Jump to content
Twins Daily
  • Create Account
  • entries
    891
  • comments
    3,675
  • views
    1,591,079

Jorge Polanco May Be What's Wrong With Minnesota


Ted Schwerzler

4,378 views

 Share

Twins Video

In 2016, very few things have gone right for any extended period of time for the Twins. Whether it be losing, injuries, or mismanagement, the group has not had a good showing coming off of a near playoff year (flukey as it may have been). There's one guy, and his situation, that may embody most of the shortcomings for Minnesota this season, Jorge Polanco.

 

Now, before you go leaping off the deep end, Jorge Polanco has been arguably one of the best players from the Twins in 2016. He's absolutely nowhere near their list of problems. However, the handling, utilization, and understanding of Jorge Polanco may almost perfectly describe a host of the Twins shortcomings this season.

 

Starting the year off down at Triple-A, Polanco was looking up at a roster that didn't seem to have much room for him. Brian Dozier was entrenched at second base, and at some point, the plan was for Miguel Sano to take over at third. Really, the only thing left up in the air was whether or not Minnesota had a real shortstop. For the better part of the first half, Eduardo Nunez played out of his gourd, earned an All Star trip, and held down the role. When he was flipped to San Franscisco though, it finally became time for Polanco to play.

 

By this time, Polanco had already been shuffled between Triple-A Rochester and the big leagues three different times. Each time he was called up, manager Paul Molitor seemingly didn't know how to use him. He didn't find time in the lineup, and he was passed over for lesser options. Molitor's public comments were of the vein that as a young player, there may not be much of a role for him one the big league club at the current juncture.

 

Here's the problem with that train of though, Jorge Polanco is 23 years old, and already out of options a season from now. He's one of Minnesota's best prospects, and there's very little track record of him being given any considerable run to showcase his talents at the highest level. On a team with a record among the worst in baseball, there's no excuse to continue to exclude him.

 

Finally, the training wheels come off. Since his most recent promotion he's played in 18 games for the Twins. Polanco has hits in 16 of those games, and has gone from hitting at the bottom of the order, to being among the top three. He owns a .347/.355/.440 slash line, and has been a catalyst for the Minnesota offense. If there was one thing known about Polanco, it's that his bat would play, and it has.

 

Then there's the other side of the equation, defense. Molitor shuffled Polanco around between third, second, and short to start. Despite knowing that two-thirds of those positions were supposedly spoken for, Polanco still being utilized as a utility type. It wasn't until his eighth game with the club, following his recall, that he finally played shortstop. Then, Molitor played him there three games in a row, and eight of the last 11 contests. The decision is only concerning because of the way in which we've gotten here.

 

Despite playing nearly 3,000 minor league innings at short in his career, Polanco played a whopping zero there this season for Triple-A Rochester. Although it appeared that was his best bet for consistent playing time, Minnesota operated using the idea that Polanco's arm wasn't strong enough for the role, as absolute truth and didn't manage their roster accordingly. Since, and with the understanding that it's a small sample size (just 72 innings), Polanco has been worth 3 defensive runs saved and posted a 1.8 UZR. Those marks make him easily the only productive defensive shortstop the Twins have had this season. Having had 40 chances now across his post-recall time at short, Polanco has committed just one error, and it was of the fielding variety.

 

At this point, Jorge Polanco is no more than long term answer at shortstop for the Twins than he may have been entering the season. What he has been however, is a tale of youth that has been underutilized, an organization that was ill-prepared, and a management style that doesn't suggest awareness of the positioning in the standings relative to the long term goals of the club. If Minnesota is actually going to rely upon their developed talent as they should be, knowing when to get the acclimated, comfortable, and productive is something that can't continue to be overlooked.

 

For now, Polanco may have given the Twins enough leash to save themselves, but this is a trend that can't continue to happen.

 

For more from Off The Baggy, click here. Follow @tlschwerz

 Share

12 Comments


Recommended Comments

When the new GM starts interviewing his underlings, I suspect this situation is going to require some explaining.  Starting with Molitor, of course, but including Quade and Steil.  Shoot, was this a case where someone like Tom Kelly harumphed and said "he's not a shortstop" and the case was closed?

 

Ever since he made his somewhat surprising debut (might have been a roster crunch) I've had high expectations.

 

Maybe after a half-season of Nunez at SS, the Twins have reevaluated how they look at the position.

Link to comment

To waste Polanco's options with little to no playing time, and to refuse him playing his natural SS position at AAA this season...especially considering its unsettled at the ML level...goes beyond misguided. It's just plain stupid.

 

We don't know yet if he can be a starting ML SS or not, or at least a decent fill in, but he's looked pretty good so far. A testament to his experience and natural ability. And all the more damping evidence to his mishandling.

 

Here's hoping he can at least be a temp solution until someone like Gordon is ready.

Link to comment

When a fairly large chunk of an organization's operational philosophy during a half decade of losing can be summed up with the sentence "92 losses is better than 98", it's even more imperative to go outside the franchise to find a new philosopher or two.

 

As Doc mentioned, there's not a whole lot to go on yet, but the Twins have finally run out of reasons, even bad reasons, to find out if Polanco can stick at short.

Link to comment

He seems to be able to flat out hit, he doesn't seem to need a specific pitch like some guys, and while he isn't a BB machine, he isn't Rosario either. His offens definitely plays. My memory of his MiLB is not just a lack of arm, but also a little inconsistent with the glove? That said, so far I take him over Nunez of EE. But given my druthers, on this club, at this time, I would trade Dozier and whatever, for a solid SP, move Polanco there, and install a glove first SS. I keep hearing Vielma can pick it, but I see he has like 15 errors this year. Maybe we don't have a SS who can really really field? Should that surprise me?

Link to comment

I don't always pay attention to the number of errors my milb infielders. Long bus rides, not as well groomed fields, not always as good of a supporting cast, etc. And thought I had heard he's been battling some injuries this season.

Link to comment

Yes, they wasted three years not giving him more of an opportunity to shine. You ahd players down, and don't bring him up to sit on the bench. You let the reserve guys ride the bench. And knowing you had Dozier at second, you played him at second at Rochester...especially odd since you have NO TROUBLE playing others out os position. That they didn't bring him up and start him in the outfield is the understatement of the year!

Link to comment

Are the Twins trying so hard to win in the minors that they forget that the minors is the testing/proving grounds for the majors? Totally giving up on Polanco at SS in the minors is borderline insanity, especially when 2B and 3B is already spoken for and the kid has proven he can hit MLB pitching. The Twins brass seem to punish those who have not wronged, but yet reward those who have not righted. I pray this mismanagement does not go on much longer.

Link to comment

I'm typically a pretty patient person, but I just cannot say enough bad things about the way Polanco has been handled. 

 

The handling of Polanco, Kepler and Meyer, along with losing Hicks (the catcher who is OPSing over .800 in AAA MiLB) was largely why I felt TR had to go and (other than the John Hicks event) part of why I think Molitor is clearly a poor coach. 

 

Does anybody in Twins management look out to the future even as far as next year? If so, there is little evidence.

 

Link to comment

I can join those concerned about lack of playing time at SS in AAA.

 

I can't join those that are concerned about the option use. I think a poorer use of options is bouncing back and forth from minors to majors without long stays at either spot. Optional assignments allow a player to develop in the minors though they are on the 40 man roster. The Twins have utilized that development time for Polanco and he has arrived displaying a good sense of the strike zone. Is it possible that his path to the majors with significant time in AA and AAA has helped him be ready to take on major league pitching?

 

The Twins did waste an option year with their handing of him in the DSL/GCL. It would have been better that he had the fourth year. They do appear to have done a good job utilizing his option years to give him the development time he needed with the bat. I am perplexed why he didn't get that development time at SS with his glove this year.

Link to comment

With TR gone the real question is - did the team learn from these errors?  Are we really going to go in a new and improved direction?  Will we change the coaching and managers - reevaluate how we operate and quit wasting young talent through capricious decisions?  I feel like Arcia will never be the player he could have been and that is divided equally between Twins and the player.

 

It is still my desire to see some latin American coaches at various levels and give our prospects a supportive journey to the bigs. 

Link to comment

 

With TR gone the real question is - did the team learn from these errors?  Are we really going to go in a new and improved direction?  Will we change the coaching and managers - reevaluate how we operate and quit wasting young talent through capricious decisions?  I feel like Arcia will never be the player he could have been and that is divided equally between Twins and the player.

 

It is still my desire to see some latin American coaches at various levels and give our prospects a supportive journey to the bigs. 

I think a big part of the "Polanco" problem, is through Molitor. Ryan doesn't deal with lineup construction and poor youth usage. That should fall squarely on Paul's shoulders, and has continued to be a problem.

Link to comment

The Twins have utilized that development time for Polanco and he has arrived displaying a good sense of the strike zone. Is it possible that his path to the majors with significant time in AA and AAA has helped him be ready to take on major league pitching?

 

Good points all -- but also a good counterpoint by Jorgenswest: isn't it possible that he is doing well now because he was NOT brought up too soon and thrust into a major league lineup he wasn't prepared for, like Buxton and so many others? This doesn't dismiss all the other concerns raised, but it's a fair point. Maybe Gomez, Hicks, Rosario, Arcia, et al should have worked on their plate discipline in the minors a little longer, too.

Link to comment
Guest
Add a comment...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...