Everything posted by bean5302
-
Article: High Expectations: Are The Twins In Win Now Mode?
I think the Twins are in the very same mode they've been in for most of the past 2 decades. Be competitive, but very risk averse. This is a team which is solidly in the mid-market arena from a revenue potential standpoint, but with the risk aversion a small market team exhibits. I think the Twins' general approach has been, try to field a competitive team and hope some magic happens, and I think the mentality is driven by ownership far more than the front office. Sustained "competitive" teams are possible for a mid-market club. Sustained World Series contenders is not.
-
Buxton needs to get off to a decent start, imo
Spring Training is meaningless. Pitchers aren't throwing their best pitches. They don't even start Spring Training off throwing their best velocities. A lot of Spring Training is just... well... training. Shaking off the rust and working on things you want to improve at the cost of "stats" for those players who aren't trying to make a special impression. Buxton has proven his ability to hit and he did it across the last half of 2017. I doubt he has major confidence issues to work through and I don't see how a fast start is at all necessary now that he's shown his breakout with the bat. Buxton isn't going anywhere. Unless he struggles at an epic level (think OPS under .600) there is no chance he sees the minors until at least after June.
-
Article: Twins 2018 Position Analysis: Starting Pitcher
A1 = 5.55 A2 = Kind of. There were 14 qualified starters with ERA's of 4.49+ last year. It's not that starters posting 4.50 ERAs are rare. It's that pitchers who post those ERAs for consecutive years are rare. A guy can have a bad season driven by luck. BABIP, a couple of his solo shots wind up being grand slams instead... those make big differences in ERA. Teams look to shed pitchers who pitch at that 4.25+ level because they make it awfully hard to win games. 6 innings and 3ER (4.50 ERA) is treated as a quality start, but it's really not. Your team will probably allow at least one more ER over the last 3 innings of the game (ERA 3.00) which means your team needs to score 5 runs to win. The probability of scoring 5 runs in a game is far lower than 4 runs. Actually, that's the very basis of the "Ace" for the playoffs discussion. An Ace is expected to give you 7 innings at 2 ER. A #3 will give you 7 innings at 3 ER, which is still a solid start, but the expectations of winning are probably 80% in favor of the Ace's team at that point.
-
Article: Twins 2018 Position Analysis: Starting Pitcher
I was under the impression Darvishes escalators were cy young awards. If he wins 2 cy Young’s, the $150M will almost certainly be money well spent. It’s possible Darvish melts down. I don’t think he will. I think he’s ripe for a really nice few years. I’m guessing 2-3 years as an ace, plus 2-3 years as a #2 and 0-2 years as a #3 would be completely reasonable. That’s be worth it.
-
Article: Twins 2018 Position Analysis: Starting Pitcher
I can understand the desire to be positive and optimistic, but I am just totally unimpressed with this off-season. The Twins needed an ace, not 12 number 3s. It feels like the ghost of Terry Ryan. Darvish went CHEAP and Darvish is what the Twins needed. Every season, the Twins spend about $35-40M on additional salary for rotation arms. This has been the case since, I think, 2013. Phil Hughes, Mike Pelfrey, Kevin Correia, Ricky Nolasco/Hector Santiago, Ervin Santana and now Lance Lynn. Odorizzi was a big jump in payroll as well. It doesn't matter to me if the Twins have new dumpster fires eating the $35M in salary up every two years. It matters to me the Twins could have spent the money more efficiently. In any case, this year's probable rotation had a simple mean 4.87 FIP (4.68 when Hughes is replaced by Santana) which would keep them at an identical rank of 23rd of 30 teams (or 22nd of 30 teams) based on last year. Berrios = 3.84 Lynn = 4.82 Odorizzi = 5.43 Gibson = 4.85 Hughes = 5.43 Santana = 4.46 FIP There's always the chance multiple arms take a step forward and Santana comes back without regression to his mediocre to poor FIPs, but I've long since learned if, if, if, and if happens isn't a great scenario for trying to predict your teams playoff or World Series potential.
-
Article: No Suspension For Miguel Sano
MLB has shown an open willingness to punish players without the type of evidence necessary to prove accusations in a legal setting before, either probable cause or beyond a reasonable doubt. MLB conducted over 20 interviews and given the current political climate, you can bet they didn’t take their decision lightly. There’s absolutely no reason to doubt the quality or integrity of the MLB investigation. MLB didn’t say “Sano’s accuser was full of ****” or something of that nature. The investigation was almost certainly very thorough, but it was obviously unable to uncover any solid evidence Sano acted inappropriately. This was never going to be about a “sexual assault” as police would have been handling that investigation. It’s not MLBs duty to investigate crimes. It’s MLBs duty to investigate personal conduct and determine whether or not a player has violated personal conduct rules, which isn’t limited in scope to crimes. There just wasn’t significant evidence OR perhaps there wasn’t significant interest from the accuser to pursue punishment. We don’t know, and we never will. It would be nice if people had a shred of respect for the hard work of MLB investigators and the process, though.
-
Article: Report From The Fort: Escobar's Opportunity
Escobar's career UZR/150 at SS is +0.3 and was +3.5 last year. Aside from a poor 2016, Escobar has never been a below average shortstop in 5 other seasons. His RF/9 has also traditionally graded out as average to better than league average at SS.
- Article: Twins 2018 Position Analysis: Right Field
-
Minor Leaguers and Minimum Wage
International signings get signing bonuses. If MLB scouts are interested in some 16 year old kid playing baseball in the Dominican, that kid is getting a signing bonus, and it's going to be enormous in value compared to what they would make in their home country. Kennys Vargas, for example, earned a 100,000 US Dollar signing bonus as an un-drafted, amateur international free agent (about 250,000 of value in the Dominican). Vargas was NOT heavily scouted prior to the Twins noticing him. Max Kepler, for example, earned a 775,000 US Dollar signing bonus as an un-drafted (pre draft eligible) amateur international free agent. International free agent signings are part of the 95%.
-
Minor Leaguers and Minimum Wage
Who signs in the 40th round? Just because players are drafted does not mean they're signed. No high schooler is signing outside the 10th round. So you have college players who might sign, but are unlikely to jeopardize a scholarship based on a 11+ round selection. That leaves you with college players losing eligibility or are graduating. Basically, anybody signing outside the 10th round knows they're an EXTREME long shot and are doing it for a single season of fun and novelty. "Hey, I was drafted by the Twins and played in the minors!" Yes, there are players like Albert Pujols, but they're ultra rare. Here's an article about the best players drafted in each round after 5, by WAR. Zero of the players listed were drafted in the past 17 years. https://www.mlb.com/news/best-late-round-picks-in-draft-history/c-182980276 So while I'm still angered by MLB's actions and lobbying in this case, when the signing bonuses are considered, I'm a lot less sympathetic to the overall plight of 95% of MiLB players. It's not as outrageous as it seemed.
-
Article: Twins 2018 Position Analysis: Right Field
Kepler had only a 40 point OPS spread between RH and LH pitchers for his last two full seasons in the minors, but lefties have definitely owned him at the MLB level. His BABIP would get a lot of help if he stopped popping the ball up as much, and with Kepler's eye at the plate, it's something I think he could work on with learning which pitches lead him to pop the ball up. Kepler still reminds me of a somewhat less talented version of Joe Mauer at the plate, but Kepler may wind up delivering more pop, which will be necessary to remain a starter at a non-premium defensive position.
-
Minor Leaguers and Minimum Wage
I don't think many of the recent posts are actually pertinent to the original topic. Arguing MiLB players shouldn't be better compensated because MLB players (who have 100% of the power in the union) have enormous compensation levels isn't on topic. Arguing you work 60-80hrs a week where you aren't appropriately compensated for that work, you don't switch employers, you don't choose to cut back to a reasonable work life balance and you don't demand more compensation doesn't have any relevance in regard to MiLB players working for under minimum wage. Simply because other problems in the world exist doesn't mean MiLB players should have their ability to even TRY to fight for LEGALLY REQUIRED compensation stripped from them. I think the big relevant point is the draft pick slot money and bonus pools for teams. No pick in the 10 rounds of the MLB draft in 2017 signed for less than a $131,100 bonus. That will carry you quite a ways even if you were to consider losing out on scholarships. For the un-drafted free agents who sign MiLB contracts, they're also usually also commanding big signing bonuses.
-
Article: Ehire Of Hope: Can Adrianza Seize A Prime Opportunity?
This is exactly what I'm talking about... a19 - 8 PA, .600 BABIP a24 - 177 PA, .391 BABIP a25 - 22 PA, .357 BABIP a25 - 195 PA, .389 BABIP (here's where he stops being a legit prospect and nearly loses rookie status) a26 - 37 PA, .267 BABIP a27 - 44 PA, .308 BABIP Career MLB 517 PA, .276 BABIP, driven down by his very high pop-up rate. His AAA BABIP is inflated. His last two seasons at AAA, in admitted very small sample sizes, have been similar to his MLB BABIP and Adrianza has a batting average more similar to his MLB career line as a result. It seems unreasonable to look at his AAA stats without a large dose of skepticism, especially given his inability to impress at other MiLB levels and his terrible hitting at the MLB level. In regard to the criticism of Escobar's abilities at SS, he's got a career 0.3 UZR/150 line in 2,363 innings, largely hurt only by a rough 2016. Escobar was billed as a slick fielding SS with the potential his bat could play with a little time. His bat now plays, and while he doesn't have the full speed and range he did a couple years ago, but he's got what it takes to put together an above average fielding (not great or elite) season at SS if the Twins decide to let him. Some links with scouting information and expectations for Escobar. http://www.chicagonow.com/future-sox/eduardo-escobar/ https://www.minnpost.com/sports/2015/09/eduardo-escobar-can-be-twins-shortstop-solution-if-they-let-him https://minnesota.sbnation.com/minnesota-twins/2012/7/28/3199423/francisco-liriano-minnesota-twins-trade-chicago-white-sox-eduardo-escobar In summary, I don't believe you've done much research on the subject and maybe formed some opinions based on what you've heard people say off the cuff. I could be mistaken, but I don't find anything to suggest your opinion on either subject is particularly well anchored.
-
Minor Leaguers and Minimum Wage
Yeah, it's pretty abominable. Truly disgusting. MLB is basically trying to lobby congress for the exemption so they can avoid MiLB players having even have an opportunity to challenge the abusive pay structure. https://www.abc15.com/newsy/mlb-could-reportedly-get-a-special-exemption-in-congress-spending-bill
-
Article: Ehire Of Hope: Can Adrianza Seize A Prime Opportunity?
Adrianza can not and will not hit. He's a utility infielder until he loses a step. He has a career wRC+ of 76 and has never even flashed an upside bat at the MLB level. His best stint, ever, was a 20 plate appearance rookie cup of coffee in 2013 where he registered a wRC+ of 100. His AAA numbers are incredibly easy to ignore. His age and far too high BABIP inflated the numbers. The idea Adrianza can or will turn a corner is just random player affection. Adrianza does bring a potentially very good glove. How good? Tough to say as he's only had 500 career MLB innings at short stop and his fielding percentage is lower than Escobar's. In regard to Escobar, he's an above average fielding short stop, and I don't get why people continue to lose sight of this. It's practically conspiracy level at this point, haha. The Twins haven't disliked Escobar's glove at SS, they've liked his utility everywhere else as they've used him as defensive duct tape to hold the roster together as needed. If Escobar had been used as a shortstop instead of everything and the kitchen sink, I think it's likely he would be looking forward to a big pay day in 2019 already. In summary, there is no way in hell Adrianza pushes or challenges Escobar at shortstop. The two players are in entirely different leagues. Adrianza is a utility AAAA infielder who's all glove and can serve as a defensive replacement or an occasional breather. Escobar is a potential 3 WAR starting MLB shortstop. Whether Escobar ends up playing shortstop seems more likely to rely upon Sano's potential suspension.
-
Eugenio Suarez extension - a template for Sano or Buxton?
Suarez may not be "elite"; however, he certainly impressed last season and has a ceiling of perennial All Star. He was signed out of Venezuela at age 16 or 17 and rose through the farms systems quickly and consistently. He made his MLB debut with the Tigers at age 22 and showed good glove work and raw talent. So while he might not have been as highly touted when signed, the league certainly recognizes his talents at this point. Now Suarez just wrapped up two consecutive full seasons at the MLB level at age 25-26 at the 2-4 WAR-ish level. His bat is coming around and he's improved at taking walks and selecting good pitches to hit all while showing sustainability at 3B with plus defense. Suarez still has some projectability and could very well end up in that 3-4+ WAR average season range. Sano's CEILING is probably in the 4-5 WAR range IF he's able to stick at 3B. It's probably 4 WAR if he has to move to 1B or DH. So Sano has a perennial All Star ceiling, but he'll never compete for an MVP and it's highly unlikely he'll ever be an "elite" player at this point. If the Twins wanted to take an enormous gamble and lock Sano up, I expect they should be able to do it for something similar, but Sano's ego might get in the way. Buxton is a different story. He's already got a 4-5ish WAR season under his belt and his bat really showed up in the last half of the season. He plays elite defense at a premium defensive position and has a perennial MVP ceiling at this point. He would cost dramatically more to lock up, but I don't think there's a good reason for the Twins to try until after this season.
-
Baseballs New Contract Era
The owners are spending. These are the median opening day payrolls in the league over the past 10 years. Based on this information, median payroll increase a cumulative average annual increase of 4.6%, and 7.6% over the past 5 years. 2008 - $81M 2009 - $82M 2010 - $84M 2011 - $87M 2012 - $88M 2013 - $91M 2014 -$107M 2015 -$115M 2016 -$116M 2017 - $127M http://www.stevetheump.com/Payrolls.htm The owners are spending, but this year's free agent crop was exceedingly poor with next year's potentially being epic. While you'll get no argument from me more money should be paid to younger players, the competitive balance rules aren't going anywhere and they shouldn't. None of the 4 major sports have more competitive balance than baseball. All teams in baseball need to rebuild from time to time.
-
Article: Twins 2018 Position Analysis: Third Base
Sano is heavier, shorter and arguably slower than Kennys Vargas. I'm not joking or exaggerating. Statcast's 2017 sprint speed has Sano at 26.9mph and Vargas at 26.6mph. Vargas has dropped weight and worked on his conditioning. Sano has gained and not been working out. Would anybody here suggest moving Kennys Vargas to 3B? I've never seen Vargas throw so I don't know as Vargas has a cannon arm or anything, but lets be realistic of Sano's potential to play a full season at 3B without dropping 50lbs regardless of whether or not a fan watching a video thinks Sano looks good or is hiding his weight well.
-
Article: Twins 2018 Position Analysis: Second Base
Robinson Cano signed with the Mariners for 10 years and $240M at age 31 going in to 2014, but Cano did have a bit more ceiling and a better track record. Dozier isn't going to get close to that, but it's hard to argue Dozier isn't a premier player. 2B hasn't been a high demand spot, but Dozier is the second best 2B in MLB over the past 3 years, and he gives a 2.5 WAR upgrade over other "good" 2B options. That's a hell of a lot. I'd be surprised if Dozier didn't command a 3-5 year contract at $75-100M.
-
Article: Twins 2018 Position Analysis: Second Base
There is no collusion. You have a bunch of agents thirsty for their next paycheck, but not a great deal of talent to sell. Agents have become accustomed to mega deals for the top free agents, but this year's talent pool was dry. Agents were still selling mediocre JAG players as if they were cornerstones for playoff teams for the next 5 years. Case in point. Mike Moustakas. A mediocre player. Solid defender, but with only one really great year in 2015. He's a 2 WAR player. Estimates ranged up to $100M for him, and Boras wanted 6-7 years and up to $125M if I remember. The guys this year... they're just not very good and they're asking for elite money because even though they're not that great, they're the best available.
-
Article: Twins 2018 Position Analysis: Second Base
Sano isn't the 3rd baseman of the future unless something dramatic happens. Escobar isn't the 3rd baseman of the future. Love him, but not at 3rd with his bat. Gordon at SS is superior to Polanco at SS. Polanco has some potential to replace a lot of Dozier's bat and add superior defense at 2B There isn't anybody in MiLB who is an obvious solution for 3rd base n the next year or two. Dozier's going to decline. He keeps defying all logic, but for the next few years, I could see him compensating for a bit of a weaker arm with superior range at 3rd base and his bat would play there. Mauer probably isn't the solution at 3rd. His cannon arm is wasted at 1B, but his speed is on the decline and asking him to just learn a completely new, and this time more difficult, position seems like a tall order. Maybe the Twins are just in the position where there are too many pieces moving to make a big commitment to Dozier.
-
Article: Report From The Fort: Peeking Ahead At Payroll
Other costs include operating facilities, front office employees, scouting, minor league teams, marketing, draft bonuses, and a huge host of other operational expenses. Pohlad indicated he said from a cash flow perspective, the Twins would be lucky to break even in 2017. Forbes reported they think Operating Income (essentially positive cash flow) was $30M last year. That said, profitability from the franchises has a lot more to do with franchise value as businesses NEVER report profits and losses based solely on cash flow. P&L is based on growth of value combined with cash flow. For the Twins, Forbes estimated a $115M increase in value and a $30M operating income for a total profit of $145M for 2017. In regard to the Twins' potential revenue, a better product on the field makes an immense impact on revnue. The Royals had a revenue of $161M in 2012. Then, as the team began to perform, revenue grew, and after their World Series appearance in 2014 it skyrocketed from $178M to $231M in 2015, then to $273M in 2016. Yes, the ROYALS had significantly higher revenues than the Twins. What did the Royals do with that revenue? They reinvested it to grow the fan base and revenue pool. The Twins have not been willing to do that, instead being more focused on ensuring cash flow stability and positive operating income.
- Article: Report From The Fort: Joe Mauer Will Give Up Hitting When You Pry The Bat From His Cold Dead Hand
-
Article: Buxton Extending Into the Future
My point is about how expensive it would be to lock Buxton up long term including securing multiple free agency years right now. I don't think the Twins risk much by letting Buxton play another full season as a "prove it" campaign. because I don't think Buxton's agent would want Byron to accept a low ball offer like Span took.
-
Article: Report From The Fort: Peeking Ahead At Payroll
The Twins have run under 48% opening day payroll for the past decade except one season. Revenue vs. Opening Day Payroll. 2009 - $162M vs. $66M = 41% 2010 - $213M vs. $97M = 46% 2011 - $213M vs. $113M = 53% 2012 - $214M vs. $94M = 44% 2013 - $221M vs. $76M = 34% 2014 - $223M vs. $86M = 39% 2015 - $240M vs. $109M = 45% 2016 - $249M vs. $108M = 43% 2017 - $249M vs. $108M = 43% 2018 - $249M? vs. $118M = 47% Revenue from: https://www.statista.com/statistics/196669/revenue-of-the-minnesota-twins-since-2006/ and https://www.forbes.com/teams/minnesota-twins/ Payroll from: http://www.stevetheump.com/Payrolls.htm#2016_payroll At this point, with this owner, I think it's unreasonable to expect the Twins to approached the expected target for MLB team expenditures.