Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

twinstalker

Verified Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by twinstalker

  1. I suspect if you look real hard when in the DR, you'll find someone age 19 who's name is Miguel Sano. If in doing so you you also come across some Jeans, you might want to check for letters and wired payments from Florida, Tennessee, and Wisconsin. But then the name thing is always funky within the hispanic culture. A friend of mine from CR introduced herself by one name, then starting using another. The maternal/paternal surnames are pretty inconsistent in the culture from our perspective.
  2. Understandable, because "in the hunt" wasn't meant to be typed. I must have been on poor autopilot. "In the hunt" should be "making offers" and my thought process was that the Reds were a team talking to him for another player (Span, tr: we want Cingrani, reds: you can't have him, though you could for JW, tr:not enough). From everything Ryan said, he didn't shop Willingham and gave no encouragement to teams putting out feelers. I am saying he might not have gotten enough of an offer for Willingham (which I believe), and that's probably because he didn't get any offers for him or maybe only one or two "feeler" type offers. You need to shop your best trade bait, hit it hard. You don't just wait for the phone to ring, and we all know that wrt Willingham, that's the best he did. So...he needed to trade JW, and he probably wasn't offered enough if he was offered anything. I think that's pretty consistent, if my first statement wasn't. And it represents prettying bad GMing.
  3. DeVries has no chance of staying on the 40.
  4. Up until this year his minor league numbers shouted severe mediocrity for his MLB potential. And unfortunately for us, the Twins would have likely been fine with that. However, they may have gotten lucky. As with Span and Plouffe, it looks like Parmelee could be better than his minor league numbers. You would think that whatever is in the Rochester water would be something they'd like all their real prospects to drink, so it's amazing they're so willing to skip that level (Parmelee, Dozier).
  5. The sad thing is that there will always be a solid segment of the population that wants to believe that natural variation/noise in their favor is actually truth. Mastroianni has batted well in the minor as a much older player, much like Dozier. However... Dozier has done it as a pretty good middle infielder. Mastroianni has played a grand total of seven minor league games at 2B after his first season (five years). DM's hitting at the high minors, after posting a .390 obp as a 24 yr old in AA in 2010 (Dozier-like), has actually be mediocre since, or worse if you adjust his .276/.358/.389 for playing in Las Vegas, the easiest park to hit in. Even this year his minor league numbers were .283/.341/.345. How people expect this guy to be even that good at the MLB level is beyond me. Because he hustles and had a good game? The Twins will try to hype anything and everything they can, so I imagine a lot of people get influenced by TV and such. He wasn't good enough to play 2B in the Toronto minor league system, he hasn't hit well enough to deserve anything Yet people are crossing their fingers and hoping for a miracle. When an older non-top prospect destroys AAA for a period of time, such as the recent examples of Span (2008), Plouffe (2011), and Parmelee (2012), then he's ready for a true shot at MLB. Or when an age-appropriate player proves he can hit AAA decently (hopefully Hicks next year), then he deserves a true shot.
  6. Yeah, the Twins middle infield situation is really crap. Carroll, if he plays like this year (which isn't a given), is ideally a utility guy but may have to start. I think Dozier is a nice bridge to something at shortstop, but the Twins might not have that something. It's really sad they didn't have a shot at Correa. Personally, I'm optimistic that Dozier will be an okay shortstop, and I'm hopeful that Levi Michael will be good. Dozier, I believe, will most certainly be MLB-worthy, but you can't as an organization automatically expect even a 25 yr old to jump to MLB after a half-season at AA. Why the Twins are willing to judge a prospect as ready after only seeing him hit straight fastballs through most of spring training is a wonder to me. Dozier should have been at AAA until he proved it wasn't challenging, which I believe he would have by now. The Twins crossed their fingers (once again) with him, and since he never was Manny Machado or Jurickson Profar, the expected outcome occurred. I think he'll be okay, but who knows how much development time was lost by putting him in over his head. Michael's first season has seeming been disappointing, but there are a few reasons to be optimistic. First, he is getting his first long-term exposure to wood bats at the hiA level in a pitcher's league. For top prospects, he's age appropriate without the benefit of a short-season or loA buildup. On June 1 Michael's on-base pct, the stat that will most define him, was .298. However, in June it was .357 and in July it was .366. This tells me he's caught up to the league, and while the Twins may want him to show he's too good for A+ by having him start there again in 2013, I think he'll soon enough be in AA. Whether Michael stays at short I'm not sure. He seems a natural MLB 2B, but if Rosario can stick at 2B, Michael will have to play short with the Twins. I can see the Twins with a decent middle infield three years from now (Rosario, Dozier, Michael), but more likely they'll be searching to fill one of those spots.
  7. While I agree with dealing Willingham, there are a few points to consider as an argument. First is that the time has passed. The Twins are the kings are missing opportunities, and they may have done so already. Teams will be "fixing" their problems in the offseason without giving up young talent. Second, perhaps Willingham is not worth all that much to teams in the hunt. I don't doubt that Terry Ryan might fail to recognize a good offer, but I also can see where the best he was offered was someone like Tony Cingrani, who, while a nice prospect, really isn't as sure a thing as they'd need to make sense. Two Tony Cingranis (say, Cingrani and Corcino) probably would ultimately provide a good pitcher, but from Cincy's viewpoint, that may have been far too much. Certainly it would be in the offseason. You're not going to get a Bundy or Machado or similar for Willingham, so you might be hoping for a team with excess MLB pitching that needs a hitter, and there just doesn't seem to be teams out there with excess anything (except Arizona with a lot of close pitcher but no need for an outfielder, much less a bad-fielding one). Third, without Willingham the Twins have gaping holes in two areas: power and right-handed sticks. That makes JW even more valuable to the Twins. Only Plouffe sort of fills both, not that one other player is enough, and he's no sure thing to continue to do so. The rest of the lineup, from Doumit to Mauer to Morneau to Parmelee to Arcia is decidedly left-handed (Doumit is pretty meh against lhp). They will have to go outside the organization to replace JW, which is going to cost one way or another. I agree that trading JW is preferable, but the Twins really needed to do it before the deadline. At this point they are much better served to wait until next year's deadline, but the Minnesota jinx almost guarantees he'll be hurt then or unproductive before then. In either case (hurt/unproductive) it behooves Minnesota to then hold onto him. Ryan blew it by not shopping this guy and taking advantage of his best year (at age 33!). It's this type of GMing that plagues the franchise. He's given a gift in the middle of a mess, and he just lets the mess swallow it up. Fans will come to see a winner, not names, and especially not names most hadn't heard of until months ago. Whether it's failing to seek a Willingham trade or allowing Liriano to pitch after his 15 strikeout game, it's clear Ryan doesn't have a grasp for taking advantage of situations or more generally how to build a winner. Maybe he can stumble into another team that has four of the best thirty players in baseball and bumble crap around them to compete for the Central division title annually, but I think that's unlikely and really shouldn't be the goal.
  8. Maybe they'll throw in Machado, too. In fact, maybe they'll just close the doors to the franchise after next year.
  9. Wow, thanks for the link. Sorry I didn't see this.
  10. I couldn't find an easy resource for this. 18 yr olds and younger at time of signing need to be added after five seasons (including the signing year season), 19 yrs old and older after four seasons. Aaron Hicks and probably all high schoolers drafted in 2008 have to be added to the 40. This includes BJ Hermsen, Kolten Wong (oh, wait), and George Springer (oh, wait). Ok, I'm being unfair here. Lots of players don't sign with teams. So Hicks and Hermsen... And college players in 2009: Kyle Gibson, Chris Herrmann, and Dakota Watts (?). Matt Bashore and Billy Bullock and Ben Tootle will not have to be added, unfortunately. Anybody else who we'd be afraid to lose? Side note while perusing the drafts (and probably worth a separate post): here are the non-first picks by the Twins who were drafted in the top five rounds. 2006: Joe Benson, Tyler Robertson, Whit Robbins, Garrett Olson, Devin Shepherd 2007: Danny Rams, Angel Morales, Reggie Williams, Nate Striz (not signed) 2008: Carlos Gutierrez, Shooter Hunt, Tyler Ladendorf, Bobby Lanigan, Danny Ortiz, Nick Romero 2009: Matt Bashore, Billy Bullock (given away), Ben Tootle, Derek McCallum, Tobias Streich 2010: Niko Goodrum, Pat Dean, Eddie Rosario (heh, they hit), Nate Roberts The jury is out on the 2011 picks and actually some of the 2006 picks (Benson, Robertson). But it's looking very likely that the Twins are going to get exactly one decent player (Rosario) out of this group 2006-2010, a five year period with 24 players the Twins chose in the first five round after their first picks (Parmelee, Revere, Hicks, Gibson, Wimmers). My first thought is that this is pretty bad drafting, though Rosario can himself bring it into the mediocre range by being the strong player I think he'll be. It would be interesting to see how other teams did here. I'm going to look at one or two teams who are not top salary teams and see what they did. Cincinatti 2006: Sean Watson, Chris Valaika, Justin Reed, Josh Ravin 2007: Todd Frazier (slugging over .500), Kyle Lotzkar, Zack Cozart (starting shortstop), Scott Carroll, Neftali Soto 2008: Zach Stewart (AAA good, MLB bad), Tyler Cline, Clayton Shunick 2009: Brad Boxberger, Billy Hamilton (top 50 prospect), Donny Joseph (dominant AA-AAA reliever), Mark Fleury, Daniel Tuttle 2010: Ryan Lamarre, Devin Lohman, Brodie Greene, Wes Mugarian Hmmm...it would be interesting to look at all the teams, but I suspect the Twins have really underachieved in this somewhat crucial area of the draft.
  11. Well, sure. But a September call-up, followed by what comes next year (over half the year at AAA) should allow for that, and if it doesn't, it won't make that huge of financial difference overall. The real kicker is making sure they end next year with under 1 year of major league time so push back the FA year and keep them under team control. i doubt there's going to be anything negative, accrual-wise, that occurs from a call-up this September.
  12. Does calling up Hicks (and putting him on the 40) start his options one year earlier than if he's added in November? I'm not worried about playing time for these guys, as they don't need to play every day, and nor do any of the current Twin outfielders need to play every day in September.
  13. They weren't willing to build a championship team when they had Mauer, Morneau, Santana, and Nathan as centerpieces, what makes you think they'd do the appropriate things when the really only have Mauer as someone who can be counted on to be well above average at his position?
  14. I think the organization should be forced to admit and correct every other obvious (at the time) mistake they've made before they get to even take Nishi out of the lineup. Examples: 1. Bunting 2. Playing the infield back, then bunting 3. Treating saves as if they're meaningful 4. Acting as if hitting the ball to the right side is doing your job (if your job is making precious outs, i guess) 5. Batting left handed hitters in a row (a.k.a making the Tyler Robertsons or Tony Sipps out there 3x more valuable) 6. Celebrating making the playoffs twice 7. Setting the bar at competing in the AL Central 8. Failing to platoon where obvious and necessary 9. Putting players in the "doghouse" and getting rid of them, if possible 10. Selling at the lowest possible point 11. Never selling at the highest possible point 12. Not understand noise (variance is the basis for the field of statistics) 13. Not appreciating fielding range and arms. 14. Not understanding how to deal with players under your control, contract-wise. 15. Thinking a player''s performance against you (versus all other info) is the truth 16. Depending on scouts, especially those scouting Japan, in spite of statistics and measureables. 17. Not appreciating obp 18. Micro-managing in the playoffs, relative to the regular season 19. Not understand the importance of K/9 20. Not understanding game theory in the least 21. Giving out long contracts to bad or not-worth-it players. 22. Not appreciating BA against I have pretty much hated most moves made by the Twins since 2002, starting with retaining Gardenhire all these years (1,2,3,4,5,6,8,9,13,17,18). You can fit most of the mistakes made by the team and organization into one of these, including: Restricting my criticism to guys who were on the Twins (at time of mistake) or brought in as free agents: not trading Jacque Jones after 2002 (8, 10, 11, 17) dumping Ortiz (17) Rick Reed (19,21) Carl Pavano (19,21) Shannon Stewart (13,19) Tony Batista (13, 16, 17) Craig Monroe (15) and you can fill in the rest... Delmon Young Matt Garza Jason Bartlett Kevin Slowey Matt Capps (definitely as a re-sign, but only one I mention also as trade return, because the bad thinking above caused you to happen) Wilson Ramos Francisco Liriano Matt Capps Tsuyoshi Nishioka Cory Koskie Johan Santana Hardy Blackburn Willingham (this is one for the future, since indication are the Twins will handle this wrong--his value will never be higher than it was in July) I'm sure I've missed a bunch. Meanwhile, here are the good things the Twins have done: Pierzynski (sold from a position of power, only case of ever selling high) Milton (to get similar back without salary) Guardado (back then we thought they understood "closers" were replaceable) Hawkins (good decision, too expensive and replaceable) Willingham (very good signing) Span (very good long-term contract) Doumit (good signing and re-signing) I'm sure I've missed some bad and good both, but most missing here are average (like the first Pavano signing after 2009 for one year). I also don't count "deals" where the Twins were basically just taking on someone else's salary, so Carlos Gomez (for Hardy) and the guy we "traded" for Rauch don't count. Except for the long-term signing of Stewart, post-2003 was the best period for the Twins decision-making, although it bugs me Terry Ryan didn't know who Liriano was when dealing (a scout recommended him after negotiations started), he got lucky there, though he already was going to get fair value in Nathan. If you would have asked my group of friends in 2003 who the Twins should go after from the Giants, they would have said Nathan and Liriano, among others...and Terry Ryan didn't know who Liriano was. That's scary. Further, the Guardado and Hawkins and Milton decisions were completely financially-based. They've made mistake after mistake after mistake. And they really only needed to make some good decisions in the middle of the last decade for us to have fond memories of another pennant. I've agonized each of these (bad) decisions when they occurred and somehow stayed a fan, to the point I still watch each game when they're out of it. I have season tix, though this might be it for me. So as far as I'm concerned, I think this organization should acknowledge each of these mistakes prior to being allowed to sit Nishioka. "We really don't understand statistics or game theory, especially as they pertain to baseball, the field I happen to work in. I want to apologize to the Twins Nation for our willingness to cap our efforts to improve our team (most of which would have more likely had the opposite effect, ironically) to a level of competitiveness beyond our own division, knowing we had four of the very best players in all of baseball. I, Terry Ryan, would like to personally apologize for Tony Batista in 2006, not understanding that I needed to deal Santana in 2007, and recommending maybe the most horrific of all replacements when I retired, though how in the world would I have understood that he was incompetent. He was my protege, after all. I didn't realize how overmatched I was. There are so many more specifics that I could apologize for or apologize for on behalf of Bill, but that would take far too much time. I would like to say to those people who think we had to pitch Liriano again after his 15 strikeout game that no, we didn't have to. We could have just rested him and let the bidders bid, given his next start was only a week before the deadline. Honestly it just didn't occur to us. Much like when we failed to offer a timely contract to Travis Lee. I hope you all remember the AJ trade, though." Okay, Terry, we accept your apology if you have actually decided to take your job seriously this time round, but your deadline decisions don't appear that you necessarily have. Still, I'm all for keeping Willingham if the best you were offered is a Daniel Corcini and nothing else of significance. Or Span if you weren't even offered that for him. Tell me that's the case, and I'll believe you. You may dump Nishioka now.
  15. Smart ones don't. Smart ones who know they're in a rebuilding phase don't. We're talking Twins. What's your point? (hopefully obviously not a jab at you) And besides, why not trade cheap and young for cheap and younger if your needs are better addressed? In this case, I don't think Parmelee's worth very much, so it's probably impossible to make a good trade.
  16. Trading Parmelee is interesting. I don't think it's a possibility for the Twins to consider keeping Morneau, but Mauer and Doumit could fill the 1B role with Willingham, if they're intent on keeping him. Arcia, Hicks, and Herrmann provide depth at the positions affected. But this would only make sense for a team that has excess pitching or middle infield and needs a 1B who's both second division and still better than their other options (because Parmelee is not a first-division 1B). That excludes almost everybody, because almost everybody has someone who projects as well as Parmelee. One team that does make some sense is Baltimore, who has Jonathan Schoop as a AA 2B. He's seemingly had a down year, but he basically skipped through loA and hiA in 2011 and is two levels ahead of Eddie Rosario at the same age. You keep Morneau for a year, trade Parmelee for Schoop, let Schoop start at AA next year and move to AAA midseason, and hope he finds his loA stroke of 2011. That's probably the best-case scenario with trading Parmelee. It probably makes more sense to get what you can for Morneau while he's still yours and let Parmelee, who's definitely better than he had projected to be (prior to September, 2011), take over at 1B. You might even get a guy like Schoop for Morneau and save $14 million while securing 1B and catcher both for 2014 and beyond.
  17. Wow, if you had stopped after the first sentence, I would have contacted you to compliment your sense of humor and ask if you have a blog.
  18. It would be interesting to know what the idea behind Nishioka is, or whether it's just a "we're out of it, and we feel bad for Nishi" type move. With Mastroeanni (sp) able to play 2nd, they don't really need an infielder.
  19. Unless rules have changed, which is possible, you don't want to waste an option on a guy like Hicks, who stands very little chance of opening for the Twins next year. I believe the "new" year starts sometime in the fall, and Hicks can be added then to start his options in 2013.
  20. I think your Hicks rating is right on. A first-division regular is pretty high praise. Hicks has the look of a 2nd-division regular with a chance to be a 1st if he learns to hit both lefties and righties. 55 is the perfect rating for him. Part of the problem is definition, because a 55 as defined incorporates risk. That is, a 55 medium is actually a 60 high.
  21. Why would you even mention Bundy? We have absolutely nothing that could ever offer to get him. Or Machado for that matter.
  22. A Liriano for Diamond trade sounds fair. Billy Bullock? Yes, I'm kidding, but it kind of makes you choke, doesn't it?
  23. I've been totally against trading Span, but I'm starting to wonder what they could get. I'd much prefer they trade Revere, even with the salary difference, but Revere might be a good stop gap to a finally-ready Hicks in 2/3 years. If the Twins could get a true prospect for Span (something better than they can get for Liriano), I would be on board, perhaps. Maybe something like Span and Carroll for Lombardozzi and Alex Meyer. Perhaps it wouldn't be horrible. Or Span for Sands and Webster from the Dodgers.
  24. You've got people who need a reason to feel like they're more important because they don't like themselves very much (similar to racism). And then you've got sheep.
  25. I think Dozier has done a pretty good job of not being overwhelmed at the plate. He should be overwhelmed. He's shot through the system and basically skipped AAA. Parmelee needed to go back. Dozier's here to stay, and I'll wager confidently that his stats improve this year.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.