Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

bean5302

Verified Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by bean5302

  1. Since the article says "top 100" that generally means at least 1 of the 2 potential prospects are outside the top 30, top 50, etc. In addition, we don't know what quality of pre-arb player the Twins are wanting. A pre-arbitration, low ceiling back end of the rotation arm? They're nice and they don't totally grow on trees, but they're not super valuable either. 1 prospect ranked 30th, 1 prospect ranked 90th and a low ceiling back end rotation arm isn't a huge ask for a pitcher at Berrios' caliber, IMHO.
  2. I think it's important to evaluate what contracts look like these days. "Ace" is a term I think most people feel should be used with elite pitchers in terms of single game value. Pitchers who routinely show ERAs in the 2s or very low 3s, "Aces" are in the 5+ years and $30MM+ AAV. For a young "ace" contract these days consider a few of these. 2013 = Felix Hernandez 7 years $175MM (AAV 25MM) 2013 = Justin Verlander 7-8 years $180MM-202MM (AAV 25-26MM) 2013 = Clayton Kershaw 7 years $210MM (AAV 30MM) 2014 = Jon Lester 6-7 years $155MM-170MM (AAV 24-26MM) 2015 = Zack Greincke 6 years $206MM (AAV 34MM) 2015 = Max Scherzer 7 years $210MM (AAV 30MM) 2018 = Yu Darvish 6 years $126MM (AAV 21MM) 2019 = DeGrom 5 years $138MM (AAV 28MM) 2020 = Stephen Strasburg 7 years $245MM (AAV 35MM) 2020 = Gerrit Cole 9 years $324MM (AAV 36MM) 5 years $125MM is nowhere near typical "ace" money. Then again, we really don't have a good idea what Berrios is asking in the first place, and we also have no clue what the Twins have been countering with. Berrios will probably bring 5 years and $125MM on the open market as a free agent. Signing now, before he becomes a free agent, transfers a fair bit of risk to the Twins and the expectation is extensions generally come with a bit of a discount built in for that reason. I'd think 5 years $115MM or 6 years $130MM would be reasonable. Anything over 5 years and $125MM feels foolhardy.
  3. Higher meaning more likely to contribute to the Twins winning a World Series on an annual basis. I believe players who are likely to generate higher fWAR and bWAR on an annual basis are more likely to contribute to a team's success. I'd wager you'd be correct in your assertion the National (and American) Leagues have valued perceived defensive contributions when choosing a shortstop for more cumulative years than the player performance at the plate over the past 100 years. I would be very surprised to see evidence backing that up over the past decade, though. I give you Pedro Florimon as a good example. Despite being an excellent defensive shortstop, he hasn't had a starting shortstop job in MLB since the Twins moved on from him after 2014. Florimon wasn't even a black hole at the plate owning a .732 OPS in his last 3 seasons at the MLB level (which ended in 2018). Right now, Florimon sits at San Diego's AAA affiliate while a poor defensive shortstop by the name of Fernando Tatis, Jr. is enjoying his first year of a 13 year $330MM contract on San Diego's MLB roster as a starter. Based on all accounts I've read, Simmons was not signed by Minnesota to be a defense only SS, btw. He has a career .267 average (since you used that statistic) and was expected to be a league average-ish bat for the Twins.
  4. Lance Lynn has been notably better across the past 3 years and far better across his career than Berrios. Lynn has much higher upside, but he was enormously burned in the 2017-2018 offseason by a number of factors including his push for a longer contract so he's probably a little risk averse at this point. Between the two? 2019-2021 Lynn (383 innings, 3.20 ERA, 3.38 FIP, 10.3 K/9, 2.7 BB/9 vs. Berrios (372 innings, 3.68 ERA, 3.76 FIP, 9.1 K/9, 2.6 BB/9)
  5. There will be a lot of FA shortstops to choose from for 2022. I'd hope the Twins would aim a little higher than Simmons if they're looking to compete.
  6. Polanco's error rate continues to be pretty high and UZR paints his play in a pretty bad light. Defensive metrics usually get closer together through the full year so it'll be interesting to see how things look at the end of the season.
  7. I am. Valimont is pitching against AA hitters who often don't have good plate discipline. If they can lay off his offerings and take pitches for balls, it means Valimont's stuff isn't going to fool anybody at the MLB level.
  8. Somebody must have told them it was the playoffs...
  9. If I was to hazard a guess it would have something to do with Donaldson being in his stance ready for the pitch and Arraez is staring off into the outfield stands, facing away from the plate unable to see what was happening. Then, Arraez started moving around in Donaldson's line of sight to pick up the pitch. Arraez wasn't in position, he wasn't ready and he was distracting Donaldson. Feels pretty disrespectful to me. I don't think it's any big deal. More of just a "Come on, man! Get your head in the game!" The dugout conversation looked like a no biggie to me.
  10. After this last start, I can't see any MLB team discussing Happ at all. There are guys any team has at AAA who would probably be a better choice.
  11. Polanco looks to be putting together a solid 2.5-3.0 WAR campaign this year based on positional value and his bat. There are reasons to think Polanco's performance at the plate continue to climb a bit since his BABIP is still a bit too low at .267 compared to his career .307, but his HR rate is probably a bit inflated. Polanco doesn't walk a ton, but he also doesn't strike out a lot and he brings a little pop. Defensive metrics can be pretty unreliable until you get a couple full seasons together and there are several different systems for measuring play. While Baseball Reference shows Polanco with a Total Zone per 1200 innings of +10 runs, UZR/150 shows Polanco at a -13.7 runs over 150 games. That's literally 2 WAR difference just in defensive metric projections across a full season. Regardless of the advanced metrics, one thing which is clear, the biggest contributor to Polanco's previous defensive shortcomings (error rate) is still an issue. That said, Polanco is playing as a 2B consistently for the first time in several years so there's still room for improvement. While Polanco's contract is pretty minimal right now, it grades up to $10.5MM by year 2024 and I don't think he provides a big upside over Luis Arraez. Honestly, I think Arraez is good enough to start on a lot of MLB teams so keeping him as a utility guy feels wasteful. I think the Twins should seek to move Arraez or Polanco before next season and if I were choosing a player to move, it'd be Polanco for the savings.
  12. I don't think this is a fair take because of how big of an impact we're talking about for both the player and the organization. There's a lot to think about. You're talking about potentially the entire career for a player who has invested a decade of very hard work into "his" company. He's negotiating a guaranteed contract worth 10s of millions (or even potentially asking for 100s of millions of dollars) where this contract could lead to enormous repercussions for a multi-billion dollar company. It's more like a business acquisition than selling a used car with a "bottom line" price which has been pre determined. Agents, lawyers, executives and business owners are all involved in these discussions around risk analysis, forecasting, competitive balance, cash flows, legal and insurance issues are at play. Trying to view it from a wider perspective may provide more insight into why these negotiations are seemingly so complicated and take so long as frustrating as it is for fans.
  13. It's also worth noting the Twins signed Morneau, Cuddyer and Nathan to extensions immediately after deciding to trade Santana after being unable to come to an agreement with Johan on an extension. The Twins may be trying to get the Buxton situation in order before looking at Berrios.
  14. I've read pretty much nothing about Berrios and the Twins' contract negotiations. It doesn't even sound like they got too invested in extension discussions earlier this spring. It wouldn't surprise me if the Twins are a little skittish of negotiating any huge contracts before the 2022 CBA and that's the reason we're not seeing a lot of extension discussion in regard to Berrios.
  15. While it's certainly true that many prospects don't pan out, teams still need to draft and develop prospects with the expectation those players will eventually supplant existing veterans. The Twins are going to have to bring up prospects one way or another, but doing it during a lost season like this one is considered by many to be the least risky way of doing it. Unfortunately, with only 26 roster spots available at the trade deadline, making room requires taking risks on letting existing talent go to other teams.
  16. Certainly tough to estimate. I don't think him being healthy for a month or two makes a significant difference, TBH. A little open to debate on just how much, actually. When the Yankees signed Hicks, he was coming off a 7.2 bWAR and 5.2 bWAR per 162 seasons. Buxton was at 5.6 bWAR and 8.7 bWAR in 2019-2020.
  17. Did you mean somebody else? Nomar Mazara is a 26 year old 6 year MLB veteran who Texas traded to the White Sox in 2020 for MiLB positional depth. Mazara was then was non tendered by the White Sox last December. After two months of job searching, the Tigers picked Mazra up on a 1 year $1.75MM contract. Mazara is not a prospect and he's not going to be anything other than organizational depth on a competitive team.
  18. I'd honestly like an independent source to go out on a limb and give a Buxton free agent contract estimate right now, but that's not going to happen since Buxton isn't going to be a free agent next year. Twins fans are not remotely objective on the issue. There's so much invested in it. When it comes to Aaron Hicks' contract, I think other teams across MLB are looking more at comparable durability than the AAV in terms of how it relates to Buxton. Even so, to be blunt, Hicks and Buxton are pretty comparable in terms of WAR production since Buxton arrived in 2015. Is a healthy Buxton dramatically superior to a healthy Hicks? Probably not. Buxton gets you an extra 1.5 WAR in defensive value in a full season and that's about it, and that's how I'd look at things from a GM perspective.
  19. Mitch Garver vs Ryan Jeffers. Luckily, Garver (258 innings) and Jeffers (298 innings) have played in a similar number of innings with the same pitching staff this year. Framing? Garver +2, Jeffers +1. Errors? Identical = 1 Passed balls count? Identical = 2 Wild pitches? Garver = 10 vs. Jeffers = 12 Caught stealing? Garver 20% (career 20%), Jeffers 35% (career 25%), but opposing teams have run on Jeffers far more frequently 26 attempts vs. 15 attempts. Jeffers was bad in 2020, catching only 13% while Garver caught 33% last year. As far as CS%, that seems to fluctuate a lot, year to year. It seems hard to gauge without a few years in a row with similar numbers. If I were a betting person, I'd wager the stance on Garver's defense has more to do with reputation than reality.
  20. Donaldson's playing history included a pretty solid track record on games played. 2013 - Full season (158) 2014 - Full season (158) 2015 - Full season (158) 2016 - Full season (155) 2017 - 113 games 2018 - 52 games 2019 - Full season (155) In my opinion, Byron Buxton's track record on games played doesn't look much like Donaldson. I also think it's a disservice to Donaldson's value added to compare Buxton to him in terms of how much a team might pay or expect in production. Donaldson's top 5 bWAR seasons are all higher than any season Buxton has ever had while Donaldson also collected an MVP, and was a 3x All Star.
  21. I don't think it's a big issue, but just for the sake of accuracy, Buxton has had migraines since childhood. Here's an article with a quote about it. https://www.mlb.com/news/twins-byron-buxton-sidelined-with-migraines-c244651028. I'm not saying concussions couldn't have influenced the severity or frequency of migraines, but it's not something which can be directly attributed to concussions.
  22. I don't see any team giving Buxton more than 3 years in the open market on a guaranteed high AAV contract. At the end of 2021, it will have been 5 years since Buxton hadn't missed an massive amount of time on the field due to injury or generated more than 3 WAR in a season. I can't see the Twins offering less than 3-4 years in total right now (2-3yr extension), and at $70MM, that's more than fair. If the speculation is accurate and the Twins are offering 7/70MM, I also can't see Buxton taking it because the potential for him to earn dramatically more on a short term deal and a new contract afterwards is realistic. The timing of this statement makes no sense to me. Are the Twins attempting to drum up some calls on Buxton across the league? If they're not already getting calls, that probably says a lot about other teams' interest level in him. Also, a statement like this is likely to agitate Buxton which reduces Twins negotiating leverage with other teams and Buxton both now and in the offseason. I just see this as a lose-lose. It would be a better strategy to leak another team is courting the Twins for Buxton.
  23. I've seen AA as a place where players work on their mechanics and craft against high level competition and AAA as a place pitchers prove their polish and locating, but that's just my opinion. If the Twins aren't having him make any mechanical changes and he keeps dominating AA for another couple weeks, it would make sense to me to push him to AAA and / or make a September call up, but I'd imagine the Twins are going to be watching his innings if it looks like he's going to throw more than 100 this year. Just my guesswork bouncing around in my head.
  24. Glad to see Garver hitting the ball right away and Jake Cave running at full speed. Phrases like "back fracture" are kind of terrifying to me, and regardless of how people feel about his abilities on the field at the MLB level, I'd think nobody wishes those kinds of injuries on anybody. The fact Balazovic got through 7.0 innings on just 90 pitches and only 2 more batters than the minimum is awesome. That's serious efficiency to go along with the double digit strikeouts. Hope he can keep it going and get up to 100 innings.
  25. Varland didn't sound like he was really heavily scouted as he was a 15th rounder in 2019 and, of course, missed 2020 due to the COVID shutdowns. The Twins reworked his delivery mechanics and he picked up several miles per hour on his fastball. Varland sits in the upper 90s now and can touch 100 in max effort throws. He also throws a slider, changeup and is working on a cutter, but based on his draft position and him describing himself as fastball heavy out of college, I expect all of them have needed some work. Evidently the work on his pitches must be paying off, but his UCL strain right away in 2019 does set off some red flags on durability expectations as far as I'm concerned. If he can continue seeing success as he moves up the ladder, it'll be a huge feather in the cap of the Twins front office and obviously a dream come true to stand on the mound at the MLB level for a kid who didn't have a hint he'd be drafted before getting the phone call. Seth did an interview with him earlier this year.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.