Leaderboard
-
Doctor Gast
Verified MemberPoints3,665Posts -
TwinsDr2021
Verified MemberPoints1,334Posts -
Nick Nelson
AdministratorPoints7,006Posts -
Popular Content
Showing content with the highest reputation on 11/09/2022 in all areas
-
What Went Wrong with the 2022 Twins Pitching Experiment?
What Went Wrong with the 2022 Twins Pitching Experiment?
Dave Overlund and 6 others reacted to Nick Nelson for an article
7 pointsHaving lost their top two starters to a deadline sell-off trade and Tommy John surgery, the Twins headed into last offseason with a barren rotation outlook. It was unclear exactly how Derek Falvey and Thad Levine would realistically be able to offset these big losses. Yes, they had money to spend. But the next premier frontline starting pitcher to choose Minnesota in free agency would be the first. Some creativity was gonna be needed to field a contending staff, and Levine hinted as much early on. The general manager's quotes led me to write a column around this time last year: Are the Twins About to Build a Radically Unconventional Pitching Staff? “I think with the challenge comes opportunity,” Levine had said. “We’re going to be as creative as we can be in terms of not being necessarily hemmed into the notion of it has to look exactly the way it has always looked. We may end up looking at this from the lens of how many multi-inning guys can we add to a staff and how far does that take us?” The Twins followed through on their foreshadowing ... to an extent. With their only stable veteran workhorses – José Berríos, Kenta Maeda, and Michael Pineda – out of the picture for 2022, the team didn't acquire proven inning-eaters to replace them. Instead, their pickups were Sonny Gray, Dylan Bundy, Chris Archer and Chris Paddack, none of whom had thrown even 140 innings the prior season. Meanwhile, the only rotation incumbents were Joe Ryan and Bailey Ober, who had thrown a collective 120 innings in the big leagues. The front office assembled a staff full of pretty good pitchers who were – almost uniformly – unequipped to provide any length, and so we saw Levine's vision more or less come to life: vast numbers of different arms rotating in and out to cobble together nine-inning games. The Twins used a franchise-record 38 different pitchers. Their starters averaged 4.8 innings, second-fewest in the American League. They used six or more different pitchers in a game 31 times. Radically unconventional indeed. And, had this approach been successful, you wouldn't hear me complaining. But clearly it was not. The Twins ranked 19th in ERA, 19th in FIP, 20th in fWAR. Even for a club that was built around the strength of its lineup, that's not nearly good enough. The plan, at its core, was not a terrible one: maximize the stuff of your pitchers in shorter stints, shield them from multiple trips through the order, and possibly reduce injuries from overuse. Alas, none of those supposed benefits came to fruition. So what went wrong, and what can we learn? Was the entire philosophy bunk, or was the execution botched? I would argue, probably more of the latter. There might be some merit to the concept, provided the Twins heed these lessons learned: The starters weren't good enough, or healthy enough, even in shortened starts. I don't dislike the idea of signing a cheap pitcher – who doesn't have the repertoire or durability to go deep – for the back of your rotation and unleashing him in highly effective 4-5 inning bursts. The problem is that this group lacked the capacity to be highly effective even with this usage. Bundy held his own the first time through the lineup, then got mashed the second time through (.291/.327/.534), often making the third time a moot point. Archer posted an 85 ERA+ despite almost never pitching past the fourth. He placed a heavy weight on the bullpen every fifth day, and rarely left them in a good spot. Meanwhile, the cautious management wasn't enough to prevent Ober, who only once threw even 90 pitches in a start, from being derailed by a season-ruining groin injury. It wasn't enough to prevent Gray, who grumbled about Rocco Baldelli's early hooks, from multiple significant hamstring injuries. If the Twins want an approach like this to pay dividends, they need to find pitchers who are actually capable of excelling in shorter starts (a la Andrew Heaney) and they need to better help their players physically adapt to the altered routines. You've got to have at least one starter who can be the workhorse. Even with all of the above being addressed, I still think you've got to have at least one starting pitcher in your rotation who you can count on to give you some length. This strategy built around five-and-flies, piggybacking and the like becomes a lot more palatable when there is a fixture like Berríos routinely firing 6-7 innings each time through the rotation. That likely contributed to the decision to acquire Tyler Mahle at the deadline. He threw 180 innings in 2021 (would've led the Twins by 60), and had completed six or more frames in eight of nine starts for the Reds leading up the trade. Of course, Mahle proved to be the opposite of a remedy for Minnesota, and now only adds to the uncertainty of a 2023 rotation in desperate need of stable and dependable durability. Their bullpen wasn't built adequately to handle the burden. This is what really gets me. Levine talked about "looking at this from the lens of how many multi-inning guys can we add to a staff," and then their only bullpen addition of the offseason was Joe Smith, who could barely be counted on for one inning. The Twins rarely carried anything resembling a long man on the staff, and would typically just march out endless one-inning relievers after short starts. This led to them frequently burning through all of their high-leverage arms on one night and burning out the back end of their bullpen for the next. To make a system like this work, you've got to have an array of arms capable of getting more than three outs on a regular basis. The routine of four-inning starts followed by 5-6 relievers is not a workable formula as we saw. Losing your pitching coach mid-season doesn't help. This one can't so much be blamed on the front office and their planning. It's difficult to anticipate such a disruptive event in the heart of your season, and Wes Johnson's abrupt departure made matters tougher as the Twins tried to hold together their experimental pitching staff through the second half. Pete Maki undoubtedly played a significant role in architecting this year's plan, and now, as the apparent choice going forward at pitching coach, he'll be able to more directly pull the strings and execute to his preferences. So, to summarize... The model of building a pitching staff with reduced emphasis on traditional 6-7 inning starters isn't bad in theory. Indeed, there's plenty of evidence that it is the inexorable direction of baseball at large. But if the Twins want to lean into this movement as they did in 2022, they need to get better at. That means: Filling the rotation with starters who can at least stay healthy and excel in 4-5 inning starts. Finding at least one workhorse type starter who can reliably give you 6+ innings each turn. Equipping the bullpen with enough firepower and multi-inning relievers to shoulder the load. Having one central mastermind oversee the operation (and if it's not working, find someone new). As you're looking through the options available in our bullpen chapter of the Offseason Handbook, these are lessons worth keeping in mind.7 points -
What Went Wrong with the 2022 Twins Pitching Experiment?
What Went Wrong with the 2022 Twins Pitching Experiment?
weitz41 and 6 others reacted to mikelink45 for a post in a topic
7 pointsYou hit on it. 162 games with a minimum of 3 relief pitchers each - 486 innings of work. No BP can handle that load. And unfortunately that is the minimum. After writing that I went and looked at the actual innings pitched by relievers - 635 and that is only from those on the 40 man - it does not include Winder, Duffey, and others we cut or have injured. Ryan had the most innings as a starter 147 - if every starter on a five man rotation matched him it would total 735 innings, but that is not the case. Bundy was second in innings with 140, Sonny Gray had 112. Bundy is gone, Ryan and Gray anchor the rotation - how many innings will Mahle be worth? Can Ober hold up? Is Maeda the pitcher we had for the very short 2020 season and can he hold up on his return? Does Paddock come back late with an innings limit? Do we turn lose any of our rookies?7 points -
Will the Front Office Choose to Build a Better Bullpen?
Will the Front Office Choose to Build a Better Bullpen?
KirbyDome89 and 6 others reacted to TwinsDr2021 for a post in a topic
7 points2 outs per game might not seem like a big deal but over the course of the season it is 108 innings. Kind of seems like a lot of innings to fill that the average MLB didn't have to, no? Dig a little deeper into the other numbers and you see they were 29th out of 30th in Quality starts, the average was 59 and they had 35 and remember they weren't using a 1 inning starter, the 3 teams below the Twins Rays, Nationals and Pirates all used a relief pitcher as a starter over 10 times, They were #1 in games where the starter went less 80 pitches with 85 games the average 45 games. They were 30th in games where the starter went between 80-99 with 67 games, the average 92 games. They were 27th in games where the starter went between 100-119 with 10 the average 25 games. I will say it again, I am not complaining about what they did last year (at least not here) and I understand some of the circumstances that may have lead to this. But to lead the majors in starts with starters having less than 99 pitches and be 29th in quality starts without ever user a "Starter" can't be summed up as "well the Twins are doing what everybody else is doing". Also my fuzzy math looks like if you remove the "starter" starts from the Rays, Pirates and Nationals the Twins drop to dead last in IP/GS.7 points -
Contemplating a Bullpen Reunion with One Former Twin
tl;dnr summary: Following his TJS in 2017, Trevor was a workhorse reliever 2019-2021, with nary a trip to the Injured List according to his page on mlb.com. 2022 was a different story, with a 60-day IL stint May-July and then another 15-day stay in September. So I'd be leery. In a vacuum he could be a good gamble, but this Twins pitching staff needs to skew healthier for 2023, not riskier. I hope they have better analytics for pitcher health than the "next year is best predicted by the most recent season" rule of thumb that I use. "When healthy" should be banished from the FO's jargon.6 points
-
Twins AFL Report (Week 5): Julien and Martin Continue Hitting
Twins AFL Report (Week 5): Julien and Martin Continue Hitting
Dman and 5 others reacted to Steve Lein for a post in a topic
6 pointsAgree. Julien isn't a batting champion (and strikes out a lot more), but he makes up for that in OBP by having a significantly greater ability to draw a walk. Arraez has been about a .060 Isolated-Discipline guy, which is decent, but not great. Julien is over .150 in the minors, which is 99th percentile and you hope it translates into something like .100 in the majors and would still be very very good. I can envision Julien being a .270/.370/.450 guy. That's pretty solid.6 points -
What Went Wrong with the 2022 Twins Pitching Experiment?
I am surprised by the lack of interest, around all MLB, in not training relievers for 2 inning stints. It's well understood that every RP used in a game is raising the risk factor as all it takes is one of those guys to "not have it" that day for the perfect plan to go south. 2 inning stints reduces this risk factor significantly. My ideal modern bullpen of 8 RP would be 4 RPs that train to pitch 2 innings per appearance and 4 RPs trained to pitch 1 inning per appearance. I admit that may not work in practice, but it sounds perfect to me in theory.5 points
-
What Went Wrong with the 2022 Twins Pitching Experiment?
What Went Wrong with the 2022 Twins Pitching Experiment?
PDX Twin and 4 others reacted to Doctor Gast for a post in a topic
5 pointsI remember very well that article you wrote last year. I also remember well the mention of some form of piggy-backing which I didn't see, which could have been a follow up article. It all made sense because of the reasons mentioned and even the pitchers the Twins were somewhat counted on never materialized (Thorpe & Dobnak as examples) not to mention Alcala. Piggy-backing is making use of the long relief corps. The problem wasn't that the experiment failed, the problem was the experiment (piggy-backing) was never incorporated. They continued the same old formula as if we had a very strong rotation & full supply of dominate short RPs. We had an abundant supply of profiled spot start/ long RP (hot out of ST Smeltzer, Ober, Winder, Sands and fragile arm Paddack) to begin the season. But the fact was that we had a weak rotation & poor short relief corp. If the experiment (type of piggy-backing) was indeed incorporated and if Duffy & Pagan were not profiled as closer and their mistake were quickly reversed. That'd vastly change our outcome, but it wasn't. Injuries, depleting our pitching resourses & ineffecency were the result of over relying on a poor short relief & over stretching the rotation. Entering '23, many of the same conditions for this hybrid pitching still exists. We don't have the money to have a stable full of work horses & an abundance of dominate RPs. You can't profile Maeda as a SP being almost 2 yrs of recouperating from TJ surgery (he was never been a work horse), hopefully Gray will be in condition after ST, Ryan will take that next step and Mahle to resemble more the SP we expected. Ober after an injured '23 shouldn't be profiled more than a spot starter/ long relief. Although an work horse is much needed, he won't solve all our problems. We still need the long relief/ spot SP role, especially when we have so many good candidates (Maeda, Ober, Varland, Winder, etc) most of them should be in MLB gaining experience and not wasting their time in AAA, SWR with a little bit more seasoning in AAA should be ready. The problem with this experiment was that it wasn't incorporated, let's not make the same mistake again.5 points -
Will the Front Office Choose to Build a Better Bullpen?
Will the Front Office Choose to Build a Better Bullpen?
roger and 4 others reacted to saviking for a post in a topic
5 pointsAll I ask is either go after top line relievers or turn to guys like Ober or Winder as sixth, seventh inning set up guys, but please, please don't don't circle what's left over of the reliever market at the end of the signing period like Buzzards as the Twins usually do. We do NOT need to sign relievers with average talent.5 points -
Twins AFL Report (Week 5): Julien and Martin Continue Hitting
Twins AFL Report (Week 5): Julien and Martin Continue Hitting
Dman and 4 others reacted to Major League Ready for a post in a topic
5 pointsThat would be great. Let's add Varland and SWR pitching effectively by that time as well. BTW ... Julien was OB 4 out of 5 ABs last night. He could be Arraez with more power and better base running. Obviously, the AFL is not MLB but we can dream, can't we?5 points -
What Went Wrong with the 2022 Twins Pitching Experiment?
What Went Wrong with the 2022 Twins Pitching Experiment?
Minny505 and 3 others reacted to Nick Nelson for a post in a topic
4 pointsRight. I think the way this model is supposed to look is how Tampa Bay did it. Here are the inning totals for their starters: McClanahan: 166 IP Kluber: 164 IP Rasmussen: 146 IP Springs: 135 IP No one was a "workhorse" and they were similarly averse to 3rd trips through the order but these guys at least lived up to the modified billing for a full starter workload.4 points -
What Went Wrong with the 2022 Twins Pitching Experiment?
What Went Wrong with the 2022 Twins Pitching Experiment?
RJA and 3 others reacted to Nick Nelson for a post in a topic
4 pointsRight. There were so many nights where the Twins were rattling through 1-IP relievers until they got to the guy having an "off day" and things blew up. You're asking for trouble with this approach unless you have an Astros or Rays bullpen.4 points -
Twins AFL Report (Week 5): Julien and Martin Continue Hitting
Twins AFL Report (Week 5): Julien and Martin Continue Hitting
Doctor Gast and 3 others reacted to roger for a post in a topic
4 pointsThere is one other aspect of both of these kids, Julien and Martin, games that isn't talked about enough. And that is speed. I want the Twins to begin running again. Put pressure on the other team's D and steal a lot of bases, especially with the bigger bags. Adding Lewis to this duo and I say bring the pirana's back. Loved watching those teams back whenever.4 points -
Twins AFL Report (Week 5): Julien and Martin Continue Hitting
Twins AFL Report (Week 5): Julien and Martin Continue Hitting
gil4 and 3 others reacted to stringer bell for a post in a topic
4 pointsNot sure I agree. If their OBP is "pretty similar" as you state, Julien certainly profiles as a superior power threat and thus would project to have a much higher OPS. Personally, I'm not sure if Julien can sustain such high walk rates and maintain his elite OBP, but if he does, he's going to be a good offensive MLB player.4 points -
Will the Front Office Choose to Build a Better Bullpen?
Will the Front Office Choose to Build a Better Bullpen?
roger and 3 others reacted to farmerguychris for a post in a topic
4 pointsIt is ridiculous of the F.O. to expect to not have starters see a batter a third time in a game, but then leave the BP completely unprepared for that kind of load. Probably the biggest glaring mistake they've made IMO. If you want the starters to go 4-5 innings fine, but you must then stock you BP with arms who can make up for the short starts period.4 points -
Twins AFL Report (Week 5): Julien and Martin Continue Hitting
It will be really nice having these guys over in Saint Paul next year as depth incase starters go down ..4 points
-
Will the Front Office Choose to Build a Better Bullpen?
Will the Front Office Choose to Build a Better Bullpen?
roger and 3 others reacted to TwinsDr2021 for a post in a topic
4 points? you can't have 4 to 5 guys going 1 inning night. And it seems you are dead on how to stop that either your bullpen guys need to pitch longer or your starters needs to pitch longer, doesn't seem that hard, and yet the Twins FO hasn't figured it out for two years.4 points -
What Went Wrong with the 2022 Twins Pitching Experiment?
What Went Wrong with the 2022 Twins Pitching Experiment?
Richie the Rally Goat and 3 others reacted to tarheeltwinsfan for a post in a topic
4 pointsNick - Thank you for one of the best TD articles I have read. Great analysis. Reads like the summation of an investigation of an expert economist, hired by a company to analyze a labor problem in an industry, including recommendations for improvements. Send this to Derek Falvey and Thad Levine, for them to use as a starting point going into this off season and on into the 2023 season.4 points -
Twins AFL Report (Week 5): Julien and Martin Continue Hitting
Twins AFL Report (Week 5): Julien and Martin Continue Hitting
Barnacles and 3 others reacted to terrydactyls for a post in a topic
4 pointsBring both to Target Field - Martin in LF and Julien at 2B. Make the best deal for Polanco and Keplar as possible. Bring in two RPs, a catcher, one of the Big Four SS, and see what money you have left over for souvenirs at the winter meetings.4 points -
Will the Front Office Choose to Build a Better Bullpen?
Will the Front Office Choose to Build a Better Bullpen?
mikelink45 and 3 others reacted to se7799 for a post in a topic
4 points4.7 is not good. I'm hoping our goal is not to be average in this or any department like this. It is far enough blow average to be at the bottom.4 points -
Will the Front Office Choose to Build a Better Bullpen?
Will the Front Office Choose to Build a Better Bullpen?
FlyingFinn and 3 others reacted to Doctor Gast for a post in a topic
4 points'21 & '22 our BP stunk from the get go. Going to closers like Colume', Duffy & Pagan & keep going to them. time after, after time, after time when everyone knew that they that they were going to bomb (how disheartening) with an exception of maybe only a couple of RP you could really count on. But prior we had some pretty good BP. Even then they would count on a few best RPs & then BP would blow up (except maybe the shorten '20). I really like our BP this season but if we forgo long relief (and keep Varland, Winder and etc. in AAA) again we need to a few more very good short RPs and a couple of pretty good SP to shore up the management's habit, if we want a competitive year.4 points -
Will the Front Office Choose to Build a Better Bullpen?
Will the Front Office Choose to Build a Better Bullpen?
FlyingFinn and 3 others reacted to stringer bell for a post in a topic
4 pointsThere is a lot more talent available for ‘23 than there was for ‘22. I think that one more proven arm needs to be added and it would be good if he was a lefty (Cleveland continues to show more vulnerability to lefties than righties). In addition, the Twins would be well-served to have a guy or two who can go multiple innings.4 points -
SS- Maybe a trade?
SS- Maybe a trade?
DocBauer and 2 others reacted to Richie the Rally Goat for a post in a topic
3 pointsCorrea money is burning a hole in my pocket3 points -
SS- Maybe a trade?
SS- Maybe a trade?
EGFTShaw and 2 others reacted to ashbury for a post in a topic
3 pointsI forgot that having Kepler around is what's keeping us from signing Judge. :)3 points -
SS- Maybe a trade?
SS- Maybe a trade?
weitz41 and 2 others reacted to Richie the Rally Goat for a post in a topic
3 pointsTrading Kepler away for a SS would open up playing time for a good hitter in right field like potentially Wallner or sign a more sure Righty bat like Mitch Haniger or Aaron Judge :)3 points -
Contemplating a Bullpen Reunion with One Former Twin
Twins have to close the front door to the house of reclamation projects.3 points
-
Jhoan Duran - Starter or Reliever?
Jhoan Duran - Starter or Reliever?
Richie the Rally Goat and 2 others reacted to Vanimal46 for a post in a topic
3 pointsHis entire 1 year minor league career. Spencer Strider minor league ERA - 3.64 in 94 innings. Described as a very effective starter Jhoan Duran ERA 2018-2019 - 3.75 in 100 and 115 innings. Described in this thread as a mediocre starter (not by you). I don’t even think Duran’s minor league stats are relevant anymore because he’s clearly a better pitcher now. I’m simply pointing out the irony. Duran could have the same path as Strider, Suarez, and countless St Louis Cardinals pitchers who started their career in the pen and transitioned to a starter.3 points -
Is a Splurge on Relief Worthwhile for Minnesota?
Is a Splurge on Relief Worthwhile for Minnesota?
Minny505 and 2 others reacted to farmerguychris for a post in a topic
3 pointsIs it worthwhile? Only if you want to win ballgames. Impossible to have starters go only 4-5 innings (which i'm fine with) but you can't do this without a great BP. Must invest here if you want to win - its that simple. Doesn't mean need to sign big time FA arms, but convert more starters who can have the potential success of Duran.3 points -
2022 Vikings Regular Season Thread
2022 Vikings Regular Season Thread
cHawk and 2 others reacted to nicksaviking for a post in a topic
3 pointsYeah, the worst thing this team can do is revel in the loss of Allen. Keenum is one of the few capable backup QBs in the league. Fortunately, there are still numerous players on the Vikings that should still remember that. Finding out early in the week should be a huge boost though as they'll be able to game plan around a pocket passer instead of having to practice with the idea that Allen will make them pay with his legs.3 points -
What Went Wrong with the 2022 Twins Pitching Experiment?
What Went Wrong with the 2022 Twins Pitching Experiment?
Oldtimer and 2 others reacted to Karbo for a post in a topic
3 pointsA couple of decent to good long guys are needed. Better coaching would help a lot also. Starters that can average at least 5 innings per start.3 points -
Will the Front Office Choose to Build a Better Bullpen?
Will the Front Office Choose to Build a Better Bullpen?
SwainZag and 2 others reacted to EGFTShaw for a post in a topic
3 pointsI'm with Doc here, " I think not spending huge on your pen is a smart idea". I think we have a good core for the BP. The Mets kept the best one off the market, but they will end up paying for the length of that contract in the end. I kind of hope not, because I love his entrance. :) That said, I am not sure there is anyone out there I would spend money on right now. You are not going to get an AWESOME RP for $3-5M. AND, I can't see spending more than that unless it was a two-year deal for one of the best. I think, to quote The Who, "The Kids Are Alright".3 points -
Will the Front Office Choose to Build a Better Bullpen?
Will the Front Office Choose to Build a Better Bullpen?
LA VIkes Fan and 2 others reacted to DocBauer for a post in a topic
3 pointsIn theory, I think not spending huge on your pen is a smart idea. But that doesn't mean not spending at all. And I do think the FO has gotten way to cute in their approach/belief in a lot of their additions. They've probably done far better in trades than in FA arms which baffles me. RP may be volatile, but spending smartly up front is better than trading prospects mid year because you didn't do your job before the season. I agree that there is a potentially really good pen in the making currently. We all know the names: Duran, Lopez, Jax, Thielbar, Alcala and Moran. And in Winder, Sands, Henriquez, etc, there are a lot of middle relief options to create the very necessary bridge between the starters and the back end of the pen. Something they grossly ignored for a good portion of last year. I'm very encouraged by Moran, (will they keep Sisk on the 40 man for LH depth?), and the return/potential of Alcala. But I don't know that I want to count on them. I want more depth, more options. I'm more than OK with Fulmer back, or someone else at least as good. I'm also very interested in Hand for another proven LH. I don't know that I'm crazy about Rogers, but if he's healthy, a return "home" might do wonders for him. And the Twins know how best to use him. They have $50M to spend, or more depending on Urshela and Kepler decisions. There are no glaring holes anywhere other than an answer at SS. But they need a RH bat somewhere, another catcher, said SS, and MAYBE a SP if the right one can be found. Can they afford a combined $10-12M for TWO pen arms? If they can fit it in to payroll, that's what I'd like to see. Fulmer or equivalent/better, and a solid LH you feel you can count on for a combined $10-12M. ONE is almost a necessity. TWO would be a luxury that I don't know if is affordable, but would be outstanding depth!3 points -
Will the Front Office Choose to Build a Better Bullpen?
Will the Front Office Choose to Build a Better Bullpen?
Unwinder and 2 others reacted to Cris E for a post in a topic
3 pointshttps://www.baseball-reference.com/leagues/majors/2022-starter-pitching.shtml The MLB-wide IP/GS was 5.2 innings. The Astros led everyone at 5.9 and the Twins were below average at 4.7, but not as far below as some seem to imply. That half inning below average is two outs, so not a ton different from the rest of baseball. What was really different was that we had our 12th and 22nd and 33rd best pitchers out there more than just about every other team and anyone's 30th pitcher is almost always going to be terrible or unprepared. There were plenty of arms in the plans for 2022 that were largely missing: Maeda, Alcala, Stashak, and big acquisitions Mahle and Paddack only made a hand full of starts. They have the bones of a good bullpen: Duran, Lopez, Thielbar, Jax and Moran are good pitchers. Pick through some of the kids, only use Pagan before the seventh and maybe re-sign Fulmer and you could be a swingman or two away from adequacy without changing too much. Mostly things hinge on being able to limit your staff to the top 15-20 guys in the org rather than finding 38 arms to run out there.3 points -
Will the Front Office Choose to Build a Better Bullpen?
Will the Front Office Choose to Build a Better Bullpen?
CarpetGuy and 2 others reacted to roger for a post in a topic
3 pointsI think I am in agreement with much of what you are saying. But this bullpen could be close to being one of the best. To get there they need to go out and sign the best damn late inning guy on the market. With Correa gone, they have a lot of money, use some of it for that guy. Get quality over quantity. With hopefully a healthy Alcala coming back along with improvement from Moran, a bullpen closed out by Signee X, Lopez and Duran could be like the KC bullpen that took them to the Series not so long ago. As for Canterino and Enlow, let them stay as starters while coming back from surgery. One other point is they are going to have to address the elephant in the room. That is how are they going to manage their starters in 2023? Are they all going to be limited to TTTO? If so, they need to have at least two relievers who pitch multiple innings every couple days.3 points -
The One That Got Away from the Twins Bullpen
The One That Got Away from the Twins Bullpen
Cris E and 2 others reacted to Riverbrian for a post in a topic
3 pointsYou win trades by improving the players that you acquire since almost all trades are near equal value when agreed upon. Houston did a great job of taking Pressly and making him much more than he was with us. That is how you win trades. Houston does a great job of making players better so they win a lot of trades... and... and... games.3 points -
SS- Maybe a trade?
SS- Maybe a trade?
Richie the Rally Goat and one other reacted to Doctor Gast for a post in a topic
2 pointsAll you hear is our need at SS, and rightfully so because it should be our #1 priority. We talk about Plan A resigning FA Correa or another big name for big bucks and long term or Plan B sign low budget/ low talent short term FA. Or maybe Plan C pick up limbo Kiner Falefa which NYY could let go or keep which we can trade for a song. Plan A will be expensive, Plan B will be terrible, Plan C isn't bad but there could be a Plan D which could be the best. Plan D is making a signficant trade. On the surface there seems to be nothing out there but if you dig deeper you can come up with some nuggets. 1st name is Willy Adames (MIL) has 2 yrs on his contract. He has a solid glove but his calling card is his bat. 2nd name is Nico Hoerner (Cubs) has three years left on his contract. Because of need he was converted from 2B to SS and he surprised everyone with his glove & bat. Both clubs are fairly deep at SS & rumors have it that the Cubs are looking for a big name FA SS. Both these guys are safety nets, where if Lewis comes back 100% we can reshuffle or easily trade him but if Lewis stumbles we can extend the one we choose long term. If we come up with a trade that's interesting to either of them we could solve our SS problem. What do you think of them? Who would you choose? or Do you have another SS to trade for? Do you have any info to share? Please do.2 points -
Will the Front Office Choose to Build a Better Bullpen?
Will the Front Office Choose to Build a Better Bullpen?
mikelink45 and one other reacted to Jamie Cameron for an article
2 pointsI’d argue that bullpen construction is one of the areas in which Derek Falvey-led Twins front office has consistently failed in executing since taking over in Minnesota. In 2021, the pen was marred by repeated first-half meltdowns from Alexander Colomé. That unit ranked 22nd by fWAR, 21st by FIP, and 16th by K/9 after a second-half recovery. In 2022, Emilio Pagán single-handedly blew a handful of games to eventual AL Central champion Cleveland Guardians. The 2022 unit ranked 20th by fWAR, 14th by FIP, and 12th by K/9. At least a modicum of improvement. Overall, however, this front office has taken the ‘building the plane while flying it approach’ to bullpen construction. While 2022 went as badly as it could for a variety of reasons, most notably player health, here are three trends to look for that might indicate a different approach to bullpen construction in 2023. Shop for Relievers, Earlier than Later This front office has shied away from any spending on relief arms. Prior to 2022, Joe Smith was the lone bullpen addition signed to a major league contract (Pagan was acquired by trade). I’m not advocating for the Twins to put together an Edwin Díaz-type contract for a relief pitcher, but $6-9 million can buy you a lot of arm. This front office typically waits until late in free agency to extract contract value. I’d like to see them add to the bullpen, aggressively, targeting velocity and stuff. The Twins couple easily push toward a top-ten bullpen by raising the floor on what they ran out in 2022, and it shouldn’t cost that much. Stop valuing good contracts over good players. There’s No Such Thing as too Many Options The Twins have several exciting internal options for the bullpen. Matt Canterino, Ronny Henriquez, Blayne Enlow, even Josh Winder. All of these options have something in common, they were either hurt in 2022 or unproven in a bullpen role in 2022. I’d bet that at least one of these names becomes a Griffin Jax type in 2023. That is to say, a solid mid-to-high-end reliever who can work in some mid-to-high leverage situations. If the Twins learned anything in 2023, however, it should be not to count on anyone or anything going to plan. The Twins need to have a semi-established bullpen pecking order by the end of April, not by the All-Star Break. Buy-Low Arms for Depth Only The Twins should never have an arm like Joe Smith in their bullpen if they want to be taken seriously. The best bullpens in MLB are stacked with velocity, movement, and high-caliber arms. The Twins capacity to reach that ceiling is pretty exciting (imagine a back end of Canterino, Alcala, López, and Duran). With that in mind, and learning and building from the best models available (Yankees, Dodgers, Astros, etc.) the Twins should only be bringing in ‘buy-low’ type arms as competition in spring training, and depth throughout the season. If the Twins front office did nothing to the bullpen between now and opening day, the ceiling is high, and the potential is exciting. The observable difference in behavior ahead of 2023 is whether they choose to raise the floor, and account for the unexpected. What changes would you like to see from the front office in how approach building their bullpen ahead of 2023? Join the discussion and leave your thoughts below.2 points -
SS- Maybe a trade?
SS- Maybe a trade?
LA VIkes Fan and one other reacted to tony&rodney for a post in a topic
2 pointsIf the Twins cannot sign Correa, Bogearts, or Turner then they should consider Elvis Andrus. After that major dip the choices are slim and at that point I'm all for Austin Martin or Brooks Lee if the first two options fail. Hopefully the decision comes early to allow for shifts to whatever other plans the Twins have with their 2023 roster.2 points -
SS- Maybe a trade?
SS- Maybe a trade?
Richie the Rally Goat and one other reacted to weitz41 for a post in a topic
2 pointsI think his post is about other options. Missing out on Correa and signing maybe Iglesias is a better option? The Twins need to do something about the LH corner OF mess. Parting with one covering SS and dealing with the consequences is better than pretending it's not there. Plus 35 mil can solve the RF defense, BP and probably a starter as good as Gray.2 points -
What Went Wrong with the 2022 Twins Pitching Experiment?
What Went Wrong with the 2022 Twins Pitching Experiment?
TiberTwins and one other reacted to Original_JB for a post in a topic
2 pointsI don't think this is fair. You know exactly what your are getting with a Hyundai, a reliable, OK, 'everyday' car that simply starts to show it's age (in every way) in fewer years. Sonny Gray is a Hyundai. We will see, but Joe Ryan could be a Honda (I don't like the software programming of the Toyotas); Bundy and Archer are the 'salvage' titled Camaros and WRX's that have been owned by teenage drivers and look like it. Those are "Flyers".2 points -
Twins AFL Report (Week 5): Julien and Martin Continue Hitting
Twins AFL Report (Week 5): Julien and Martin Continue Hitting
chpettit19 and one other reacted to jmlease1 for a post in a topic
2 pointsLet's calm down a little. I'm a big fan of both players, but the AFL is roughly AA from a competition/talent level and neither Julien or Martin have ever played above AA at this point. That's a big jump. I'm perfectly fine with moving on from Kepler, since we have a barrel full of LH corner OF options, and it seems unlikely that Kepler will ever have a year like 2019 again without a juiced ball (although ending the shift will help a few of his bouncers to the right side bleed through next season). but Polanco is a very different case. he had a down year, but still had an OPS+ of 117 and should get back some of his power with better health. Tossing him in favor of the unproven tandem of Julien/Martin seems foolish, especially since Polanco is still on a very good contract. It will be especially interesting for Julien if baseball moves to an automated strike zone by the time he reaches MLB. Might help him stay good in terms of controlling the zone. If his power production from the AFL translates for him next season, he could be a monster at the plate. I'm really glad to see Martin having a strong AFL season. His lack of power in Wichita this season was concerning, and it's good to see him back to showing elite contact skills but with a little more pop behind them. Still a small sample size, but it suggests that maybe the approach he's working with right now can be successful for him, especially with his speed. I think he should start in AAA, but he's definitely someone that should push Celestino if he has to move off the infield long-term. I have trouble assessing the pitchers the Twins sent to the AFL; when you only have 10-15 innings to judge a player that stats aren't as helpful. It doesn't take much to blow up someone's ERA, WHIP, etc. Shreve seems to be making a case for himself, though? Maybe he's the next Laweryson.2 points -
What Went Wrong with the 2022 Twins Pitching Experiment?
What Went Wrong with the 2022 Twins Pitching Experiment?
PDX Twin and one other reacted to Otaknam for a post in a topic
2 pointsRocco should not be so tied to analytics. If a starter is pitching well let him continue until he is not. The Bundy and Archer retread pitcher types are the exceptions because of who they are. I’m not a fan of using a cookie cutter approach to starting pitching and ignoring intuition or gut feeling about a starter. A manager should be able to do both, like Dusty Baker. Let’s find out what some of the young starters can do. But the team has to have a very good bullpen to consistently pull the starters after five innings, a concept that Rocco seemed unaware of.2 points -
Twins AFL Report (Week 5): Julien and Martin Continue Hitting
Twins AFL Report (Week 5): Julien and Martin Continue Hitting
Steve Lein and one other reacted to Nashvilletwin for a post in a topic
2 pointsPrediction: Given good health, Julien, Martin, Lewis, Wallner, and maybe even Lee (for Lee it’s just timing as he has the biggest upside of this group) will be on and contributing to the big club by the the end of August. That means Kepler, Polanco, and Urshela will be gone. Celestino will be in AAA.2 points -
Will the Front Office Choose to Build a Better Bullpen?
Who knows? One thing's for sure...they won't improve it by bringing Duffey back. I'm sure that pic is him watching another ball leave the park!2 points
-
RonCoomersOPS’s 2023 Payroll Blueprint
RonCoomersOPS’s 2023 Payroll Blueprint
weitz41 and one other reacted to RonCoomersOPS for a post in a topic
2 pointsArraez's knees likely let him play more games as a first baseman, and I like Gordon as a super-utility guy. Also, depending on how well he hits, Julien is potentially just a placeholder at second base for that Lee fellow we drafted this summer.2 points -
The One That Got Away from the Twins Bullpen
The One That Got Away from the Twins Bullpen
tarheeltwinsfan and one other reacted to miller761 for a post in a topic
2 pointsPressly would have been gone after 2019 or traded at that deadline cause we wouldn't have paid. Don't think that was that bad of trade in fact it might turn out to be a good trade.2 points -
Will the Front Office Choose to Build a Better Bullpen?
Will the Front Office Choose to Build a Better Bullpen?
Minny505 and one other reacted to TwinsDr2021 for a post in a topic
2 pointsCanterino turns 25 in just over a month and has pitched 60 innings since 2019 his time as a starter is over, because it will take a couple of years to stretch him out anyway. He has the ability to be like one of the Astros relief pitchers and that is what he should be groomed for. Given him some innings in the minors and if he is good get him up to the Twins bullpen. I think Alcala should be start out as a low pressure guy until he proves he is back and better than ever. Both these two should/could jump Jax in the pecking order and pass the ball off to Duran and Lopez.2 points -
Will the Front Office Choose to Build a Better Bullpen?
Will the Front Office Choose to Build a Better Bullpen?
Blyleven2011 and one other reacted to TwinsDr2021 for a post in a topic
2 pointsThe Twins need every regular RP to be better than Jax, he gave up ER's in 17 of his 65 games, that is 1 out of 4 games. With as much as the Twins use the bullpen that has to be better. They need Lopez to the be the Baltimore version, they need Duran to be Duran, they need Moran to be as good or better than last year, they need Fulmer to be better than he was last year. Thielbar needs to be as good as he was last year. When you use the bullpen as much as they do they have to be good 9 out of 10 outings.2 points -
The major undiscussed topic regarding Twins pitching
The major undiscussed topic regarding Twins pitching
DocBauer and one other reacted to Bigfork Twins Guy for a post in a topic
2 pointsI initially thought that with the staff going somewhat downhill the second half of the season that the cause was Wes leaving the team. But, given that the Twins did not hire a new pitching coach and just made Pete Maki the permanent pitching coach, I guess that the team at least feels that he was not the cause of the decline. Since they are closer to the situation that I am I guess I will defer to their judgement here.2 points -
Rumor: Dodgers Interested in Carlos Correa
Rumor: Dodgers Interested in Carlos Correa
SkyBlueWaters and one other reacted to ashbury for a post in a topic
2 pointsOf course. Who wouldn't? And the present Twins FO has tried twice with Royce Lewis and now Brooks Lee. Meanwhile, until that pans out (if ever), the choice is Correa or not, Bogaerts or not, et cetera, and not some other player under team control.2 points -
C'mon there's a big hole for you to walk through.
C'mon there's a big hole for you to walk through.
RpR and one other reacted to PatPfund for a comment on a blog entry
2 pointsBrooks may have been a little rough, but Martin was absolutely brutal at short in the games I saw. Not sure you can clean that up in the off-season. Outfield might be more Martin's speed, and I'd love to see him (or pretty much ANYONE) push Gilberto down to AAA.2 points