Twins Future Position Analysis: Centerfield

When Buxton is in CF, we have the best CF defense in MLB. But there is a sharp drop off when he's not. Kepler is OK but he is stretched there & then RF suffers. Celestino is listed at AAA but in fact he hasn't been above A, his last 8 games were at A+. Celestino has good potential to cover CF but according to management timetable he's far from ready. 

The Twins seems like when Buxton came up that he`d be always great defensively, offensively & never get hurt. There has never been an adequate plan B & we have been limping around at CF since & even before waiting for Buxton. Plan B at CF never has been a priority much less plan C or D. We are presently, near future & future lacking very much depth at CF. Our priority has been big bats & neglect CF, that should change. If we don`t draft high CF prospects we should trade for them. 

In a couple of years Buxton is eligible for FA, we should make every effort to extend his contract or we're up the creek

Watching a natural-born centerfielder like Buxton is a beautiful thing. I suppose the same could be said about catchers and shortstops, but neither of those positions inspired John Fogerty to write a song about them.

I'm thinking Celestino could outplay Cave and Wade this year when considering defensive value, plus he's a righty bat. I wouldn't be surprised if 2 years from now Buxton walks and Gilberto is roaming center. This guy has a real chance to be a player, but even in this scenario as DG said we still need to augment the position. Maciel could be a fourth in the future.

I do not want Kepler/Cave/Wade in CF.  If Buxton goes down I want a true CF even if he is not yet at the development level the team wants.  Defense and speed do not need more minor league time.

Will agree with the above comments that our defense suffers when Kepler is moved to center. Not so much because he isn't adequate in center, because he is solid, but the big step down defensively when he isn't in right.

Also agree that this situation hasn't be adequately addressed over the past few years. Yet, with Buxton as the starter I understand why the FO would work on other, more pressing needs.

But I think we are approaching a time when the backup center fielder isn't a problem any longer. Unless there is a big move to an infielder, second, short or third, I see Lewis breaking in as a super utility man in the mold of Gonzalez...only much, much better. He could play nearly full time at second, short, third, left, center and right. When someone is banged up or on the IL, he becomes the starter at that spot. He then moves to one position in 2022 or 2023.

Have a feeling the FO may see him in this role soon, perhaps by opening day. Expect we will learn more about their view with what moves they make (or don't make) over the next two months. 

I also agree with the above comment.  Lewis is key in many respects.  Where will be end up ?

CF & SS is where our current talented players have suffered thru injury issues.  The idea that Lewis can break in as a "super utility" guy is interesting because the Twins can see him at a variety of positions both in the infield and the outfield while also seeing how he fares with the bat.

He could flop.

He could shine.

He could show that he is better at CF than SS or vice-versa.

Whatever develops the hope is he will eventually force himself into the starting lineup

and solve a SS or CF problem and help the Twins decide what to do with Buxton and Polanco in a year or two.

Guys like Celestino, Maciel, and even guys like Urbina and Rodriguez also provide potential upside and options down the line.  

 

 

But I think we are approaching a time when the backup center fielder isn't a problem any longer. Unless there is a big move to an infielder, second, short or third, I see Lewis breaking in as a super utility man in the mold of Gonzalez...only much, much better. He could play nearly full time at second, short, third, left, center and right. When someone is banged up or on the IL, he becomes the starter at that spot. He then moves to one position in 2022 or 2023.

 

Have a feeling the FO may see him in this role soon, perhaps by opening day. Expect we will learn more about their view with what moves they make (or don't make) over the next two months. 

This is my hope also. But to my astonishment in what I hear, is that Lewis wasn't put one time in CF during 2020. Although they might think that w/ all the time Lewis spends w/ Tori Hunter away from the system, he doesn't need it

Will agree with the above comments that our defense suffers when Kepler is moved to center. Not so much because he isn't adequate in center, because he is solid, but the big step down defensively when he isn't in right.

 

Also agree that this situation hasn't be adequately addressed over the past few years. Yet, with Buxton as the starter I understand why the FO would work on other, more pressing needs.

 

But I think we are approaching a time when the backup center fielder isn't a problem any longer. Unless there is a big move to an infielder, second, short or third, I see Lewis breaking in as a super utility man in the mold of Gonzalez...only much, much better. He could play nearly full time at second, short, third, left, center and right. When someone is banged up or on the IL, he becomes the starter at that spot. He then moves to one position in 2022 or 2023.

 

Have a feeling the FO may see him in this role soon, perhaps by opening day. Expect we will learn more about their view with what moves they make (or don't make) over the next two months. 

I think asking a rookie to break in as a Super Utility will slow his progress. Not getting enough reps at a position consistently. Also, Aside from 2 weeks in AZ Fall League his bat seems questionable

This is my hope also. But to my astonishment in what I hear, is that Lewis wasn't put one time in CF during 2020. Although they might think that w/ all the time Lewis spends w/ Tori Hunter away from the system, he doesn't need it

That may be true, however, he spent a lot of time in center in the AFL a year ago when he won the MVP award.

Agree w/everyone who mentioned Lewis.  For someone who made such an impact in CF at the highest level besides AAA I was surprised he wasn't mentioned.  I also agree that Lewis should succeed or fail at SS first.  Watching him play CF though, was a thing of beauty.  His jumps on the ball and his speed were extremely impressive, but more importantly, purely natural.

Buxton would be great if we could keep him on the field but he's too injury prone. Cave has improved a bit but is not your every day answer. Bradley would be a good backup if we would sign him. At least he prevents runs. I don't see any of the minor leaguers as being an answer but would be curious to see how Urbina develops.

Buxton is gone in two years to roam the d.l. for somebody else. Wade Cave, and Kepler aren't the answer. If they would have been smart they would have taught Rosario to play cf. Celestino is never gonna be the next Puckett or Hunter or even Buxton. This is a new era. The Cleveland/Texas Stranger player development philosophy ....the one where we waste 13 roster spots on mediocre relievers and can't score any runs.

Thad Levine is secretly still an advisor for Texas....just look at the contract they gave to Kyle Gibson and Lance Lynn ....lmmfao

That may be true, however, he spent a lot of time in center in the AFL a year ago when he won the MVP award.