position back to Chirinos unless he gets hurt. I highlighted the top five in each category in green and the bottom five in red. Here are the results:
Some observations:
1) Alejandro Kirk should definitely be the starter in the AS game. Wow!
2) Cal Raleigh has been a good find for Seattle. Note: He's also hitting below the Mendoza line, but more than making up for that in other areas.
3) Jonah Heim had something click offensively. I remember seeing his stats pop-up last season, and I assumed he'd be an automatic out. He hit a homer, and I was thinking, "I can't believe he just gave up a homer to Jonah ****ing Heim.
4) Damn Yankees! Of course, they bring in the 29 yo cast-off Trevino, and he's having a career year.
5) Salvador Perez has really fallen off on the defensive side of the ball.
Now to Jeffers:
I think the main takeaway from the exercise is that patience is in order with Jeffers. Overall, he's middle-of-the-pack defensively. Obviously, he needs to work on his part in controlling the running game. Offensively, he's right at the edge of bottom-of-the-barrel and middle-of-the-pack. We've seen flashes, but he needs to get more consistent. However, he's just 25 with a lot of control years left, so I think he's one that we shouldn't give up on just yet. That probably isn't what folks want to hear when hoping for a deep playoff run, but it's impossible to make everything line up perfectly unless you have the deep pockets of New York and LA. Also, if you turn your head just right looking at the stats I gathered, you could argue that Jeffers is the most valuable catcher in the (terrible) AL Central. (Yes, I know Grandal is hurt, but you have to play or value isn't being earned.)
Comments are welcome - including suggestions on which stats may be more valuable than what I captured.
Edit:
Here is the NL:
Dang, Realmuto! 587 innings behind the plate. Earning that paycheck!
NOTE: Victor Caratini (Brewers) and Jorge Alfaro (Padres) actually had better bWAR than the primary catchers on the team.