Everything posted by twinstalker
-
Article: Is Tom Brunansky Mr. Fix-It for the Twins' Hitters?
I'm not sure Parker considers it his duty to increase your optimism. Why is the article great when mentioning something I'll assume you consider positive...and "killed" when he mentions the flipside? I think it would be interesting to find out what the deal is with the guys who've struggled, but that's another story, and to Parker's credit, he didn't ignore their existence.
-
Article: Twins Go to 'Pen Early and Often on Day 2
Sorry, I'm cranky. And the Twins have jaded me.
-
Article: Twins Go to 'Pen Early and Often on Day 2
Good job going for relief. It's a known fact that starters can never become relievers, so it's better to find those guys who even colleges don't want to start or who don't have more than one good pitch. And they have late-inning experience. Just like Capps.
-
The Bard Strategy
Baseball America ranked Lucas Giolito as the 9th best selection in the MLB draft due to uncertainties about his arm, and I believe he was taken 16th. There was a decent chance he would have gone first overall had he been healthy. The injury affected his ranking, and it affected his selection. BA's lower ranking was heavily dependent on the uncertainty. Baseball American ranked Luke Bard #93, stating that his current injury should be no issue. Still, he was likely hurt, though he could have been helped, by not playing any baseball since March. Given that the injury isn't future-pitching-serious, I would trust the #93 is a pretty good estimate for where BA would have ranked Bard the Younger had he pitched this year. With error, of course. The Minnesota Twins, apparently using optimal game theory strategies (heh), selected at pick #42 (with an associated $1.227M value) the #93 player on the board (#93 pick has a $0.516M value). Our Twins know one thing well, and that's that you can save money by drafting a player you've "overreached" for. I would imagine they expect to save a half a million dollars by giving Bard #70 money. So what do they do with that "saved" money? Chances are, even though Buxton will be far overpaid, the Twins will give him pick value. Or perhaps they anticipate issues with his signing and need extra money just in case. That actually makes the Bard pick somewhat sensical. We're not sure how it's going to go with Buxton, and so we need to have some money in reserve. Picking Bard should allow that. I honestly do not believe the Twins are smart enough to determine how to use that money optimally further down in the draft. And I fear they'll actually pay Bard the $1.2 mil. One thing we have to hope is that the Twins didn't have a scout at Bard's best game, because sample size has never been a concern with this organization. Nor have statistics when a scout has actually seen the player of interest. Top college starters who go in the first round or so generally have extremely high strikeout rates, with 11-14 k/9 common. Relievers, as also is common, tend to have better K rates than starters. Luke Bard has an 8.x k/9 ratio. As a reliever. In college. This translates to the same-old mediocre can't-miss-bats pitchers that are strewn across the Twins organization, seemingly half of whom are on the DL. But never fear...I'm pretty sure a scout with a name like Jesse Rodriguez with twenty years hitting the diamonds saw Bard strike out the side in the 9th against Hofstra or Iona in early March. Regardless of the reasons for the pick, it's somewhat clear the Twins saw an opportunity to save money by taking Bard at #42. Whether that's for their own pockets or to use elsewhere, we can only guess, but we can be virtually guaranteed it had nothing to do with either statistical analysis or game theoretical draft strategies. By the way, BA listed its top 100 draft prospects on Feb 12, well before Bard's injury. He wasn't in the top 100. His stats were mediocre. The only thing I can fathom is that his injury kept his rating steady while many rated ahead of him flopped...and he ended up ranked #93. Or maybe Jim Callis saw that Hofstra inning.
-
Where do they rank?
2, 14, and 112, respectively.
-
Article: Grading In A Void
I'm betting on the last three lines being more correct.
-
Article: Grading In A Void
Drafting is not just about picking the right guy, it's about picking the right guy in the right place. Bard may surprise, but the Twins almost certainly could have taken him later and had a much better chance at a quality player with their third pick. While that is a simple concept, I honestly don't believe Terry Ryan understands the absolute basics of game theory.
-
Ben Revere
His arm is so bad it doesn't matter which field he's in? Wow. I can't really appropriately respond to that logic. Yes I can. Let's say he had no throwing arm attached at all. He'd had to run every ball in. He'd be much more valuable in left than right in that extreme situation. The situation you're looking for is the one where he throws every ball into the stands. I haven't seen him do that yet on a ball in play.
-
Article: Twins Select Byron Buxton #2 Overall In MLB Draft
That's fine. If he crushes the GCL, they'll move him up. If he doesn't, he needs to stay there...as well as improve during the instructional league in the fall. Simple as that. I think he starts at Beloit next year. I don't see him staying in extended spring training after playing this summer.
-
Report: Twins to take Buxton
There is no doubt about Correa's hit tool. With Buxton there is all kinds of doubt. People compare him to BJ Upton. I'll be honest, I'd be disappointed if they ended up with someone equally as good as BJ Upton. Correa may take four years, but he'll be in the majors raking. Of all the players mentioned for the top seven, Correa has the best risk/upside combo.
-
MLB Draft Discussion: Day One
Sickels loves Correa and wants the Twins to take him (he's a Twins fan). I also think he's the one.
-
Report: Twins to take Buxton
Repost from another thread: The best player in the draft is Carlos Correa. John Sickels, a Twins fan, is almost beside himself with the possibility the Twins will pass on him. (Note: you'll find a mock draft where John takes Appel, but the draft where he got to choose who he wanted, he took Correa).
-
Article: DRAFT DAY: Twins Myth #3448: Outfield Depth
The best player in the draft is Carlos Correa. John Sickels, a Twins fan, is almost beside himself with the possibility the Twins will pass on him. (Note: you'll find a mock draft where John takes Appel, but the draft where he got to choose who he wanted, he took Correa).
-
Article: Marquis Out. Who Should Replace Him?
Willingham, I guess, sorry.
-
Article: Marquis Out. Who Should Replace Him?
Jerald Clark, Tony Batista, Jason Marquis, I want to add Craig Monroe because he's was added with Ryan's rec...almost every free agent Ryan has had anything to do with has been bottom of the heap. Or if not, then expected to do far more than capable of (Carroll, e.g)
-
Article: Marquis Out. Who Should Replace Him?
I did guess that he'd be the worst pitcher in baseball. And so did everyone else in my fantasy simulation leagues. He was the only starter with a for-sure job who was not chosen in my three leagues he was eligible (drafts occurring prior to his daughter's accident). And that's with Target Field being viewed as a pitcher's park. So at least forty-some of us all knew it. It doesn't surprise me that Terry Ryan didn't.
-
2012 MLB Mock Draft picks 1-10
If they're looking at upside with a pretty high floor, I think Correa might be the guy. As far as I'm concerned all pitchers have a pretty low floor, and if none are an 80 (and none are), I don't think you risk it with the #2 pick. Man, just keep Garza. I hope that lesson is learned.
-
Article: A Tale of Two Rookies: Harper and Dozier
One player will be a superstar, the other could be a solid player for ten years. Let's not throw glitter on both and pretend they're close to the same. One is holding his own in the major leagues at age 19. That's just plain stupid. It doesn't happen. Harper and Arod.
-
Article: Twins should go all in on Greinke
The Twins and I (because I matter) are scared to sign pitchers long-term. I think Baker/Blackburn is the last straw for that notion. Secondly, I think the Twins are a long way (and a long pitching way) from seriously competing. That being said, if the Twins were to spend on a pitcher who would be around if the Twins suddenly started making good personnel decisions and began winning, I think they could do a LOT worse than Greinke.
-
Parmalee needs to be sent back to Rochester
Wrote this on April 2 on one of these threads where the Parmelee excitement was a little out of control: Parmelee euphoria, I love it. Where solid rationale goes out the window. I won't go into the minor league numbers, which were extremely consistent and everyone knows (K rate high, hit rate pretty low). Parmelee was all along touted to be an eventual major leaguer. He's fulfilling that promise right now. But he's pretty much been projected to be a second division regular if everything goes his way. Justin Morneau was projected to be an all-star. To even put them in the same sentence, unless that sentence starts with "Due to Morneau's inability to play first base..." is blasphemy. Parmelee's upside, meaning if everything goes right (which they usually don't) is hitting like Cuddyer. Problem is, Cuddyer's numbers were not good, not first-division, for a 1st baseman. And make no mistake, it's highly unlikely Parmelee ever plays much OF.* In 2008 Denard Span completely "found it." In 2011 Trevor Plouffe had something click that hadn't shown itself before. And then in September Parmelee had a good month. Unfortunately, good Septembers happen to a lot of eventually mediocre players. He's followed that up with a very good spring training...again, not normally the basis for sound projections. So...here's my thought based on all the evidence: Most likely scenario is that Parmelee is a mediocre, below average 1B. However, we have no evidence that the Span-type light didn't come on. The Plouffe AAA sudden explosion. In other words, there's hope that something special clicked. I hope so, too. But realistically, Parmelee is going to be below average as soon as MLB pitchers discover how to pitch to him. Here's crossing our fingers. *Almost the only way Parmelee plays in the OF is if he's in the lineup with Morneau, Mauer, and Doumit, AND Mauer is at 1B. In other words, I don't think it's going to happen all that often. Six weeks isn't enough to crucify him, either, but the rational prior on Parmelee was that he is who his AA stats say he is. In other words, an eventual second-line MLBer who needs to be in AAA right now.
-
Cafardo: Denard Span remains on Nationals' radar.
No, a lot of people agree with you, it's just that some of us who agree with you don't come here that often...not when supposed Twins fans/intellects advocate dumping Span for, say, a reliever. It's bad enough we have a GM without much of a clue...who might actually do something like that.
- Wilson Ramos
-
Bill Smith's Biggest Blunder Was Something He Never Did
Officially the Twins traded Mulvey for Rauch, but in reality giving up Gomez and Mulvey were as much about Bill Smith trying to fool the MN public that he was getting something ultimately for Santana. Hardy and Rauch were contracts their teams wanted to get rid of, no one wanted to take them on...except for Bill Smith, who was trying to twist perception.
-
Best Free Agent (hitter) signing since Chilli Davis?
Two things: 1. Willingham will bat .265, 345, .475, okay, but not exactly a star. The way noise works is that someone has to perform much better at the beginning, and someone has to perform much worse. To take a look at the guy that's "high" and pretend you have something special is a pretty fallacious line of thinking. He will put up Cuddyer numbers. More HRs, less everything else. Oh, and not enough more HRs. 2. Still, you may be right, not because JW is so good, but because the Twins haven't really signed a FA hitter, except off the scrap heap. So to say he's the best FA hitter since Chili isn't saying, well, anything. If the Twins have signed more than one other "good" player still close to the prime of his career, let me know. I doubt JW's season will be better than Molitor's, but it could be.
-
Article: 2012 MLB Draft starting to come into focus
Consensus is that the talent is waaaaaaaayyyyy down at the top of the draft. Buxton is rated slightly worse than Starling, and the consensus said Starling was drafted too high. The top pick this year would maybe have gone 8-10 last year. While it may be true that this is a deep draft, that doesn't matter at all for the 2nd pick. As usual, the Minnesota team gets hosed with its top pick after a miserable previous season. What's really sad is that last year's pitchers were all the guys the Twins need this year: Bauer Cole Bundy Hultzen Bradley and then there's Anthony Rendon, a 3B/2B who could quickly take Valencia's spot (Sano's going to end up corner OF) The Twins would have taken ANY of those five pitchers long before any pitcher this year. Zimmer might have some possibilities, but I think Houston will take him if he's good enough to go #2, which is debatable. Appel is getting hit and not striking guys out at a good enough rate for a very high pick (3.32 ERA in 57 IP, 55 K as of last week). This looks bad. Right now the safest pick Zunino. Giolito would have been the first pick, I think, and I guess now I'm following Gausman, Wacha, and Stroman. All these guys are reaches right now, but maybe two will look better come June.