Everything posted by dex8425
- Revisiting the Eddie Rosario Decision
- Projecting the Defensive Future of Minnesota's Top Prospects
- 6 Questions that Will Determine the Twins' Offseason Course
-
Which Free Agent Starter Fits the Twins?
Ray- too expensive. Twins won't outbid a bunch of teams for him. Kershaw will be back with LAD. Verlander will want to sign with a contender. Maybe NYY. Scherzer goes back to LAD. Greinke goes to an NL contender so he can hit. Matz is getting a big multi-year deal. I think Twins get outbid for Stroman, consider Thor too risky, and end up with someone like Jon Gray and then someone like JA Happ.
- The Twins Would Be Wise to Avoid Signing Zack Greinke
- Projecting the Defensive Future of Minnesota's Top Prospects
-
6 Questions that Will Determine the Twins' Offseason Course
I agree with almost all of this but would be thrilled if the Twins signed Greinke to a 1-2 year deal. He's durable, effective, and shouldn't be super expensive given his age and bad August 2021. Verlander is a risk, but Kluber bounced back pretty well from similar circumstances. I would sign a glove first SS to a cheap 1 year deal. Even Simmons; he can't be worse with the bat than he was in 2021.
-
Deja Vu - Buxton Extension and Mauer Extension
The average fan doesn't really know Buxton is the best player on the team, because he hasn't been, because he only plays in 25% of the games. The average MN sports fan knew Mauer was on a HOF track before he signed the extension. Mauer had already won 3 batting titles, one MVP and like 5 silver sluggers before the extension. Buxton has received low level MVP votes one full season and has never even been an all star. No comparison here. Then, the average fan complained when the team was terrible around Mauer in his 30's. That wasn't Mauer's fault. Buxton on a 120+ million dollar deal could really hurt the franchise if Buxton continues to play in 60 games a year...
-
What should the Twins offer Byron Buxton?
Thanks for this, was a pleasure to read. 7/133 actually seems more than fair to Buxton. I wouldn't make him the highest paid player in baseball. He's not Mike Trout, because Trout has actually proven he can stay healthy and win MVP's. 7/133 would be a huge gamble for the Twins. If Buxton wants more than that I'd honestly try and trade him this offseason.
-
Free Agent starting pitchers
I'd definitely be interested in Greinke on a 1-2 year deal. Either him, or someone at the Jon Gray/Matz/Wood level, then sign Pineda. I expect the Twins to sign Pineda and someone like Rich Hill, and win 80-85 games next year.
-
4 Plausible Developments That Would Dramatically Alter the Twins' Fortunes
If the Twins trade Josh and don't pay all or most of the contract, the Twins will have to give up a decent prospect. Donaldson was the 2nd best player on the team this season. If the Twins want to compete next season, which the FO is saying they want to, they won't trade Donaldson.
-
Buyer Beware: Flaws with the Top-5 Free Agent Shortstops
Twins won't really be interested in any of these guys. I expect them to look for a one year stop-gap until Lewis or Martin can assume the position. If you don't think Lewis is the SS of the future, you should have traded him already. Story is a legit star. Semien is not a defensive SS already. Correa will get the biggest deal of these five.
- Grading Rocco Baldelli’s First Losing Season
-
Basking in Buxton’s Season
You're missing the fact that aging occurs, and it occurs faster if you've been injured a lot. Buxton's primary asset is his speed. He's not getting faster, and he's not getting healthier. If you break a bone, or have surgery, you're never quite the same again in that area. I'd bet that Donaldson plays more games than Buck next year. Donaldson has a history of injury issues but also can at least stay on the field as shown by his 44 career WAR and 4 seasons in top ten MVP voting. Buxton has zero years in the top ten of MVP voting. Personally, I wouldn't be mad if the Twins gambled on Buxton and signed him to an extension, but if I'm the GM I'm definitely shopping the trade market this winter to see if a team will overpay.
-
What Happens to the Twins Emerging Star?
I think the FO intends on putting the best team they can on the field in 2022. With that said, Donaldson is the every day 3B. If Donaldson goes down with injury, bring up Miranda and give him every day looks. Depth is always good.
- Game Score: Tigers 10, Twins 7
- Game Score: Twins 5, Tigers 2
- Game Score: Twins 5, Tigers 2
-
Bailey Ober's successful innings management
Given his injury history in the minors, I'd be inclined to keep treating him with kid-gloves. Realistically the team is not going to compete for a division next year; all you want to see is growth and health from Ober and Ryan next year with an eye to compete in 2023.
-
Settling in at Shortstop
Simmons will certainly be available on a one year deal again, for cheaper. He can't possibly hit worse than he did this year, right??
-
Week in Review: Small Victories
Solid starter, no. His benefit is versatility. He's a competent defender in all three outfield spots, not on the level of Buxton, Kepler or even Celestino. Re Gordon: if the FO has to make a choice between Gordon and Astudillo as the utility guy, that's a no brainer. I have no doubt Gordon is going to work hard and improve.
-
How do you define "ace" and is Jose Berríos one?
He was very good in the playoffs and in the world series last year. 4.19 ERA in 37 postseason games isn't downright awful, although it's not Clayton Kershaw regular season level.
- 3 Twins Players Set to Bounce Back in 2022
- 3 Twins Players Set to Bounce Back in 2022
-
How do you define "ace" and is Jose Berríos one?
I'd use Cy Young votes. If you consistently receive Cy Young (or even MVP) votes in today's game, you're an ace. Berrios is a really, really good pitcher but has never received Cy Young votes. Just to name a few in the game right now: Scherzer, Cole, Bieber, Degrom, Lynn, Kershaw, Wheeler, Bauer, Buehler, Burnes. Until 2020 Verlander and Kluber were obviously in that category as well.