Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Elliot

Verified Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Elliot

  1. Three thoughts. First, catchers put too much confidence in their protective equipment. There are far more tag plays and potential for collisions at second base. The reason there are fewer collision injuries is that middle infielders know better than to try to block or obstruct the base. Second, foul tip concussions are similar to body impact issues in football/hockey. They can be lessened with advances in equipment but they are inherent to the game. Third, I am not ready to put Garver in the Joe Mauer category as a hitter after one partial year. His 2019 offense was great, but was clearly an outlier based on past performance. I have a strong suspicion that over a full year of daily play and exposure he will come back to earth. That said, I think he will remain an above average hitting catcher, but probably not when compared to first basemen/DH’s across MLB. Leave him behind the plate unless his defense, or lack thereof, dictates otherwise. That is where his greatest value lies.
  2. Versatility is great, but an above average SS or catcher doesn’t get moved around. This is especially true if they possess starter quality offensive skills. A well below average offensive player needs defensive versatility to stick in the majors. Unless Lewis shows himself to be below average as a SS without reasonable expectation for improvement, I would give him all the reps possible there. The other exception is the appearance of a better SS option. As of now that is not the case or likely in the foreseeable future. Another possibility for improvement of the infield defense is to greatly upgrade the third base defense to help cover some range and arm concerns with Polanco. If that is the plan I can get behind a Lewis move to third.
  3. If his main SS competition is Polanco, I keep him at short. If the Twins sign or trade for a competent defensive SS, then I move him to third. The only way I see him in CF is if Buxton suffers another injury, admittedly not unlikely.
  4. Infield defense focuses first and foremost on shortstop. When Polanco was signed originally, the concern was whether or not he would ever hit. Seemed his defense was his strength. Now I don’t think he will ever be even an average MLB shortstop defensively. I would like to see Polanco and Arraez filling 3rd and 2nd (not sure which would be better at 3rd) with Sano moving to first. SS remains an unknown. Lewis??? Adrianza??? Gordon (doubtful defensively)??? Some FA or trade?? Biggest question of the offseason.
  5. Just read a BR report on the top 10 FA starting pitchers. The 3 Twins FA’s are all listed in the 5 thru 10 range. For those insistent on a complete overhaul, the question is, “where will you find someone better”? 6 or 7 years at $200M+ for Cole isn’t happening. 5 yrs at $120m for Wheeler or MadBum isn’t likely either. How happy should we all be that we didn’t get Darvish? Gibson and Pineda are the type of arms that can be gotten on decent deals. I think they will have to overpay to get Odorizzi back, but I think they should I hope the bring 2 or 3 of them back and pull off a trade for a younger arm (Rosario as a centerpiece). Their biggest shortcoming is not pitching, but infield defense followed by the ability to score runs other than via HR.
  6. In many cases the pitchers weren’t optioned to Rochester due to performance but to get a fresh arm. Particularly true with minor league starters being used as relievers in MLB. They can’t be counted on to pitch every other day as most experienced relievers can. Citing those roster moves as indicators of poor performance gives an unfairly negative perspective.
  7. One of my he problems with big name players is that we tend to remember what they have done in the past and equate it to present value. The role of the FO is to determine what value they bring in the window of control; just a couple of months for many of these players. Same issue is there in FA. The mistake is to pay now for past performance rather than reasonable expected future results. Couple this with the uncertainty of prospects and it gets very difficult. Of the prospects mentioned in the rumors and discussions, most will not be stars, and many will never see MLB. No one knows which will be which. So the FO makes their best guess in hopes of giving a career minor leaguer for a Justin Verlander type of ace. That would be great, but the outcome with biggest impact is trading the next Kepler/Rosario/Berrios/Garver/Polanco for a couple of months of someone living on past performance. Then we get to see the bad results for years (Capps and Ramos).
  8. (not sure of numbers too lazy to verify, but they are close) Twins with Byron Buxton, 52 wins 23 losses (.693). Twins w/o Byron Buxton 7 wins 14 losses (.333). I know, SSS ... but it sure seems as if what he brings to the team far exceeds what the numbers would seem to say. Very important extension, with the caveat that he has missed 20% of the games ytd.
  9. 2019 is really all about Rosario, Sano, Buxton, Polanco, Berrios, Kepler etc. The Twins need to find out if this wave is actually who they thought they were or if 2018 was what the future holds. If they do become the solid core that management hoped for, they are far enough along that consideration needs to be given to near future arbitration costs and long term contracts. To a lesser degree the same thought applies to Garver, Austin, Cron, and many of the younger bullpen arms. Finding out about these players does not preclude being competitive in 2019, but this year's decisions should all be made in the context of the player development. The process probably does discourage long term commitments to aging veteran FA's. The last thing they should be doing is creating a situation in 2020 or 21 in which the ability to lock down young stars to long term deals is hindered due to prior financial decisions. That concept probably excludes Ottavino at 3/27M. Passing on Allen at 1/9M would be less of a financial decision and more a fit or ability call. I expect the Twins to make another move or two on one year deals for pitchers (starters or relievers); or possibly 2 yrs at the most. I really do not care if they are at 71% or 100% of average payroll in 2019. I am much more concerned about the quality of the team long term. If Sano, Buxton, and others put it all together and they are competitive come June or July they will have the financial flexibility to make some targeted in season moves to improve and compete.
  10. 1. Defense 2. Defense 3. Defense It starts up he middle. Catcher will be improved with the return of Castro and growth of Garver. Centerfield specifically, and the outfield overall, is buoyed by the return of Buxton. Molitor needs to resist the urge to be impressed by early ST success and keep Buxton hitting 8th or 9th for at least the first half of the season. The biggest challenge is SS and 2nd base; and the infield overall. Infield defense starts with SS. I don't think Polanco is the SS of a successful major league team. However; he has certainly shown much more offensively that most expected, so there is a place for him. It appears that the Twins believe that Lewis can be an MLB SS, but that is probably not until 2020 at the earliest. They need a solid defensive SS on a short term deal; preferably a veteran that can add a little stability to the clubhouse (Iglesias???). Sano should not be at 3rd, but I still have faith that he can return to his early offensive success at 1B or DH. Along with Austin, Grossman, and an occasional Kepler appearance at first, they should be set at the 1B/DH slot (if Mauer returns he bumps Grossman). That leaves 2nd and 3rd base. My first preference is Polanco at 3rd and Forsythe at second on a one year deal. If Gordon can beat him out so be it. If Polanco cannot play third then he becomes part of the 2nd base mix. FA NOTE- it is not only the Twins, but the FA route overall in MLB is a crapshoot at best. Last offseason these pages were filled with passionate pleas for the FO to sign a starting pitcher; generally for somewhere in the 4 year $70M range. The names varied, but it was almost always Lynn, Cobb, Arietta, or Darvish at half again as much. Falvine suceeded in getting Lynn at a steal which was still too much. And he may have been the best of the group. Year in and year out it is the same story. Hope that you are the one in 10 that strikes gold in the FA market, and not part of the 90% that gets burned badly. The risk of course is that unlike the Red Sox/Yankees/Dodgers/Cubs, a miscalculation on a long term contract that pays out $20M/yr can devastate a team like the Twins.
  11. Buxton - bring him up. He has shown that he can dominate AAA; both in the past and with this latest run. Find out if it works at the MLB level; at least in September. Mauer- help him decide to retire. The 1B/DH role is too valuable to fill with Joe. They need to find out what they have with Austin, Rooker, Vargas, Raley, ... not to mention the Sano/Kepler option in that role.
  12. Late season promotions at the AA or AAA level often have to do with playoffs. Apparently not an issue this year, other than maybe preventing promotions from high A to AA. The big issue now will probably deal with offseason status in regards to 40 man roster, rule 5 draft eligibility, and minor league free agent standing. Moves like Kohl Stewart over Stephen Gonsalves are less about who deserves the promotion and more about a prospects future. Gonsalves is not going anywhere unless it is part of a trade. He is on the 40 man and not a milb FA. Stewart was rule 5 eligible last year but had not shown enough to be selected. Probably not the case this year. They need to find out what the have with him. Don’t count on seeing anyone brought up for a September look if they are not already on the 40 man or have to be added this winter. Also be aware that they starting of the major league clock is a big issue as well. As much as I would like to see what Lewis, Rooker, or Kirilloff could do against MLB pitching, it is not going to happen. As painful as it will be to watch Stewart, Slegers, Enns, Littel ... take their lumps, it is proabably the smart route for those that need to make offseason decisions.
  13. Part of improving depth in the minor league system is the yearly loss of players like Randy Rosario, Niko Goodrum, and Jeremy Palka via rule 5 or waiver claims. You cannot keep them all. This is where you trust the talent evaluators for the team. There was a lot of hand wringing over the loss of a couple of minor league relievers last year and now I cannot even remember their names. Same will be true this year. We hate to see people go that we have followed as they climbed the ladder with the Twins, but there are a lot more like them in the same situation with other teams (ie Ryan Presly). I have to believe that a few who have stalled out, such as Kohl Stewart, will be left unprotected again. Losing potentially good players is a sign of a healthy system and sure beats being able to protect every player with potential.
  14. Generally, for a team to compete, they need to have the majority of the players perform up to expectations; a few players exceed them; and few, if any, fall far short of what they are capable of. It also helps to have one or two young players come on quicker than expected. By this measure, the 2018 everyday Twins players were a disaster. Due to injury or suspension, Buxton, Sano, Castro, and Polanco have provided next to nothing. Dozier, Mauer, Morrison, and Kepler have been healthy for the most part, but have underperformed dramatically. The only everyday players who performed at or above expected levels were the two Eddies. Garver and Cave are really the only young players, and neither has over delivered on their promise. When 80% of your players fall short of expectations you are either facing bad evaluations leading to unreasonable expectations or just plan bad luck. Pitching was a different story. Santana (health) and Lynn (performance) were the only real washouts. Berrios and Gibson have probably exceeded reasonable expectations. I would say that Romero fits in that category as a young player. Most of the bullpen has been relatively healthy, and overall has performed adequately. Rogers may be the biggest disappointment. A number of young arms have performed well in the minors and are awaiting their chance. What does this mean for 2019 and beyond? An everyday lineup with Sano, Buxton, Polanco, Rosario, Kepler, and Castro/Garver performing at reasonable expectations is still very potent. Bringing back one of either Dozier or Escobar would not be totally out of the question either. Mix in a surprise young player (Gordon, Rooker, one of the new guys) and maybe one new veteran and the offense does not seem so inept. I expect nothing from Mauer, Grossman, or Morrison. The current pitching staff with the addition of a few of the young starters and pen pieces currently at AAA or AA should reasonably be expected to be competitive. The big question is whether or not this is based on unreasonable expectations. I, for one, am not ready to give up on Sano and Buxton. They are players who dominated at every level of the minors and have performed well at times in the majors. As noted, Kepler has in some ways performed better than his numbers indicate, and still holds reasonable hope. I am not advocating a stand pat approach; however, I do believe that the doom and gloom some are expressing is a bit premature for this group of players. While it is true that the next wave of stars (Kiriloff, Lewis, Graterol, …) won’t arrive until 2020 at the earliest, there is still a great deal of talent on the current 40 man with some good potential on the verge of arriving or available for trades. .
  15. Don’t be so quick to write Dozier off for next year. The FA market has shifted and players are being paid more on the basis of what they are expected to produce in the future than what they have in the past. As such, I am not so certain that he will receive a huge FA offer that will price the Twins out of the picture. I think he has more value to the Twins as a solid veteran player amidst a roster of young, somewhat unstable core. The same is true for Escobar. These should not be salary/player dumps. If someone offers some solid Prospects, go for it. If not, hang on to them and attempt to resign them going forward at reasonable rates. The Twins have built some solid middle infield depth, but all of it, including Gordan, is a ways off yet.
  16. It seems like catcher may be on the upswing. How about an article looking into the catching depth with the introduction of Jeffers, Williams, Casanova, Weiss(of??), and Hale from this years' draft; Banuelos and Villalobos from trades; as well as holdovers Rortvedt, Navarreto, Kranson, Hamilton, and Grzelakowski. Who will stick at catcher? Who has the defensive ability to be a major league catcher?
  17. This is an expansion of an earlier comment I had made in a different string, but it applies here as the move has now been made on Vargas. I pointed out that international players face a disadvantage with early signings, and eventual early decisions regarding the 40 man. Early inclusion on the 40 man roster makes them eligible for early call ups; often from high A or early in AA. Although the player is probably thrilled, I wonder about the impact of that type of development plan. As pointed out by a few, Vargas did have significant MLB at bats as well as a number at AAA. However; averaging 200 AB's per year over 4 years is not the same as getting 500 to 600 in a year. Same issue with his AAA time. This was a similar issue with position players Danny Santana and Jorge Polanco, as well as pitchers Randy Rosario and Felix Jorge. Early, surprise promotions to MLB that seem to interrupt minor league development. The next will likely be Lewin Diaz. After his first year at low A the team needed to make a 40 man decision. Although left off and eligible for the rule 5 last year, the outcome will probably not be the same if he is left unprotected again after his second year at low A or a promotion to high A. Sano was more of an exception, as I expect Javier will be; an international player that is allowed to develop through a normal system progression.
  18. A problem with international players. The decision points arrive too soon. I would like to have seen Vargas get more time at AAA to prove he could dominate, but everything seems to get accelerated. I think Diaz is the next case. Having to make 40 man roster decisions when they are still in low A is a problem. The part of the Ortiz comp that is true is that the Twins know he can hit, but the decision is being driven by “fit” on the 25 man roster. I think with Ortiz the competition was a chunky RH hitting c/1b named Matt who had similar stats to that point in their careers but fit the 25 man needs better. I would not be surprised to see Vargas outrighted, claimed, and resurfacing a couple years from now after maturing a bit as a hitter.
  19. I see a lot of lineup predictions with Mauer leading off. Makes sense on paper, but from what we have heard over the years Dozier is more comfortable leading off and Mauer likes to hit second. I think the comfort level of the veterans will influence the decision.
  20. Most effective major league relievers are failed starters. High end pitchers are generally starters in college and the minors. The previous FO became infatuated with mph rather than effective pitchers. The Twins bullpen future probably lies with May, Romero, and others from the pool of potential starters who don't crack the rotation. The college relievers were flawed pitchers that the Twins took a flier on. Probably not a terrible plan, but better when used later in the draft. High velocity throwers are not that hard to come by as evidenced by the Twins recent pickups via Rule 5 and minor league trades. Hard throwers that can stay healthy and show command are the difficult part. My guess is that JT is done, regardless of what team he ends up with. He may recover enough to make a roster but arm troubles every year dating back to college is not a good sign.
  21. This is just a point of discussion now. It will become more important when arbitration comes around and the Twins use the lack of availability as an argument for lower pay. Even a bigger issue when the discussion of a long term contract starts. Sano is really hurting himself in terms of his future. It isn't the positional issue (I have always viewed him as a first baseman) as much as durability and longevity. The Hrbek analogy is very appropriate. A very good player who could have been so much more for so much longer.
  22. I just ran across an interesting article on free agents from 5 years ago. https://www.sbnation.com/mlb/2017/11/9/16624864/mlb-free-agents-history-offseason The best MLB free agents from 2012-2013 are a sobering reminder for everyone The article looks at the MLB Trade Rumors list of the top 50 free agents. The article did not include who signed them or what they signed for. The thrust of it was to look at where these top 50 are 5 years later; interesting in that 5 years gets thrown around often as if it isn’t that big of a deal. The section in quotes below is their assessment of the class. “Again, this is five years ago. Let’s do a quick tally: • 32 players who are either retired or playing internationally • 10 players who might play a role on a bench or in the back of a bullpen next year • Three players who might play a significant role with their current/future team, but probably won’t • Four players who are expected play a significant role with their current/future teams • Zack Greinke That is, just 10 percent of the free agents from five years ago are still playing at roughly the same level right now. This is a small sample, and it’s possible this was an especially unlucky class. We’ll do this experiment next year.” Looking at just the top 10 you have Zack Greinke and BJ Upton (unless you want to include #4 Anibal Sanchez). I was not able to determine the other 3 who would constitute the 10%. Maybe Russel Martin or Melky Cabrera. Needless to say it is not an impressive list and would have been almost as unimpressive 2 years ago, with only David Ortiz standing out. Even the #1 at that time, who would clearly be the #1 now as well (Zack Greinke) is a contract that Arizona looks to be trying to unload. The lesson to be learned is that there is a small number of players in a typical free agent class that will be worth the money 4 or 5 years down the line. In most cases you are paying for past performance and will be sitting on dead money well before the end of the contract.
  23. Gotta wonder if somehow Dickerson will surface with the Twins. Maybe part of the original discussion but now trying to get him for less money than what it would have been in a trade. Don't hold your breath on any additional pitching moves. I think they will feel comfortable with finding their staff in Santana, Berrios, Odorizzi, Gibson, Mejia, Hughes, May, Duffy, Gonsalves, Romero, Slegers. I'm happy, but I always am when spring training starts.
  24. The worst move the FO can make is to commit 20% of the payroll for the next 5 to 6 years to a bad, large contract. The hope is that over the next few years they will be locking up Buxton, Sano (??), Berrios, Rosario, Kepler, Polanco ...; as well as dealing with vets such as Dozier and Mauer; a process that will require considerable payroll space. I much prefer a flier on Sanchez to overpaying for any of the pitchers in this incredibly flawed FA market. The consensus top pitcher available was a sub .500 starter who almost single handedly cost the Dodgers the WS. The next three in line are even more flawed; in no way worth anything more than a three year deal, and even that is a stretch. An incentive laden 2 year is more like it. Hearing that the top FA pitchers are all looking for 4 years plus and $15M/yr type of money, I sincerely hope that the FO steers clear and continues to "dumpster dive". I hate to ever see the Twins give up prospects but my guess is that if a big move is coming it will be a trade for a lesser known starter (not Archer) and will involve moving a young major leaguer as well as some highly rated prospects.
  25. I am not a huge fan of Garrison Keillor and certainly am on the opposite end of the political spectrum from Al Franken.. I do not know or particularly support the many individuals who have been publicly accused of various levels of sexual assault. I am however; very concerned about the current practice of assuming guilt and punishing without any level of due process. If a crime has been committed, allow the legal process to play out. If it falls short of a crime, allow the civil process to run its course. if neither of the above holds true, then trust the electoral process or pressure from advertising dollars to do their part. My concern is that, if not already in place, there will be an instance of a woman accusing a man of a sexual assault that did not take place; who knows why, but anything from vindictiveness to financial gain to some level of notoriety could be the case. With the pubic insistence on immediate action fueled by the current need for instant answers, that individual's life will be destroyed. I do not know the female photographer involved, but lean towards believing her story (or at least parts of it) based on statements from those that do. I do not know Miguel Sano, but based on many statements from those around him throughout his career, it would not surprise me if he is indeed the typical athlete suffering from extreme entitlement. That being said, no action should be taken unless or until the appropriate processes have run their course. I have to believe that the Twins front office, managerial staff, and players know Sano's character very well. If he is the jerk that is displayed in this story, not only will his time in MN be short lived, but so will his career. Those accused of such actions certainly have the right to step out of their public positions if they wish to avoid the public outcry; but if they wish to continue in their role, they should not be forced out until whatever process involved runs its course. As of now, friends of the photographer should support her and leave the conviction and punishment to others. Until then, these pages should be focused on Miguel Sano's leg healing, controlling his weight, cutting down on his strikeouts, and finding a defensive role that he can handle.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.