Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

twinstalker

Verified Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by twinstalker

  1. Thanks. There is no doubt the Rosario stands with the best of them bat-wise. Unfortunately, defense is a difference-maker, and we don't know where Rosario stands there, yet. The other guys have all shown they'll handle 2B in the majors (well, Gyorko might be a 3B, but his bat is that good). If Rosario can't play 2B, his value to the Twins declines immensely.
  2. How rare is Perkins? It's really a subject that could be debated quite a bit, with ample evidence for the positions of very rare and not so rare. The obvious problem teams have is that the guy they give the role to doesn't have much room for error, so finding someone with both the success and matching peripherals that predict future success lends to a real comfort level that at important times (like the playoffs) the end of your bullpen won't implode. That's worth a lot, and it's why Perkins' value is higher now than it would be in the offseason when team think they might be able to develop their own successful closer (like Rondon in Detroit).
  3. No, but the thought has crossed my mind that Plouffe works out with Braun in the offseasons.
  4. Well, yeah, but realistically the only way the Twins get Bradley is to give them Mauer and pay for his salary*...and I'm not exaggerating. He's a franchise pitcher. *I'm not saying this is necessarily a bad idea.
  5. I agree and don't think the Twins are likely to find a much better bridge and prospect than Dozier/Rosario. I feel like 2B is determined. Though I don't recommend just any bum, they can still use some corner sticks. Arcia, Hicks, Sano will be a part of this team going forward. They need five or six when you include DH in the picture.
  6. Along those lines, is there a shortstop (beside Machado or Bogaerts) who's waiting in line for some team? Frankly, the Twins don't have any reasonable options there, and if they could acquire someone like Erick Aybar was his first couple of years, that (with a decent but not top prospect) might be the sort of thing that makes sense.
  7. There's quite a difference between AAAA players who have figured out AAA but not MLB and 21 year olds who have advanced so far. His numbers are very good at AAA for a 21 yr old. That his numbers don't quite match the year-older Arcia's shouldn't be a slight at all. To wit, having another Arcia-quality bat would be a very big deal to the team. Also, I should add that Castellanos has hit 9 of his 12 HRs away from Toledo, a sign that the Mud Hens' park might mute his power. Just my two cents.
  8. Glen Perkins is obviously the Twins biggest trade chip, if they choose to make him available. Normally, a much sought-after reliever on a bad team is a no-brainer trade candidate, but Perkins is different. Consider: We have to hope 2014 shows substantial improvement for the Twins as both the pitching stabilizes and the prospects graduate. Then we pretty much have to hope this team can contend starting in 2015. If that hope isn't there, then what in the hell are we even doing here? I personally expected 2013 to be just like it is, but the time for crap is over after this season. Perkins, unlike most outstanding relievers, has a very team-friendly contract that extends out through 2016. To wit: 14:$3.75M, 15:$3.75M, 16:$4.5M club option with incentives that likely add a mil or two each year. Much better than $8-12M you normally pay for his level of performance. When the team is ready to contend in 2015, the absence of a lock-down stopper could create problems. So there is a lot to weigh here. What is the probability we'll need a closer like Perkins in 2014, 2015, and/or 2016, and what is the probability that the Twins could find a suitable replacement if they let him go? By 2015 Michael Tonkin or another unknown could well be a fine stopper. Then, of course, there is the question of what sort of return Perkins can bring. It's my personal opinion that if we're not talking high-end prospects, the discussion ends right here. As much as I like, say, Jorge Polanco and Adam Brett Walker, if another team were to offer them up to the Twins for Perkins, the probability of one of them being a positive impact eventually is too small and their upside not high enough to give up a commodity like Perkins. So I'm going to bring up six scenarios and attach names to them. Not necessarily names that are available but names that represent their positions and their prospect status. Please avoid the "the Giants/Rangers/Whatevers will never give him up" statements, because that's not really the point. The point is the value from the Twins point of view. If the team in question would never consider such a deal due to not being in contention or just the value from its point of view, that's fine, the names are just examples. Scenario 1: Trade Perkins for a top shortstop prospect at the A level. I'm talking almost sure things here, names like Addison Russell, Francisco Lindor, Carlos Correa. Do the Twins do it? These guys won't contribute until 2015 or 2016, but there is very little doubt about them, and your shortstop is set for perhaps a decade. The obvious problem is that the names I mention are basically the only names in this class, and their teams aren't going to make that deal. But do you make that deal if offered? I think you obviously have to. More realistic shortstop names are in Scenario 6, guys that I'd want but not alone for Perkins. Scenario 2: Trade Perkins for a top prospect hitter who's nearly ready but is a corner guy, an area where we expect Hicks, Arcia, Sano, Plouffe, and perhaps the best of the rest to occupy. One name I've heard mentioned in this regard is Detroit 3B/OF Nick Castellanos, a current AAA rh hitter with a very good hit tool and very moderate power (but no less so than any current MLB Twins). There is a very good chance that Castellanos will be a quality bat at even the corner positions. Another is Pirate prospect Gregory Polanco, whose prospect to us is dimmed just slightly by the fact that some of his value is as a good CF, which he won't play here. Both these players are in the current BA top 15, but it's important to note there is a gap between their prospects and the Top 10 guys like Bogaerts, Yelich, and Sano. Do you trade Perkins for one of these guys? As difficult as it is, I think you do. These might not be as unrealistic as the Scenario 1 guys. Detroit is filling needs, and Pittsburgh already has two star CFers playing everyday. Castellanos is ready in 2014, Polanco not until 2015 probably. My opinion is yes, trade Perkins, because a high-quality hitter in the hand is worth one hundred non-Sano non-Buxtons. Scenario 3: Would you trade Perkins for a top and close pitching prospect? The type of names I'm referring to here are the Alex Meyer types. There are certain pitchers (Dylan Bundy, Archie Bradley, Taijuan Walker e.g.) that carry franchise-type labels. We won't consider them. Would you, though, trade Glen Perkins straight up for a pitcher of the quality of Jameson Taillon, Yordano Ventura, or Noah Syndergaard? These three are all very close to MLB and all have extremely high upside, but none are sure things. Note that each is considered a better prospect than Meyer. I do this trade for any of the three. The first two hit 100 mph, and the third is uber-polished. I doubt any guy like this would be made available. Scenario 4: Would you trade Perkins for a high end prospect pitcher in A ball? This is what Alex Meyer was last year at this time. Names are Robert Stephenson, Taylor Guerreri, and Max Fried. Scout gush over these guys for different reasons and predict MLB success for all. We're looking at 2016 for this type of guy. Again, I think I would pull the trigger. This type of return for Perkins should not be unrealistic. Fans of the other team will scream, but so many things happen to derail even the best Class A arms. Scenario 5: The Ramos scenario, except that Perkins is good. The Twins need a catcher to catch 60-80 games in 2015 and take over for Mauer soon thereafter. Gary Sanchez (NYY) and Austin Hedges are the guys who qualify here as candidates from strictly our point of view. Do you trade Perkins for a catcher as good as these guys? I think this is a tough one, and we should consider Josmil Pinto is already in the system putting up great stats. Are they better than Pinto? Scenario 6: Should we look at lesser prospects in tandem for Perkins? The teams involved here, if interested in Perkins, would certainly not want to give up more than just one name, but I don't know that it would make sense for the Twins to get just one name. Alen Hanson (Pit) and Dorsyss Paulino (Cle) are two name that are relatively highly rated (Top 100) but not guaranteed to stick at SS. Getting a shortstop is important, but getting a shortstop's bat that has to move to another position is dangerous. Adding another name would reduce the risk. Again, what we'd likely need is something another team won't likely give, but you never know when the Bill Smith in a GM might come out, like it did with Sabean in 2003. Would you make a deal for two nice prospects (one top 150, one top 250) for Perkins? Combinations that come to mind are Pittsburgh's Hanson and Josh Bell (yeah, I know, too much), Baltimore's Eduardo Rodriguez and Nick Delmonico, Arizona's Chris Owings and Andrew Chafin (or David Holmberg), Texas' Luis Sardina and Jorge Alfaro and Cleveland's Dorssys Paulino and Mitch Brown (Paulino being good enough for us to accept lesser-rated Brown as the addition). I would do any deal like this that brings back a shortstop or top prospect starter as one of the pieces. To put this in perspective, Baltimore laughed when the Cubs wanted either Jonathan Schoop or Eduardo Rodriguez in a deal for Matt Garza. Of course, Garza is a free agent at the end of the year, and Perkins is controlled through 2016, so perhaps we're not too far off. Again, this is supposed to be from the Twins' point of view. What would it take for a deal to make sense for the Twins, given the value Perkins brings with his arm and his contract? The simple answer could be that we'll never get this kind of return in any of the scenarios, and that therefore why trade him? For instance, I mentioned Mitch Brown, the kid from Rochester, MN who was deemed 1st-rd supplemental quality in the 2012 draft. Perkins would easily bring him and probably another like him, but that package for the Twins (two Browns) would be extremely risky and, well, dumb. You would cross your fingers lottery-like and hope one would become Perkins. So perhaps Perkins is un-tradeable. If true, so be it.
  9. I keep forgetting that Wimmers could have a future with the Twins. This gives us one more top prospect to follow. "Top" in the Adam Brett Walker sense, not in the Alex Meyer or Oswaldo Arcia sense.
  10. Hey, saving $500k or whatever is $500k. It might be the difference between a Summit tap staying at $9 or going to $9.50.
  11. I don't think there's even a spark of hope having anything to do with Blackburn (such as hoping he might have a good start and a team relieves them of his contract), so I think they're just doing him a favor and going through the motions with him until the contract is up, or they decline whatever option there is. Being good to a player they'd just as soon release will help their reputation.
  12. Once again a commenter assumes Gardenhire would use a platoon. I love it.
  13. Not to be glib, but you're taking one flawed, non-sensical measure, doing something non-sensical to it, creating another flawed, non-sensical measure, and comparing them. Ugh. Both are obviously non-sensical because they involve adding together two percentages that are based on different denominators. A measure that makes sense is one with one denominator, probably PAs. Then proper weights need to be assigned to each outcome of each PA. In the end, what you'll get is a percentage that is probably just a standardization of a runs created measure. For example, just intuitively I used to rate players (pre-card) to determine who would have the better strat-o-matic card for our drafts my league conducted (again, prior to the cards coming out). I assigned a value to a walk, hbp, single, double, triple, hr and used plate appearance as the denominator. In slg, you assign weights 1, 2, 3, and 4 with ABs as the denominator, so I had to determine what I thought everything was worth and usually did so with a combination of intuition and some simple regression. I gave singles a weight of 1 and changed or created new weights for the other outcomes. What was nice about my measure was that the distribution was relative close, pct-wise, to slug, so I inherently understood the numbers. I guarantee I drafted better than all the guys using OPS (a non-sensical measure I still am not comfortable understanding what's good what's not good--for good reason). FYI, for those who don't know, strato is a retrospective game, so this has nothing to predicting the future (nor does any of what Seth discusses).
  14. There is no evidence that this is anything but a bad team. Gardenhire's probably totaled two losses by himself, though, so they could actually have a winning record at this point. Still, a bad team is one that on average would reasonably be 29-40, and for a team that is exactly that good (on average), 33 wins instead is probably just a product of noise or schedule. Chicago was a bad team last year, but hell, they actually were leading the division at this point, I think. That didn't change the fact they were a bad team.
  15. It will be a good team in the Appy league for the simple reason that this is a high rookie league for the Twins, but a lot of other organizations use it as a low rookie league. That's why the E-Twins win it so often.
  16. Gardenhire has no idea about platooning, so it's a moot point.
  17. My guess is there is an inherent statistical bias in your numbers arising from your choice of starting point. That is, I'll wager you chose the best place to start for Gibson.
  18. Terry Ryan and the Twins have done little right, so I don't know where this faith is coming from. They had an outstanding basis for a championship team and their way of doing business minimized the production over the course of the last twelve years with their personnel moves and their retention of a manager who needlessly loses them 5-8 games a year with his game strategy. Perhaps Terry Ryan and the Twins realize now that the goal is a championship not just winning a division, though that could just be because Detroit is for real and looks to stay that way. As with Joe Mauer, the Twins drafted the right guy in Buxton, and so kudos in both instances (and with signing Sano), but nothing about Twins operations should provide excess optimism vis a vis the current talent level.
  19. I really think Buxton has a shot at getting to the show as fast now as Sano. Can you imagine all three of Buxton, Sano, and Rosario getting the call on June 20, 2014 (arbitrary date that should delay the financials)?
  20. Two Charlottes? I believe this is Port Charlotte, near Fort Myers. Rangers use to (still do?) farm there.
  21. Two relevant things that should have probably been included are that Pinto is on the 40 and that he's right-handed, which the Twins really need at catcher. I actually doubt Herrmann will be anything other than a AAAA player, not too different than Clete Thomas in that he'll get bits of MLB time but belongs in AAA. I'm actually shocked that Doumit isn't already a Yankee, given they have no starting catcher. Arcia is probably here to stay, and the Yankees might part with reliever Mark Montgomery in such a deal.
  22. A major reason Rochester dumped Baltimore after decades was the poor quality of teams the Orioles were giving them in the late 90s and turning the decade. The Twins were consistent winners at the AAA level at the time.
  23. Arcia is indeed a CF at some level. The question is how much it costs in the field compared to the improvement he brings at the plate. To me Delmon Young was almost absolutely worthless because he gave up doubles and singles in left field that would have been outs, and I don't think its magnitude was properly accounted for. Regardless, Arcia's been DHing at AAA, so I suspect that's his role here this week.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.