Everything posted by dex8425
-
Am I wrong? I'd rather the Twins have Martin, Woods Richardson, and $20M per year to spend than Jose Berrios?
I like the return. The contract seems like a good value for TOR but I don't think Berrios signs that contract with the Twins, even if the Twins had offered. Of course, like everyone else, I assume/hope the FO chooses to spend the $ on another #2 starter.
- Can Twins Level Up to Matt Chapman from Josh Donaldson?
-
Debate No. 2: Who was the better player: Kirby Puckett or Joe Mauer? (Debate/poll concluded - thread open)
I didn't realize how good of a topic this was until pulling up their baseball reference pages. 55 WAR for Joe, 51 WAR for Puckett. Joe has 100 more games. Honestly, I was thinking the answer is Puckett before this debate, but I'm actually voting for Mauer now. I never saw Puck play. Too young.
-
What the Hell Are the Twins Doing with Byron Buxton?
The numbers we're hearing probably aren't related at all to what is actually going on. I know Jim's group isn't cheap. They will pay to keep Buxton if Derek and Thad think it's worth it. I think Derek and Thad aren't sure that paying Buxton a 100million dollar guaranteed contract is a good idea. I'm not sure it's a good idea either.
-
ROSENTHAL: Byron Buxton Trade “Likely”
I'd feel a bit disappointed if the Twins trade Buck this offseason, just because that signals the Twins won't be competitive in 2022, and also because I won't get to watch Buxton play next year. The return is also not going to be great, because it's only for one year of a guy who doesn't stay on the field and will earn about 10 million in 2022, so it's not like he's cheap. My position on this is clear: Generally, you don't sign large guaranteed contracts to frequently injured outfielders who rely on speed to determine their value. Injuries just don't go away. Speed does go away. Buxton is not going to suddenly become durable in his 30's. If he hits, he could have value playing a corner spot, but corner outfielders who can hit are not hard to find.
-
Berrios signs Extension with Blue Jays
This is pretty disappointing as a Twins fan, since I'd consider that (on the surface) as very reasonable for Berrios. Something the Twins could've easily afforded.
-
MLB Trade Rumors looks at the Minnesota Twins
Braves also already have a young superstar roaming centerfield, and he is cheaply under long term team control.
-
The Case Against a New Shortstop for the Twins
If the Twins roll with Gordon or Maggi as the opening day shortstop, then I expect them to have also traded Buxton, Kepler, Donaldson and Sano and committed to a full rebuild.
-
What Would You Pay Byron Buxton?
Aaron Judge is kind of similar. He would have been even closer had he not played a full season this year. Both put up MVP level production when on the field but Judge only had one full season (2017, his rookie year) before this year. He also becomes a free agent after next year. Predictions for Judge are around 6/150, which seems about right? I certainly wouldn't want the Twins to pay that for Judge. Buxton should be cheaper. Judge has been much more consistent and just better overall.
- Should the Twins Gamble on a Veteran Ace?
- All Eyes on Free Agent Target Jon Gray
- Should the Twins Gamble on a Veteran Ace?
- All Eyes on Free Agent Target Jon Gray
-
Poll: Which longer-term starting pitcher contract would you sign?
Stroman is projected to get a smaller contract though. I don't see a team going 140m to get Gausman. Personally I'd give Stroman more $$ over Gausman because of his much more consistent track record of success.
-
Poll: Which longer-term starting pitcher contract would you sign?
Wow, I'd be shocked if Gausman gets 6/138. He's had one good season as a starter.
- Comparing Joe Mauer and Buster Posey’s Hall of Fame Cases
-
Twins Hire Jayce Tingler as new Bench Coach
Wow that's big news.
-
Community Blueprints: What Do Twins Fans Want to See This Offseason?
Here's mine. (Edited to reflect higher price for Gausman) Gray gets 4/60. Stroman gets 5/100. Buxton extended- 6 years, 120m, backloaded and incentive driven. He gets 10 this year. I'm bringing back Simmons because he played well while the team was near the division lead and he's a good bounce back candidate. Happy with this bullpen and rotation. Dobnak, when healthy and not jerked around by team plans, has been more effective than Pineda. https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1-XChUZHAKmTFWms2MjhZ31d9L8Mqrm1UQhDUQbCglhs/edit?usp=sharing
-
Community Blueprints: What Do Twins Fans Want to See This Offseason?
Who plays shortstop then?
-
Houston and Minnesota Both Made Drafting Mistakes
I'd think more than 1/100. Strasberg did. Mark Prior did. Harper was drafted as a 17 year old and then won ROY at age 19 by playing every day. Garrett Crochet was drafted last year and pitched for CWS last year. Just off the top of my head...
-
Houston and Minnesota Both Made Drafting Mistakes
He was picked in 2015 and played in MLB the very next year. In 2017 he played every day. I don't recall the Twins promoting this aggressively, even with college players. When has a draft pick made an MLB debut the next year for the Twins?
-
Are the Twins Destined for an Andrelton Simmons Reunion?
Without looking it up...I think Ozzie Smith would be the leader in career defensive WAR, right? Brooks Robinson has to be up there too. Simmons actually has an outside HOF chance but needs to play 3-5 more years at 3 WAR or so. That will not happen if he has more seasons like 2021 obviously.
- Are the Twins Destined for an Andrelton Simmons Reunion?
- Are the Twins Destined for an Andrelton Simmons Reunion?
-
Back in the Saddle: My Twins Offseason Blueprint
Assuming he rejects the QO from Colorado, I'd guess 4/40? He should get more guaranteed $ than Kyle Gibson did.