Everything posted by mazeville
-
How Do You Solve The Catching Problem?
I agree that finding a catcher on the trade market is probably the best route but I'd imagine that such players just don't grow on trees. My theory is to target a AA-AAA catcher with one of the deadline deals, then hope a combination of Castro and Garver can do it for you next year while you wait on that player to take over the starting job. I read Pat's column and I think he's overblowing it a bit, but his comments on the Wilson Ramos trade are a stark reminder of how bad that trade was.
-
Article: The Time to Trade Kyle Gibson Is Now
I agree with this. Trade Gibson, get a couple of prospects for him. And do so quickly. Frankly, I would love to see the Twins trade Gibson and Lance Lynn and give guys like Aaron Slegers, Aldaberto Mejia and Stephen Gonsalves extended looks. Because they'll be needed next year.
-
Article: Week in Review: Cooked
It's hard for me to answer on what kind of return would be adequate. I'd probably expect a pair of decent prospects for him and if I can't get that, then I probably don't do it. I won't argue that the Twins' problem this season has been luck to an extent. Buxton's regression this season has probably cost the team about four wins and probably more than that given that the team has had to trot out guys like Robbie Grossman in the outfield. So who would it be then? Escobar is a free agent. Dozier is probably gone next year. Mauer probably retires but is a shadow of what he once was. Maybe Max Kepler can finally put things together and maybe Polanco plays like he did in the second half of last year. But none of those guys have the potential that Buxton and Sano do. If those two are both playing to their capabilities this season it's no exaggeration to say they'd be right behind Cleveland and we're not having this conversation. Bad luck or not, this team has no chance this season. So you make an assessment of your team and its chances for next year and you trade players based on that. It's just hard for me to see this team contending next year, however, without one of those two players anchoring that team.
-
Article: Week in Review: Cooked
Well, in any event, you peruse the market. If you feel you can contend next year, then you demand a relatively high price for someone like Rodney and if you can't get that price, you keep him. But I'm not sure I agree with you on this. Rodney has performed quite well this season and I believe he would fetch a good enough price on the market to make it attractive. Part of my problem here is, I just don't know that the Twins can contend next year, either. The biggest issue here is that Sano and Buxton aren't playing to their capabilities. Until they do this entire conversation is moot. The entire rebuild is hinged on at least one of those two meeting expectations.
-
Article: Week in Review: Cooked
Then we're basically in agreement. The market is going to be pretty buyer friendly this year. I wouldn't be surprised to see few deals get done as a result. So it's not like I think the Twins should get rid of all of those players. But it's going to make for a rather dull deadline unless the Orioles deal Machado. I doubt Dozier gets much at this point, to be honest. Escobar is the best bet to fetch any sort of return among position players but Escobar is also someone you'd want on your team next year if you plan to contend.
-
Article: Week in Review: Cooked
I would highly doubt that the Twins would be able to trade ALL of those pieces, especially in a year with so few contenders. But I still believe in getting something for them rather than nothing and think the team should make an effort to sell off a couple of pieces. In the case of Rodney, a 2019 option would make him a more attractive candidate on the trade market because it means they have an extra year of control. Relievers tend to get the most return at the deadline because contending teams typically can always use an extra arm in the bullpen. Age works against Rodney a bit, but he could definitely fetch a return. As for Dozier, do you really believe the Twins plan to sign him to a QO? They haven't given any indication at all that they would like him beyond this year. And his performance has been terrible thus far in 2018. So maybe it would just be a one-year deal, but it would be an expensive one-year deal. I'm just not so sure they do that. I don't know that I would do that. Assuming the Twins want to compete next year, they would be far better off keeping Escobar and letting Dozier walk. Maybe Escobar is expensive, but with his positional versatility he is a tremendously valuable player to have around and he could man second base while Gordon gets up to speed.
-
Article: Week in Review: Cooked
I'm not under any illusion that any of these guys could get much on the open market, though a reliever like Rodney could fetch an OK return. And the Twins have made some somewhat sneaky good trades involving players on expiring contracts. And there's plenty of players available ... The Twins have a number of young relievers in AAA who could step in and help the big league club. They could call up Nick Gordon to replace Brian Dozier and they have Adrianza on the roster who could be the effective replacement for Escobar, given the presence of Polanco. The thing I hate the most is "we can't make trades we won't get anything for those guys." We face the prospect of losing these guys at the end of the year, anyway. People like Zach Duke and Fernando Rodney and Brian Dozier are blocking young guys who WILL be here next year, and we'd lose them for nothing in almost any case. So why not get something for them?
- Article: Week in Review: Cooked
- Article: Is Paul Molitor the Right Man to Lead the Twins?
-
Article: Is Paul Molitor the Right Man to Lead the Twins?
In which case they're still trying to punish him for two years ago, while purely ignoring the two unexpectedly good years that sandwiched that bad year. What's driving me absolutely crazy on this thread is that people are blowing off the two good years while providing as much punishment as humanly possible for the really bad year and fully ignoring the clearly obvious factors toward the underperformance this year -- which are a large slate of injuries. He took over a team, remember, that lost 90+ games for four straight years and had several bad drafts while players expected to take the team to the next level took longer than expected to pan out. And he has had winning seasons more often than not, the current one thus far incomplete. Frankly, I think it's a wonder this team is even in shouting distance of first place given the injuries they've had.
-
Article: Is Paul Molitor the Right Man to Lead the Twins?
Sure. But in both Buxton's and Sano's cases you can make a strong case that injuries have played a role in their struggles. It CLEARLY did in Buxton's case after he came back early from the broken toe. And there are some who believe that Sano's leg injury has hampered his swing this season. In both cases, the players are gone and not playing for the major league team. And Polanco hasn't played at all. Neither has Ervin Santana. You can't forget either of those players. They were vital contributors to the team last year. And Jason Castro has always been a defense-first catcher. So his loss has been important, even if he wasn't hitting before he left (and he was clearly injured, too.) So MY point is this: People are jumping off the Paul Molitor bandwagon awfully fast given the sheer number of losses. Cut him some slack. Today's lineup, for instance, includes Robby Grossman (again) in right field, even though he is a horrid defender. It includes Adrianza at short. I don't even know if he should be on the team. And it includes Bobby Wilson at catcher, who can't hit and isn't a good defender. As for Brian Dozier ... he always has one good half and one bad half. This year is no different.
-
Article: Twins Daily Roundtable: Fixing the Offense
The Twins are missing four players from the opening day lineup, three of whom were expected to be major offensive contributors this season. Step One is to get two of them back and contributing positively on offense: Jorge Polanco, Byron Buxton and Miguel Sano. I don't care what two. Just two. It would also help if someone not named Ed that is on the current lineup could step up and elevate their game. Again, pick two from a group that includes Logan Morrison, Brian Dozier or Max Kepler. Invariably, one of the Eds is going to slow down some. So you need three or four guys to step up and make a difference.
-
Article: Is Paul Molitor the Right Man to Lead the Twins?
All of last year. Look at the lineup from yesterday's game against the Red Sox. It was basically Mauer, Rosario, Escobar, Dozier and then pray that some bloop single falls or a guy gets lucky with a line drive. That they won against Chris Sale was a complete miracle. The point is that the team has lost an awful lot of its key players this season. People have to give Molitor a break on that.
- Article: Is Paul Molitor the Right Man to Lead the Twins?
-
Article: Is Paul Molitor the Right Man to Lead the Twins?
And yet the injuries have had a far worse impact. And chief's reliever comments completely ignore that only one of those three relievers is currently among the top 10 in the league in appearances. You pointed to a few gaffes. That hardly counts as solid statistics. Give me a few minutes and I'll find some baserunning and defensive lapses by the Houston Astros, New York Yankees, Boston Red Sox and the Chicago Cubs. And in any event, injuries mean you have more replacement players getting more playing time than they should, which exposes all of that. It is completely unfair to look at the first half of 2018 and simply say, "Well, bad managing ..." when the team has lost so many starters. Injuries happen. That many injuries to that many starters at one time is not usual. Talk to me at the end of the year, after Polanco, Buxton, Sano and Santana have all returned and contributed a significant portion to the season. But simply pointing to a few mistakes and some very debatable statistics on bullpen use simply does not work.
-
Article: Is Paul Molitor the Right Man to Lead the Twins?
Maybe they might be on pace to be "1st, 4th and 5th in the majors" but they are not remotely "1st, 4th and 5th" in the majors this year. Only Pressly is in the top 20. And by the way, we're talking about a reliever whose ERA has improved by more than a full run over last year. So maybe he IS "overworked," as you say, but he clearly likes the way he's being worked this year because his numbers are vastly improved. It's a ridiculous complaint at this point.
-
Article: Is Paul Molitor the Right Man to Lead the Twins?
Santana + Buxton + Sano + Castro + Polanco = 17 WAR. None currently playing. All of them have missed most of the season thus far, at least. Plus Mauer's absence, which hurt a lot and which I've never mentioned. Injuries matter. They matter a lot. And you're so wrong on Santana it's not even funny. He has not been "easily replaced." You do not "easily replace" a good starter like that. Santana's absence forced the Twins to go with Phil Hughes in the rotation early, then replace him with Fernando Romero. Romero was great early and has been exposed more recently. So no. He has NOT been easily replaced.
-
Article: Is Paul Molitor the Right Man to Lead the Twins?
Wow, is this comment wrong. Lance Lynn was one of the better starters on the market. Logan Morrison was a legitimate power hitter. Jake Odorizzi was also a solid mid-rotation starter. Frankly, the front office did far more than just about any previous front office did to improve the Twins over the offseason. The FO definitely did its job.
- Article: Is Paul Molitor the Right Man to Lead the Twins?
-
Article: Is Paul Molitor the Right Man to Lead the Twins?
What "defensive lapses?" What "poor bullpen management?" What "base running gaffes?" Are these your perception or do you have data to back up your contention? The defense has taken a hit this year. But you lose a Byron Buxton and a Jason Castro from a team for most of the year and your defense will take a hit. People complain about bullpen management. I don't see that at all. What poor bullpen management? From what I can see, the problem has been mostly pitchers who should be entrusted to pitch an inning haven't done so often enough. And if you're talking overuse, which some people think is the problem, only two Twins are among the top 50 relief pitchers in games. So I'm not sure where people are getting that. The baserunning? I don't even know what to say about that. And injuries are going to make ALL of that worse by forcing the coach to insert replacement players. The good news for the Twins has been the emergence of Eduardo Escobar as an offensive force. But when your center fielder is Ryan Lamarre, your team is going to have some problems. Back your contentions up. And if you simply point to the team's record, which is legitimate, you have to take into account injuries. Tell you what: I'll take that into account. The loss of Ervin Santana, Byron Buxton, Miguel Sano, Jason Castro and Jorge Polanco removed 17 wins above replacement from the starting nine. As roughly, what, 40% of the season is done? That's about seven wins. Twins would be in first place, theoretically, with those players in the lineup, playing simply at the level they performed last year. And we aren't having this conversation.
-
Article: Is Paul Molitor the Right Man to Lead the Twins?
The injuries are a massive factor this year. Not just "A" factor. This team has four members of its starting lineup our in some form or fashion and its No. 1 starter. Please explain to me what team would not be reeling from losing more than half of the starting nine from the opening day roster. Please. And keep in mind that three of those five are supposed to be the players who form the core that would lead this team to the promised land. Two of those three were the two single biggest factors that led to that run to the wild card last year. And now you're blowing off last year's wild card simply to shoehorn last year's strong performance into your thesis that Molitor sucks. That was a strong improvement with relatively little help in the way of players from the front office. If you're going to hammer him for the 103 loss season you have to give him credit for the strong season last year. I will not argue that Molitor is perfect. But I sure as hell am not going to suddenly turn on a manager who helped get this team to the playoffs last year after the sheer number of problems the Twins have faced. Beyond that, please explain where he's the problem.
-
Article: Is Paul Molitor the Right Man to Lead the Twins?
Wow. The comments. Let's take a step back here and look at what's happened in 2018: 1. His biggest power threat spent the offseason recovering from surgery on his shin and getting investigated for sexual assault and has been terribly ineffective all year; 2. His No. 1 starter had offseason surgery and still hasn't thrown a slider; 3. His shortstop was busted for taking drugs and is out until July; 4. His catcher is out for the season; 5. His otherworldly centerfielder has been injured, is currently at rehab, and has been ineffective when he's been in. As I count it, that's five -- FIVE! -- starters that are currently out of the lineup. Add to that the ineffectiveness of Logan Morrison and Addison Reed, two big free-agent signings, and you have a recipe for a team that is not doing well. Hit the brakes on the bad manager talk. For crying out loud I think it's a wonder they're close to first place as it is. And for those of you yearning for Doug Mientkiewicz just stop. Stop.
-
Going forward, what moves do you think will happen?
I agree with people who say change little. I still say this team is close. Here's what I would do: 1. Make some trades. I'd trade people like Zach Duke, Addison Reed, Lance Lynn, Fernando Rodney and perhaps Brian Dozier at the deadline. 2. I'd give Joe Mauer a fabulous retirement gift of a promise of a statue outside of Target Field in the near future. I love Joe and think he's had some raw treatment by a lot of fans. But concussions suck. And this was bad. 3. Start playing Miguel Sano at first because that's where he's going next year. Play Eduardo Escobar at third until Nick Gordon is moved there to make room for Royce Lewis. 4. Get more kids playing time. Trevor May, Stephen Gonsalves, John Curtiss, Luke Bard. Maybe even Brent Rooker. 5. Move Jorge Polanco to 2nd and call up Nick Gordon. 6. Make a very big splash in the offseason. Show fans you mean business.
-
What Does a Byron Buxton Trade Look Like?
Don't make the trade, but mostly because I still think the price the Twins should extract would be higher than teams would pay. I mean, I think the Twins need to send him down immediately. He is a sub-zero WAR player right now, even with his defense. Let him play in AAA for a month, get his confidence back up, etc. But the longer Buxton plays the way he's thus far demonstrated in his major league career, the lower the price on a trade. Depressing.
- Article: BREAKING NEWS: Jason Castro Out for the Year