Twins Daily 2022 Top Prospects: #8 Simeon Woods Richardson

A work in progress. By the end of the year there should be some clarity

This is another good writeup!  Thanks for mentioning how far he fell during the season. He was two different pitchers last year.  He started off in May with 19 innings pitched a 2.35 ERA with a WHIP of 1.16 and 31K's in those 19 innings.  Really dominant for a 20 year old at AA. 

Then it all fell apart. Not sure exactly what the issues were but have to say it does give one pause.  Was he injured or the arm tired after the first 6 weeks of the season?  It seems like he had time to recover over the Olympics and yet he was even worse once he returned.  

So at this point which guy is he.  The dominant K machine that started last year or the guy giving up hits, walks and runs like crazy?  I don't know.  All I do know is he is young with plenty of time to improve and he has shown flashes of dominance so no reason he can't get back there.   He was a pretty big part of the Berrios deal so we need him to work out.  Hoping for a big year that puts my fears to rest.

I am seeing this list under a very different lens than the TD listers.  When I read the 'What's left to work on" section I think this is not a top ten guy.  He has too much to prove yet.  Another pitcher that I would put Winder ahead of.  I hope he fulfills the expectations.  

I am slowly beginning to understand that these lists are so different from the last few years because of all the players who are no longer eligible because they have been called up.  So in the past I was looking for the next one to take Target field and in this list I am seeing more wait and see and hope with the exception of a few arms I still hope to see this year. 

He probably has some of the best stuff of the Twins minor league pitchers. Command is an issue and might never be good enough to make it.  This has bullpen written all over it.  Not what I wanted here, but he has a few years to work things out.  Like a previous poster, given the issues, he looks to be rated too high for me.

Great summary--I think you identified his strengths and weaknesses beautifully.  While this kid has the stuff to be a solid starter, last year raises concerns.  I too think he should be a little lower on the list.  It will be interesting to see where he sits at midseason.  Hopefully, I will have to eat crow :).  

54 minutes ago, mikelink45 said:

When I read the 'What's left to work on" section I think this is not a top ten guy.

He's easily a top 10 guy. He's top 5 on most lists. Ceiling is higher than anyone except Balazovic.

SWR being in the Stroman and Berrios trades is kind of funny. As a young dude in AA, I'm just glad the Ks are there. The walk rate isn't good but the fact that he got something right as a young AA guy is nice. I'm hyped for him.

I like SWR's attitude and has 3 working pitches. He's definitely not BP material. Once settled in and time for the coaching staff to work with him, he'll be fine. Like baseball's Yogi Berra said "baseball is 90% mental and the other half is physical". IMO SWR has that mental toughness. 

IMO SWR is rated this high because of his potential, attitude and mental toughness.

 Nice thing about having a number of starters closer to the majors than SWR, we don't have to cut short his development time. So if he breaks in as a reliever in late 2023 and forces someone else out of the rotation, I think that's a good thing.

2 hours ago, chpettit19 said:

I think he was terribly mismanaged last year. First by the Blue Jays and then by whoever let him go to the Olympics and not throw a single pitch. After not throwing a competitive pitch in 2020 he should've started at high-A for the Blue Jays and taking 6 weeks off in the middle of the season to throw 0 competitive pitches and not even be around his developmental coaches was terrible. I look at him as basically a brand new prospect after these last 2 years. I don't know that I'd rank him significantly higher or lower than this on my list, but I'd view him as basically a new draftee/signee. His track record is completely wiped out for me after the last 2 years. Fresh start and let's see what he looks like this year.

This. He might have been ok starting in AA, but having that get interrupted by the Olympics and then not actually pitching in Japan on top of not having a season of games in 2020 really screwed him. He needed last year as a development year and it got completely borked up with the Olympics. Considering he only had 6 starts in A+ at age 18, I don't think there was any need to rush him to AA, especially with the skip year in 2020. 

His time with the Twins so far was pretty meaningless: it's only 8 innings coming off a essentially a 6 week layoff. I'm guessing they were just trying to see what he looked like and try to figure out what he needed to work on. Hopefully, he's back in AA and gets to be on a real program this year and show what he can do. the talent is there.

I really don't want him factoring in to any trade right now; pretty sure we'd be selling low on a guy with a lot of talent.

6 hours ago, DJL44 said:

He's easily a top 10 guy. He's top 5 on most lists. Ceiling is higher than anyone except Balazovic.

I hope you are right

Woods-Richardson was an MLB's #93, Fangraphs' #76, Bleacher Reports #78 prospect in 2020/entering 2021 and was the cornerstone of the Marcus Stroman trade. While he's unranked this year among top 100 lists, he hasn't really changed.

There's little surprise Woods-Richardson's struggled with control after losing 2020 and half of the 2021 season due to just sitting on a bench for his name to be called in the Olympics. People can point fingers all they want in regard to fault for that situation, but as a young prospect developing mechanics, the loss of playing time is about the worst possible thing which can happen. It also would explain why the Twins put him on the Development List rather than assigning him directly to AA after he arrived back from Tokyo last year. 

Woods-Richardson's MLB scouting report lists his pitches as Four seam fastball, curveball, slider, changeup. I haven't seen much in regard to scouting on his slider, but what's out there indicates it's an MLB caliber offering, just not his best. Woods-Richardson's curveball and changeup both have plus potential.

Basically, Woods-Richardson has the stuff to get the job done and has shown impressive performances into the high minors despite aggressive promotions. There's some projection potential left in his fastball and the Twins have been very successful so far in getting a little extra velocity from mechanical adjustments on other prospects. There's a reason Woods-Richardson was so highly coveted by the Blue Jays and by the Twins. The negativity directed at his stock is unwarranted at this point.

His athletic build is mentioned: what is it exactly?

Size and age would be a good fundamental for these-write ups, along with last season's numbers.

An athletic 6' 3" and listed at 210, but I'm sure that number is light.

Saw his debut with the Saints yesterday.  His strikeouts were incredible to watch.  Watching him get rocked for 3 huge hits, the last being a lead-surrendering 3 run blast sucked.