Everything posted by Elliot
-
Article: Twins Sign Closer Rodney To One-Year Deal
i am fine with a low $ signing that will bridge to the next internally developed closer. I am not in favor of strapping the payroll for years to come (think Joe Mauer) to try to get a big name starter. You are almost guaranteed that even if he performs for a couple of years you will be looking at $25M/yr dead money towards the end. I am even less in favor of dealing any of the young starter prospects. Essentially the most valuable asset in baseball is good controllable young starting pitching. The biggest risk is veteran FA starters. If the twins are serious contenders 3 years from now it will be because 2 or 3 of the current crop of prospects in the minors or already in the bigs have blossomed, not because they overpaid for past performance of Darvish or Arrieta.
- Article: Twins Sign Closer Rodney To One-Year Deal
-
Article: Minnesota Making Strikeouts A Priority
I am still baffled by the concept that a strikeout is not a bad thing from a hitter's perspective (an out is an out) so just swing for the fences no matter the situation or the count; but that from a pitcher's perspective a strikeout is the number one priority. The goal for the pitcher and defense is to get outs. Admittedly there are situations in which a strikeout is paramount; runner on third and less than two outs; but those are not measured by SO's/9 innings. One SO per nine is great if you get it when you need it. The Twins simply need better pitchers,not necessarily harder throwers or strikeout machines.
-
Article: Minnesota Making Strikeouts A Priority
"the strikeout has been (fairly) reduced to just another out." True, an out is an out. Why is this true statement followed by an entire article of why a strikeout is more important than any other out. To me it is a parallel to the dunk in basketball. All kinds of hype and emotion, but when all is said and done it is worth 2 points. Get pitchers who can get people out. I would love to see some analytics on fielding performance on batted balls in play behind strikeout pitchers as compared to pitch to contact guys. My guess would be that fielders perform better when batters see fewer pitches. Nothing like a 8 or 9 pitch at bat to put fielders on their heels.
-
Article: Twins Mailbag: Extensions, 2020 Line-Up, Darvish, Ohtani
In question 1 you suggest signing Dozier to a 4/5 year extension, but in #2 he is gone by the second year unless he is the mysterious 3B. I am on board with that unless for some reason he or the management team feel he cannot play the position.
-
Article: Twins Add Three Players To 40 Man Roster
Based on performance to date, Stewart would not even be in the discussion. We are concerned only due to his draft status. In 5 years he has not done anything to warrant the concern. Losing Rodriguez as a minor league FA was a much bigger deal. I put the likelihood of Stewart being drafted at 75+% and being returned at 50%+. He is the perfect type of prospect for someone to take a flyer on. If he shows something out of a bullpen maybe he sticks with someone. If not, its only a $25k cost. With Diaz, keep in mind that not only does he have to stay on the 25 man all of 2018, but he has to stay on the 40 man indefinitely after that. Removing him would expose him to waiver claims. He is likely 3 to 4 years away from being a contributing major league hitter, so he will be a roster dilemma for years.
-
Article: Twins Add Three Players To 40 Man Roster
Each year the Twins (and every other team) add between 30 and 40 young players thru the draft and undrafted international signings. The harsh reality is that there will be between 5 and 10 left in the system 4 or 5 years later; with fewer yet ever seeing the majors. If there is one solid major leaguer found per year you are lucky. A star every few years is all you can really expect. The 2012 draft was outstanding in that it produced 4 solid major league players (Buxton, Berrios, Duffey, and Rogers); 2 who have definite star potential. In addition 4 more are still hanging around (Bard, Melotakis, Chargois, and Baxendale) 2 of which are part of this rule 5 discussion. There is basically no one left from the 2011 draft; and 7 or 8 from 2013 and similar number for '14; none of whom have established themselves as even marginal major leaguers at this point (other than Hildenberger in 14). Along with the two from '12, these individuals make up the current rule 5 discussion. We love to talk about these names, debate their value, and blame Terry Ryan, Bill Smith, or the new guys; but the reality is that the nature of the beast is that none of these names who were left off the 40 man will even be remembered 2 or 3 years from now. The good ones make it in 4 or 5 years. (Disclaimer - international 16 year old signings like Diaz are wild cards). A new crop will have emerged and the real prospects will be those chosen in the 2014 to 2017 drafts. The chances are slim of any of the hanger ons who reach rule 5 discussion becoming solid major leaguers, much less stars. There are always exceptions, but barring injury, high schools seniors make it in 4 or 5 years (age 22 - 24) and college draftees should show up in 3 to 4 (age 24 to 26). The names to focus on are not Bard, Burdi, Melotakis, and Diaz; but Kiriloff, Lewis, Gordon, Jay, Moran, Badoo,...
-
40 Man Roster prior to Rule 5 Draft Deadline
It seems that some of the minor league losses recently illustrate the problem with placing young players on the 40 man roster too early. The rule 5 draft is less of a threat than having to outright someone off the 40 man. Would Rosario have been selected if the team choosing him had to keep him on their 25 man roster all year as is the case in the rule 5? As it is, by placing him on the 40 man and 25 man earlier in the year he had to be outrighted off the 40 man to clear a spot. He might have been lost in the rule 5 if they did not protect him, but it seems much easier for a team to simply claim him and place him in their minor league system as the outright process allowed. I don't think he was set to become a minor league free agent like Derek Rodriguez, so he was not free to leave on his own. I may be missing something here, but this may be a cautionary tale regarding the desire to see young prospects brought up too early.
-
Article: Buxton, Dozier Win Their First Gold Glove Awards
Never been a fan of defensive metrics. For me, the eye test says that Dozier has always been an above average defensive player at 2nd base, but not at short. I also believe he could transition to third and perform at the same level. His quick first step and lack of great range would fit better there. I believe he has plenty of arm for the majority of plays. If he stays healthy Buxton will be in the running for many more in center. If he finishes 2nd or 3rd in some years to the crop of high end defenders now in the American league that will not seem like an injustice.
-
Article: Part 1: Seth's Updated Top 50 Prospects (41-50)
Don’t get too worked up about minor league relievers. They are in the pen in the minors due to flaws. The best pitchers are almost always in the rotation. History of the Twins (Aguilera, Guadado, Perkins ...) and most other teams is that the best relievers are failed starters. The future of the pen probably rests with MayGonsalves, Romero, Jorge, and other current minor league starters.
-
Article: Part 1: Seth's Updated Top 50 Prospects (41-50)
Don’t get too worked up about minor league relievers. They are in the pen in the minors due to flaws. The best pitchers are almost always in the rotation. History of the Twins (Aguilera, Guadado, Perkins ...) and most other teams is that the best relievers are failed starters. The future of the pen probably rests with May as well as Gonsalves, Romero, Jorge, and other current minor league starters. That is not to say that a couple of the current crop of minor league relievers won’t pitch in the majors, but exposing them to other teams doesn’t mean they will be lost (see Mason Melotakis).
-
Article: Supplementing the Twins: Lance Lynn
The focus won't be on who they trade, but who they go after. The twins can only work with the assets they have. Not having the veteran trade options only means that they will have to use their minor/major league options. Falvey will show his value in deciding which minor leaguers to trade and identifying younger, not yet established arms in other organizations. At Cleveland they did not trade their veteran assets for other established veterans, but instead went after Corey Kluber types (admittedly not easy to find). They have also been very limited in the FA route. I expect that the offseason moves will not involve the names being kicked around, but will very likely be somewhat anonymous names coming back in return for minor leaguers that are identified as less likely to be stars at the major league level. I do not think Lance Lynn will be a Nolasco disaster, but he might. He might be an Ervin Santana success. A good chance he is Hughes; a success for a year and then injured which seems to be the St Louis pattern. No matter what, he will cost a lot in terms of both years and $, and will impact the rest of the team moves for years to come.
-
Article: Supplementing the Twins: Lance Lynn
The Twins have made 3 major free agent starting pitcher moves in the recent past; three moves that give a great example of the pitfalls of this route. Ervin Santana (great success), Phil Hughes (great success, then injury), and Ricky Nolasco (disaster) were all highly touted within these pages prior to their signings; and for good reason; they were veterans with track records of success. It is probably more than just coincidence that out of 3 moves with similar contract commitments, there can be such widely varying results. I would guess that it probably represents the approximate odds of success with this avenue of building a staff. Lance Lynn, or almost any other FA starter out there, has probably a 33% chance of long term success if the Twins (or any other team) signs them. The variable is what impact the 66% failure rate has on the signing team. The Yankees, Cubs, or Dodgers swallow hard and move on from the failure. The Twins are strapped and unable to make moves to offset the mistake unless or until they are able to unload the contract. The Verlanders and Darvishes of the world probably have a somewhat better chance of success but come with a much greater cost in both annual dollars and number of years. Think "Joe Mauer's contract and the impact it has had. Joe is probably a much better value in the final 2 or 3 years of his 8 year deal than either of those pitchers will be. My preference would be to trust in the young arms coming, maybe even rushing one or two of them. If they are not ready, the cost is not as great and the team is not hamstrung moving forward. If it is deemed necessary to go outside of the organization I prefer a trade for an arm or two that will not excite the fan base as much since they will probably be somewhat unknown, but they will be earlier in their careers and the Twins can capitalize on their affordable years. (NOTE - check out how Cleveland built their staff). Twins assets leaving in this type of deal should be the likes of Nick Gordon (sell high) and Kohl Stewart (potential not production). The idea is that you have to give something to get something and we have to quit fearing that one of the young players we trade will go on to excel somewhere else. That is the price of getting pitching. The real price to fear and to avoid is long term onerous contracts with no production.
-
A Change Coming In The Twins Dugout?
Huge fan of Paul Molitor the player. Not so of Molitor the manager. I would kind of like to see either Jake Mauer or Doug M. Mauer seems to have done a great job wherever he has been. The Lookouts are currently playing at a .750 pace in the second half after posting a .600 line in the first half. Both have worked with and seem to know and get along with the young core of players.
- Article: Twins Trade Kintzler To Nationals
-
Article: Jorge Polanco At SS Could Be Disastrous
Polanco 2b, Dozier 3b, Vielma or veteran defensive SS via FA or trade Sano, Mauer, Park, Vargas fight for 1B, DH opportunities. Let the best man win and the others sit or move to AAA. Advantages - Dozier, a veteran and leader takes the hit of learning a new position without it affecting his offense (I believe he has the skill set to be an above average 3B). Polanco, and hopefully Sano, begin long careers at positions in which they have a chance of being average to above average defensively while shining offensively. 3B and SS are arguably two of the most crucial defensive positions on the field, and neither will be filled by Polanco or Sano on an effective defensive team. At least the starts the process of getting people in the roles in which they can succeed. The 1B/DH competition may be good for both Sano and Mauer. Based on recent performance Mauer may be the least deserving of the candidates. If he beats out Sano, a trip to AAA may be just what Sano needs to figure things out. Downside - Entirely new infield alignment, potential of blocking Gordon's opportunity at short with a veteran. Highlights the lack of apparent 3B solutions in the system.
-
Article: Twins First Half Summary: Murphy's Law
I attended my first game of the year yesterday and came away with a number of impressions; one that I want to focus on. For the entire year there has been ongoing discussion of the "Sano in right field" plan. Although I was never a big fan of the move, I supported it since it was clearly the lesser of two evils. Now the greater evil has come into view. Miguel Sano is not now, nor will he ever be, a third baseman. I was always baffled by the statement that he is too big and not athletic enough to play right field, but he could somehow slot nicely in at third base. Equally baffling was the injury concern. A hamstring strain is more likely for a DH than an outfielder due to the relative inactivity between at bats. However; the more serious injury concern involves the likelihood that Sano will take a ground ball to the face if he stays there much longer. Although he was able to catch a pop up without damage to his noggin, he did manage to display on two different plays why he does not belong anywhere in the infield other than first base. The first was a base hit grounded between Sano and Nunez. I was seated part way down the first base line so I had a perfect view as the ball eluded both. It was catchable for both; but both simply missed it. I am giving Nunez a free pass since I don’t think anyone is seriously considering him as a long term shortstop; simply a stopgap for now. The second misplay was a potential double play ball to Sano. I am not sure what he was trying to do, but although it was hit almost directly at him he somehow managed to not only botch the play, but not even come close to fielding the ball. Fortunately it bounced harmlessly into left field. Had it been at his head I seriously doubt that he could have defended himself. Miguel Sano is the future of the Twins. He is too young to be slotted into a full time DH role, but he only has one place on the field where he can play and that is first base. Fortunately, I think he has the skill set to not only succeed, but potentially be a very good defensive player there. Unfortunately that spot is filled by a catcher who needs to return to catching, retire, or take up a utility role, all of which would be good roles for a .280 hitter with little power or speed.